{ "instance_id": "lastmile_large_s123", "strategies": { "routefinder": { "final_metrics": { "total_distance": 11865.88, "total_lateness_min": 101159.89, "total_objective": 821145.0, "reoptimization_count": 145, "avg_route_change_penalty": 1.037 }, "stability_metrics": { "schedule_stability_score": 0.8282, "avg_route_change_penalty": 1.037, "reoptimization_count": 145, "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083, "driver_disruption_index": 16.074 }, "n_steps": 145 }, "rolling_horizon": { "final_metrics": { "total_distance": 12519.3, "total_lateness_min": 103305.07, "total_objective": 838976.32, "reoptimization_count": 145, "avg_route_change_penalty": 1.64 }, "stability_metrics": { "schedule_stability_score": 0.8162, "avg_route_change_penalty": 1.64, "reoptimization_count": 145, "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083, "driver_disruption_index": 25.42 }, "n_steps": 145 }, "alns": { "final_metrics": { "total_distance": 12484.79, "total_lateness_min": 101565.65, "total_objective": 825027.35, "reoptimization_count": 145, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.299 }, "stability_metrics": { "schedule_stability_score": 0.843, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.299, "reoptimization_count": 145, "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083, "driver_disruption_index": 4.63 }, "n_steps": 145 }, "monte_carlo": { "final_metrics": { "total_distance": 11357.97, "total_lateness_min": 100448.9, "total_objective": 814949.17, "reoptimization_count": 145, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.448 }, "stability_metrics": { "schedule_stability_score": 0.84, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.448, "reoptimization_count": 145, "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083, "driver_disruption_index": 6.943 }, "n_steps": 145 }, "scenario_tree": { "final_metrics": { "total_distance": 11291.03, "total_lateness_min": 100403.48, "total_objective": 814518.87, "reoptimization_count": 145, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.311 }, "stability_metrics": { "schedule_stability_score": 0.8427, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.311, "reoptimization_count": 145, "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083, "driver_disruption_index": 4.821 }, "n_steps": 145 }, "ortools": { "final_metrics": { "total_distance": 11828.51, "total_lateness_min": 85941.8, "total_objective": 699362.91, "reoptimization_count": 145, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.637 }, "stability_metrics": { "schedule_stability_score": 0.8362, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.637, "reoptimization_count": 145, "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083, "driver_disruption_index": 9.879 }, "n_steps": 145 }, "reinforcement_learning": { "final_metrics": { "total_distance": 12763.08, "total_lateness_min": 101196.92, "total_objective": 822338.44, "reoptimization_count": 145, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.118 }, "stability_metrics": { "schedule_stability_score": 0.8466, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.118, "reoptimization_count": 145, "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083, "driver_disruption_index": 1.827 }, "n_steps": 145 } }, "ranking": [ "ortools", "scenario_tree", "monte_carlo", "routefinder", "reinforcement_learning", "alns", "rolling_horizon" ], "winner": "ortools" }