{ "instance_id": "lastmile_medium_s123", "strategies": { "routefinder": { "final_metrics": { "total_distance": 5587.97, "total_lateness_min": 50436.22, "total_objective": 409077.73, "reoptimization_count": 145, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.566 }, "stability_metrics": { "schedule_stability_score": 0.8376, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.566, "reoptimization_count": 145, "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083, "driver_disruption_index": 8.767 }, "n_steps": 145 }, "rolling_horizon": { "final_metrics": { "total_distance": 5899.25, "total_lateness_min": 51337.19, "total_objective": 416605.04, "reoptimization_count": 145, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.619 }, "stability_metrics": { "schedule_stability_score": 0.8366, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.619, "reoptimization_count": 145, "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083, "driver_disruption_index": 9.59 }, "n_steps": 145 }, "alns": { "final_metrics": { "total_distance": 5896.93, "total_lateness_min": 50720.68, "total_objective": 411679.82, "reoptimization_count": 145, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.454 }, "stability_metrics": { "schedule_stability_score": 0.8399, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.454, "reoptimization_count": 145, "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083, "driver_disruption_index": 7.043 }, "n_steps": 145 }, "monte_carlo": { "final_metrics": { "total_distance": 5334.98, "total_lateness_min": 50041.62, "total_objective": 405667.94, "reoptimization_count": 145, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.301 }, "stability_metrics": { "schedule_stability_score": 0.8429, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.301, "reoptimization_count": 145, "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083, "driver_disruption_index": 4.66 }, "n_steps": 145 }, "scenario_tree": { "final_metrics": { "total_distance": 5372.43, "total_lateness_min": 50018.97, "total_objective": 405524.19, "reoptimization_count": 145, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.289 }, "stability_metrics": { "schedule_stability_score": 0.8432, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.289, "reoptimization_count": 145, "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083, "driver_disruption_index": 4.481 }, "n_steps": 145 }, "ortools": { "final_metrics": { "total_distance": 5583.03, "total_lateness_min": 42820.43, "total_objective": 348146.49, "reoptimization_count": 145, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.481 }, "stability_metrics": { "schedule_stability_score": 0.8393, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.481, "reoptimization_count": 145, "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083, "driver_disruption_index": 7.456 }, "n_steps": 145 }, "reinforcement_learning": { "final_metrics": { "total_distance": 5995.04, "total_lateness_min": 50481.38, "total_objective": 409846.08, "reoptimization_count": 145, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.048 }, "stability_metrics": { "schedule_stability_score": 0.848, "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.048, "reoptimization_count": 145, "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083, "driver_disruption_index": 0.747 }, "n_steps": 145 } }, "ranking": [ "ortools", "scenario_tree", "monte_carlo", "routefinder", "reinforcement_learning", "alns", "rolling_horizon" ], "winner": "ortools" }