A total eclipse of the sun occurred in Egypt,
17th May, 1882; and reckoning forward from that date by means of
the saros, we can predict
the eclipses of 28th May,
1900, and 8th June,
1918. But only in a general way;
if the precise circumstances of
the eclipse are required,
and
the place where it is to take place,
then we must refer to
the Ephemeris,
or Nautical Almanac.
Mark
the effect
of
the one third year
in
the saros:
the eclipse at each recurrence falls visible about
120°
longitude farther than
the previous visible eclipse
in Egypt,
in
1900. In
the Atlantic Ocean,
1918 on
the Pacific Ocean,
14 years one month 1 day,
or three times
the length
of
the saros,
will therefore bring a return
of an eclipse
in very nearly
the same longitude,
but its track will be considerably changed.
For example,
the total eclipse
of
8th July,
1842,
was observed
in central Europe;
but its return,
9th August,
1866,
fell visible
in Norway.
About
90 eclipses have been recorded under
the saros,
of which about
40 are
eclipses of
the sun,
and
50 of
the moon.
Life History of Eclipses. — As to eclipses in their relation to
the saros,
every eclipse may be said to be connected with some conspicuous character,
whether partial,
total or annular;
it has not always been so in the past,
nor will its character continue unchanged in
the indefinite future.
New and very small partial eclipses of
the sun are born at
the beginning of a new saros;
they increase in size until they become total and annular eclipses,
and then decline down their life scale as merely partial obscurations,
becoming smaller and smaller until even
the moon's periphery is obscured.
The last of these eclipse completely disappears.
For a lunar eclipse,
this long cycle embarks upon new years,
that is,
the number of returns according to
the saros is almost
50;
but solar eclipses,
for which the ecliptic limit is larger,
will return nearly yearly.
The following table shows how many eclipses occur.
Occultations of Stars and Planets by the Moon. — Closely allied to eclipses are the phenomena called occultations. When the moon comes in between two stars or planets and passes over them,
we say that it occults it.
There are but two phases,
the disappearance and the reappearance;
and in case of stars,
these phases take place with startling suddenness.
Disappearances between new and full,
and reappearance between full and new,
are very common;
but when a planet passes over a star's or limb of the moon.
When the crescent is slender,
a very small telescope is sufficient to show these interesting phenomena for the brighter stars and planets;
but for fainter objects such observations are rare and important.
Many hundreds of occultations of stars are predicted in
the Nautical Almanac each year.
Occultations of the major planets are very rare,
and some can be well seen in the United States during
the remainder of the 19th century.
310
| 310 |
Eclipses of Sun and Moon |
A total eclipse of the sun occurred in Egypt,
17th May, 1882; and reckoning forward from that date by means of
the saros, we can predict
the eclipses of 28th May,
1900, and 8th June,
1918. But only in a general way;
if the precise circumstances of
the eclipse are required,
and
the place where it is to take place,
then we must refer to
the Ephemeris,
or Nautical Almanac.
Mark
the effect
of
the one third year
in
the saros:
the eclipse at each recurrence falls visible about
120°
longitude farther than
the previous visible eclipse
in Egypt,
in
1900. In
the Atlantic Ocean,
1918 on
the Pacific Ocean,
14 years one month 1 day,
or three times
the length
of
the saros,
will therefore bring a return
of an eclipse
in very nearly
the same longitude,
but its track will be considerably changed.
For example,
the total eclipse
of
8th July,
1842,
was observed
in central Europe;
but its return,
9th August,
1866,
fell visible
in Norway.
About
90 eclipses have been recorded under
the saros,
of which about
40 are
eclipses of
the sun,
and
50 of
the moon.
Life History of Eclipses. — As to eclipses in their relation to
310
| 310 |
Eclipses of Sun and Moon |
A total eclipse of the sun occurred in Egypt,
310; and reckoning forward from that date by means of
310, we can predict
310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310; and reckoning forward from that date by means o310;
CHAPTER XIII
THE PLANETS
TETHERED by an overmastering attraction to the central and massive orb of the solar system are a multitude of bodies classified as planets. Next beyond the moon, they are nearest to us of all the heavenly spheres, and telescopes have on that account afforded astronomers much knowledge concerning them. But before presenting this we first consider their motions, and the aspects and phases which they from time to time exhibit.
**Motions — Classification — Aspects — Phases**
**Apparent Motions of the Planets.** — Watch the sky from night to night. Nearly all the bright stars, likewise the faint ones, appear to be fixed on the revolving celestial sphere; but, as they do not change their position with reference to each other. But nearly all times, one or two bright objects are visible which evidently do not belong to the great system of the stars considered as a whole; these shift their positions slowly from week to week, with reference to the fixed stars adjacent to them. The most ancient astronomers detected these apparent motions, and gave to such bodies the general name of planets; that is, wanderers. Their movements among the stars appear to be very irregular—sometimes advancing toward the east, then slowing down and finally remaining nearly stationary for different lengths of time, and again retrograding, that
311
312
The Planets
is, moving toward the west. But their advance motion always exceeds their motion westward, so that all, in greater or less intervals, journey completely round the heavens.
None of the brighter ones are ever found outside of the zodiac; in fact, Mercury, which travels nearest to the edge of this belt, is always about two moon breadths within it. A study of the apparent motions of all the planets reveals a great variety of curves. If the motions of the planets could be watched from the sun, there would be no such complication of figures; for they exist only because we observe from the earth, itself one of the planets, and continually in motion as the other sun-bound bodies are.
**Planets' Motions explained by the Epicycle.** The irregular far motions of the planets among the stars were ingeniously explained by the ancient astronomers from the time of Hipparchus (b.c. 130) onward, by means of the epicycle.
A point, which moves uniformly round the circumference of a small circle whose center travels uniformly round the periphery of a large one, is said to describe an epicycle.
The figure should make this plain : the center, c, of the small circle, called the epicycle, moves round the center f of the large circle, called the *deferent* ; and at the end of each 24th part of a revolution, it ocu-
A Planet's Motion in the Epicycle
Their Naked-eye Appearance 313
plies successively the points $t_1$, $t_2$, $t_3$, $t_4$, and so on. But while $e$ is mov-
ing to $t_1$, the point $a$ is traversing an arc of the deferent equal to $\alpha_{p_1}$. By combination of the two motions, therefore, the point $a$ will traverse the heavy curve, reaching the points indicated by $\alpha_{p_1}$, $\alpha_{p_2}$, $\alpha_{p_3}$, $\alpha_{p_4}$ when it arrives at $t_1$, $t_2$, $t_3$, and $t_4$. From $t_1$ to $t_2$, the planet will turn backward, or seem to describe its retrograde arc among the stars. By combining different rates of motion with cir-
cles of different sizes, it was found that the average movements of the planets could be represented exactly. This system, advanced by Ptolemy (A.D. 140) in his great work called the Almagest, was in vogue until overthrown by Copernicus on the publication of his great work De Revolutionibus Corporum Celestium in 1543.
Naked-eye Appearance of the Planets.—Mercury can often be seen in all latitudes of the United States by looking just above the eastern horizon before sunrise (in August, September, or October), or just above the eastern horizon after sunset (in February, March, or April). In these months Mercury's ecliptic is at a very large angle with the horizon, and Mercury will appear as a rather bright star in the twilight sky, always twinkling violently. Venus, excepting sun and moon the brightest object in the sky, is known to everybody. She is always so much brighter than any of the other planets that she cannot be mistaken—either eerily in the early mornings or westerly after sunset, according to her orbital position rela-
tively to the earth. Usually, when passing near the sun, Venus cannot be seen because the sun overpowers her rays. During periods of greatest brilliancy, however, Venus may be difficult to see because she is situated near the meridian in a clear blue sky. Many times visible, it is always distinguishable among the stars by a brownish red color. Distance from both earth and sun varies so greatly that he is sometimes very faint, and again when nearest, exceedingly bright. Jupiter comes next to Venus in order of planetary brightness. Though much less bright than Venus, he is still brighter than any fixed star. Saturn
314
The Planets
is difficult to distinguish from a star, because he shines with about the order of brightness of a first magnitude star. His light has a yellowish tinge, and by looking closely, absence of twinkling will be noticed. Unless very near the horizon, none of the planets except Mercury ever twinkle; and this simple fact helps to distinguish them from fixed stars near them. Uranus, just on the limit of visibility without the telescope may be seen during spring and summer months, if one has a keen eye and knows just where to look. Also Vesta, one of the small planets, may at favorable times be seen without a telescope. Neptune is never visible without optical aid.
Convenient Classifications of the Planets.—Neither appar- ent motion nor apparent size affords any basis for classification of the planets. But distance from the sun and size do. In order of distance, succession of the eight principal planets with their symbols is as follows, proceeding from the sun outward:
$\text{I}$. Mercury, $\text{II}$. Venus, $\text{III}$. Earth, $\text{IV}$. Mars, $\text{V}$. Jupiter,
$\text{VI}$. Saturn, $\text{VII}$. Uranus, $\text{VIII}$. Neptune. Of these, Mercury and Venus, whose orbits are within the earth's, are classified as inferior planets, and the other five from Mars to Neptune, as superior planets. In the same category would be in- cluded the ring of asteroids, or small planets, between Mars and Jupiter. The real motions of the planets round the sun are retrograde in some cases, or even east towards.
Also the planets are often conveniently classified in three distinct groups:
(I) The inner or terrestrial planets, Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars; also the unverified intermerrucian bodies.
(II) The asteroids, or small planets, sometimes called planetoids, or minor planets.
(III) The outer or major planets, Jupiter, Saturn,
Uranus, Neptune.
**Configurations of Inferior Planets** 315
In this classification the zone of asteroids forms a definite line of demarcation; but the basis is chiefly one of size, for all the terrestrial planets are very much smaller than the outer or major planets. Here may be included also the sidereal light, and the **gegenchein**, both faint, luminous areas of the nightly sky. Probably their light is mere sun-light reflected by the moon, and they are therefore not considered as planetary bodies, because, like the planets, each particle must pursue its independent orbit round the sun. All the planetary bodies of whatever kind, with the exception of our own earth, and mul- titudes of comets and meteors are often called the solar system.
**Configurations of Inferior Planets.** — In consequence of their motions round the central orb, Mercury and Venus regularly come into line with earth and sun, as illustrated in above diagram. If the planet is between us and the sun, this configuration is called **inferior conjunction**; supe- rior conjunction, when the planet is beyond that luminary. At inferior conjunction, distance from earth is least possible at superior conjunction, the greatest possible. On either side of inferior conjunction the inferior planets attain greatest brilliancy; with Mercury this occurs about three weeks, and with Venus about five weeks, preceding and following inferior conjunction. For many days near
A diagram illustrating aspects of inferior and superior planets.
The diagram shows a circular orbit around a central body (likely Earth). The innermost circle represents the orbit of Mercury. The next circle outwards represents Venus. The outermost circle represents Mars.
Labels on the diagram include:
- **QUADRATURES OF WEST**
- **QUADRATURES OF EAST**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJUNCTION**
- **CORONAL CONJunctions**
Aspects of Inferior and Superior Planets
**Aspects of Inferior and Superior Planets**
316
**The Planets**
this time, Venus is visible in the clear blue even at mid-day; but in a dark sky her radiance is almost dazzling, and with every new recurrence she deceives the uneducated afresh.
Near her western elongation, in 1878-88, many thought she was the "Star of Bethlehem," because on the night of December 25, 1878, when Venus stood high above the horizon, multitudes in New England gave credence to a newspaper story that the brilliant luminous which glorified the western sky was actually a balloon light attached to a balloon sent up by Syracuse and hauled down on the same night about 9 p.m. Venus will again attain her greatest brilliancy on 24th October, 1804, elongation east; also on 3rd January, 1859, elongation west; but what stories may then be set going is idle to surmise.
**Greatest Elongation of Inferior Planets.** — An inferior planet is at greatest elongation when its angular distance from the sun, as seen from the earth, is as great as possible. The follow ing illustrations tend to make these points clear.
The earth is at the eye of the observer, and a thin disk about 18 inches in diameter, and held about one foot from the eye, represents the plane of the orbits of the inferior planets. They travel round with the arrow shown superior conjunction when farthest away from their smallest apparent size. Coming round to greatest elongation, they are nearer and larger, and their phase is that of the quarter moon. The angle between
Inferior Planets at Greatest Elongation. East (after Sunset in Spring)
conjunction when farthest away from their smallest apparent size. Coming round to greatest elongation, they are nearer and larger, and their phase is that of the quarter moon. The angle between
**Configurations of Superior Planets** 317
Venus and the sun is then 47°. Mercury at a like phase may be as much as 28° distant; but his orbit is so eccentric that if he is near perihelion at the same time, he may be only 18° from the sun.
Passing on to inferior conjunction, the phase is a continually diminishing one, with a gradually increasing diameter, as shown. The opposite figure represents the apparent position of the or-
bits (relative to the observer) when the greatest eastern elonga-
tions occur in our springtime.
The observer is looking west
at sunset, and the planets at
elongation shine far above the
horizon in bright twilight, and
are becoming more and more
seen. When greatest elonga-
tions west of the sun occur,
one sees them rising, and for
them, before sunrise, as in the
adjacent illustration (autumn
elocation to east horizon),
the ancients called them
Venus in these two relations
was one and the same planet;
and they distinguished this
distinction of a double name,—Pho-
sphorus for the morning star, and Hesperus for the evening.
**Configurations of Superior Planets.** — By virtue of the
position of superior planets outside our orbit, they may recede as far as 180° from the sun. Being then on the opposite side of the celestial sphere they are said to be in opposition (page 315). When in this part of the zodiac with the sun, they are in conjunction. Halfway between these two configurations a superior planet is in quadrature; that is, an elongation of 90° from the sun.
Opposition, conjunction, and quadrature usually refer to
celestial longitude, nearly. Sometimes, however, it is
A diagram showing Venus and Mercury's positions relative to Earth during their respective phases.
- **Venus**: A large circle representing Venus is shown with a smaller circle inside it, indicating its phase.
- **Mercury**: A smaller circle representing Mercury is shown with a smaller circle inside it, indicating its phase.
- **Sun**: A larger circle representing the Sun is shown.
- **Earth**: A small circle representing Earth is shown.
- **Inferior Conjunction**: The text "inferior Planets at Greatest Elongation West (before Sunrise in Autumn)" is written around this configuration.
*Inferior Planets at Greatest Elongation West (before Sunrise in Autumn)*
318
The Planets
necessary to use conjunction in right ascension. Inferior planets never come to opposition or even quadrature, because their greatest elongations are much less than 90°.
The Phases of the Planets. Some of the planets, as observed with the telescope, are seen to pass through all the phases of the moon. Others are seen at times to resemble certain lunar phases; while still others have no
Phases and Apparent Size of the Planet Mercury
phase whatever.
To the first class belong the inferior planets, Mercury and Venus. On approaching inferior conjunction, their disk becomes more and more slender; they then appear of the very old crescent shape, new; while from inferior conjunction to superior conjunction, they pass through all the lunar phases from new to full.
As in the case of the moon, the horns of the crescent are always turned from the sun (toward it, as seen in the inverting telescope). When near their greatest elon-
gation, the phase of these planets is that of the moon at quarter. One of Galileo's first discoveries with the first astronomical telescope, in 1610, was the phase of Venus.
None of the superior planets can pass through all the phases of the moon, because they never can come be-
tween us and the sun.
The degree of which they do experience, however, is less in proportion to their distance beyond us is greater. Mars, then, has the greatest phase. At quadrature the planet is gibbous, about like the moon three days from full. Mars appears at maximum phase in plate vi,
page 35. But at opposition it is only half-gibbous, and does not
appear full. Some of the small planets, too, give evidence of an appreciable phase: not that it can be seen directly, for their disks are
**Retrogressive Motion**
319
too small, but by variation in the amount of their light from quadra-
ture to opposition, as Parkhurst has determined. Jupiter at quadrature
has a slight, though almost imperceptible, phase. Other exterior planets—Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune—have practically none.
Loops of the orbit of a planet are shown in the figure. The largest ellipse, $ABCD$, is the ecliptic. Intermediate ellipse is orbit of an exterior planet; and smallest ellipse is the path of earth.
To explain Formation of Loop in Exterior Planet's Path
itself. A planet when advancing always moves in direction GH. The sun is at S. When earth is successively at points marked 1, 2, 3, 4, 5,
6, 7 on its orbit, the outer planet is at the points marked 1', 2', 3', 4', 5', 6', 7'
on the middle ellipse. So that the planet is seen projected upon the sky by a line drawn through the points marked 1' to 7'. These lines intersect the zone $F_1G_1H_1$, of the celestial sphere in the points also marked upon it 1', 2', 3', 4', 5', 6', 7', and among the stars of the zodiac. Fol-
lowing them in order we see that when earth is at point 1, the planet ad-
vances from $A$ to $B$, retrogrades from $B$ to $C$, and advances again from $C$ to $D$. Also its backward motion is most rapid from $C$ to $D$,
when the planet is near opposition, and the distance from earth is
the least possible. In general, the nearer the planet to earth, the more extensive its loop.
**A Planet when Nearest Retrograde.** — First consider the inferior planets of which Venus may be taken as the type.
Fixed stars are everywhere round the outer ring, represent-
ing the zodiac (page 320). Within are two large arrows fly-
ing in the counter-clockwise direction in which the planets
really move round the sun. Earth's orbit is the outer cir-
cle in the left-hand figure, and the dotted circle within is
the orbit of Venus. As Venus moves more swiftly than
320
# The Planets
the earth does, evidently the latter may be regarded as stationary, and Venus as moving past it at the upper part of the orbit, where inferior conjunction takes place. But Venus in this position appears to move among the stars far beyond the sun, consequently her real motion forward seems to be motion backward among the stars, as indicated by
A diagram showing the apparent retrograde motion of planets. The Earth is at the center with a small circle around it representing its orbit. An arrow points to the right indicating motion forward. A larger circle represents the orbit of Venus, which is shown to be behind the Earth's orbit. Another arrow points to the left indicating motion backward. A smaller circle represents the orbit of Mars, which is shown to be ahead of the Earth's orbit. A third arrow points to the right indicating motion forward.
Inferior Planets retrograde at Inferior Conjunction
Superior Planets retrograde at Opposition
All Planets retrograde when nearest to, and advance when furthest from, the Earth
The right-hand arrow at the bottom. Next, consider the exterior planet, of which Mars may be taken as the type. In the right-hand figure, inner circle is orbit of earth, and outer, orbit of Mars; and as earth moves more swiftly than Mars, earth may be regarded as the moving body and Mars as stationary. In the upper part of the figure occurs opposition, and in the lower part retrogression. But Mars is seen among the stars above and beyond it, and evidently his apparent motion is westerly, or retrograde, in the direction of the small arrow at the top of the figure.
Thus is reached the conclusion that the **apparent motion** of all the planets, whether inferior or superior, is always retrograde when they are nearest the earth.
A Planet when Farthest Advances. — Return to the in-
Orbits of Inner Planets 321
ferior planet Venus, and the left-hand figure; when farthest she is in the lower part of her orbit, and her apparent position is among the stars still farther below, west or to the left of the sun. Advance or eastward mo- tion will continue until she is again observed among the stars. Seemingly, Venus is moving toward the sun, and will soon overtake and pass behind him. Now the exterior planet again. Assuming Mars to remain stationary in the position of the black dot in lower part of orbit, earth (in upper part of orbit, where distance between the two is nearly as great as possible) moves eastward in the direction of the arrow through it. As a consequence of this motion, then, Mars seems to travel forward on the opposite or lower side of the celestial sphere (in the direction of the white arrow along the bottom of the figure). Thus is reached the general conclusion that apparent motion of all the planets whether inferior or superior, is always retrograde when they are nearest the earth, and advance or eastward when farthest from it.
Orbits — Elements — Periods — Laws of Motion
The Four Inner or Terrestrial Planets. — On next page are charted the orbits of the four inner planets, Mercury, Venus, earth, and Mars. Observe that while Venus and the earth move in paths nearly circular, with the sun very near their center, orbits of Mercury and Mars are both eccentrically placed. So nearly circular are the orbits of all planets that, in diagrams of this character, they are indicated accurately enough by perfect circles. Orbits having a considerable degree of eccentricity are best represented by placing an ellipse on one side of their center.
The double circle outside the planetary orbits represents the ecliptic, graduated from $0^\circ$ eastward, or counter-clockwise, around to $360^\circ$ of
TODD'S ASTRON. - 21
322
The Planets
longitude, according to the signs of the zodiac, as indicated; the vernal equinox, or the first point of the sign Aries corresponding to 0°.
Small black dots on each orbit represent positions of the planets at intervals of ten days, zero for each planet being at longitude 180°. All the planets travel round the sun eastward, or counter-clockwise, as
Orbits and Heliocentric Movements of the Four Terrestrial Planets
Indicated by arrows. In order to find the distance of any planet from earth, or from any other at any time, first find the position of the two planets in question on the chart, and then draw a line through them given for each planet on the left-hand side of the chart, at longitude 180°. Then with a pair of dividers the distance of the planets may be found from this line.
The Four Outer and Major Planets. — Opposite is a chart of the orbits of the four outer planets, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune. Ob-
True Form of Planetary Orbits 323
serve that these orbits are all sensibly circular and concentric, except that of Uranus, the center of which is slightly displaced from the sun.
The double outer circle represents the ecliptic, the same as in the diagram on the opposite page. The small black dots on the orbits of Jupiter and Saturn represent the positions of these planets at intervals
A diagram showing the true form of planetary orbits. The outermost circle represents the ecliptic. The innermost circle shows the positions of the four major planets (Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune) at different intervals. The positions of these planets are indicated by small black dots on the innermost circle.
Orbits and Heliocentric Movements of the Four Greater Planets
a year in length; and similarly, the positions of Uranus and Neptune are indicated at 10-year intervals; the zero in every case being coincident with the position of the earth at the beginning of each century. Each other, or from the earth at any time, may be found in the same way as described on the opposite page for the inner planets.
True Form of the Planetary Orbits. — Were it possible to transport our observatory and telescope from earth to
4
324
**The Planets**
each of the planets in turn, and then repeat the mea-
sures of the sun's diameter with great refinement, just as
we did from the earth (page 136), we should reach a result
precisely similar in every case. So the conclusion is, that
the orbits of all the planets are ellipses, so situated in
A diagram showing the orbits of Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune. The orbits are shown as ellipses with the Sun at one focus. The diagram also shows the ecliptic plane and the line of nodes.
Planetary Orbits having Greater Inclinations to the Ecliptic
space that the sun occupies one of the foci of each ellipse.
None of them would lie in the same plane that the earth
does, but each planet would have an elliptic of its own, in
the plane of which its orbit would be situated.
**Inclination and Line of Nodes.** — The orbits of all the
great planets, except Mercury, Venus, and Saturn, are
inclined to the ecliptic less than $2^\circ$. Saturn's inclination
is $24^\circ$, that of Venus $38^\circ$, and Mercury's $7^\circ$, as in the dia-
gram. Orbits of the small planets stand at much greater
angles; six are inclined more than $25^\circ$, and the average
of the group is about $8^\circ$. The two opposite points where
a planet's orbit cuts the ecliptic are called its **nodes**.
**Eccentricity of their Orbits.** — The eccentricity of Mer-
cury is $\frac{1}{2}$, of Mars $\frac{1}{2}$, of Jupiter $\frac{1}{2}$, of Saturn about
$\frac{1}{2}$, and of Uranus and Neptune very slight. The chief
effect of the eccentricity is to change a planet's distance
from the sun, between perihelion and aphelion; and to
vary the speed of revolution in orbit. At top of next
page are eccentricities of the planetary orbits, together
with total variation of distance due to eccentricity.
Some of the small planets have an eccentricity more than double
that of Mercury even, so that their perihelion point is near the orbit
of Mars, while at aphelion they wander well out toward the path of
ECLIPTIC PLANE
Mercury Venus Earth Mars Jupiter Saturn Neptune
Synodic Periods 325
ECCENTRICITY AND VARIATION OF DISTANCE FROM THE SUN
| Eccentricity |
Change of Distance due to Eccentricity |
Eccentricity |
Change of Distance due to Eccentricity |
| Mercury |
0.2056 |
15 Millions |
Jupiter |
0.0482 |
47 Millions |
| Venus |
0.0068 |
1 of Urans, 0.0561 of Neptune |
Saturn |
0.0561 |
90 miles of Neptune, 0.0096 miles |
| Mars |
0.0933 |
26 miles |
Uranus |
0.0464 |
49 miles |
Jupiter. The average eccentricity of their orbits is excessive, being about equal to that of Mercury. The path of Andromache (172) is very like the orbit of Tempe's comet (page 40).
Synodic Periods.—Just as with the moon, so each planet has two kinds of period—(a) the planet's sidereal period in which it revolves while it is journeying once completely round the ecliptic, setting out from conjunction with some fixed star and returning again to it. If during this interval the earth remained stationary as related to the sun, the times occupied by the planets in traversing the round of the ecliptic would be their true sidereal periods.
But our continual eastward motion, and the apparent motion of sun in same direction, makes it necessary to take account of a second period of revolution—the synodic period, or interval between successive conjunctions. If a superior planet, the average interval between oppositions is also the synodic period. Following are the Synodic Periods.
| The Terrestrial Planets |
The Major Planets |
| Mercury |
126 days |
Jupiter. |
399 days |
| Venus |
584 days |
Saturn. |
378 days |
| Mars |
780 days |
Uranus. |
376 days |
|
|
Neptune. |
368 days |
326
The Planets
The exceptional length of the synodic periods of Venus and Mars is due to the fact that their average daily motion is more nearly that of the earth than is the case with any of the other planets.
Sidereal Periods or Periodic Times.—As our earth is a moving observatory, it is impossible for us to determine the sidereal periods of the planets directly from observation. But their synodic periods may be so found; and from them the true or sidereal periods are ascertained by calculation, involving only the relation of the earth's (or sun's apparent) motion to that of the planet. They are as follows:
| The Terrestrial Planets |
|
The Major Planets |
|
| Mercury |
88 days |
Jupiter |
11½ years |
| Venus |
225 days |
Saturn |
20½ years |
| The Earth |
365 days |
Uranus |
8½ years |
| Mars |
687 days |
Neptune |
16½ years |
Periodic times of the small planets range between three and nine years.
Kepler's Laws.—Kepler, to whom the motions of the planets were a mystery, nevertheless had discovered in 1619 three laws governing their motions. (I) The orbit of every planet is elliptical in form, and the sun is situated at one of the foci of the ellipse. (II) The motion of the radius vector, or line joining the planet to the sun, is such that it sweeps over equal areas of the plane in equal times. (III) The squares of the periodic times of the planets are proportional to the cubes of their average distances from the sun. Kepler was unable to give any physical explanation of these laws. He merely ascertained that all the planets appear to move in accordance with them.
Distances of Planets from Sun 327
Verification of Kepler's Third Law — A half hour's calculation suffices to prove the truth of this law. The results are shown in the last column of the following table, where the number in each line was obtained by dividing the square of the planet's periodic time by the cube of its mean distance from the sun.
| Name of Planet |
Periodic Time (in Days) |
Mean Distance (Earth's Distance × 1) |
[Time]² / [Distance]³ |
| Mercury |
87.97 |
0.387 |
132-414 |
| Venus |
242.70 |
0.7313 |
133-430 |
| Earth |
365.26 |
1.0000 |
135-415 |
| Mars |
686.95 |
1.2317 |
135-400 |
| Ceres |
1681.41 |
2.7673 |
135-408 |
| Jupiter |
4323.58 |
5.2028 |
135-472 |
| Saturn |
10759.23 |
9.3388 |
135-400 |
| Uranus |
19889.89 |
19.5213 |
135-410 |
| Neptune |
60811.17 |
30.0511 |
135-403 |
The third law of Kepler, often called the 'harmonic law', is rigorously exact, only upon the theory that planets are mere particles, or exceedingly small masses relatively to the sun. On this account the discrepancy in the case of Jupiter, and in quite large, in the case of Neptune, because his mass is nearly zero than that of the sun.
**Mean Distances of the Planets.** — Kepler's third law enables us to calculate a planet's average distance from the sun, once its time of revolution is known : for regarding the earth's period of revolution as unity (one year), and our distance from the sun as unity, it is only necessary to square the planet's time of revolution, extract the cube root of the result, and we have the planet's mean distance from the sun. For example, the periodic time of Uranus is 84 years ; its square is 7056 ; the cube root of which is 19.18. That is, the mean distance of Uranus from the sun is 19.18 times our own distance from that central luminary.
328
The Planets
Its distance in miles, then, will be 19.18 x 93,000,000. In like manner may be found the distances of all the other planets from the sun; and they are as follows:
MEAN DISTANCE FROM THE SUN
| THE THREEIRURAL PLANETS |
THE MAJOR PLANETS |
| Mercury |
36 |
Jupiter |
483 |
| Venus |
671 |
Millions |
Millions |
| The Earth |
93 |
Saturn |
886 |
| Mars |
141 |
of Uranus |
1780 |
|
|
Neptune |
2790 |
| Mercury |
36 |
Jupiter |
483 |
| Venus |
671 |
Millions |
Millions |
| The Earth |
93 |
Saturn |
886 |
| Mars |
141 |
of Uranus |
1780 |
|
|
Neptune |
2790 |
These distances are all represented in true relative proportion in the figure on page 334. Scattered over a zone about 280 millions of miles broad, or $\frac{1}{2}$ of the distance separating Mars from Jupiter, is the ring of small planets, or asteroids probably many thousand in number, of which nearly 500 have already been discovered.
**The Nearest and Farthest Planets.** — Mars is often said to be the nearest of all the planets because his orbit is so eccentric that favorable oppositions, shown later in the chapter, occur at intervals of more than two cycles of the earth. But Venus comes even nearer than that. Her distance from the sun subtracted from ours gives 26,000,000 miles for the average distance of Venus from the earth at inferior conjunctions; and Venus may approach almost 2,000,000 miles nearer than this, if conjunction comes in December or January, near earth's perihelion. But we must not think of Venus as being proportionately easier to observe, because so much nearer. It might even be said that the nearer Venus comes, the more difficult she is to observe, because she is then nearly in line with the sun, whose brightness diffused through our atmosphere
Elements of Planetary Orbits 329
sets a serious barrier to thorough knowledge of her surface.
Of the known planets the farthest from the earth is Neptune. So far away is he that we must multiply the least distance of Venus more than a hundredfold in order to obtain the distance of Neptune from the earth.
Aberration Time.—Knowing the velocity of light by experiment, and knowing the time required for light to travel from us, it is easy to calculate the time consumed by light in traveling from any planet to the earth. So distant is Neptune, for example, that light takes about 4½ hours to reach us. The ratio between this quantity and the planet's aberration time, or the equation of light, its value in seconds for any planet is equal to 499 times the planet's distance from the earth (expressed in astronomical units).
Newton's Law of Gravitation.—Sir Isaac Newton about 1675 simplified the three laws of motion of the planets into a single law, hence known as the Newtonian law of gravitation. It has two parts of which the first is this: that every particle of matter in the universe attracts every other particle exactly in proportion to their masses; and second, that the amount of this attraction increases in proportion as the square of the distance between the bodies decreases. That Kepler's three laws are embraced in this one simple law of Newton may be shown by a mathematical demonstration. With a few trifling exceptions, all the bodies of the solar system move in exact accordance with Newton's law, whether planets themselves, their satellites, or the comets and meteors. Newton's law is often called "The Law of Universal Gravitation," because it appears to hold good in stellar space as well as in the solar system.
Elements of Planetary Orbits.—The mathematical quantities which determine the motion of a celestial body are called the elements of its orbit. They are six in number, and they define the size of the orbit, its shape, and its relation to the circles and points of the celestial sphere.
330
The Planets
(1) $a$ Mean distance, or half the major axis of the ellipse in which the planet moves round the sun.
(2) $e$ Eccentricity, or ratio of distance between center and focus of ellipse to the mean distance.
(3) $\Omega$ Longitude of ascending node, or arc of great circle between this node and the vernal equinox.
(4) $i$ Inclination of plane of orbit to ecliptic.
(5) $\omega$ Longitude of perihelion, or angle between line of apsides and the vernal equinox.
(6) $e$ Longitude of the planet at some definite instant, often technically called the epoch.
Once the exact elements of an orbit are found, the undis- turbed motion of the body in that orbit can be predicted, and its position calculated for any past or future time.
Secular Variations of the Elements. About a century ago, two French mathematicians, Lagrange and Laplace, made an important discovery that the action of gravitation among the planets can never change the size of their orbits; that is, the element $a$, or the mean distance, always remains the same. As for the other elements affecting the shape of the orbit and its position in space, they can only oscillate harmlessly between certain narrow limits in very long periods of time. These slow and minute fluctuations of the elements are called secular variations; and they may be roughly represented by holding a flexible and nearly circular hoop between the hands, and allowing it to compress slightly, also wobbling it a little, and at the same time allowing it to move one about the other. The oscillatory character of the secular variations secures the permanence and stability of our solar system, so long as it is not subjected to perturbing or destructive influences from without. One who really wishes fully to understand these complicated rela-
A diagram showing a flexible hoop being held between two hands.
Variation in Apparent Size
331
tions must undertake an extended course of mathematical study — the only master key to complete knowledge of the planetary motions.
Colors — Albedo — Bode's Law — Relative Distances
A Planet when Nearest looks Largest. — In proportion as a planet comes nearer to us, its apparent disk fills a
Variation in Apparent Size of Mars
Variation in Apparent Size of Mars
larger angle in the telescope. The two planets, then, nearest the earth, Venus within our orbit, and Mars without, must undergo the greatest changes in apparent diameter, because their greatest distance is many times their least. Mars, at nearest to the earth, is 35,000,000 miles away; at farthest, more than seven times as distant.
The seeming variation in size is shown in above figure. The next greatest variation is exhibited by Venus (lower figure) at superior conjunctions she seems to be only one sixth as large as at inferior conjunction.
The figure illustrates not only this marked increase of her diameter as she comes toward us, but her phases also. Third in order is Mercury,
Variation in Apparent Size of Venus
Variation in Apparent Size of Venus
332
The Planets
whose diameters at greatest and least distance are about as 1 to 3 (already shown on page 318). And following Mercury is Jupiter, whose variations are but slight; then comes Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune, too, show fluctuations of the same character, but much less, because of their very great distance from us. From this it appears that the apparent breadth of Saturn increases only about one third ; while the similar increase of Uranus and Neptune is so slight that a micrometer is necessary to measure it.
Variation in Apparent Size of Jupiter
Colors of the Planets. — All the planets vary in brightness according to their distance from the sun and from each other. Those which shine with an average brightness exceeding that of a first magnitude star. Of these, Venus is by far the brightest, and Jupiter next, the others following in the order Mars, Mercury, and Saturn. Uranus is a little brighter than Saturn, and Neptune a little fainter. A few of the small planets approach this limit when near opposition. But Neptune's vast distance from both sun and earth renders him as faint as an eighth magnitude star, so that he is invisible without at least a small telescope. The moon is visible whenever it is
Mercury, pale ash;
Venus, brilliant straw ;
Mars, reddish ochre;
Jupiter, bright silver;
Saturn, deep green;
Uranus, pale green;
Neptune, the same.
The entire significance of these colors is not yet known; but apparently they are indicative as to degree and composition of atmosphere respectively.
Albedo of the Planets. — Albedo is a term used to express the capacity of a surface, like that of a planet, to reflect light. It is a number expressing the ratio of the amount of light reflected from a surface to the amount falling upon it. When measured by means of a spectroscope with a photometer, it can be compared with a star or another planet, and its albedo found by computation. The moon's surface reflects about 4 the light falling upon it from the sun. The albedo of Mercury is even less, or 1 ; but the surface of Venus is highly reflective, its albedo
Distances and Motions
333
being 1. The albedo of Mars is about 1; that of Saturn and Neptune, about the same as Venus; while the albedo of Jupiter and Uranus is the highest of all the planets, or nearly 1. This means that their sur-
faces reflect about four times as much light as sandstones do.
The So-called Law of the Planets, which gives what approxi-
mately we mean by the relative distances of the planets from the sun. It
is derived in this way. Write this simple series of numbers, in which
each except the second is double the one before it:
| o |
3 |
6 |
12 |
24 |
48 |
96 |
| Add 4 to each, giving |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 4 |
7 |
10 |
16 |
28 |
52 |
100 |
The actual distances of the planets known in the time of Titius
(1760) are as follows (the earth's distance being represented by 10):
| 39 |
7.2 |
10 |
15.3 |
23.0 |
35.4 |
55.2 |
| 8 |
9.6 |
12 |
18.4 |
27.6 |
40.8 |
65.4 |
| 9 |
12.0 |
15.0 |
22.5 |
33.0 |
48.0 |
75.0 |
| 10 |
15.0 |
20.0 |
30.0 |
45.0 |
65.0 |
100.0 |
| 11 |
18.0 |
25.0 |
37.5 |
55.0 |
82.5 | ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
Although the law is by no means exact, Bode, a distinguished Ger-
man astronomer, promulgated it. On that account it is always called
Bode's law, though it was first proposed by Kepler, who gave it little
importance; for its error, when extended to the outer planets, Uranus
and Neptune, is even greater than in the case of Saturn. But by direct-
ing attention to the fact that Mercury is nearest to the sun, and Jupiter
and Bode's law led to telescopic search for a supposed missing body;
a search speedily rewarded by discovery of the first four small planets,
i., Ceres, n., Pallas, n., Juno, and n., Venus.
Relative sizes of these bodies have been found by measuring the distances of the
planets have been found, measures of their disks with the telescope en-
able us to calculate their true dimensions. One need not try to improve upon Sir William Herschel's estimate of the size of Jupiter; but his
motions in the solar system.
Choose any well-leafed field or bowling green.
On it place a globe two feet in diameter; this will represent the
sun; Mercury will be represented by a grain of mustard seed on
the circumference; Venus will be represented by a pea on a circle of
384 feet in diameter; the earth also a pea, on a circle of 430 feet; Mars a rather large pin's head; the moon a circle of 64 feet; the
interior of a large apple; Saturn a large orange; Jupiter a large orange;
a moderate-sized orange, in a circle nearly half a mile across; Saturn a
small orange, on a circle of four fifths of a mile; Uranus a full-sized
cherry or small plum upon the circumference on which that is
mile and half and Neptune a good sized apple, on a circle about two
miles and a half in diameter . . . . To imitate the motions of the
334
The Planets
planets, in the above-mentioned orbits, Mercury must describe its own diameter in 41 seconds; Venus, in 4 m. 14 s.; the earth, in 7 m.; Mars, in 4 m. 48 s.; Jupiter, in 2 h. 56 m.; Saturn, in 3 h. 10 m.; Uranus, in 3 h. 20 m.; Neptune, in 3 h. 25 m. A farther and helpful idea of relative motion of the planets may be obtained from the fig. on page 335, where the distance of each planet from the sun is taken as the unit. While he is moving 600, that is in 88 days, the other planets move over the arcs set down opposite their distance from the sun. This shows how much more slowly Neptune moves decreases on proceeding outward from the sun. If Neptune moves as an athlete runs, Mercury speeds round with the celerity of a modern locomotive.
Sizes — Masses — Axial Rotation — Tidal Evolution
The Size of the Planets. — Regarding the group of small planets as a dividing line in the solar system, all planets inside that group are, as previously said, relatively small, and all outside it large. The illustration on next page serves to show this well, presenting not only the relative sizes but also the comparative values of their diameters to the sun's. More particularly the mean diameters are:
|
Mercury, |
3,000 miles |
| Inner Terrestrial Planets |
Venus, |
7,700 miles |
|
Earth, |
7,920 miles |
|
Mars, |
4,200 miles |
Group of small planets : Ceres the largest, 490 miles in diameter.
|
Jupiter, |
87,000 miles |
| Outer Major Planets |
Saturn, |
71,000 miles |
|
Uranus, |
31,700 miles |
|
Neptune, |
34,500 miles |
Relative Distances and Orbital Motions of the Planets
Their Masses and Densities 335
Other small planets whose diameters have been measured (by Bar-
nard) are Pallas, 300 miles; Juno, 120 miles; Vesta, 250 miles. Prob-
ably none of the others are as
large as Juno, and the average of
recent faint discoveries cannot ex-
ceed 20 miles.
Masses and Densities of Planets.--Just by comparison can some idea of the masses
of the planets be conveyed. Relative
weights of common things are helpful, and
sufficiently precise. Let an ordinary bronze
cent give us a standard weight. Mercury
and Mars that we have no coin
light enough to compare with them ; but
those two planets together weigh more than
one, might be well represented by an old-
fashioned silver threepence piece; Venus,
by a silver dollar. Uranus, a silver dollar,
half dollar, and quarter together; Neptune,
two silver dollars; Saturn, eleven silver dol-
lars; and Jupiter, thirty-seven silver dollars
rather than one hundred and twenty cents.
An inconveniently large sum of silver would be required if this comparison were to be
carried out on the same scale as that for
he is nearly 750 times more massive than all the planets and their satellites together,
and, on the same scale of comparison, he would weigh about 18 tons instead of a
long ton. In striking contrast with this vast and weighty globe are the tiny asteroids,
a lightness which is only equalled by the
moon. The moon is estimated to have a mass of only $1/6$ that of our earth. If we derive the densities of
planets from their masses and diameters, as we have done for the earth, we find that Mercury is the densest of all (one fifth denser than the earth).
Venus, Earth, and Mars come next, the last
A diagram showing the relative sizes of planets on a scale where their diameters are equal to the length of the cut. Mercury is shown at the top left, followed by Venus, Earth, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and finally Neptune at the bottom right.
Relative Sizes of Planets (Planets Diameter on Same Scale equal Length of Cut)
Mercury (actual size)
Venus (actual size)
Earth (actual size)
Mars (actual size)
Jupiter (actual size)
Saturn (actual size)
Uranus (actual size)
Neptune (actual size)
Mercury (standardized)
Venus (standardized)
Earth (standardized)
Mars (standardized)
Jupiter (standardized)
Saturn (standardized)
Uranus (standardized)
Neptune (standardized)
Mercury (actual size)
Venus (actual size)
Earth (actual size)
Mars (actual size)
Jupiter (actual size)
Saturn (actual size)
Uranus (actual size)
Neptune (actual size)
Mercury (standardized)
Venus (standardized)
Earth (standardized)
Mars (standardized)
Jupiter (standardized)
Saturn (standardized)
Uranus (standardized)
Neptune (standardized)
Mercury (actual size)
Venus (actual size)
Earth (actual size)
Mars (actual size)
Jupiter (actual size)
Saturn (actual size)
Uranus (actual size)
Neptune (actual size)
Mercury (standardized)
Venus (standardized)
Earth (standardized)
Mars (standardized)
Jupiter (standardized)
Saturn (standardized)
Uranus (standardized)
Neptune (standardized)
Mercury (actual size)
Venus (actual size)
Earth (actual size)
Mars (actual size)
Jupiter (actual size)
Saturn (actual size)
Uranus (actual size)
Neptune (actual size)
Mercury (standardized)
Venus (standardized)
Earth (standardized)
Mars (standardized)
Jupiter (standardized)
Saturn (standardized)
Uranus (standardized)
Neptune (standardized)
Mercury (actual size)
Venus (actual size)
Earth (actual size)
Mars (actual size)
Jupiter (actual size)
Saturn (actual size)
Uranus (actual size)
Neptune (actual size)
Mercury (standardized)
Venus (standardized)
Earth (standardized)
Mars (standardized)
Jupiter (standardized)
Saturn (standardized)
336
The Planets
a quarter less dense than our globe. Three of the major planets have about the same density as the sun himself; that is, only one fourth part that of the earth. Saturn's mean density is the least of all, only one eighth that of our globe.
**Center of Gravity of the Sun and Jupiter.** — Though the sun's mass is vastly greater than that of his entire retinue of planets put together, he is nevertheless forced appreciably out of the position he would otherwise occupy by the powerful attraction of the giant planet whose mass is $\frac{1}{1047}$ his own. It is easy to calculate how much, for the sun and Jupiter revolve round their common center of gravity, except as at the two vast globes $S$ and $J$, were connected by a rigid rod of steel, but as $S$ weighs 1047 times as much as $J$, the center of gravity of the system is $\frac{1}{1048}$ of the distance between the centers of $S$ and $J$. Now as Jupiter in perihelion makes this distance 460,000,000 miles, the center of gravity is displaced from $S$ toward $J$ 440,000 miles. But the radius of the sun is 433,000 miles; so the center of gravity of the Sun-Jupiter system is never less than 7000 miles outside the solar orb. And this distance becomes greater as Jupiter recedes to his aphelion.
**Axial Rotation of the Planets.** — The giant planet turns most slowly on his axis, for the average period of rotation of the white belt girdling his equator is only 9 h. 54 m. But, like the sun, his zones in different latitudes revolve in different periods, the average of which is about 9 h. 54 m. The period of revolution of the great red spot averages 9 h. 55 m. 39 s. Saturn, too, exhibits similar discrepancies, but the white spots of its equatorial belts gave, in 1863, a period of 10 h. 12 m. 53 s. There are indications that the
A diagram showing the positions of S (Sun) and J (Jupiter) with respect to each other and their centers of gravity.
Source: Wikipedia
Their Librations
337
axial period of Uranus is about the same; but that of Neptune is unknown. Next in order of length is Mars, whose day is equal to 24 h. 37 m. 22.7 s., a constant known with great precision, because it has been determined by observing its eclipsings upon the surface, and the whole number of revolutions made by it. These occur our earth with its day at 23 h. 56 m. 09 s.; following, though at a long distance, are Mercury and Venus, which turn round but once on their axes while going once round the sun. The axial period (sidereal) of the former, then is 88 days; and of the latter, 225 days,—the longest known in the solar system. Her solar day, therefore, is infinite in duration, and her year and sidereal day are equal in length. This equality of periods, in both Mercury and Venus, was undoubtedly effected early in their life history, through the agency of friction of some sun-raised tides in their masses, then plastic.
Ellipticity and Axial Inclination of the Planets.—The disks of many of the planets do not appear perfectly circular, but exhibit a degree of ellipticity. This is due partly to the rotation about their axes, the centrifugal force producing an equatorial bulge. In the case of Jupiter and Saturn, it is so marked as to attract immediate attention except in the case of the Earth. The eccentricity of the orbiting of Saturn's ball is (page 367), of Uranus $j_1$, and of Jupiter $j_1$ (page 363), these planets being exceptionally large, and their axial rotation relatively slow. Next come Mars, whose polar flattening is 0.00066 by the earth's axis. The other four great planets, of the satellites, and of the sun itself, is so small as to escape detection. Inclination of planetary equator to plane of orbit round the sun is excessive in all four cases; probably in Neptune ; has a medium value (about 3°) for the earth, Mars and Saturn; and is very slight for all the other three great planets.
Librations of the Planets.—There are librations of planets, just as there are librations of the moon. But the only planetary libration we need to consider is libration in longitude. This is due to the fact that, while the planet
TODD'S ASTRON.-- 22
338
**The Planets**
turns with perfect uniformity on its axis, its revolution in orbit is swifter near perihelion, and slower near aphelion than the average. The amount of a planet's libration in longitude, therefore, will depend upon the degree of eccentricity of its orbit; and it must be taken into account in finding the true period of the planet's day.
Mercury's libration is the greatest of all. His average daily angle of rotation is about 4°; but at perihelion he moves round the sun more than 6°, and at aphelion rather less than 9° daily. The effect of libration is an apparent oscillation of the disk, alternately to the east and west. Since Mercury's orbit is nearly circular, his angular velocity gains about 2° each day on the axis of axial turning; the amount of gain constantly diminishing, until nearly three weeks past perihelion. Mercury's libration is thus greater than that of any other planet at the center of the disk. In the opposite part of his orbit, the disk seems to swing as much in the opposite direction, making thus the extent of the angle of Mercury's libration equal to 47°. On ⅔ of his surface the sun shines, and on ⅓ it is dark; on ⅔ it is generally shining, and on ⅓ it is alternate sunshine and shadow. So, too, on Mars, there is an apparent libration of center of the disk, though no such oscillation can be observed by eye. On Venus' equatorial plane, and the sun shines on every part of the surface, because the rotation and revolution periods of Mars are not equal. Still less are the librations of Jupiter and Saturn, their eccentricity of orbit being only about half that of Mars.
**Tidal Evolution.** — By tidal evolution is meant the distinct role played by tides in the progressive development of worlds. The term tide is here used, not in its common or restricted sense applying to waters of the ocean but to that periodic elevation or plastic motion of a world in its early stages, occasioned by gravitation of an exterior mass. Newton's law of gravitation first gave a full explanation of the rising and falling of ocean tides, but as applied to motions of planets, it presupposed that all these bodies were rigid. In 1877, George Darwin, in a series of elaborate mathematical papers, showed the effect of gravitation upon these masses in earlier stages of their history, when,
A diagram showing a rotating planet with a moon orbiting around it.
Transits of Inferior Planets 339
according to the nebular hypothesis, they were not rigid, but composed of yielding material. Ocean tides are raised at the gradual, though almost inappreciable, expense of earth's energy of rotation. In like manner, early raised tides in the youthful moon continued to check its axial rotation until that effect was completely exhausted, and the moon has never since turned on its axis relatively to the earth. Evidently this effect of tidal friction has been operant in the case of sun-raised tides upon the planets, — more powerfully if the planet is nearer the sun; less powerfully if its mass is great; also less powerfully if its materials have early become solidified on account of the planet's small size. Combination of these conditions explains the long periods of rotation of the planets.
Mercury and Venus strongly acted upon by the sun, so that they now and for some time turn their constant face toward him; earth, also probably Mars, even yet suffering a very slight lengthening of their day; Jupiter and Saturn, also probably Uranus and Neptune, still endowed with swift axial rotation, because of (1) their massiveness, and (2) their vast distance from the center of attraction.
Transits—Satellites—Atmospheres—Surfaces
**Transit of Inferior Planets.** — If either Mercury or Venus at inferior conjunction is near the node of the orbit, the planet can be seen to pass across the sun like a round black spot. This is called a transit. About 13 transits of Mercury take place every century, the shortest interval being 34 years, and the longest 13. They can happen only in the early part of May and November, because the earth is then near the nodes of Mercury's orbit. There are about twice as many transits in November as in May, because Mercury's least distance from the sun falls near
340
The Planets
the November node. Transits of Venus occur in pairs, eight years apart; and the intervals between the midway points of the pairs are alternately 1111 and 1293 years. June and December are the only possible months for their occurrence. A June pair one century will be followed by a December pair in the next. Both Mercury and Venus at transit, being then nearest the earth, their apparent motion is westerly or retrograde. Consequently a transit always begins on the east side of the sun. Duration of transit varies with the part of the disk upon which the planet seems to be projected, whether north or south of the center or directly over the middle.
A diagram showing three phases of contact during a transit of Venus. The leftmost circle represents the Earth's shadow, the middle circle represents Venus, and the rightmost circle represents the Sun. The first phase (I) shows Venus just beginning to enter the Earth's shadow. The second phase (II) shows Venus fully within the Earth's shadow. The third phase (III) shows Venus emerging from the Earth's shadow.
Contacts at Ingress and Egress. — Hold the book up south. The white arc in the figure adjacent to the Sun represents the edge of the sun, upon which the planet enters at ingress, or beginning of transit, as seen in an ordinary telescope. The black arc in the figure shows the phase called external contact. Actual geometric contact cannot be observed, because it is impossible to see through its shadow into its light. It is a slight notch into the sun's limb. The observer catches sight of this as soon as possible after ingress, before any sign of external contact. The planet then moves along to the left, until it reaches the phase shown in II, when it is in direct external contact. The observer must then watch intently the bright horn, which will soon close in rapidly toward each other, and finally a narrow filament of light will shoot quickly across and join with another similar filament coming from the opposite side at 12 o'clock. After a few seconds the planet will have advanced to III, well within the limits of the sun. Then there will be little to observe until the planet has crossed out of sight. This is about to precede the phases of egress. These will be exactly similar to those of ingress but will take place in reverse order. The atmosphere of Venus (page
Transits of Mercury
341
3.8) complicates observations of these contacts, and they cannot be observed within two or three seconds of time.
Past and Future Transits of Mercury. — Cassini made the first observation of a transit of Mercury in 1671. The annexed engraving shows the paths of Mercury during all transits from 1808 to 1954.
A diagram showing the paths of Mercury during various transits. The circle represents the disk of the sun; near the top is north, and below the right side west. The broken line is part of the ecliptic. Consider first the November transits. Their dates are: 5th November, 1808 ; 6th November, 1907 ; 6th November, 1914. Mercury is then near ascending node; and the paths of these transits are drawn at an ascending angle of about 7° to the ecliptic. The dotted lines show positions at half-hour intervals. Dots on these paths show positions at half-hour intervals. Observe how far apart they are. This is because Mercury is near perihelion, where it moves very rapidly around the sun. Next, consider the May transits. They are shown here for the same interval, and their dates are: 6th May, 1878; 9th May, 1891; 7th
Paths of Transits of Mercury at Ascending and Descending Nodes
The circle represents the disk of the sun; near the top is north, and below the right side west. The broken line is part of the ecliptic. Consider first the November transits. Their dates are: 5th November, 1808 ; 6th November, 1907 ; 6th November, 1914. Mercury is then near ascending node; and the paths of these transits are drawn at an ascending angle of about 7° to the ecliptic. The dotted lines show positions at half-hour intervals. Dots on these paths show positions at half-hour intervals. Observe how far apart they are. This is because Mercury is near perihelion, where it moves very rapidly around the sun. Next, consider the May transits. They are shown here for the same interval, and their dates are: 6th May, 1878; 9th May, 1891; 7th
342
**The Planets**
May, 1794. They occur near Mercury's descending node, as shown, that of 1794 being nearly central because Mercury happens to come to inferior conjunction with the earth, at very nearly the time of reaching its node. The transit of Venus is therefore a transit of inferior transits, because Mercury is near aphelion, and consequently his motion is as slow as possible. The greatest length of a transit of Mercury is 7 hours 5 minutes, and that of Venus 6 hours 30 minutes.
Past and Future Transits of Venus. — Jeremiah Horrocks made the first observation of a transit of Venus in 1639. Nearly every century witnesses a pair of these transits. Below are four disks representing
A diagram showing the paths of transits of Venus at ascending and descending nodes.
Paths of Transits of Venus at Ascending and Descending Nodes
the sun; and upon them are indicated apparent paths of Venus, for all transits occurring in the 17th to the 21st centuries inclusive. In each case the top of the disk is north, and the bottom-hand side west. The dots show the times of occurrence, intervals of fifteen minutes. Pairs of transits take place at average intervals of 11 centuries; so there will be no transit of Venus in the 20th century.
| DATES OF TRANSITS OF VENUS |
| AT THE ASCENDING NODE |
AT THE DESCENDING NODE |
| 1631, December 7 |
1765, June 5 |
| 1639, December 4 |
1769, June 3 |
| 1824, December 9 |
2004, June 8 |
| 1828, December 6 |
2012, June 6 |
As is evident from the figure, a pair of transits at ascending node (1631 and 1639) is followed by a pair at descending node (1767 and 1769), and so on alternately. Southern transits at ascending node (1639 and 1882) are followed by southern transits at descending node
Their Satellites 343
(1761 and 2004); and a northern transit at descending node (1769) is followed by a northern transit at ascending node. Rows of black dots in contact with each other indicate the chord of the sun's disk traversed at each transit. The shortest possible length of a transit of Venus is 7 h. 58 m., and the shortest one ever observed was that of 1874. Transits of Venus are phe-
nomena of great interest to astronomers, because they enable the planet to produce a large effect of parallax. By measuring it, her dis-
tance from the earth is found. This tells us the scale on which the solar system is built, including therefore the length of the unit in astronomical measure. The first two transits of Venus were observed in 1761 and 1769. The third was in 1874, and the fourth in 1882. The
transits of 1769 and 1882 were visible in the United States. Those of 1874 and 1882 were extensively observed by costly expeditions under the auspices of the principal governments.
Satellites of the Planets
**Satellites of the Terrestrial Planets.** — The solar system has this curious and interesting feature, that most of its chief planets are accompanied by moons or satellites.
Twenty-one are now known. No satellite has yet been discovered belonging to either of the inferior planets.
There have, however, been many spurious observations of a supposed satellite of Venus. Our earth has but one.
Mars has two satellites, discovered by Hall in 1877. They are about seven miles in diameter, and can be seen only by large telescopes. Their condition is such that the inner moon of Mars, is less than 400 miles from the planet's surface, and travels round in 7 h. 39 m., a period less than one third that of Mars' rotation. To an observer on the planet, Phobos must, therefore, seem to rise in the west and set in the east. Its horizontal parallax is enormous, being $21^{\circ}$. The outer moon, Deimos, is rather more than 12,000 miles from the surface of Mars, and its periodic time is 30 h. 18 m. As at the planet's day is 24 h 37 m., Deimos must consume, allowing for parallax, about $\frac{2}{3}$ days in leisurely circuiting the Arcan sky from horizon to horizon.
344
**The Planets**
**Satellites of the Major Planets.** — Jupiter, has five moons, the fifth or innermost discovered only in 1892 by Barnard. The four large ones were discovered by Galileo in 1610 with the first telescope ever used astronomically. The orbits of Jupiter's moons lying nearly in the ecliptic are always seen edgewise, or very nearly, so that the satellites in traveling round the primary seem merely to oscillate forth and back, just as the pedals of a distant bicycle, moving toward or from us, seem simply to rise and fall.
Saturn is very rich in attendants, having not only the wonderful rings (quite different from everything else in the solar system, and undoubtedly made up of an infinity of small particles), but also two other moons (too small to be separately seen), but in addition eight distinct satellites are known. Uranus has four moons, and far-away Neptune has one attendant body. The paths of all these satellites are nearly circular, except those of our moon and Hyperion.
**Periods, Transits, Occultations, and Eclipses.** — Following are the principal data of the satellites of Jupiter:
| Num- |
Diameter |
Distance from Jupiter |
Sidereal Period of Revolution |
Made in Time of Jupiter? |
| V |
100 miles |
112,000 miles |
o d. h. 57 m. 22 s. |
? |
| I |
2300 |
261,000 |
1 18 27 33-5 |
? |
| II |
2100 |
415,000 |
3 13 42-1 |
? |
| III |
3500 |
664,000 |
4 17 33-5 |
? |
| IV |
3000 |
1,169,000 |
16 16 32 41-2 |
? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?? |
So near Jupiter is the fifth satellite that his disk, as seen from the surface of the satellite, would stretch more than half way from horizon to zenith. Referring to conditions which produce eclipses of sun and
Light Requires Time to Travel 345
moon, illustrated on page 293, and remembering that the orbits of Jupiter's satellites nearly coincide with the plane of his path, it is clear that eclipses of the sun and of Jupiter's moons must occur every time the satellite passes between the sun and earth. So there are nearly 8000 eclipses of the sun and moons annually, from some point or other of the earth's orbit, but only one alone escapes eclipse - about half the time. When the dark shadow of a satellite is seen to cross the disk of the sun, we call this an eclipse; and the projection of the satellite itself on the disk is called a transit of the satellite. In the opposite part of their orbits, a similar phenomenon occurs which is called an occultation; and its dropping into the planet's shadow is called an eclipse. Eclipses vary from just a few minutes to nearly five hours in length. Eclipses, occultations, and transits are recorded in almanacs called Ephemeris, and are very interesting to observe, even with small telescopes. An opera glass will show at a glance the moons which are not in transit, occultation, or eclipse. Sometimes all four disappear for a time, though not again in the 19th century.
Light Requires Time to travel. — In 1675, Roemer first suspected this, because he found that when Jupiter was in opposition, eclipses of his satellites took place several minutes earlier than the average, and when in conjunction, the same amount later. The figure shows why: for when Jupiter is in conjunction, sunlight reflected from a satellite must journey an entire diameter of the Earth's orbit farther than a similar distance if eclipsed by another moon exhibited the same discrepancy. So the conclusion was manifest, that light requires a definite time to travel; and we now know, from elaborate calculations, that light from these moons travels across the Earth's orbit in 998 seconds. Half this number, or 499, is the constant factor in 'the equation of light.' Its careful
Jupiter (Shadow of Satellite in Eclipse)
| EARTH (JUPITER'S ORBIT) |
O |
EARTH (JUPITER'S ORBIT) |
| Earth (Jupiter's Orbit) |
O |
Earth (Jupiter's Orbit) |
346
The Planets
determination is a matter of great importance, and eclipses of Jupiter's satellites are now recorded with high accuracy by the photometer and by means of photography.
Physical Peculiarities of Jupiter's Satellites. — The first satellite is a sphere, but a prolate ellipsoid, its axis being directed toward the center of Jupiter—a remarkable peculiarity which has been verified by Douglass. Markings, very faint in character, have been seen upon the surface. By means of these their periods of axial rev- olution are found. Fading out at the edge may be indication that it possesses an atmosphere. The moon Tityus, discovered in 1801, has a period of 7 days 7 h. It turns round once on its axes while going once round Jupiter, a relation like that of our moon to the earth. Douglass, from observations of very small spots both on its in 1897, and its periphery in 1898, 7 d. 5 h. Also he has photographed the shadow of the satellite upon the surface. Near the poles of its 100 and white spots have been seen by several observers.
Satellites of Saturn. — Following are the principal data of the satellites of Saturn:
| Num. |
Name of Satellite |
Name of Discovered |
Date of Discovery |
Diameter |
Distance from Saturn |
Spherical |
| Diameter |
Radius |
| 1 |
Mimas |
W. Herschel |
17 Sept., 1795 |
150 miles |
150 miles |
d h m. |
37° 47' |
| II |
Enceladus |
W. Herschel |
8 Aug., 1796 |
350 miles |
350 miles |
t 83° 6'9" |
| III |
Tethys |
J. D. Cassini |
24 Mar., 1664 |
1100 miles |
1100 miles |
t 21' 45' 6" |
| IV |
Dione |
J. D. Cassini |
24 Dec., 1665 |
1500 miles |
1500 miles | | |
| V |
Rhea |
J. D. Cassini |
24 Dec., 1665 | 3000 miles | 3000 miles | | |
| VI |
Titan |
Huygens |
25 Mar., 1655 | 3000 miles | 3000 miles | | |
| VII |
Hypatia |
C. W. Bessel J. D. Cassini | 16 Sep., 1848 4 Oct., 1897
|
THE SATELLITES OF URANUS
**Satellite of Neptune** 347
The orbits of the five inner satellites are circular. The satellites first discovered are easiest to see, the largest, Titan, being nearly always visible even with very small instruments. Its mass according to Stone is about that of Saturn. Eclipses and transits of some of the satellites have occasionally been observed with large telescopes.
**Satellites of Uranus.** — Following are the principal data of the satellites of Uranus:
| Number |
Name of Satellite |
Distance from Uranus |
Spherical Period of Revolution |
| I |
Ariel |
120,000 miles |
2 d. 12 h. 29 m. 211 s. |
| II |
Umbriel |
167,000 |
4 d. 27 h. 37 s. |
| III |
Titania |
273,000 |
8 d. 56 m. 29 s. |
| IV |
Oberon |
365,000 |
13 d. 11 m. 6 s. |
The two inner satellites are about 500 miles in diameter, and the outer ones are nearly twice as large. For the next fifteen years, while the earth is near a line perpendicular to their orbits, the satellites may always be seen whenever Uranus is visible. Only great telescopes, however, will show them. The satellites of Uranus revolve in planes nearly at right angles to the planet's orbit, and their motion is retrograde. The first two were Ariel and Umbriel were discovered by Lassell in 1851; Titania and Oberon, by Sir William Herschel in 1787.
**Satellite of Neptune.** — Its distance from Neptune is 224,000 miles, the period of revolution $5 \text{ d} \times 21 \text{ h} \times 3 \text{ m}$, with motion retrograde. It was discovered by Lassell in 1846, only a few weeks after the planet itself was found. Probably Neptune's satellite is about the size of our own moon.
348
# The Planets
## Atmospheres of the Planets
**Atmosphere of Mercury.** —Without much doubt, the atmosphere of Mercury is inappreciable. His color by day, when best observable, resembles that of the pale moon under like conditions. If there is no air, then quite certainly no water; as evaporation would continue to supply a slight atmosphere as long as it lasted. The improbability of an atmosphere surrounding this planet is confirmed by the argument from the kinetic theory of gases, already stated (page 244); for Mercury's mass is too slight to retain an envelope of aqueous vapor.
**Atmosphere of Venus.** —Observations of Venus when very near her inferior conjunction prove the existence of an atmosphere which is thought to be more dense than ours. The illustration on the left part of the evidence—Venus is just entering upon the sun's disk during the transit of 1882, and sunlight shining through the planet's atmosphere illuminates it in a nearly complete ring surrounding Venus, which appears dark because her sunward side is turned away from us. Also an aureole surrounds the dark disk when in transit; and on several occasions when Venus has passed below the sun at inferior conjunction, just escaping a transit, the horns of the atmospheric ring have been observed almost to meet, forming a nearly complete ring. This crescent would be little more than a complete semicircle, if there were no atmosphere.
Venus entering the Disk of the Sun in 1882 (Langer)
The Sun
Atmospheres of the Planets 349
**Atmosphere of Mars.** — Doubtless a thin atmosphere en-
velops this planet, although neither so extensive nor so
dense as our own. While usually cloudless, occasional and
temporary vellings of some of the best known regions of
the planet have been observed by photography, and, by
using the spectroscope, have found absorption lines in
the spectrum of Mars thought to be due to neither solar nor
terrestrial atmosphere, indicating water vapor in a gas-
eous envelope. Also regular shrinking and subsequent
enlarging of the polar caps are excellent evidence that the
ruddy planet is surrounded by a medium acting as an
agent in the formation and deposition of snow. Chang-
ing intensity of the light, with a change of the planet's
phase also indicates the presence of an atmosphere.
Another important piece of evidence is the discovery of a
twilight arc about 12°, causing a regular increase of the
planet's apparent diameter when its phase increases.
Quite certainly density of the atmosphere of Mars cannot exceed one half that of our own, and prob-
ably it is very much less. Referring again to the kinetic
theory of gases, and calculating the critical velocity for
Mars, we find it to be rather more than three miles per
second. Free hydrogen, then, could not be present in his
atmosphere, but other gases might. Campbell and Keeler
have found the spectrum of Mars practically identical with
that of the moon, indicating probably that the spectro-
scopic method is inconclusive.
**Atmosphere of Jupiter and Saturn.** — The indications of a
dense and very extended atmosphere encircling Jupiter
are unmistakable — ceaseless changes in markings called
belts and spots; varying length of the planet's day in dif-
ferent regions of latitude; absorption shadings in the in-
terior portion of Jupiter's spectrum; and withal his giant
mass potent to retain captive all gaseous materials origi-
349
350
The Planets
nally belonging to him. Probably in point of both depth and chemical constitution, the atmosphere of Jupiter is widely different from our own fact, it is not unlikely that the great planet still be in a gaseous condition throughout. At least the depth of atmosphere may be reckoned in thousands of miles. Dark bands in the red may be due to some substance in the planet's atmosphere not in our own, and possibly metallic. In nearly every respect the atmosphere of the ball of Saturn resembles that of Jupiter, but the ring gives every appearance of being without atmosphere. Saturn's spectrum, too, is quite the same as Jupiter's, and its intense absorption bands indicate a little more plainly the presence of gaseous elements as yet unrecognized on the earth and in the sun. Another indication of atmosphere, common to both these planets, is the strong absorption of all markings at the limbs or edge of their disks.
Atmosphere of Uranus and Neptune. — So remote are these planets, and so small their apparent disks, that practically nothing has yet been ascertained concerning their atmospheres except by the spectroscopie. Uranus is bright enough so that its spectrum shows to broad diffused bands, between $C$ and $F$, indicating strong absorption by a dense atmosphere very different from that of the earth, as Keeler has shown. The position of these lines in the red is sufficient to account for the sea-green tint of the planet. Neptune's color is almost the same; and its spectrum, if not so faint, would probably show similar absorption bands.
Surfaces of the Planets
Zodiacal Light. — Interior to the orbit of Mercury, but possibly stretching out beyond the path of the earth, is a widely diffused disk of interplanetary particles moving
The Gegenschein 351
round the sun, mildly reflecting its rays to us, and called the zodiacal light.
The illustration shows it well — a faintly luminous and ill-defined triangular area, expanding downward along the ecliptic toward the western horizon, shortly after sunset on clear, moonless nights from January to April. Its center is white, its brightest and slightly yellowish. It has suf-
fered no change for more than two centu-
ries. Its spectrum is short and continuous,
without any lines, though possibly a few
faint dark ones are present.
In the higher latitudes, where the
ecliptic always stands high above the hori-
zon, the zodiacal light can be well seen in
clear skies the year round. In the middle latitudes it cannot be
seen early in autumn evenings, because of
the slight inclination of the ecliptic to the
horizon, as the next figure shows. At this part
of the zodiacal light near a and above the horizon, HH', is lost in
low-lying mist and haze.
In autumn it must be looked for in the east
just before sunset.
The Gegenschein. — This is a name of German origin, given to a
zodiacal counterlight discovered by Brorson in 1854—an exceedingly
faint and even more difficult to see light, nearly opposite the sun, some-
times slightly so, and again somewhat behind it. A bright star or planet near by is sufficient to overmaster its light; even proximity to the Milky Way obliterates it. Sometimes the gegenschein
A crescent moon with a small dot in its center.
The Zodiakal Light in Tropic Latitudes
352
**The Planets**
is circular, at others elliptic; and its diameter varies between 3° and 13°, according to Barnard and Douglass. It is best seen in September and October, in Sagittarius and Pisces. No satisfactory theory of its existence exists. Very likely the gegenschein is due to the reflection of the sun's rays on planetary bodies, though possibly it may be caused by abnormal refraction in our atmosphere.
A series of images showing the phases of Mercury.
Why Zodiakal Light is Invisible in our Fall Evenings
**Surface of Mercury.** — Mercury is so small a planet and so distant from the earth that the disk is disappointing. In the northern hemisphere he is best seen near greatest elongation east in spring; his greatest elongation west in autumn; because he is then in the northernmost part of the zodiac, where meridian altitude is as great as possible. Markings on the surface of Mercury are described by Lowell as less difficult than those on Venus without color, and lines rather than patches; and the fact that they do not change from hour to hour, nor perceptibly from day to day, shows that the planet's periods of rotation and revolution are the same. Above are nine drawings of the planet in October, 1896; also on the next page Lowell's chart of all that portion of the surface of Mercury ever visible, amounting to five eighths of the entire spherical superficies. The surface is probably rough,
Typical Drawings of Mercury, 1896 (Lowell)
Surface of Venus 353
because, like the moon, the amount of light reflected from a unit of surface increases from crescent phase to full.
**Illuminated Hemisphere of Venus.** — The unilluminated half of Venus appears to be forever sealed from investigation by our eyes; but that part of the sunward hemisphere turned towards us has been repeatedly drawn during the last 250 years. Only dull, indefinite markings, or spots covering large areas have, however, been seen until recently. The illustration below shows the general nature of markings drawn by the earlier observers. Frequently the terminator was irregularly curved, indicating mountains of great height; and polar caps were depicted. According to recent observations of Lowell, however, the disk of Venus is colorless, and resembles "simply a design in black and white over which is drawn a brilliant straw-colored veil." This
A diagram showing the illuminated and unilluminated hemispheres of Venus.
Chart of All the Visible Surface of Mercury (Lowell)
Venus as drawn by Mawari in 1892.
Rond's ASTRON. - 23
354
**The Planets**
veil is doubtless the planet's atmosphere. No polar caps were seen.
Markings on the disk, seen and drawn independently by Lowell and his assistants, Douglass, See, and others, are broad belts, not spots.
Three specimen drawings are shown here. The markings are mostly great circles on the planet's surface, and many of them radiate from a single point. A accompanying chart shows they partake of the general brilli-
ance of the sun, being visible objects, except to observers trained in visualizing faint planetary detail. Three slight proba-
bilities, probably due to chance, are interesting facts. The Lowell Observatories, located at Flagstaff,
Arizona, was done in the latter months of 1869. The fine atmos-
pheric conditions of that region, and the critical manner in which
the observations were made lend significance to the fore-
going results, although they are not so well confirmed by observers in other parts of the world. Taken in con-
nection with the practical cer-
tainty of the theory, the
constant aspect of one hemi-
sphere perpetually toward the
sun is very significant; pro-
ably electric currents would gradually remove all water and nearly all moisture from the dark hemi-
sphere, and deposit it as ice on the dark side of the planet.
A probable explanation of the so-called phosphorescence of the dark hemi-
sphere; for a faint light diffused over the unilluminated portion of the disk has repeatedly been seen by many good observers.
**Surface of Mars in General.** — Huygens, in 1659, made the first sketch of Mars to show definite markings; and in
Venus as drawn by Lowell in 1890
Chart of Visible Hemisphere of Venus (Lowell)
Surface of Mars 355
1840, Beer and Maedler drew the first chart of the planet.
The two hemispheres exhibit a marked difference in brightness, the northern being much brighter. Probably it is land, while the southern is mainly water, but in general there is no great difference between land and water on the earth. Four to eleven here; but on Mars land somewhat predominates. Probably the waters have for the most part slight depth.
Extensive regions which change from yellow, like continents, to dark brown, are thought to be marshes, varying depth of water causing the diversity of color. Mars appears to be so far advanced in his life history that areas of permanent water are very limited.
The border of the disk is brighter than the interior, and changes in apparent brightness of certain regions are well established. In considerable part these depend upon the angle of vision as modified by axial turning of the planet. Photographs of Mars have been taken, but they show only salient features of the disk. Markings of Syria Major, a well-known region (see fifth figure on page 358) appear to be vegetation rather than water. Smoothness of the terminator alone, which, for projection and flattening have been observed, indicates clearly that the Martian surface is relatively flat, as compared with the present rugged exterior of earth and moon.
* Orbits of Earth and Mars. —Inner circle in next illustration represents orbit of earth, and outer one orbit of Mars eccentrically placed in true proportion. Around inner circle are indicated positions of earth
Mars in 1877 (Green)
356
**The Planets**
In different months, and around outer circle are shown the points occu-
pled by Mars at opposition time in the several years indicated. The
most favorable opposition of Mars, or when that planet is at the mini-
mum distance of 33,000,000 miles from the earth, can take place only
in August and September, as indicated on right-hand side of diagram.
A diagram showing the orbit of Mars around Earth. The diagram includes labels for various months (Jan., Feb., Mar., Apr., May, Jun., Jul., Aug., Sep., Oct., Nov., Dec.) and indicates the least and greatest distances at oppositions.
Orbits of Mars and Earth, showing Least and Greatest Distances at Oppositions
Similarly on left-hand side the least favorable oppositions occur in those
years when the opposition time falls in February and March. Exact
positions of Mars at recent favorable oppositions are shown at 1877
and 1892. But at opposition, October, 1894, although the planet was
then much nearer to the earth than at any other time since 1877, it was
not observed because the sun crosses the meridian lower in October than in August.
Higher southern declination enabled the planet to be observed to
greater advantage in 1894 than in 1892, because nearly all the observa-
tories of the world are located in its northern hemisphere. Subsequent
Polar Caps of Mars 357
opposition distances of Mars, are all unfavorably great until 1807; or better still, 1809, which will occur in September, in nearly the same longitude as did that of 1877.
**Polar Caps of Mars.** — These were discovered by Cassini in 1666. Rather more than a century later, Sir William Herschel first made out their variation in size with progress of the seasons on Mars, which are in general similar to ours, although longer, because the Aresian year is longer. Near the end of Martian winter the polar caps are largest, and they gradually shrink in size till the end of summer.
This remarkable diminution of the south polar cap has been repeatedly observed since Herschel's time, and the illustrations show its progress during the Martian spring and summer of 1894. Without much doubt, this shrinkage is due to melting of snow and ice. The north polar cap exhibits a like succession of phenomena, but these are less easy to observe, because the direction of the planet's axis in space is such that when this pole is turned toward us at night it is nearly overhead as far as we see when the south pole is toward us. The north polar cap covers the planet's pole of rotation almost exactly, while the south is now displaced about 200 miles from the true pole, and this distance varies irregularly with the seasons. At the beginning of the summer season of 1892, the south polar cap was 1200 miles in diam- eter; gradually a long, dark line appeared near the middle, and eventually cut the cap in two; the edge became notched; dark
Illustrations showing changes in size of Martian polar caps over time.
Shrinkage and Disappearance of South Polar Cap in 1894 (Illustrated in Popular Astronomy)
(3) Top of Funk on left is Pectinum Argo.
Dark Mars nearly central; a Magenta-Infarct Druis.
(3) Sulla Locus is nearly central.
Double Nectar runs to the left from it.
(3) Seven Canals diverge from Sinus Titia-
num. Eumenides-Orchestrades Nine Oases
(4) The Rectangle is Trisum Chasontis.
Dark Mars Cimmerius is central.
(5) Largest Roundish Area in Helles.
Below Helles is the pointed Syrtis Major
Mars according to Schiaparelli and Lowell (1877-1894)
358
A series of six circular diagrams depicting various Martian features.
A series of six circular diagrams depicting various Martian features.
A series of six circular diagrams depicting various Martian features.
A series of six circular diagrams depicting various Martian features.
A series of six circular diagrams depicting various Martian features.
A series of six circular diagrams depicting various Martian features.
**Canals and Oases of Mars**
359
spots grew in its central regions, and isolated patches were seen to separate from the principal mass, and later dissolve and disappear.
The phenomenon was similar in 1804, as Barnard's 12 pictures of the cap show (page 357). In three months the cap's diameter had shrunk to 170 miles, and in eight months it had vanished entirely.
**Canals and Oases of Mars.** — This diminution of the polar cap seems to afford a key to the physiographic situation on Mars; for, coincidently with its shrinking, a strange system of markings begins to develop, traversing continental areas in all directions, and forming a network of darkish lines.
Six engravings opposite exhibit the planet's surface in all longitudes, and show the canals much intensified. All appear on the flat disk as either straight or uniformly curving lines; and if transferred to the surface of a globe, they are found to traverse it on areas of great circles. Many canals are seen to intersect each other at right angles, which may be actual gulfs and bays. At numerous intersections with other canals are oval or circular spots, called oases, many of them appearing like lakes. The largest lake is Lacus Palus, whose diameter is about 130 miles. For example, seven canals converge to Lacus Phoenicis.
The most signal marking of this character is in Arian latitude about 30° south (shown above), where there is a large risk opposite). Though often called the "oculus" or eye of Mars, it is really Solis Lacus, or Lake of the Sun. Its breadth is 300 miles, and its length 420 miles. Through Solis Lacus run narrow double channels, whose combined length exceeds that of the Nile by more than one-fifth. Average about 1200 miles but the longest one is Emeites-Orusca, whose combined length is 300 miles, or nearly equal to the entire diameter of the planet. The shortest canal known is that between Solis Lacus and Emeites-Orusca, which is only about 30 miles. Canals were first discovered by Schiaparelli in 1877. They are bluish-green in color, and have been repeatedly observed by their discoverer in Italy; Lowell in Arizona; Perrotin, in France; W. H. Pickering in America; and by Prof. J. D. Beers at Lick Observatory; Willson, in Minnesota; and Williams, in England. About none have been seen in all; so that their reality is now generally conceded. But some doubt has arisen respecting their existence.
**Doubling of the Canals and Oases.** — Lowell, one of the few observers who have yet seen the doubling of the canals, thus describes this marvelous phenomenon:
"A upon a part of the disk where up to that time a single canal has been visible, of a sudden, some night, in place of the single canals, are
360
The Planets
perceived twin canals, — as like, indeed, as twins, if not more so, run-
ning side by side the whole length of the original canal, usually for
upwards of a thousand miles, of the same size throughout, and abso-
lutely parallel to each other. The pair may best be likened to the
two tails of a butterfly, or the two wings of a butterfly, when spread
wide.
Many double canals are shown in the sixth figure on page 338. Aver-
age distance between the twin canals is 150 to 200 miles. This phe-
nomenon, still more remarkable than the mere existence of two inter-
nal optical illusions or double refraction; but rather a really double exist-
ence, seen only under exceptionally favourable conditions of atmosphere.
More strangely do the cases too are occasionally seen to be double.
Meaning that Canal Theory is not only a theory of science but also a theory
not only to record but to explain appearances; and the canals, whether
double or single, have, to many astronomers who have seen them, a look of artificiality. But this is not all. The explanation of the canals themselves, advanced by W. H. Pickering
and reinforced by the argument of Lowell, seems very plausible:
water is supposed to have been carried along by streams which had natu-
rally conducted along narrow channels through the middle of the
canals, thereby irrigating areas of great breadth which, with the ad-
vance of the season, become clothed with vegetation. Similarly the
cases; as in the case of the Canals in Mars, where vegetation is visi-
ble in the Ares winter; grows visible as canal and oasis with every return of spring. The fact that cases are seen only at junctions of
canals and not at any other point is another argument in favour of it.
Of course, acceptance of this theory implies that Mars in ages past has,
been and may be still, peopled by intelligent beings; and that continu-
ation of their existence upon that planet, during secular dissipation of
natural water supplies, would be impossible without some artificial means.
For animal life, or types known to us, is dependent upon vegetable life;
which, in turn is conditional upon water distribution, either natural or
artificial. In view of these facts, and considering the number of canal and oasis in both hemispheres of Mars, can we hope for a rational
solution of the question of life in another world than ours. Such
difficult research Lowell and his able corps of observers are now faith-
fully prosecuting with a 24-inch Clark telescope in favorable skies.
Seasonal Changes. — Striking seasonal changes seem to
keep step with progress of Mars in its orbit, are best ex-
hibited by direct comparison between drawings at intervals
of several months. Three such are chosen in plate vi. The
region known as Hesperia is central in all. The first, 7th
Early Summer.
Late Summer.
Plate VI.--THE PLANET MARS (from original drawing by Lowell).
Early Spring.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Discoveries of Small Planets
361
June, 1894, corresponds to early spring on Mars. South polar snows have just begun to melt. Everywhere encircling it is the dark area, as if water from the melting of the cap; for this belt follows the curve as it does, the common legend being that the great smalls are there. This is shown in the middle disk, which corresponds to early summer.
Mark the other changes in the disk: (1) the general thinning out of dark areas which on the actual planet are greenish-blue; (2) the increase in intensity of reddish ochre regions through the southern hemisphere, as if the water had in considerable part evaporated, Hesperia already beginning to show as an oblique, V-shaped, reddish marking in the center of the disk; (3) progress in development of canals though not as much as before.
As the planet approaches its summum in the third drawing, Hesperia becomes a broad cleft through the water area, three canals are particularly well developed in the northern hemisphere, and the south polar cap has practically vanished. In other longitudes like changes went on simultaneously, and in the same significant and seemingly obvious direction.
Discoveries of Small Planets. — In 1800, the closing year of the eighteenth century, conspicuous absence of a planet between Mars and Jupiter as required by Bode's law, led to an association of 24 astronomers intent upon search for the missing body. Piazzi of Sicily inaugurated the long list of discoveries by finding first Ceres in the night of the 19th century (1st January, 1801). He called it Ceres, that being the name of the tutelary divinity of Sicily. Three others, named Pallas, Juno, and Vesta, were found by 1807, but the fifth was not discovered till 1845.
Since 1847 no year has failed to add at least one to the number, and in 1896 the increase was 40. The total number is now approaching
362
**The Planets**
500. Of these, 75 were discovered in the United States, mainly by Peters (48) at Clinton, New York, and Watson (24) at Ann Arbor, Michigan. Palisa, of Vienna, found no less than 72. In 1891, Wolf of Heidelberg inaugurated discoveries of these bodies by the aid of photography, and he has since made many more. The photographs are exposed for two or three hours to a suspected region of sky makes a permanent record of all the stars as round disks, and of any small planets as short traces on the photographic plate. These are then examined with a telescope. So they are discovered about so-fold more readily than by the old-fash- ioned method at the eyepiece of a telescope. Charlois de Nice has found nearly go such planets by photography. Altogether too of the more recent discoveries are now known. The following details show this number, thus (41); also by a double letter and year of discovery, as 1897 DE (=q). Probably there are hundreds more, and possibly thou- sands. Discoveries are disseminated by Ritchie's international code.
**Orbits and Origin of Small Planets.** — The orbits of small planets, although linked together inseparably, still present wide degrees of divergence. They are by no means evenly distributed: in those regions of the zone where a simple relation of commensurability exists between the appropriate period of revolution and the periodic time of Jupiter's gaps are found, resembling those shown farther on as existing in the ring of Saturn.
Especially is this true for distances corresponding to one half and one third of Jupiter's period. Not only are the orbits of small planets far from concentric, but they are inclined at exceptionally large angles to the ecliptic, that of Pallas (1) being 35°. Several groups exist having a near identity in inclination. The orbit of Uranus (2), the "hymnia" (3) is much perturbed by the attraction of Jupiter, and its mo- tion has recently been employed by Newcomb in finding anew the mass of the giant planet, equal to 1/200 that of the sun. The orbits (4), Sopho- (5), and others, on account of their proximity to the earth have been very useful in the hands of Gill and Eklund in helping to ascertain sun's distance from earth. Data concerning orbits of these bodies are published each year in the Berliner Astronomisches Jahrbuch.
Olbers early originated the theory, now disproved, that small planets had their origin in explosion of a single great planet. Most probably, however, proximity of so
The Surface of Jupiter
363
massive a planet as Jupiter is responsible for the existence of a multitude of small bodies in lieu of one larger one; facts which may operate upon the ring in its early formative stage, in accordance with principles of the evolution of planets may readily have precluded ultimate condensation of the ring into a separate planet.
Surface of Jupiter. — In a telescope of even moderate size, Jupiter appears, as in this typical view, striped with many light and dark belts, of varying constant widths, lying across the disk parallel to each other and to his equator, or nearly so. They always appear practically straight because the plane of Jupiter's equator always passes very nearly through the earth. The belts are not difficult to see; but the telescope had been invented 20 years before this view was discovered by Rome, in 1630. Usually the equatorial zone, about 25° broad, is lightest in hue, and almost centrally through it runs a very narrow
Jupiter in 1889 (Keeler)
Jupiter in 1889 (Keeler)
364
The Planets
dark stripe. Larger telescopes reveal a variety of spots and streaks in this zone, and permanence of markings is rather the exception than the rule. It appears to be a region of great physical commotion. Bordering this zone, on either side, are usually two broad reddish belts, about 20° of latitude in width. These are zones of little disturbance, but the southern one often appears divided.
Just beyond it is the 'great red spot.' Here and there what appear to be masses at the edge of the equatorial zone, appear to flow over into the red belts as long oblique streamers, seemingly dividing these broad zones into two or three narrow stripes. Farther from the equator are still other belts, growing narrower as the poles are approached, because curvature of the spherical surface forecloses them, and around the limb, whether at poles or equator, the belts fade into indistinctness. Color and intensity of the principal belts are by no means constant, their hue being at times brownish, copper-colored, and purple. Of the two hemispheres, the reddish tint of the southern is rather more pronounced.
Jupiter's Great Red Spot — Probably this gigantic marking, whose area exceeds that of our whole earth, has long been known to observers, but was first definitely observed until 1869, and still more definitely in 1878 first by Pritchett, there are indications that Cassini, at Paris, observed it in 1685.
Jupiter's Great Red Spot in 1881 and 1885 (Dennig)
Jupiter's Great Red Spot — Probably this gigantic marking, whose area exceeds that of our whole earth, has long been known to observers, but was first definitely observed until 1869, and still more definitely in 1878 first by Pritchett, there are indications that Cassini, at Paris, observed it in 1685.
A Chart of Jupiter 365
The opposite illustrations show its appearance in 1874 and 1883. Breadth of this elliptic marking was about fiveoo miles, and length 30,000.
The great red spot has not been uniformly conspicuous, for it nearly faded out in 1883-84. The year following a white cloud appeared to cover the middle, making it look like a chain-link. The lowest drawing (page 19) shows the spot at its maximum, but it quickly disappeared, having a periodicity, and again reappear. Cloud markings near it have been observed to be strikingly repelled. If the spot remained stationary any upon the disk, it would be impossible to explain its presence within the outer atmospheric envelope of Jupiter, through which are seen dense red vapors of interior strata, if not the planet's true surface; but its slow drift precludes that view. No satisfactory explanation of the great red spot has been advanced.
A Chart of Jupiter. - notwithstanding considerable variations in detailed appearance of Jupiter's disk, many larger markings present a sufficient permanence from month to month to admit of charting. Adjacent is such a chart, on the Mercator projection, and intended to be accurate as to general features only. Center of the great red spot is taken as zero meridian. The principal markings and two important white spots are clearly indicated. From the construction of many such charts at intervals of about a year, much can be learned about the planet's atmosphere, present physical condition, and future development. This chart was made by Mr. J. H. Henderson, Hopkins and Russell, and at the Lick Observatory, although showing accurately a great quantity of detail, including a multitude of white and dark spots, does not equal the eye in recording finer markings. Length of exposure and steadiness of atmosphere are the chief obstacles. Though
A Chart of Jupiter showing various markings on Jupiter's disk.
Approximate Chart of a Portion of Jupiter in 1895 (Henderson)
366
The Planets
in America and Williams in England have been constant students of Jupiter.
Surface of Saturn. — A telescope of only two inches' aperture will show the ring of Saturn, also Titan, his largest satellite. A four-inch object glass will reveal four other satellites on favorable occasions. The entire disk appears as if enveloped in a thin, faint, yellowish veil. At irregular
Saturn and its Rings (drawn by Pratt in 1884)
intervals belts are seen similar to Jupiter's; but they do not persist so long, and are much fainter. As a rule Saturn's equatorial belt is his brightest region, while an olive-green zone often covers the pole. Early photographs have been taken at the Lick and Greenwich Observatories.
At intervals of nearly 15 years, the belts appear very much curved, as in the illustration above; because the earth is then about 20° above or below the plane of the planet's equator, this being the angle by which the axis of rotation of the earth differs from that of Saturn. Midway between these epochs, the belts appear practically curvless, like Jupiter's, because the plane of Saturn's equator is then passing near the earth (see drawing opposite on the right). Few bright spots and
**Saturn's Rings and their Phases** 367
irregularities of marking characterize this planet, and his true period of rotation is on that account difficult to ascertain. Celestial photography is not yet sufficiently perfected to afford much assistance in recording the minute details of so small a disk as Saturn's. With the invention of the photographic plate, however, we may hope that such an accuracy, unavoidable blurring of atmosphere will be less harmful. Numerous faint and nearly circular dark and white spots or mottlings were observed on the ball in 1866.
**Saturn's Rings and their Phases.** — Saturn is surrounded by a series of thin, circular plane rings which generally appear elliptical in form. To astronomers of the first half of the 17th century Saturn afforded much puzzlement, and they drew the planet in a variety of fanciful forms, some of which are here shown. Huygens first guessed the riddle of the rings in 1655. When widely open, as in 1884 (opposite page), and in 1809 and 1809, a keen-eyed observer, even with a small telescope, can see faint, darkish lines or markings near the middle of the ring. These are divisions of the system, and there are three distinct rings; $(A)$ outer bright ring, $(B)$ inner bright ring, $(C)$ innermost or crape ring.
Very Early Drawings of Saturn
In the left-hand column.
Saturn in 1891. (Mark the Excessively Dark Ring.)
368
The Planets
A diagram showing the phases of Saturn's rings.
0787 While Saturn moves round the sun, the ring main-tains its own plane constant in direction, just as earth's equator is always parallel to itself. Consequently the plane of Saturn's rings is seen at different times on earth, sometimes through the sun, and again between earth and sun. At these times the rings of Saturn may appear to be either complete or broken, as illustrated. In the first case, the ring is so thin that it cannot be seen when the earth is exactly in the plane of the rings. In the second case, the ring disappears because the sun is shining directly on it, and only on its edge. The ring may disappear in the third instance when earth and sun are on opposite sides of Saturn. This happens when the ring is turned toward us. Disappearances due to these causes take place about every 15 years, or one period of revolution of Saturn. The intervals shown in 1879, as well as the adjacent figures (for inventing telescopes) show. Interval between disappearances are unequal partly because of eccentricity of Saturn's orbit, perihelion occurring in 1851 and aphelion in 1899.
0788 Size and Constitution of the Rings. — The dimensions of the ring system are enormous, especially in comparison with its distance from earth, which is nearly 930 million miles. Seen edge on, it has the appearance of a fine and often broken hair line (page 367).
0789 Outer diameter of outside ring is 172,000 miles, and its breadth, 11,500 miles. Then comes the division between the two luminous rings, discovered by Bond in 1840; its inner diameter is 144,000 miles, and its breadth, 17,500 miles. Next, the innermost or dusky ring, discovered by Bond in 1840; its inner diameter is 144,000 miles, and its breadth, 17,500 miles. It joins on the inner bright ring without any apparent division. So guary is it that the ball of Saturn can be seen through it.
Characteristic of the inner bright ring is a thickening of its outer edge,—much the brightest zone of the ring system. The rings of Saturn are neither solid
Phases of the Ring of Saturn
The Discovery of Neptune 369
nor liquid, but are composed of enormous clouds or sheets of very small bodies, possibly meteoric, travelling round the planet, each in an orbit of its own, as if a satellite. Perhaps they are thousands of miles apart in space; but so distant is the planet from the earth and so numerous are the particles that they present the appearance of a continuous solid ring. This view is supported by the close approach of the constitution of Saturn's rings, showing that inner particles move round the primary more swiftly than outer ones do, in accord with Kepler's third law. The period of revolution of the particles may be one day, or but little more than half the rotation time of the ball itself, which, according to some observers, is slightly displaced from the center of the rings. Not imposably the ring system is a transient feature, and may be a ninth satellite in process of formation (page 467).
Surface of Uranus and Neptune.—The great planet Uranus, the first one ever found with the telescope, was discovered by Sir William Herschel, 16th March, 1781. Calculation afterwards showed that this planet had been observed about twenty times during the century preceding, and mistaken for a fixed star. So remote is Uranus and so small the apparent disk that very few observers have been able to detect anything whatever on his pale green surface. Some have seen belts resembling those on Jupiter, others a white spot from which a rotation period equal to 10 hours was found. More recently the planet has been sketched by Brenner, from the clear skies of Istria, and six of his drawings are reproduced on the next page. The markings appear neither numerous nor definite; yet a little is found upon Uranus, vastly less must be expected elsewhere, and no marking whatever has yet been certainly glimpsed.
The Discovery of Neptune.—The discovery of Neptune was a double one. Early in the present century it was found that Uranus was straying widely from his theoretic positions, and the cause of this deviation was for a long time unsuspected. Two young astronomers, Adams in England, and Le Verrier in France, the former in 1843 and the
TODD'S ASTRON., — 24
370
The Planets
latter in 1845, undertook to find out the cause of this perturbation, on the supposition of an undiscovered planet beyond Uranus. Adams reached his result first, and English astronomers began to search for the suspected planet with their telescopes, by first making a careful map of all the stars in that part of the sky. But L. L. Venard, on reaching the conclusion of his search, sent his result to the Berlin observatory, where it chanced that an accurate map had just been formed of all stars in the suspected region. On comparing this with the sky, the new planet, afterward called Neptune, was at once discovered, 23d September, 1846. It was soon found that Neptune, too, had been seen several times during the previous half century, and recorded as a fixed star. The tiny disk, however, is readily distinguishable from the stars around it, if a magnifying power of about 100 diameters is used.
There are no specific reasons for supposing the existence of two planets exterior to Neptune; but no such bodies have yet been discovered, although search for them has been conducted both optically and by means of photography.
Uranus in 1896 (Brenner)
CHAPTER XIV
THE ARGUMENT FOR UNIVERSAL GRAVITATION
S O striking a confirmation of Newton's law was afforded by the discovery of Neptune, and so completely does the universality of that law account for the motions of the heavenly bodies, and the variety of their physical phenomena, that the present chapter is devoted to a partial outline sketch of the argument for universal gravitation.
From Kepler to Newton. — The great progress made by Kepler in dealing with the motions of the planets had not in any proper sense explained those motions; for his three famous laws merely state how the planets move, without at all touching the reason as to their laws of their motion we trust. It is clear that this situation could not have existed, the fundamental principles of physics, or natural philosophy as it was called in his day, had to be more fully understood. These principles concern the state of bodies at rest and in motion. Meaning of the term rest is relative, and absolute rest is indefinable. Motion is a change of place; and absolute rest is a state of absence of motion. Galileo early in the 17th century was the first philosopher who ascertained the laws of motion and wrote them down. But as they were better formulated by Newton, his name is always attached to them. They are axioms, an axiom being a proposition which is generally acknowledged by everybody, as soon as terms expressing it are clearly understood. Newton, indeed, in his great work entitled
371
372
**Argument for Gravitation**
the *Principia*, or principles of natural philosophy, called these laws *Axiomata, sive Leges Motus*. Antecedent to proper conception of Newton's law of universal gravitation must come an understanding of the three fundamental laws of motion.
**Newton's First Law of Motion.** — The first law reads as follows: Every body continues in its state of rest or of uniform motion in a straight line, except in so far as it may be compelled by force to change that state. Newton asserts in this law the physical truth that a state of uniform motion is just as natural as a state of rest. To one who has never seen a ball rolling on a level field it is first very difficult to realize; because rest seems the natural state, and motion an enforced one. But difficulty is at once dispelled, as soon as one begins to inquire into the causes that stop any body artificially set in motion.
A baseball rolling upon a level field soon stops because, in moving forward, it must repeatedly rise against the attraction of gravity, in order to pass over minor obstacles, as grass and pebbles. Also there is much surface friction. A rifle shot soon stops because resistance of the air opposes its forward motion. A stone thrown up and falling upon the earth. A vigorous winter game common in Scotland is called curling. The curling stone is a smooth, heavy stone, shaped like a much-finished marble. It is sent gliding upon ice. When stones are sent sliding on smooth ice as swiftly as possible, they go for long distances with but slight reduction of speed, thus affording an excellent approximation to Newton's first law. But a perfect illustration is not found among the planets. If we were to project a rifle shot into space very remote from the solar system, it would travel in a straight path for indefinite ages, because no atmosphere would resist its progress, and there is no known celestial body whose attraction would draw it from that path.
**Newton's Second Law of Motion.** — The second law reads: Change of motion is proportional to force applied, and takes place in the direction of the straight line in which the force acts.
Newton's Laws of Motion 373
This law is easy to illustrate without any apparatus. Throw a stone or other object horizontally. Everybody knows that its path speedily begins to curve downward, and it falls to the ground. From the smooth and level top of a table or shelf, brush a coin or other small object off swiftly with one hand: it will fall freely to the floor a few
A man is shown throwing a coin off a table.
Illustrating Newton's Second Law of Motion
feet away. Repeat until you find the strength of impulse necessary to send it two feet, three feet, four feet, five feet, six feet, etc., through the air, thus six feet as in the picture. With the other hand, practice dropping a coin from the level of the table, so that it will not turn in falling, but will remain nearly horizontal. Then take both hands together and throw coins with both hands together, and at the same time. Repeat until one coin is released from the fingers at the exact instant the other is brushed off the table. Then observe whether they reach the ground at precisely the same time; this will be true only if the first coin is projected to a distance of two feet, four feet, six feet, or whatever the distance. Had gravity not been acting, the first coin would have traveled twice as far as the second coin. The second coin would have traveled a distance of two feet, or four feet, proportioned to the impulse. What the second law of motion asserts is this: that the constant force (gravity in this case) pulls the first coin just as far from the place it would have reached; had gravity not been acting, as the same force, acting
374
Argument for Gravitation
vertically and alone, would in an equal time draw it from the state of rest. Whatever distance the coin is projected, the charge of motion is always the vertical distance between the level of table and floor, that is, 'in the direction of the straight line in which the force acts.' The law of action and reaction, by which the coin is projected horizontally, provided the floor (or whatever the ball falls on) is parallel to the surface from which it is projected.
**Newton's Third Law of Motion.** — The third law reads: To every action there is always an equal and contrary reaction; or the mutual actions of any two bodies are always equal and oppositely directed. This law completes the steps necessary for an introduction to the single law of universal gravitation, because it deals with mutual actions between two bodies, or among a system of bodies, such as we see the solar system actually to be.
To illustrate in Newton's own words: 'If you press a stone with your finger, the finger is also pressed by the stone. And if a horse draws a stone tied to a rope, the horse (if I may so say) will be equally drawn back by the stone. But if you try to relieve this same endeavor to relax or unstretch itself, draws the horse as much toward the stone as it draws the stone toward the horse.' Action and reaction are always equal and opposite.
So when one body attracts another from a distance, the second body attracts with an equal force, but oppositely directed. If there were two equal, and therefore balanced, forces acting on but one body, that would be in equilibrium; but the two forces specified in this third law act on two different bodies, neither of which is in equilibrium. Always there are two bodies and two forces acting, and one force acting upon one body while another is impossible. There must be, and always is, a pair of forces equal and opposite. Horse and stone advance as a unit, because the muscular power of the horse exerted upon the ground exceeds the resistance of the stone.
**Transition to the Law of Gravitation.** — Having clearly
Newton's Law of Gravitation 375
apprehended the meaning of Newton's three laws of motion, transition to his law of universal gravitation is easy. The law of motion, however, must now be thought of separately, but all as applying together and at the same time. First, consider the earth in its orbit. Our globe has a certain velocity as it goes round the sun; it would go on forever in space in a straight line, with that same velocity, except that some deflecting force draws it away from that line. This change of motion or direction from a straight line must be proportional to the force producing it, and the change itself must indicate direction in which the force acts; also, if there is a force acting from the sun upon the earth, there must be an equal and oppositely directed force from the earth upon the sun, for action and reaction are equal.
Similarly the motion of other planets round the sun; and Newton's reasoning and mathematical calculations, based on the laws of Kepler, made it perfectly clear that planetary motions might be dependent upon a central force directed toward the sun, the intensity of this force growing less and less in exact proportion as the square of the planet's distance grows greater: thus at twice the distance the intensity is but one fourth as great. By making this single hypothesis, the meaning of all three laws of Kepler was perfectly apparent. But could the action of any such force be proved? If it could, the motions of all the satellites round their centers might be explained by supposing a like force emanating from the central planets. This would mean, too, that the moon must move round us obedient to a force directed toward the earth, but decreasing in intensity just as rapidly as square of moon's distance from our center increases. Can it be that the common attraction of gravity which draws stones and apples downward is a force answering to this description? Why
376 Argument for Gravitation
should it attract only common objects near at hand? Why may not the realm of this mysterious force extend to the moon? To the calculation of this problem, Newton next addressed himself.
Gravitation holds the Moon in her Orbit. — If gravity causes the apple to fall from the tree, the bird when shot to fall to the ground, and hail to descend from the clouds, certainly it is possible, thought Newton, that it may hold the moon in her orbit, by continually bending her path round the earth. If so, the moon must perpetually be falling from the straight line in which she would travel, were the central force not acting. Force can be measured by the change of place it produces. At the surface of the earth, about 4000 miles distant from its centre, an object will fall 16.1 feet in the first second of time. But our satellite is 240,000 miles away, or 60 times more distant. So the moon, if held by the same attraction, only diminishing exactly as the square of the distance increases, should fall away from a straight line
$$\frac{1}{(60 \times 60)}$$ of 16.1 feet;
that is, $\frac{1}{60}$ of Newton. Newton calculated how much the moon actually does curve away from a tangent to her orbit in one second; and he found it was precisely that amount (page 217). So that law of gravitation was immediately established for the moon; and Newton's subsequent work showed that it explained equally well the motion of the satellites of Jupiter round their primary, and the motion of earth and all other planets round the sun. He found, in fact, that the force acting depends, in each case, on the product of the masses of the two bodies, and on the square of the distance between them.
Law of Gravitation extends also to the Planets. — Newton
Curvilinear Motion
377
by no means considered his law of gravitation established, just because it explained the motion of the moon round the earth. If the law is universal, it must completely account for the movements of all known bodies of the solar system, including the sun itself. Since the force which attracts the moon as the moon does round the earth, a force directed toward the sun must continually be acting upon them. Is not this the force of gravitation? Recall Kepler's third law. Newton's calculations from it proved that the planets fall toward the sun in one second of time through a space which is less for each planet in exact proportion as the square of its distance from the sun is greater. Also Kepler's second law: if the attracting force emanates from the sun, the planet's radius vector will pass equal areas in equal times. On the other hand, it cannot pass over equal areas at equal times if the center of attraction resides in any direction but that of the sun. So Kepler's second law shows that the force which attracts the planets is directed toward the sun. What chance for farther doubt that this force is the attraction of gravitation of the sun himself? The farther Newton's investigations were pushed, the more striking the confirmation of his theory. Historically, the three laws of Kepler expressed the bare facts of planetary motion, and formed the basis upon which Newton built his law of universal gravitation. But once this general law was established, it was seen that Kepler's laws were immediate consequences of the Newtonian law—merely special cases of the general proposition.
Curvilinear Motion due to a Central Attracting Force.—A facile form of apparatus will help to make clear the motion of a body in arcs of conic sections under influence of a central attracting force, and
A diagram illustrating curvilinear motion.
Approvision to Illustrate Curvilinear Motion
378
Argument for Gravitation
to impress it upon the mind. A glass plate about 18 inches in diameter is leveled (preceding page); and through a central hole projects the conical pole-piece of a large electro-magnet. Smoke the upper face of the glass plate evenly with lampblack. Connect battery circuit, and the apparatus is ready for use.
The ball is placed at different velocities a small bicycle ball of polished steel, aimed a little to one side of the center of attraction. It is convenient to blow the ball out of a stout piece of glass tubing, held in the plane of the plate. The ball then leaves the tube with the velocity shown in the figure shows; and the form of orbit is purely a question of initial velocity. Lowell's law of gravitation leads us to the ellipse with the pole-piece at one of its foci: friction of the ball in the tube causes it to deviate from this path, so that the ball is likely to be drawn in upon the center of attraction, on completing one revolution. A higher speed gives the parabola, whose form is almost that modified by friction in the tube; still lower velocity; and still higher initial velocities produce the two hyperbolas, C and D. This ingenious experiment is due to Wood. The true form of all these curves is given on page 397.
Mutual Attractions.—One farther step had to be taken, to apply Newton's third law of motion to the case of sun, moon, and planets. This law states that whenever one body exerts a force upon another, the latter exerts an equal force in the opposite direction upon the first. Earth, then, cannot attract moon directly; but also attracting earth with an equal force oppositely directed. Sun cannot attract earth unless earth also attracts sun in a similar manner. So, too, the planets must attract each other; and if they do, their motions round the sun must be mutually disturbed, in accordance with the second law of motion. Kepler's laws, then, must need some slight change to fit them to the actual case of mutual attractions. But it was known from observation that the planets deviate
Center of Gravity of Earth-Moon 379
slightly from Kepler's laws in going round the sun. The question, then, arose whether deviations really observed are precisely matched by calculated attractions of planets upon each other. Newton could not answer this question completely, because the observations of his day were insufficiently developed, but over and over again, refined observations of moons and planets since his time have been compared with theories of their movements founded on Newton's law of universal gravitation, as interpreted by the higher mathematics of a later day, until the establishment of that law has become complete and final. Essentially everything is accounted for. And unexpected and triumphant verification came with the discovery of Neptune in 1846; for this proved that the law of mutual attractions was capable, not only of explaining the motions of known bodies, but of pointing out an unknown planet by disturbance it produced in the motion of a known and neighboring one.
Earth and Moon revolve round their Common Center of Gravity. - It has been said that the moon revolves round the earth. This statement needs modification, and it admits of ready illustration. Strictly speaking, the moon revolves, not round the earth, but round the center of gravity of earth and moon considered as a system or unit. And as moon's attraction for earth is equal to earth's for moon, the center of our globe must resolve round that center of gravity also.
Cut a cardboard figure like that in next illustration — exact size inessential. Its center of gravity will lie somewhere on the line joining the centers of two disks. Now place a pin through both disks so that when rotated with a pin until point is found where disks balance each other, and gravity has no tendency to make the card swing round. This point will be the center of gravity. Around it describe a circle passing through centers of large disk and near from its center elsewhere also an arc passing through center of smaller disk. Twirl the card round
380
**Argument for Gravitation**
its center of gravity, by means of a pencil or penholder; or the card may be projected into the air, spinning horizontally, and allowed to fall upon the floor: these circular arcs then, represent paths in space actually traversed by centers of gravity.
To find where center of gravity of earth-moon system lies in the moon's orbit, we find that the mass of our globe is 84 times that of the moon. Moon is therefore 84 times as far from center of gravity of the system as earth's center is. This places the center of gravity at a continually shifting point always within the earth, and at an average distance of about 6000 miles below that place on its surface where the moon is in the first quadrant. The moon really does swing round in this monthly orbit nearly 6000 miles in diameter is a fact readily and abundantly verified by observation.
**The Newtonian Law of Universal Gravitation.** — If this attraction for common things, possessed by the earth and called gravity, extends to the moon; if the same force, only greater on account of greater mass of central body, controls the satellites of Jupiter in their orbits; if the same attraction, greater still on account of the yet greater mass of the sun, holds all the planets in their paths around him; if these bodies are so remote that excessive diminution of the sun's gravitation, in accordance with the law of inverse squares, would render that force so weak as to be unable to effect any visible change in their motion, even in thousands of years. As observed with the telescope, motions
A diagram showing a pendulum swinging back and forth.
Motion of Center of Gravity of Earth-Moon
Gravitation alone Sufficient 381
of certain massive stars relatively near each other do, however, uphold the Newtonian law. No reason, therefore, exists for doubting its way throughout the whole universe of stars. If we pass from the infinitely great to the infinitely little, dividing and subdividing matter as far as possible, each particle still has weight, and therefore must possess power of attraction. Gravity, then, attracts each particle to the earth, and in accordance with the third law of motion, each particle must attract the earth in turn and equally. So the gravitation of earth and moon, for example, is really the mutual attraction of all the particles of the earth to all the particles of the moon; then, this simple but all-comprehensive law may finally be written: Every particle of matter in the universe attracts every other particle with a force exactly proportioned to the product of the masses, and inversely as the square of the distance between them.
**Curvilinear Motion: No Propelling Force needed.** — Newton's theory amounts simply to this: Granted that planets and satellites were in the beginning set in motion (it does not now concern us in what manner), then the attraction of gravitation of the sun for all the planets and of each planet for its satellite would account for the curved forms of their orbits, and for all their motions therein. It may be supposed that the state of motion was originally impressed upon these bodies by a projectile force, or that their present motions are a resultant inheritance from untold ages of development of the solar system from the original solar nebula, in accordance with the working of natural laws. Once set in motion, however, Newton's theory suffices to show that there is no propelling or other force always pushing from behind, nor is the action of any such force at all necessary to keep them going. Once started with a certain velocity,
382
Argument for Gravitation
the uninterrupted working of gravitation maintains every body continually in motion round its central orb. In one part of its elliptic path, a planet, for example, may recede from the sun, but the sun again pulls it back; afterward it again recedes, but equally again it returns, perihelion and aphelion perpetually succeeding each other. Gravitation alone explains perfectly and completely all motions known and observed.
Why the Earth does not fall into the Sun.—Draw several arrows tangent to the ellipse at different points, to show in each case the direction in which earth is going when at that point. From these points of tangency draw dotted lines toward that focus where the sun is, to represent direction in which gravitation is acting. It is apparent that the planet is never moving directly toward the sun, but always at a very large angle with the radius vector; greatest at perihelion, $B$, and aphelion, $D$, where it becomes a right angle. There the sun is powerless either to accelerate or retard. According to Kepler's law of velocity, in orbit it is continually increasing from aphelion to perihelion, because gravitation is acting at an acute angle with the direction of motion $A$. Therefore earth's motion is all the time accelerated, until it reaches perihelion. Here velocity is a maximum, because the sun's attraction has evidently been helping it along, ever since leaving aphelion. Gravitation of the sun, too, has increased, exactly as the square of the planet's distance has decreased. Calculating these two forces at perihelion, it is found that earth's velocity makes the tendency to recede even stronger than the increased attraction of the sun; so that our planet is bound to pass quickly by its nearest point to the sun, and recede again
A diagram showing an ellipse with arrows representing the direction of motion of a planet around the sun. The arrows are drawn at various points on the ellipse, indicating different angles between the radius vector and the line connecting the planet to the sun.
Earth is never moving directly toward the Sun
Strength of Solar Attraction 383
to aphelion. On reaching its farthest point, relation of the two forces is reversed; velocity has been diminishing all the way from perihelion, because gravitation is acting at an obtuse angle with direction of motion, $C$. The earth is all the time retarded, gravitation holding it back, until at aphelion its velocity is so much lessened that even the enfeebled attraction of the sun overpowers it, and therefore begins to draw the earth toward perihelion again. So all the planets are perpetually preserved (1) against falling into the sun, and (2) against receding forever beyond the sphere of his attraction. At points where both these catastrophes at first seem most likely to occur, direction of planet's motion is perpendicular to the light angles to the attractive force; thus is assured that curvature of orbit requisite to carry it farther away from the sun in one case, and in the other to bring it back nearer to him.
Strength of the Sun's Attraction. — It was shown on page 144 that the earth, in traveling $r\pi$ miles, is bent from a truly straight course only one ninth of an inch by the sun's attraction. So it might seem that the force is not very intense after all. But by calculating it and converting it into pounds, we find that a rod or cylinder of this material 1000 miles in diameter would be required to hold sun and earth together; if gravitation were to be annihilated, a sphere of this material 1000 miles in diameter would be required by heavy telegraph wires, the entire hemisphere of the earth turned toward the sun would need to be thickly covered with them,—about 10 to every square inch of surface. But the necessity for this vast weight is removed by considering that on recalling that the weight of the earth is six sextillions of tons, while the weight of the sun is more than 33000 times greater; and the stress between them is inversely as their weights, and directly as each other. Gravitation in the solar system must be thought of as producing stresses of this character between all bodies composing it, and taken as such they are sufficient to keep all parts in place as the product of their masses, and varying inversely as the square of the distance separating them varies. Sun disturbs the moon's elliptic motion greatly, and even Venus, Mars, and Jupiter perturb it perceptibly.
384
**Argument for Gravitation**
**What is Gravitation?** — Distinction is necessary between the terms *gravity* and *gravitation*. On page 88 it was shown that gravity diminishes from pole to equator, on account of (1) centrifugal force of earth's rotation, and (2) oblate-ness of earth, or its polar flattening, by which all points on the equator are further from the center than the poles are. Earth's attraction lessened in this manner is called gravity. Gravitation, on the other hand, is the term used to denote cosmic attraction in accordance with the Newtonian law, between all bodies of the universe taken in pairs, and depending solely upon the product of the masses of each pair and the distance which separates them. Do not make the mistake of saying that Newton discovered gravity, because he did not say that it must be such like saying that Benjamin Franklin discovered lightning. Men had always seen and known that everything is held down by a force of some sort, and had recognized from the earliest times that bodies possess the property called weight. What Newton did do, however, was to discover the universality of gravitation, and the law of its action between all bodies : upon all common objects at the surface of the earth ; upon the moon revolving round us ; and upon the planets and comets revolving round the sun. This cardinal discovery is the greatest in the history of astronomy. Gravity as it exists in nature, for Newton did not discover it nor did he busy himself inquiring, what gravitation is. Indeed, that is not yet known. We only know that it acts instantaneously over distances whether great or small, and in accordance with the Newtonian law ; and no known substance interposed between two bodies has power to interrupt their gravitational tendency toward each other. How it can act at a distance, without contact or connection, is a mystery yet not fathomed.
**Weighing a Planet that has a Satellite.** — If a planet has
**Weighing the Planets**
385
a satellite, it is easy to find the mass, or quantity of matter in terms of sun's mass. First observe mean distance of satellite from its primary, and then find the time of revolution. Cube the distance of any planet from the sun, and divide by the square of its time of revolution : the quotient will be the same for every planet, according to Kepler's third law. Also cube the distance of any satellite of Saturn from the center of the planet, and divide by the square of its time of revolution : the quotient will be the same for every satellite, if distances and periodic times have been correctly measured. Do the same for satellites of other planets,— Mars, Jupiter, Uranus, and Neptune. The quotients will be proportional in each case to mass of central body in terms of the sun; in the case of Saturn, for example, the quotient for each satellite will be $\frac{1}{3}$ that for sun and planets. The sun, then, is 330 times more massive than Saturn, as found by J. L. E. D'Alembert (found the mass of any other planet attended by a satellite). It is not necessary to know the mass of the satellite, because the principle involved is simply that of a falling body; and we know, in the case of the earth, that a body weighing 100 pounds or 1000 pounds will fall no swifter than one which weighs only 10 pounds. By the same method, too, binary stars are weighed (page 454), when their distances from each other and times of revolution become known.
**Weighing a Planet that has No Satellite.—This is a much more difficult problem. Fortunately only two large planets without satellites are known—Mercury and Venus. Their motions can be determined only by finding what disturbances they produce in the motions of other bodies near them. The mass of Venus, for example, is found by the deviation she causes in the motion of the earth. The mass of Mercury is found by the perturbing effect upon Encke's comet, which often approaches very near him. The New-**
TODD'S ASTRON.—25
386
Argument for Gravitation
tonian law of gravitation forms the basis of the intricate calculations by which the mass is found in such a case. But the result is reached only by a process of tedious computation and is never certain to be accurate. Much more precise and direct is the method of determining a planet's mass by its satellite.
The vast difference between the two methods was illustrated at the Naval Observatory, Washington, 1872, shortly after the satellites of Mars were discovered. The mass of that planet, as previously estimated from his perturbation of the earth, was far from right, although it had cost many years' laborious observation. Nine days after the satellites were first seen, a mass of Mars very near the truth was found by only a half hour's facile computation.
**Weighing the Sun.** In weighing the planets, the sun is the unit. Our next inquiry is, what is the sun's own weight? How many times does the mass of the sun exceed that of the earth? Evidently the law of gravitation will afford an answer to this question if we compare the attraction of sun with that of earth at equal distances.
At the surface of the earth a body falls 16.1 feet in the first second of time. Imagine that man's mind all concentrated on a globe of the size of the earth: how far would a body on its surface fall in the first second? First recall how far the earth falls toward the sun (or deviates from a straight line) in a second: it was found to be 0.0099 feet (page 144). This is deflection produced by the sun at a distance of 93,000,000 miles. But we desire to know how far the earth would fall in a second, were its distance only 4000 miles from the sun's center; that is, if it were 23,250 times
A diagram showing Earth and Moon orbiting each other.
WATER OF THE EARTH
WATER OF THE MOON
To explain the Direct and
the Opposite Tides
Explanation of the Tides 387
nearer. Obviously, as attraction varies inversely as the square of the distance, it would fall $0.009 \times (25,250)^2$, or $5,351,520$ feet. But we saw that the earth's mass causes a body to fall $16.1$ feet in the first second; therefore the sun's mass is nearly $332,000$ times greater than that of the earth.
**Gravitation explains the Tides.** — According to the law of gravitation, the attraction of moon and earth is mutual; moon attracts earth as well as earth attracts moon. Earth, then, may be considered also as traveling round the moon (page 380). Therefore, earth falls toward moon, just as moon in going round earth is continually dropping from the straight line in which it would move, if gravitation were not acting. Imagine the earth made up of three parts: (a) the moon itself, independent and free to move upon each other; (b) the water on the side toward the moon; (c) the solid earth itself; (d) the waters on the side away from the moon. In going round moon or sun these three separate bodies would fall toward it, through a greater or less space according to their individual distance from sun or moon. Waters of the opposite tide, therefore, would fall moonward or sunward through the least distance, waters of the direct tide through the greatest distance, and the earth itself through an intermediate distance. The resultant effect would be a separation from earth of the waters on both sides and further sides of it. As, however, these waters are so far apart that they are not entirely independent, but only partially free to move rela- tively to each other, the separation actually produced takes the form of a tidal bulge on two opposite sides. These are known as the direct and the opposite tides.
**Tides raised by the Sun.** — Besides our satellite the only other body concerned in raising tides in the waters of the earth is the sun. Newton demonstrated that the force
388
**Argument for Gravitation**
which raises tides in proportional to the difference of attractions of the tide-raising body on two opposite sides of the earth. Also he showed that this force becomes less as the cube of the distance of tide-producing body grows greater, and that the moon's attraction is greater than sun's attraction, and the sun tide is much exceeded by that of the moon. To ascertain how much : first as to masses merely, supposing their distances equal, sun's action would be
A diagram showing the positions of high and low tides at different phases of the moon cycle.
NEW MOON
LOWEST TIDE
HIGHEST TIDE
PESHEST TIDE
LOWEST TIDE
HIGHEST TIDE
FULL MOON
Spring Tide at Full Moon
Spring Tide at New Moon
261 million times that of moon, because his mass is $81 \times 332,000$ times greater. But sun's distance is also 390 times greater than the moon's; so that
$$\frac{261}{(390)^2}$$
expresses the ratio of sun tide to moon tide, or about the relation of 2 to 5.
**Sun Tides and Moon Tides combined.** — As each body produces both a direct and an opposite tide, it is clear that very high tides must be raised at new moon and at full moon, because sun and moon and earth are then in line.
Luni-Solar Tides 389
These are spring tides (or high-rising tides), occurring, as the figures opposite show, twice every lunation. Similarly is explained the formation of lesser tides, called neap tides, which occur at the moon's first and third quarters. Instead of the sun acting with the moon, as in the formation of the sun acts athwart the moon's, so that the resultant neap tides are raised by the difference of their attractions, instead of the sum. Both relations of sun, moon, and
A diagram showing different types of tides.
- The top left shows "NEAP TIDE at First Quarter".
- The top right shows "NEAP TIDE at Last Quarter".
- The bottom left shows "NEAP TIDE at First Quarter".
- The bottom right shows "NEAP TIDE at Last Quarter".
earth producing such tides are shown. Considering only average distances of sun and moon, spring tides are to neap tides about as 7 to 3. For the earth generally, highest and lowest spring tides must occur when both sun and moon are nearest the earth, that is, when the moon at new and full phases also happen at the same time during the calendar year. The complete theory of tides can be explained only by application of the higher mathematics. But the law of gravitation, taken in connection with other physical laws, fully accounts for all observed facts; so that the tides form another link in the chain of argument for universal gravitation.
| NEAP TIDE at First Quarter |
NEAP TIDE at Last Quarter |
| NEAP TIDE at First Quarter |
NEAP TIDE at Last Quarter |
390
Argument for Gravitation
The Cause of Precession.--- Precession and its effect upon the apparent positions of the stars have already been de-
scribed and illustrated in Chapter vii. This peculiar behav-
ior of the earth's equator is due to the gravitation of sun and moon acting on the earth, combined with the centrifugal force at the earth's
equator. As equator stands at an inclination to ecliptic, this attraction tends, on the whole, to pull its protuberant ring toward the plane of the ecliptic itself. But the earth's
turning on its axis prevents this, and the resultant effect is
a very slow motion of precession at right angles to the
direction of the attracting force, similar to that exemplified by attaching a small weight to the exterior ring of a gyroscope.
Three causes contribute to produce preces-
sion: if the earth were a perfect sphere or if the equator
were in the same plane as the orbit which round the sun (and
with the lunar orbit); or if the earth had no rotation on
its axis, there would be no precession. The action of
forces producing precession is precisely similar to that
which raises the tidal wave; and, accordingly, solar pre-
cession takes place about two fifths as rapidly as that pro-
duced by the moon. The slight attraction of the planets gives rise to a precession $\frac{1}{180}$ that of sun and moon.
Rotation of the Earth's Axis.--- Nutation is a small and periodic
swinging or vibration of the earth's poles north and south, thereby
changing declinations of stars by a few seconds of arc. The axis of our globe, while travelling round the pole of the ecliptic, $A$, has a slight oscillation about $B$ in a circle whose centre is at $C$. This is called
precession. So that the true motion of the pole does not take place along $AB$, an exact small circle around $A$ as a pole, but along a wavy arc as shown in fig. 156. The period of nutation is one year,
given time. This wavy motion of the axis, and consequent undu-
lation in the circular curve of precession, is called nutation. The period of one cycle oscillation due to lunar nutation is 181 years, so that there are 7 cycles in 200 years. The amplitude is greatly in excess
of the proportion represented in the figure. In reality there are nearly
A diagram showing a wavy line representing nutation around an axis.
Nutation Illustrated 391
1400 of them. Just as the celestial equator glides once round on the ecliptic in 25,000 years, as a result of precession, so the moon's orbit also slips once round the ecliptic in 181 years, thereby changing slightly the direction of moon's attraction upon the equatorial pro-
tuberance of our earth, and producing nutation.
A diagram showing the motion of the Celestial Pole by Nutation.
Illustrating Motion of the Celestial Pole by Nutation
When Newton had succeeded in proving that his law of universal gravitation accounted not only for the motions of the satellites round the planets, for their own motions round the sun, for the rise and fall of the tides, and for those changes in apparent positions of the stars occasioned by precession and nutation, evidence in favor of his theory of gravitation became overwhelming, and it was thenceforward accepted as the true explanation of all celestial motions.
CHAPTER XV
COMETS AND METEORS
C
OMETS, as well as other unusual appearances in the heavens, were construed by very ancient peoples into an expression of disapproval from their deities. 'Fireballs flung by an angry God;' they were for centuries thought to be 'signs and wonders,' - a sort of celestial portent of every kind of disaster. The downfall of Nero was supposed to be heralded by a comet; and for centuries the densest superstition clustered about these objects.
True Theory of Comets not Modern. - Chaldean star-gazers were apparently the sole ancient nation to regard comets as merely harmless wanderers in space. The Pythagoreans, only one of the few philosophers, had some general idea that comets might be bodies obeying fixed laws, returning perhaps at definite intervals.
Seneca held this view, and Emperor Vespasian attempted to laugh down the popular superstitions. But in those days, far-seeing utterances had little effect upon a world full of obstinate ignorance. Some of the old prophecies were still current, and the common belief in an oracular which, according to the sky and so coming to the notice of God, are set on fire by His wrath. Texts of Scripture were twisted into apparent proofs of the supernatural character of comets, and for several centuries the belief persisted in the existence of superstitious fanaticalism. Copernicus, of course, refused to regard comets as supernatural warnings, but the 16th century generally accepted their evil omens as facts. In England, however, the change came much later than in other countries; and even now, though we have seen the dawn of changing views, although even as late as the end of that century, knowledge of the few facts known about comets was kept so far as possible from students in the universities, that their religious beliefs might not be contaminated.
302
Discoveries of Comets 393
But credence began to be given to the statements of Tycho Brahe and Kepler that comets were supralunar, or beyond the moon, and perhaps not so intimately concerned in war, pestilence, and famine as was believed. Newton farther demonstrated that comets are as obedient to law as planets; and with his authoritative statements came the full daylight of the modern view.
Discoveries of Comets.
Comets are nearly all discovered by their motion among the stars. The illustration shows the field of view of a telescope, in which appeared each night two faint objects. Upper one remained stationary among the stars, but lower one was recognized as a comet because it moved, as the arrow shows, and was seen each night farther to the right. A century ago, Caroline Herschel in England, and Messier in France, were the chief discoverers of comets. Pons discovered 30 comets in the first quarter of the 19th century.
Among other noteworthy European 'comet-hunters' during the middle and latter half of this century were Broersen, Donati, and Galle. In America, Lowell was preeminently successful. Between them and several other astronomers, both at home and abroad, the
Early View of Donati's Comet (1858)
Brooks, and Barnard have been successful. Between them and several other astronomers, both at home and abroad, the
A Comet is discovered by its Motion
A Comet is discovered by its Motion
394
Comets and Meteors
entire available night-time sky is parcelled out for careful telescopic search, and it is not likely that many comets, at all within the range of visibility from the earth, escape their critical gate. Sweeping for comets is an extremely difficult task, re-
quiring close application and much patience. Large and costly instruments are by no means essential. Herschel discovered all his comets with a spy-
glass of 2] inches diameter, magnifying only five times; and the name of Dicks, who was one of the comet-hunters, a doorkeeper at the observa-
tory of Marseille, is now more famous in astronomy than that of Tholus, the then director of that observatory, who taught and encouraged him.
Their Appearance. — Usually a comet has three parts. The
nucleus is the bright, star-like point which is the kernel, the true, potential comet.
Around this is spread the coma, a sort of luminous fog,
shading from the nucleus, and forming with it the head. Still
beyond is the delicate tail,
stretching away into space.
And this to the world in gen-
eral is the comet itself, though always the least dense of the whole. It may be entirely wanting, or hardly detectible; the tail is again an exten-
sion millions of miles long.
Although usually a single brush of light, comets have been seen with no less than six tails.
Halley's Comet (1835)
Head of Donati's Comet (1858)
Development of the Tail
Changes in Appearance. — With increase in a comet's speed on approaching the sun and its state of excitation, perhaps electrical, its physical appearance changes and develops accordingly. When remote from the sun, it is never visible except by aid of a telescope, and their appearance is well shown at top of opposite page; but on approaching nearer the sun, a nucleus will often develop and throw off jets of luminosity toward the sun, sometimes curving round and opening like a fan. On rare occasions the comet will become so brilliant as to be visible in broad daylight. The most remarkable development of the tail is shown in the development of the tail; and this showy appendage sometimes reaches stupendous lengths, even so great as sixty millions of miles, growing often several million miles in a day.
Development and Direction of Tail. — It is not a correct analogy that the tail streams out behind like a shower of sparks from a sparkler. There is no medium to spread the tail; for there is no material substance like air in interplanetary space, and therefore nothing to sweep the tail into the line of motion. Explanation of the backward sweep of the tail, nearly always away from the sun, as in above diagram, is found in the fact that Tail always points away from the Sun
A diagram showing a comet with a nucleus and a long tail extending outward from it. The tail appears to be moving away from the sun.
396 Comets and Meteors
while the comet is attracted, the tail is probably repelled by the sun. Rapid growth of tail upon approaching the sun is explainable in this way: the comet as a solid is attracted, but when it comes near enough to be partly dissipated into vapor, the heat energy of the sun is so great that gravitation is entirely overcome, and the tail streams visibly away from the sun, as long as it is near enough to have part of its substance continually turning into vapor. Receding, the great heat diminishes; and the tail becomes smaller, because less material is converted into vapor.
**Types of Cometary Tails.** — Bredチン divides tails of comets into three types: (1) those absolutely straight in space, or nearly so, like the tail of the great comet of 1843; (2) tails gently curved, like the broad streamers of Donati's comet (1858) (page 20); (3) short bushy tails, curving sharply round from the comet's nucleus, as in Encke's comet. The origin of tails of the first type is related to ejections of hydrogen, the lightest element known, and the sun's repulsive force is in this case 14 times stronger than his gravitational attraction. The highly curved tails of the second type are due to hydrocarbons repelled with a force somewhat in excess of solar gravity. In producing the sharply curved tails of the third type, the sun's repellent energy is about one fifth that of his gravity, and these tails are formed from emanations of still heavier substances, principally iron and chlorine.
Types of Cometary Tails (Bredchin)
Types of Cometary Tails (Bredchin)
Cometary Orbits 397
This theory permits a complete explanation of a comet's possessing tails of two different types; or even tails of all three distinct types.
Hussey's fine photograph of comet Rordame-Quinisset (1893) showed four tails, which subsequently condensed into a single one. Evidently the ejected matter is composed of water, ammonia, carbon, or iron, or any combination of these, according to the chemical composition of substances forming the nucleus.
Observations for an Orbit. — As soon as a new comet is discovered, its position among the stars is accurately observed at once. On subsequent evenings, these observations are repeated; and after three complete observations have been obtained, the precise path of the comet can generally be calculated. This path will be one of the three conic sections:
(1) if it is an ellipse, then the comet belongs to the class of periodic comets, and the length of its period will be greater as the eccentricity of orbit is greater;
(2) if the path is a parabola, the comet will retreat from the sun along a line nearly parallel to that by which it came in from the stellar depths;
(3) if a hyperbola, the paths of approach to and recession from the sun will be widely divergent.
Cometary Orbits. — Some comets are permanent members of the solar system, while others visit us but once. Three forms of path are possible for them—the ellipse, the parabola, and the hyperbola. With a path of the first type only can the comet remain permanently attached to the sun's family. The other two are open curves, as in above diagram; and after once swinging closely round the sun, and saluting the ruler of our solar system, the comet then plunges again into unmeasured distances of space.
A diagram showing three conic sections: an ellipse, a parabola, and a hyperbola.
Forms of Cometary Orbits
398
Comets and Meteors
Whether or not an orbit is a closed or open curve depends entirely upon velocity. If, when the comet is at distance units, or 93,000,000 miles from the sun, its speed exceeds 26 miles a second, it will never come back; if less, it will return to the sun, but with much longer periods more or less remote.
Very often the velocity of a comet so as to meet this critical value is such that a return is impossible; then it is difficult to say certainly whether it will ever return or not. Such comets do make periodic visits which are accurately foretold.
The orbits of many of their orbits show in numerous instances that these comets were captured by planets long ago. When it has reduced their original velocity below 26 miles a second, they are compelled to remain as members of the solar system indefinitely, and do not leave the control of any planet.
A Projectile's Path is a Parabola.
(From an Instantaneous Photograph by Lowell.)
This proposition, demonstrated mathematically from the laws of motion, shows the exact form of curves described by objects thrown high into the air. Resistance of the atmosphere does not affect the figure of the curve appreciably. The photograph shown here exhibits the truth of this proposition beautifully, in its flight from the bat, high into the air, and then swiftly down to the "catcher" whom the photograph shows in the act of catching the ball, though some- what exhausted. The line drawn through the point where the ball is called the directrix, and the vertical line through the middle of the parabola is its axis. One point in the axis, called the focus, is at a far below the directrix than any other point on it. Another property of remarkable properties, one of which is that every point in the curve is just as far from the focus as it is perpendicularly distant from the directrix (shown by equality of the dotted lines). Another property, very important for much utilisation in optics, is that from a target at any point of the parabola, the line from this point to the focus makes
The Periodic Comets 399
the same angle with the tangent that a line drawn from the point of tangency parallel to the axis does. According to this property, parallel rays all converge to the focus of a reflector (page 196).
**Direction of their Motion.** — Unlike members of the solar system in good and regular planetary standing, comets move round the sun, some in the same direction as the planets; others revolve just opposite, that is, from east to west. The planes of cometary orbits, too, lie in all directions— their paths may be inclined as much as 90° to the ecliptic. A comet can be observed from the earth, and its position determined, only while in that part of its orbit nearer the sun. Generally this is only a brief interval relatively to the comet's entire period, because motion near perihelion is very swift. It is desirable whether any comet has ever been observed farther from the sun than Jupiter.
**Dimensions of Comets.** — Nucleus and head or coma of a comet are the only portions to which dimension can strictly be assigned. There are doubtless many comets whose come are so small that we never see them—probably all less than 15,000 miles in diameter remain undiscovered. The heads of telescopic comets vary from about 25,000 to 100,000 miles in diameter; that of Donati's comet of 1818 was 250,000 miles in diameter, and that of the great comet of 1811, the greatest on record, was nearly five times as large. The tails are immensely extensive; short ones being about 10,000,000 miles long, and the longest ones (that of the comet of 1882, for example) exceeding 100,000,000. To realize this prodigious bulk, one must remember that if such a comet's head were at the sun, the tail would stretch far outside and beyond the earth.
**The Periodic Comets.** — Comets moving round the sun in well-known elliptic paths are called periodic comets. About 30 such are now known, with periods less than 100
400
Comets and Meteors
years in duration, the shortest being that of Encke's comet (34 years), and the longest that of Halley's (about 76 years). Nearly all of these bodies are invisible to the naked eye, and only about half of them have as yet been observed at more than a single return. Nearly as many comets travel in long oval paths, but their periods are hundreds or even thousands of years long, so that their return to perihelion has not yet been verified.
**Planetary Families of Comets.** — When periodic comets are classified according to distance from the sun at their aphelion, it is found that there is a group of several corresponding to the distance of each large outer planet from the sun. Of these, the Jupiter family of comets is the most remarkable, and its distribution is excellently shown on the opposite page. Without much doubt, these comets originally described open orbits, either parabolas or hyperbolas; but on approaching the sun, they passed so near Jupiter that he reduced their velocity below the parabolic limit, and they have since been forced to travel in elliptical orbits, having indeed been captured by the overmastering attraction of the giant planet. While Jupiter's family of comets numbers 18, Saturn similarly has 2, Uranus 3, and Neptune 6.
**Groups of Comets.** — Vagaries in structure of comets prevent any classification into any peculiarities of mere physical appearance. Identity of these bodies then, or the return of a given comet, can be established only by similarity of orbit. In several instances comets have made their appearance at irregular intervals, traveling in one and the same orbit. They could not be one and the same comet; so these bodies pursuing the same track in the celestial spaces are called groups of comets.
The most remarkable of these groups consists of the comets of 1668, 1843, 1880, 1882, and 1887, all of which travel *randomly* round the sun.
Jupiter's Family of Comets. (From Professor Payne's Popular Astronomy)
TODD'S ASTRON. - 36 404
402
Comets and Meteors
Probably they are fragments of a comet, originally of prodigious size, but disrupted by the sun at an early period in its history; because the perihelion point is less than 300,000 miles from the sun's surface. At this distance an incalculably great disturbing tidal force would be exerted by the sun on such a body, and it would be reduced to a volume; and separate or fragmentary comets would naturally result.
Number of Comets.—In the historical and scientific annals of the past, nearly 1000 comets are recorded. Of these about 100 were reappearances; so that the total number of distinct comets known and observed is between 800 and 900.
During the centuries of the Christian era preceding the eighteenth, the average number was about 90 per century; but nearly all these were bright comets, discovered and observed without telescopes. As telescopes came to be used more and more, 70 comets belong to the eightieth and ninetieth centuries; and only 20 to the nineteenth. Of this last number, less than one tenth could have been discov- ered without telescopes. The average number of bright comets appears to vary but little from century to century. The number of meteors, however, each year is on the increase, because more observers are engaged in the search than formerly, and their work is done with greater skill and organized system. About seven comets are now observed each year. Fewer are visible in summer than in winter. During the 200 years although but a minute in the probable duration of the solar system"—the comets coming within reach of our telescopes are very few indeed—sands; for it is probable that about 1000 comets pass within visible range from the earth every century. It is not, however, likely that more than two hundred appear in any one year.
Remarkable Comets before 1850.—Comets of immense proportions have visited our skies since the earliest times. Others having singular characteristics must be mentioned also. Halley's comet is famous because it was the first whose periodicity was proved. This comet appeared in 1759, but the verification did not take place till 1759, again in 1835,
Cheeseaux's Multi-sited Comet (1759)
Cheeseaux's Multi-sited Comet (1759)
The Lost Biela's Comet 403
and it will reappear in 1910. The comet of 1784 (opposite) had a fan-shaped, multiple tail. The great comet of 1811 was one of the finest of the 19th century, and its period is about 900 years in duration. In 1818 Pons discovered a very small comet, which has become famous because of its return in 1866, and its revolution took some 31 years. This fact was discovered by Lick, a great German astronomer, and the comet is now known as Encke's comet. It has been seen at every return to perihelion, three times every ten years. Up to 1866, the period was considered to be 30 years. But observations show that it returns at least 24 hours, at each return; and this diminution led to the hypothesis of a resisting medium in space - not well sustained by more recent investigations. The comet of 1866 was remarkable for its remarkable eccentricities of form and structure, and is now invisible without a telescope. Returns are in 1893, 1895, and 1901. The great comet of 1843, perhaps the most remarkable of all known comets, was visible in full extent for only two days. Its orbit was so eccentric that it must have passed within 90,000 miles of the surface of the sun - nearer than any known body. At perihelion, its motion was unprecedented in brilliance, travelling 1,500,000 miles an hour. Its period is between 390 and 600 years.
The Lost Biela's Comet. — Montaigne at Limoges, France, discov- ered in 1773 a comet which was seen again by Pons in 1805, and then escaped sight until 1826. It was rediscovered and thought to be new by an Austrian officer named Blei- n, by whose name it has been since been known. He calculated its orbit, and showed that the period was 67 years. In 1843, when it returned, it was seen to have split into two unequal fragments, as in the illustration and their distance apart had greatly increased since its first appearance in 1825. At no return since that date has Biela's comet been seen ; and the showers of meteors observed near the end of November in 1872, 1882 and 1902 may be attributed to the passage of the orbit of this lost body, and to indicate its further, if not complete dis- integration. These meteors are, therefore, known as the Biellids; also Andromedes, because they appear to come from the constellation of Andromeda. In December, 1892, a meteorite fell on Decem- ber, a large iron meteorite fell, and was picked up in Mazapil, Mexico.
Without doubt it once formed part of Biela's comet.
Remarkable Comets between 1850 and 1875.— In 1848 appeared Donati's comet, which attained its greatest brilliancy in October, having
Biela's Double Comet (1845-46)
404
Comets and Meteors
a tail 40° long, sharply curved, and 8° in extreme breadth. Also there were two additional tails, nearly straight, and very long and narrow, as shown in the following illustration. Its orbit is elliptic, with a period of nearly 2000 years. In 1861 appeared another great comet. Its tail was very long and narrow, and its body was almost straight. The outer ones attained the enormous apparent length of nearly 120°, and were very divergent, owing to immersion of the earth's depth of 300,000 miles. This comet also travels round the sun in an elliptic path, with a period exceeding four centuries. It first appeared in 1874, and is known as Coggia's comet. Its nucleus was of the size of a large apple, about 50° in length, and very slightly curved. Coggia's comet was the first of striking brilliancy to which the attention of astronomers was directed; but it was found that its gaseous surroundings were in large part composed of carbon monoxide gas mixed with carbon. Coggia's comet, when far from perihelion, presented an anomalous appearance, well shown by the following diagram. The opaque nucleus is seen at the bright streak immediately following the nucleus and running through the middle of the tail. When nearer the sun, this streak was replaced by the tail. No satisfactory explanation of either has yet been proposed. The orbit of Coggia's comet is an ellipse of so great eccentricity that this body cannot resume its place in the solar system.
Remarkable Comets between 1825 and 1860.—Only two require especial mention, the first of which was discovered in 1881, and was a splendid object in the northern heavens in June of that year. It was similar to Halley's comet, but much more brilliant, and was successfully photographed. In 1882 there were two bright comets, one of them in many respects extraordinary. So great was the intrinsic brightness of their nuclei that they could be seen even during transit over the sun. Indeed, it passed between the earth and the sun, in actual transit; and just before entering upon the disk, the intrinsic brightness of the nucleus seemed to be scarcely inferior to that of the sun itself.
It was a comet of huge proportions. Its tail stretched through space over a distance exceeding that of the sun from the earth, and parts of Donati's Triple-tailed Comet of 1828
When Will the Next Comet Come 405
its head passed within 300,000 miles of the solar surface, at a speed of 300 miles a second. Probably this near approach explains what was seen to take place on recession from the sun—the breaking up of the comet's head into several separate nuclear masses, each pursuing an independent path. Also the tail, which was very long and perpendicular, changed its course by being single and nearly straight while again there were two tails slightly curved.
Besides this, its coma was surrounded by a faint cloud or envelope several million miles long, extending toward the sun.
Remarkable comets appeared in 1890—
No very bright comet appeared between 1882 and 1897; but the Brooks comet of 1893, although a faint one, was visible to the naked eye, is worthy of note because of some remarkable photographic effects it produced.
The illustration (next page) is re-
produced from one of them, and enlarged from the original negative.
Changes in the comet's orbit were rapid and violent, and the tail appeared broken and distorted, like 'a torch flickering in a stormy wind.' The comet is, in the wind.' Ejections of matter from the comet's nucleus may have been irregular or it may have encountered some obstacle which shat-
tered it—perhaps a swarm of meteors.
When will the Next Comet come?—If a large bright comet is meant, the answer must be that astronomers cannot tell. One may blaze into view at almost any time. During the latter half of the 19th century, bright comets have come to perihelion at an average interval of about seven years. But at least since 1867 this interval has been more than doubled since the last great comet (1846). A bright one is certain, however, in 1910, because Halley's periodic comet, last seen in 1835, will return in that year. Of the lesser and fainter periodic comets, several return nearly every year; but they are for the most part telescopic, and
Drawings of Coggia's Comet (1874)
406
Comets and Meteors
rarely attract the attention of any one save the astronomers.
Three are due in 1898, and four in 1899.
Light of Comets.---The light of comets is dull and feeble,
and not always uniform. When in the farther part of
their orbits, comets seem to shine only by light reflected from the sun; and that is why they so soon become invisible, on going away from perihelion. They are then bodies essentially dark and opaque. But with approach to-
ward the sun, the vast increase in bright-
ness, often irregular, is due to light
emitted by the comet itself, and it is
this intrinsic brightness of comets,
that, for the most part, makes them
the striking objects they are. In this
manner not completely understood, radiations of the sun act upon loosely com-
pacted materials of the comet's head,
producing a luminous condition which,
in connection with the repulsive force
exerted by that central orb gives rise to
all the curious phenomena of the heads
and tails of comets.
Chemical Composition.---Through analysis of the light of comets by the
spectroscope it has been known that the chief elements in their composition is carbon, combined with hydrogen; that is, hydro-
carbons. The elements so far found are few. Sodium, magnesium, and iron were
found in the great comet of 1882; also nitrogen, and probably oxygen. It is not certain that the spectrum of a comet remains always the same; perhaps there are
Brooke's Comet of 1893 (photographed by Barnard)
Comets Discovered during Eclipses 407
rapid changes on approaching the sun. The faint continuous spectrum, a background for brighter lines in the blue, green, and yellow, is reflected sunlight.
The illustration shows a part of the spectrum of the comet of 1882, with the spectrum of the sun superposed. The great prominence distinctly confirms this hypothesis. The spectra of between 20 and 30 comets have been observed in all, and they appear to have in general very nearly the same chemical composition.
Spectrum of Comet of 1882 (Sir William Huggins)
Photographing Comets. — The light of a comet is usually feeble, at least so far as the eye is concerned, and its active power is even less.
How then can a comet be photographed? Evidently in one of two ways only: either by making a long exposure, or by increasing the aperture of the exposure must be very long. Before invention of the modern sensitive dry plate, it had been found impossible to photograph comets.
The first successful photographs of comets were made by Sir William Huggins who photographed the comet of 1880. Since 1890 many faint comets have been successfully photographed at the Lick Observatory, and elsewhere, by the use of very sensitive plates and a long exposure. Next illustrations show some photographs taken at Lick Observatory which show that exposure was prolonged to i h. o m. The comet was moving rapidly, and as the clockwork moving telescope was made to follow the comet accurately, it was found that it is appear upon the photographs, not as points of light, but as parallel lines of equal length. Hinsey and Wil- son have met with equal success.
Comets discovered during Eclipses. — Probably more than one half of all comets coming within range of visibility from earth remain undiscovered, because of the overpowering brilliancy of the sun. Ought not, then, new comets to be discovered during total eclipses of the sun? This has actually happened on at least two such occasions, and a like appearance has been suspected on two more.
| K |
H |
b |
G |
| 27 |
23 |
19 |
15 |
| 23 |
20 |
16 |
12 |
| 20 |
17 |
10 |
6 |
| 17 |
14 |
4 |
4 |
| 14 |
11 |
3 |
3 |
| 11 |
8 |
2 |
2 |
| 8 |
5 |
|
|
| 5 |
|
|
|
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | td td=""> <page_number>407</page_number> |
408
**Comets and Meteors**
During the total eclipse of the 17th of May, 1882, observed in Egypt, Schuster photographed a new comet alongside the solar corona, as shown on page go1. This comet was named for Tewkill, who was then khedive.
Also, on the same day, a second comet was photographed immediately upon the streamers of the corona, during the total eclipse of the 16th of April, 1853, by Schaerle and Schuster. Neither of these comets has been seen again, and neither of them has since been seen. As there is but one observation of each, nothing is known about their orbits round the sun, nor whether they will ever return.
**Mass and Density.** — So small are the masses of comets that only estimates can be given as compared with the mass of the earth. Comets have in certain instances approached very near to lesser bodies of the solar system; but while cometary orbits and motions have been greatly disturbed thereby, no change has been observed in the motion of satellites or other bodies near which a comet has passed. So this mass must be slight. Probably no comet's mass is so great as the thirtieth part of the earth's; but even if only one third of this, it would still equal a ball of iron 100 miles in diameter. The volume of a comet is also small, while its volume is so vast, what must be the density of these bodies? For the density is equal to the mass divided by the volume, and comets must, therefore, be exceedingly thin and tenuous. On those rare occasions when stars have been observed through the tail of a comet, although it may be millions of miles in thickness, still no diminution of the star's luster has been perceived. Even through the denser coma the light of a star passes undimmed; though the star's image, if very near the comet's nucleus, may be rendered
Galileo's Comet of 1894 (photographed by Herschel)
Collision with a Comet 409
somewhat indistinct. The air pump is often used to pro-
duce an approach to a perfect vacuum ; but in a cubic
yard of such vacuum there would be many hundred times
the amount of matter in a cubic yard of a comet's head.
**Passing through a Comet's Tail.** —Curious as it may seem, these enormous tails are in actual mass so slight that thrusting the hand into their midst would bring no recognition to the sense of touch. Collision would be much like an encounter with a shadow. Comets' tails are excessively airy and thin, or, as Sir John Herschel remarks, possibly only an affair of pounds or even ounces.
The mass of a comet's head may be large or small; it may not be more than a very large stone, or in the case of the larger comets it is perfectly possible that the mass of the head should be composed of an aggregation of many hundreds or even thousands of small compact bodies, stony and metallic. Usually the speed is so great that the comet may pass through the atmosphere without causing the shock of collision with any of the planets. In at least two instances it is known that the earth actually passed through the tail of a comet, once on 30th June, 1861. The figure shows positions of sun (S), head of comet (C) and tail (T). The comet was seen to have a long diaphanous tail. But we came through without being in the least conscious of it, except from calculations of the comet's position.
**Collision with a Comet.** —As the orbits of comets lie at all possible inclinations of the earth's path, or ecliptic, and as the motion of these erratic bodies may be either direct or retrograde, evidently it is entirely possible that our planet may some time collide with a comet, because these bodies
A diagram showing Earth about to pass through Tail of Comet of 1861.
Earth about to pass through Tail of Comet of 1861
410
Comets and Meteors
exist in space in vast numbers. It has been estimated that one such collision must take place every 1,500,000 years, so that the chances are immensely against the happening of such an event at any specific time, and comets can hardly be regarded as dangerous bodies. Not only would it be futile, but not worth the while to 'excommuni-
cate' them, as the pope did in centuries gone by.
However, should the head of a large comet collide squarely with our globe—the consequences might be inconceivably dire: probably the air and water would be instantly consumed and dissipated, and a con-
siderable region of the earth's surface would be raised to incandescence. But considering the immense distance between the sun and the earth, and the much more probable encounter of the earth's atmosphere with solid particles of a large hydricarbonet comet—it might well happen that diffused rays from the sun would be sufficient to raise the temperature of the atmosphere so as to vitate it as to render it unsuitable for breathing.
In this manner, while the earth itself, its oceans, and even human habi-
tations, might escape unharmed, it is not difficult to see how even a brief fire-storm might occur which might cause universal death to nearly all forms of animal existence.
Origin of Comets.—The origin of comets is still shrouded in mys-
tery. They may have originated in some distant part of our solar system,
and so are entirely extra-solar in origin. Arriving apparently from all points of space in their journey from one star to another, they wheel about the sun somewhat like moons round a candle. Sometimes, as already mentioned, they appear to pass through the solar system without making any permanent impression upon it; sometimes they make a visit of a future visit, though at some date which cannot be accurately assigned. Sometimes they continue upon interstellar journeys of such vast periods that no return appears likely within any period during which man can ever be expected. Probably the comets are but chips in the work-
shop of the skies; mere waste pieces of the stuff that stars are made of.
It has been urged too, that these comets may have been formed by various cos motions ejected by our own sun or the larger planets of our system; but here we tread only the vast fields of mere conjecture, tempting, though unsatisfying.
Disintegration of Comets.—Every return to perihelion appears to have a disintegrating effect upon a comet. In a few cases this process has actually been taking place while under observation; for example, the lost
**Meteors and Shooting Stars** 411
Bial's comet in 1846, the great comet of 1882, and Brooks's comet of 1889, the heads of which were seen either to divide or to be divided into fragments. Groups of comets probably represent a more complete disintegration.
For example, the comets of 1843, 1880, 1882, and 1889 travel tandem, and originally were probably one huge comet. In the case of still other comets, this disintegration has gone so far that the original cometary mass is now entirely obliterated. Instead of a comet, then, there exists only a group of small fragments flying in different directions. These are too small, in fact, to be separately visible in space. Such interplanetary masses, originally single comets of large proportions, have by their repeated collisions with each other been reduced to fragments, and by renewed action of disrupting forces ; and all that is now left of them is an infinity of meteoric particles, trailing everywhere along the original orbit. The astronomer becomes aware of the existence of these small bodies when they enter our atmosphere, sometimes penetrating even to the surface of the earth itself.
**Meteors, Shooting Stars, and Meteories.** — Particles of matter thought to have their origin in disintegrated comets, and moving round the sun in orbits of their own, are called meteors. In large part, our knowledge of these bodies is confined to the relatively few which collide with the earth. The energy of their motion is suddenly converted into heat on impact with the atmosphere, and friction in passing swiftly through it. As a rule, this speedily vaporizes their entire substance, the exterior being brushed off by the air as soon as melted, often leaving a visible train in the sky. The luminous tracks pass through the upper atmosphere, and may be observed at altitudes greater than 100 miles, and few below 30 miles. These paths, if very bright, can be recorded with great precision by photography as Wolf, Barnard, and Elkin have done.
As the speed of meteors through the air is comparable with that of our globe round the sun, we know that their motion is controlled by the sun's attraction, not the earth's.
**412 Comets and Meteors**
Very small meteors, sometimes falling in showers, are frequently called shooting stars, but the late Professor Newton's view is gradually gaining ground, that there is no definite line of distinction. The shooting stars are thought to be very much smaller than meteors, because they are visible only for a short time, and disappear completely at much greater heights than the meteors do. Many millions of them collide with our atmosphere every day, and are quickly dissipated. Although the average of them are not more massive than one grain of sand, yet they are so numerous that without the kindly mantle of the air (were it possible for such to live without it) would be pelted to death. If a meteor passes completely through the atmosphere, it is said to be a meteorite, and this term comes known as a meteorite. Many thousand pounds of such inter-planetary material have been collected from all parts of the earth, and the specimens preserved in cabinets and museums are among the most complete of which are London, Paris, Berlin, Vienna. Remarkable collections in the United States are at Amherst College, Harvard and Yale Universities, and in the National Museum at Washington.
**Meteors most Abundant in the Morning.** — Run rapidly in a rain-storm: the chest becomes wetter than the back, because of advance of the body to the left side. In like manner, when we look toward the north hemisphere of the earth, in its motion round the sun, is pelted by more meteors than any other portion. As every part of the earth is turned toward the radiant during the day of 24 hours, it is obvious that the most abundant meteors must come from directions opposite to those of the dome of the sky is nearly central around the general direction of our motion about the sun; in other words, when apex of earth's way is southward, meteors will be most numerous in directions oppo- sition figures on pages 134-5; it is apparent that this takes place about sunrise; and in like manner, when apex is northward where the sun is above the earth, and illuminating the horizon, meteors will be most numerous at d., and the earth is speed- ing through space in the di- rection d., indicated by the great arc shown in figure 106. advancing to meet the meteors which seem to fall from the directions p.. If we suppose meteoric particles evenly distributed throughout the shawl, the number becoming visible by collision with our atmos- phere will increase from midnight onward to six in the morning, pro- vided the season is such that dawn does not interfere. From noon at
A diagram showing a meteor streaking across a night sky.
When Meteors are most Abundant
The Radiant Point 413
at to sunset at A, there would be a gradual decrease, with the fewest meteors falling from the directions JFF, upon the earth's rearward hemisphere, etc. Also, as to time of the year, it is well known that our globe encounters about three times as many shooting stars in passing from aphelion to perihelion as from perihelion to aphelion.
**Radiant Point.** —On almost any clear, moonless night, especially in April, August, November, and December, a few moments of close watching will show one or more shooting stars. Ordinarily, they appear in any quarter of the sky; and on infrequent occasions they streak the heavens by hundreds and thousands, for hours at a time, as in November of 1799 and 1833. These are known as meteoric showers. Careful watching has revealed the very important fact, that practically all the luminous streaks of a shower, if prolonged backward, meet in a small area of the sky which is fixed among the stars. Arrows in the following figure indicate the visible paths of 20 meteors, and the direction of their flight. It is clear that lines drawn through them will nearly all strike within the ring. This area is technically known as the radiant point, or simply the radiant. Divergence from it in every direction is only apparent—a mere effect of perspective, proving that meteors move through space in parallel lines. The radiant is simply the visible point. Notice that these luminous paths are longer, the farther they are from the radiant; if a meteor were to meet the earth head on, its trail would be foreshortened to a point, and charted within the area of the radiant itself. About 300 such radiant points are now
A diagram illustrating the concept of a radiant point in meteor showers.
To illustrate the Radiant Point
414
Comets and Meteors
known, of which perhaps 50 are very well established.
The constellation in which the radiant falls gives the name to the shower; so there are Leonids and Perseids, Andromedas and Geminids, and the like.
List of Principal Meteor Showers. — Following is given, in tabular form, a short list of the chief meteoric displays of the year, according to Densing, a prominent English authority —
| ANNUAL SHOWERS OF METEORS |
| Name of Shower |
Position of Radiant |
Date of Maximum |
DURATION in Days |
|
R.A. |
Decl. |
|
| Quadrantids |
15 h. 19 m. |
N. 33° |
Jan. 2 |
| Lyrids |
17 59 S. 32° |
N. 32° |
April 18 |
| Eta Aquarids |
35 h. 38 m. |
S. 12° |
May 8 |
| Delta Aquarids |
22 38 S. 12° |
|
July 28 |
| Perseids |
3 h. |
N. 57° |
Aug. 10 |
| Orionids |
6 h. |
N. 15° |
Oct. 19 |
| Louidids |
10 h. |
N. 23° |
Nov. 13 |
| Andromedas |
41 h. |
N. 43° |
Dec. 25 |
| Geminids |
7 12 h. |
N. 33° |
Dec. 7 |
| | | 14 |
When more than one radiant falls in any constellation, the usual designation of the nearest star is added, to distinguish between them.
Paths of Meteors. — Repeated observation of the paths of meteors belonging to any particular radiant soon establishes the fact that showers recur at about the same time of the year. Also that few meteors fall with any prominently marked at intervals of a number of years. So it has become possible to predict showers of meteors, which on several occasions have been signally verified.
Conspicuously so is the case of the shower of November, 1866, which came true to time and place; and a like
**Meteoric Orbits**
415
shower is confidently predicted for 12th-14th, November, 1899. The periodic time of these meteors is $3\frac{1}{4}$ years.
The position of their radiant among the stars, and the direction in which the meteors are seen to travel, has afforded the means of calculating the orbits of these bodies, and of determining their distance from space. The figure shows the orbit of the Leonids, or November meteors, as related to the paths of the planets, and it is evident that these bodies, although they are at a distance of 100,000,000 miles from the sun at their perihelion, recede about 16½ years later to a distance greater than that of Uranus. They are not aggregated at a single point in their orbit, but are scattered over a considerable part of it, called the 'Gem of the ring.' As the breadth of the gem takes more than two-thirds of the peri-
helion point, which nearly coincides with the position of the earth in its orbit. In this case, there will usually be two or three meteoric showers at yearly intervals, while the entire shoul
d be passed by them. So that lesser showers may be expected in November of 1868 and 1900, in addition to the chief shower of 1899.
**Meteoric Orbits in Space.**
—But it must not be inferred from the figure here given that the Leonids travel in the plane of the planetary orbits; for, at the time when their distance from the sun is equal to that of the planetary bodies, they are really very remote from all the planets except the earth and Uranus. This is because of the large angle
Orbit of Comet I (1866) and of the Novem-
ber Meteors
A diagram showing the orbits of various celestial bodies around a central point. The largest circle represents Jupiter's orbit. Inside Jupiter's orbit is Saturn's orbit. Inside Saturn's orbit is Earth's orbit. Inside Earth's orbit is Mars' orbit. Inside Mars' orbit is Venus' orbit. Inside Venus' orbit is Mercury's orbit. A smaller circle represents the Sun's position. The lines connecting these circles show how each planet moves relative to others. The diagram also shows a comet's path around Jupiter's orbit. The comet's path is shown as a curved line starting from Jupiter's orbit and ending near Earth's orbit. The comet's path is labeled "COMET'S ORBIT." The diagram also shows a line labeled "JUPITER'S ORBIT" extending from Jupiter's center to its outer edge. Another line labeled "SATURN'S ORBIT" extends from Saturn's center to its outer edge. A third line labeled "EARTH'S ORBIT" extends from Earth's center to its outer edge. A fourth line labeled "MARS' ORBIT" extends from Mars' center to its outer edge. A fifth line labeled "VENUS' ORBIT" extends from Venus' center to its outer edge. A sixth line labeled "MERcury'S ORBIT" extends from Mercury's center to its outer edge. A seventh line labeled "SUN'S POSITION" extends from the Sun's center to its outer edge.
416
Comets and Meteors
of 17° by which the orbit of the November meteors is inclined to the ecliptic. It stands in space as the ad-
A diagram showing the orbits of two comets. The larger comet (Comet 1866) has an orbit that is tilted at approximately 17 degrees relative to the ecliptic plane. The smaller comet (Comet 1865) is shown with its orbit cut off, indicating that it is not visible in this diagram. The diagram also shows the position of the Earth's orbit around the Sun.
Fenbillion Parts of Orbits of the August and November Meteor-showers
jacent figure shows, being the lower one of the two orbits whose planes are cut off. Similarly, the upper and nearly vertical plane represents the position in space of another meteoric orbit, which intersects our path about 10th August. This shower is therefore known as the August shower; also these meteors are often called Perseids.
What are Meteors 417
As shown by the arrows, both the Perseids and the Leonids travel oppositely to the planets; so that their velocity of impact with our atmosphere is compounded of their own velocity and the earth's also.
This velocity of approach is great enough to vaporize all meteoric masses within a few seconds; so it is unlikely that a meteoric product from the Leonids will ever be encountered by any observer on the earth, because it will have passed through the atmosphere below, because they overtake the earth. In the case of meteors, the velocity of ground impact probably never exceeds a few hundred feet per second, so great is the resistance of the air; and several meteoric stones which fell in Sweden, and which were very large, though thick, rebounded without either breaking or being themselves broken.
Connection between Comets and Meteors. — Not long after the important discovery of the motion of meteors in regular orbits, an even more significant relation was ascertained: that the orbits of the Perseids and the Leonids are practically identical with the paths in which two comets are known to travel. The orbit of the Leonids is coincident with that of Tempel's comet (1865), and the Perseids pursue the same track in space with Swift's comet (known as 1862 II). The latter has a period of about 120 years, and recedes far beyond the planet Neptune. So do the meteors traveling in the same track. They are much more evenly distributed all along their path than the Leonids, although no August ever fails at a slight sprinkle, although the shower nights in our hemisphere often interfere with the display.
What are Meteors? — Several other meteor swarms and comets have been investigated with a like result; so the conclusion is now well established that these meteors, and probably all bodies of that nature, are merely the shattered residue of former comets. This important theory is confirmed, whether we look backward in the life of a comet, or forward: if backward, comets are known to disintegrate, and have indeed been 'caught in the act'; if forward, our expectation to find the disruption farther advanced in the
TODD'S ASTROLOGY - 27
418
Comets and Meteors
case of some comets and meteors than others is precisely confirmed by the facts regarding different showers. Then, too, as will be shown in a later paragraph, the spectra of meteorites vaporized and photographed in our laboratories are practically identical with the spectra of the nucel of comets. The conclusion is, therefore, that these latter are nothing more than a compact swarm or shoal of meteoric particles, vaporized in their passage through space, under conditions not yet fully understood. The practical identity of composition between comets and meteors had long been suspected, but it was not completely conclusively until 27th November, 1886, when meteor orbits which fell to the earth showed that particles were picked up in Mexico, and chemical and physical investigation established their undoubted nature as originally part of the lost Biela's comet.
**Falls of Meteorites.**—In general the meteorites are divided into two classes: meteoric stones and meteoric irons. Falls of the stony meteorites have been much oftener seen than actual descents of masses of meteoric iron. The most remarkable fall ever seen took place on 10th May, 1789, in Iowa, the heaviest stone weighing 437 pounds. This is the smallest mass weight to the largest meteorite ever discovered, though many have fallen to fail. It was found in Hungary in 1865, and is now part of the Vienna collection. The iron masses are often much heavier: the 'signet' meteorite, a complete ring found in Tucson, Arizona, and now in the United States National Museum at Washington, weighs 1400 pounds; a Texas meteorite, now part of the Yale collection, weighs 1635 pounds; and a Colorado meteorite in the Amherst collection weighs 437 pounds. But although the cabinets contain hundreds of specimens of meteoric irons, only eight or ten have actually been seen to fall.
Analysis of Meteorites 419
Of these, the largest one fell in Arabia in 1865, and its weight is 130 pounds. It is now in the British Museum. The average velocity of meteorites is 35 miles per second. Their visibility begins at an altitude of about 70 miles, and ends at about 100 miles. The work done by the atmosphere in suddenly checking their velocity appears in large part as heat which fuses the exterior to incandescence, and leaves them, when cooled, thinly encased as with a glassy crust.
The inner meteorite stones are usually, but not invariably covered with deep pittings or thumbs. Meteorites are always irregular in form, never spherical; and the pittings are in part due to impact of minute aerial columns which resist their swift passage through the air.
**Analysis of the Meteorites.** — Meteoric iron is an alloy, containing on the average ten per cent of nickel, com-
mingled with a much smaller amount of cobalt, copper, tin, carbon, and a few other elements. Meteoric iron is distinguishable from terrestrial irons by means of the 'Widmannstätten figures,' which are seen only upon those polished metallic surfaces - a test which rarely fails. The illustration shows these figures of their true size, as it was made from a transfer print from the actual etched surface of a meteorite in the Amherst collection. In me-
teoric stones, chemical analysis has revealed the pre-
sence of about one third of all the elemental substances recognised in the earth's crust; among them the elements found in meteoric irons, also sulphur, calcium, chlorine,
sodium, and many others.
The minerals found in meteoric stones are those which abound in terrestrial rocks of igneous or volcanic origin, like trachy and lava.
Cathedral Peak is a fine example of this class. The analysis of meteorites has brought to light a few compounds new to mineralogy, but has not yet led to the discovery of any new element; and the study
Widmannstätten Figures
420
Comets and Meteors
of meteorites is now the province of the crystallographer, the chemist, and the mineralogist, rather than the astronomer. Even the most searching investigation has so far failed to detect any trace of organic life in meteorites.
Occlusion is the well-known property of a metal, particularly iron, by which at high temperatures it absorbs gases, and retains them until again heated red hot. Hydrogen, carbonic oxide, and nitrogen are usually present in iron meteorites as occluded gases, also, in very small quantities, the light gas, newly discovered, called helium. In 1865, on a visit on the evening of 3rd March to a room in the Royal Institution, London, was lighted by gas brought to earth in a meteorite from interplanetary space. We have now traversed the round of the solar system; it remains only to consider the bodies of the sidereal system, and the views held by philosophers concerning the progressive development of the material universe.
CHAPTER XVI
THE STARS AND THE COSMOGONY
OUR descriptions of heavenly bodies thus far have concerned chiefly those belonging to the solar system.
We found distance growing vast beyond the power of human conception, as we contemplated, first the neighboring moon, then the central orb of the system 400 times farther away, and finally Neptune, 30 times farther than the sun,—not to say some of the constellations which take their even remotest stars. But outside of the solar system, and wherever our surroundings is a stellar universe the number of whose countless hosts is in some sense a measure of their inconceivable distance from our humble abode in space.
The Sidereal System.—All these bodies constitute the sidereal system, or the stellar universe. It comprises stars and nebulae; not only those which are visible to the naked eye, but hundreds of thousands besides, so faint that their existence is revealed only by the greatest telescopes and th: most sensitive photographic plates. Remoteness of the stars at once forbids supposition that they are similar in composition to the sun; for they are by light alone from the sun as the moon and planets do. Even Neptune, on the barriers of our system, is too faint for the naked eye to grasp his light. But the nearest fixed star is about 9000 times more distant. So very the brightness of the lucid stars leads us to suspect that they at least must be self-luminous like the sun; and when their light is analyzed
423
422
Stars and Cosmogony
with the spectroscope, the theory that they are suns is actually demonstrated. It is reasonable to conclude, then, that the sun himself is really a star, whose vulgulence, and importance to us dwellers on the earth are due merely to his proximity. The figure will help us to understand for if we recede from the sun even as far as Neptune, his disk will have shrunk almost to a point, though a dazzling one. Were this journey to be continued to the nearest star, our sun would have dwindled to the insignificance of an ordinary star.
The Magnitudes of Stars. — While stars as faint as the sixth magnitude can just be seen by the ordinary eye on a clear dark night, still other and fainter stars can be followed with the telescope beyond this limit, to the fifteenth magnitude and even farther by the largest instruments. Division into magnitudes, although made arbitrarily, is a classification warranted by time, and use of many generations of astronomers. Brightness of stars decreases in geometrical proportion as the number increasing magnitude increases; the constant term being 2\. Thus,
an average star of the first magnitude is 2\(\frac{1}{2}\) times brighter than one of the second magnitude; a second magnitude star gives 2\(\frac{1}{2}\) times more light than one of the third magnitude, and so on. At the observatory of Harvard College,
A diagram showing the apparent size of the Sun as seen from Mercury, Venus, Earth, and Jupiter.
Our Sun has a brilliant Star as seen from Neptune
The Brightest Stars 423
Pickering, its director, has devoted many years to determination of stellar magnitudes with the meridian photometer, a highly accurate instrument of his devising, by which the brightness of any star culminations may be compared directly with a standard as a standard. But Sirius, all the stars is Sirius, and as no others are so brilliant, strictly he ought perhaps to be the only first magnitude star. But many fainter than Sirius are ranked in this class, three of them so bright that their stellar magnitude is negative, as below. Decimal fractions express all gradations of magnitude. Even the surpassing brilliancy of the sun can be indicated on the same scale; the number - 25.4 expresses his stellar magnitude.
The Brightest Stars. Twenty stars are rated of the first magnitude; half of them are in the northern hemisphere of the sky. They are the following:
| Order of Brightness |
Stellar Magnitude |
Stars' Names |
Order of Brightness |
Stellar Magnitude |
Stars' Names |
| 1 |
-1.6 |
Cæsis Majoris (Sirius) |
11 |
0.0 |
Oriens (Fétegeres) |
| 2 |
-0.8 |
Argus (Caputu) |
12 |
0.0 |
Crucis (Cruce) |
| 3 |
-0.1 |
Cænus (Capella) |
13 |
0.0 |
Sagittarius (Sagittari) |
| 4 |
-0.1 |
Bolus (Capella) |
14 |
0.0 |
Tauri (Tauri) |
| 5 |
-0.3 |
Orobus (Arcturus) |
15 |
1.1 |
Virgoins (Virgo) |
| 6 |
-0.4 |
Lysyr (Lysyr) |
16 |
1.3 |
Scorpius (Scorpius) |
| 7 |
-0.5 |
Cænus (Capella) |
17 |
1.3 |
Piscis Australis (Pisces) |
| 8 |
-0.4 |
Eridani (Eridanus) |
18 |
1.3 |
Piscis Australis (Pisces) |
| 9 |
-0.5 |
Cænus Minoris (Pisces) |
19 |
1.3 |
Lacerta (Regulus) |
| to 10 |
-0.7 |
Cænus Minoris (Pisces) |
20 |
1.4 |
Cygni (Deneb) |
| These stars culminate at different altitudes varying with their declination, and at different times throughout *Invisible in our middle northern latitudes.* |
A table listing stars and their magnitudes.
These stars culminate at different altitudes varying with their declination, and at different times throughout *Invisible in our middle northern latitudes.*
424
Stars and Cosmogony
the year, which you may find from charts of the constellations (pp. 60-63).
**Number of Stars.** — Besides twenty stars of the first magnitude, not only are there nearly six thousand of lesser magnitude visible to the naked eye, likewise many hundreds of thousands visible in telescopes of medium size, but also millions of stars revealed by the largest telescopes. From careful counts, partly by Gould, the number of stars of successive magnitudes is found to increase nearly in geometric proportion:
| 1st magnitude |
20 |
6th magnitude |
5000 |
| 2d |
65 |
7th |
20,000 |
| 3d |
200 |
8th |
68,000 |
| 4th |
500 |
9th |
22,000 |
| 5th |
1400 |
10th |
730,000 |
Any glass of two inches aperture should show all these stars. But in order to discern all the uncounted millions of yet fainter stars, we need the largest instruments, like the Lick and the Yerkes telescopes. Their approximate number has been ascertained not by actual count, but by estimates based on counts of typical areas scattered in different parts of the heavens. The number of stars within reach of our present telescopes perhaps exceeds 125 millions. But the telescope by itself, no matter how powerful, is unable to detect any important difference between these faint and multitudinous luminaries; seemingly all are more alike than peas or rice grains to the naked eye. There is still another reason for believing that the dark or non-luminous stars are many times more numerous than the visible ones, and modern research has made the existence of many such invisible bodies certain.
**Total Light from the Stars.** — Argelander, a distinguished German astronomer, made a catalogue and chart of all the stars of the northern hemisphere increased by
Colors of the Stars 425
an equatorial belt, one degree in width, of the southern stars. His limit was the 94 magnitude, and he recorded rather more than 324,000 stars in all. Accepting a sixth magnitude star as the standard, and expressing in terms of it the number of all the stars that can be seen with the naked eye, they give an amount of light equivalent to 7,000 sixth magnitude stars. But calculation proves also that the telescopic stars of this extensive catalogue yield more than three times as much light as the luides ones do. The stars, then, we cannot see with the naked eye give more light than those we can, because of their vastly greater numbers. If, now, we suppose the southern heavens to be studded just as thickly as the northern, there would be about 600,000 stars to the 94 magnitude, and their total light has been calculated equal to $\frac{8}{9}$ that of the average full moon.
**Colors of the Stars.** — A marked difference in color characterizes many of the stars. For example, the polestar and Procyon are white, Betelgeux and Antares red. Capella and Alpha Ceti yellowish, Vega and Sirius blue. The blue stars are very numerous; the reddish ones are rare; but variable stars are numerous among them. In observing true stellar colors, the objects should be high above the horizon, for the greater part of the light is scattered by the atmosphere before reaching our eyes; and this tends to give all stars more of an orange tint than they really possess. Colors are easier to detect in the case of double stars (page 441), because the components of many of these objects exhibit complementary colors when combined; thus a double star which is yellow when combined, if components of a 'double' are of about the same magnitude, their color is usually the same; if one companion is much fainter, its color is that of a star of a different class. The violet end of the spectrum is often out of focus. Complementary colors are better seen with the stars out of focus. Following are a few of these colored double stars:
| $\gamma$ Cassiopeiae |
yellow and purple |
4 mag |
7 mag |
| $\gamma$ Andromedae |
orange and green |
3 |
5 |
| $\epsilon$ Cancri |
orange and blue |
4) |
6 |
| a Herculis |
orange and green |
3 |
6 |
| $\beta$ Cygni |
yellow and blue |
3 |
7 |
426
**Stars and Cosmogony**
There is some evidence that a few stars vary in color in long periods of time; for example, two thousand years ago Sirius was a red star, now it is bluish white. Any significance of color as to age or intensity of heat is not yet recognized; rather it is probably due to variant composition of stellar atmospheres.
**Star Catalogues and Charts.** — When you consult a gazetteer you find a multitude of cities set down by name. Corresponding to each is its latitude, or distance from the equator, and its longitude, or arc distance on the equator, measured from a departure point or prime meridian. These arcs are measured on the surface of our earth. Turning, then, to the map, you find the city in question, and perhaps many neighboring ones set down in exact relation to it. Precisely in a similar manner all the brighter stars of the sky are registered in their true relations one to another, on charts and photographic plates. These will be accurate enough for many purposes, but not for all. When you wish precise information you must consult those gazetteers of the sky known as star catalogues. Set down in them will be found the coordinates of a star; that is, its right ascension and declination, the counterparts of terrestrial longitude and latitude. But we shall soon observe this peculiar difference between longitude on the earth and right ascension in the sky: the star's right ascension will (in nearly all cases) be perpetually increasing, while the longitude of a place remains always the same. This perpetual shifting of the stars in right ascension is mostly due to precession. It is as if Greenwich or Washington were constantly traveling westward, but so slowly that only in a few years would it have traveled all the way round the globe.
**Precession and Standard Catalogues.** — It was Hipparchus (c.e. 130) who first discovered this perpetual and apparent shifting of all the stars. And partly for this reason he
A diagram showing the precession of the Earth's axis.
Photographic Charts of the Heavens 427
made a catalogue (the first one ever constructed) of 1080 stars, so that the astronomers coming after him might, by comparing his map and catalogue with their own, discover what changes, if any, are in progress among the stellar systems. No competitor appeared on the field, until the 15th century when the second catalogue was constructed, by Ulrich von Strassburg, an Austrian astronomer. Since his day vast improvements have been made in methods of observing the stars, and in calculating observations of them. There are now about 100 large catalogues of stars, constructed by astronomers of both hemispheres; and the place of every star in the entire celestial sphere revealed by telescopes of medium dimension will soon be determined with astronomical precision.
Several of the larger government observatories prepare a catalogue of stars every year from their observations; and these again are combined into other and more accurate catalogues called "star maps," which contain positions of the zodiacal stars. These afford average or mean positions of stars for the beginning of a particular year, called the epoch of the catalogue. Positions for any given dates are obtained by bringing the epoch forward, and farther correcting for precession, aberration, and nutation (pages 130, 164, and 390). The mean position so corrected becomes the apparent place. The chief American authorities on standard stellar positions are Newcomb, Boss, and Safford.
Photographic Charts of the Entire Heavens.—On proposal of David Gill, but at the expense of Sir William Herschel, a committee of international congresses of astronomers met at Paris in 1878, and arranged for the construction of a photographic chart of the entire heavens. The work of making the charts has been allotted to 18 observatories, one third of them being in America. Each station is provided with instruments equipped with 13-inch telescopes, all essentially alike; and exposures are of such length as to include all stars to the fourth magnitude, probably more than 50 millions in all. Stars to the 7th magnitude inclusive (about 2,000,000) are to be counted and their positions measured and
The Visibility of * Carina (Eta Argus) / 10 h, 4 j m., Dr. S. 5" photographed by Bailey with the Bruce Telescope, 1896. Exposure 4 hours
438
**Proper Motions of the Stars**
429
catalogued. Each photograph covers an area of four square degrees; and as duplicate exposures are necessary, the total number of plates will be not less than 25,000. The entire expense of this comprehensive map of the stars will exceed $1,000,000. The observations of the United States Naval Observatory have been considerably assisted by the liberality of Miss Bruce, the Observatory of Harvard College, which has a station in Peru, as he has undertaken independently to chart in detail the more interesting regions of the entire heavens, with the Bruce plate and the telescopes at Harvard, and with the assistance of four lenses, each 24 inches in aperture. A section of a recent chart obtained with this great instrument is shown opposite. The plates are 14 x 14 inches in size, and cover an area of 36 square degrees of the entire sky. On the original plate of which the illustration is part were counted no less than 400,000 stars. Also Kapteyn has measured and catalogued about 300,000 stars on plates taken at Capetown.
**Proper Motions of the Stars.--If Ptolemy or Kepler or any great astronomer of the past were alive to-day, and could look at the stars and constellations as he did in his own time, he would be able to discern no change what-ever in their apparent positions, because they move their apparent positions relatively to each other. Consequently they seem to have been well named fixed stars. If, however, we compare closely the right ascensions and declinations of stars a century and a half ago with their corresponding positions at the present day, we find that very great changes are taking place; but these changes relatively to the imaginary circles of the celestial sphere are in the main due to precessional motion of the equinox. A star's annual proper motion in right ascension is the amount of residual change in its right ascension in one year, after allowance for aberration, and motion of the equinox. The proper motion in declination may be similarly defined. Proper motion is simply an angular change in position atwhart the line of vision, and may correspond to only a small fraction of the star's real motion in space.
As a whole, proper motion of the lighter stars exceeds that of the fainter ones, because they are nearer to us; and proper motion is a
430
Stars and Cosmogony
combined effect of the sun's motion in space and of the stars among each other. Ultimately these two effects can be distinguished. Still, even the largest proper mo-
tion yet known, that of a star in the constellation of Ursa Major, according to Groombridge's catalogue, and often called the "runaway star," would require more than three centuries must elapse before it would seem to be displaced so much as the heaviest of the average proper motion of first magnitude stars is about of 25'. In magnitude stars, only one sixth is great. Among European astronomers Auer has con-
tributed most to these critical studies, and Porter in America has published a catalogue of proper motions.
Secular Changes in the Constellations.—The accumu-
lated proper motion of the stars of a given asterism will hardly change its naked-eye appearance appreciably within 2000 years. But when intervals of 15 to 20 times greater are taken, the present well-known constellation figures will in many cases be seriously distorted.
Particularly is this true of Cassiopeia, Orion, and Ursa Major. In the left-hand diagram above is shown the present asterism of the Dipper, to each star of which is attached an arrow indicating the direction and amount of its proper motion in about 400 centuries. The companion diagram at right shows what it would appear after that interval has elapsed though much distorted; though much distorted, it would be recognized as Ursa Major still. As indicated by the direction of the arrows, the extreme stars, Alpha and Eta, seem to move almost in the opposite directions from those of Beta and Delta. The spectroscopy confirm this result. As the spectra of the five intermediate stars are quite identical, it is likely that they originally formed part of a physically connected system. The two nearest stars of the Pleiades are also moving in one and the same direction, and this com-
munity of proper motion has received the name star drift.
A diagram showing the apparent positions of stars in Ursa Major over time.
Ursa Major now and after 400 Centuries
Apex of the Sun's Way 431
Apex of the Sun's Way. — When riding upon the rear platform of a suburban electric car, where the ties are not covered under, observe that they seem to crowd rapidly together as the car swiftly recedes from them. If possible to watch from the front platform, precisely the opposite effect will be noticed: the ties seem to open out and separate from each other just as rapidly. In like manner the stars in one part of the celestial sphere, when taken by thousands, are found to have a common element of proper motion inward toward a center or pole; while in the opposite region, they seem to be moving radially outward, as if from the hub and along the spokes of a wheel.
This double phenomenon is explained by a circular motion of the solar system around its axis, comprising the entire family of planets, satellites, and comets along with him. This hub or pole toward which the solar system is moving is called the sun's goal, or the apex of the sun's way; and recent determinations by L. Struve, Boss, and Porter make it practically coincident with the star Vega.
Similarly the point from which all directions are radiating is known as the sun's quiet, and it is roughly a point halfway between Sirius and Canopus. So vast is this orbit of the sun that no deviation from a straight line is yet ascertained, although our motion along that orbit is about 12 miles every second.
This result is verified both by discussion of proper motions, and by finding the relative movement of stars 'for e and af' by means of the spectroscope. As yet, however, there is no indication of a 'central sun,' a favorite hypothesis in the middle of the 19th century. This
A stylized drawing of a comet or similar celestial object.
Earth's Helical Path in Space
432
Stars and Cosmogony
motion of the sun does not interfere with the relations of his family of planets to him ; but simply makes them describe, as in the figure just given, vast spiral convolutions through interstellar space.
Stellar Motions in the Line of Sight. — From a bridge spanning a rivulet, whose current is uniform, we observe chips floating by, one every 15 seconds. Ascending the stream, we find their origin; an arithmetic youth on the bank has been throwing them at regular intervals, four chips to the minute. We interfere with his programme only by asking him first to walk down stream for two minutes, then to return at the same uniform speed; and to repeat this process several times, always taking care to throw the chips at precisely the same intervals as before. Returning to the bridge to observe, we find the chips no longer pass at intervals of 15 seconds as at first; but that the interval is less than this amount while the boy who tosses them is walking down stream, and greater by a corresponding amount while he is going in the opposite direction. The difference between these from 15 sec-onds, is the speed at which he walks can be found. Similarly with the motions of stars toward or from the earth; the boy is the moving star, and the chips are the crests of light waves emanating from it. When the star is coming nearer, more than the normal number of waves reach us every second, and a given line in the star's spectrum is displaced toward the violet. Likewise when a star is receding, the same line deviates toward the red. This effect was first recognized in 1842 by Doppler, from whom comes the name "Doppler's principle." Research of this character is an important part of the programme at Green- wich (opposite page 76), and Yale Observatory (page 7).
The spectral observation is an exceedingly delicate one, but by measuring the degree of displacement of stellar lines, as compared with the same lines due to terrestrial substances artificially vaporized, the motions of about 100 stars toward or from the solar system have been
TOBI'S ASTRON. — 25
The Royal Observatory, Greenwich. W. H. M. Churchill, F.R.S., Astronomer Royal.
Founded by Charles II in the year 1675, to serve the state's needs. It was proposed of building under the advice of the Rev. John Flamsteed, who was appointed Astronomer Royal in 1675, and who inaugurated its operations in 1676.
In later years other improvements have been made.
434
Stars and Cosmogy
ascertained. The limit of accuracy is two or three kilometers per second. The observed motions of stars, not situated at the poles of the ecliptic, or near them, require a correction depending on the earth's orbital motion round the sun. When thus modified, the motions of few stars in the line of sight exceed 40 kilometers per second.
Medicine, Maunder and Starry Night by Huggins of London, Maunder at Greenwich, Vogel at Potsdam, Germany, and Keeler and Campbell at the Lick Observatory, have these researches been conducted. Below are results for a few stars showing best accordance:
| Star's Name |
Position for 1900.0 |
Motion per Second toward or from the Sun |
R.A. |
Dul. |
Miles |
Kilometers |
| Alpha Arietis |
2° 5' 30" N. 7° 59' S. |
-11.7 |
-19 |
| Aldebaran |
4° 30' N. 16° 8' |
+31.1 |
+50 |
| Rigel |
5° 10' S. 8° 19' |
+13.6 |
+22 |
| Betelgeux |
5° 50' N. 7° 23' |
+17.6 |
+28 |
| Gamma Leonis |
10° 14' N. 21° 21' |
-25.1 |
-40 |
| Spica |
13° 30' S. 10° 46' |
-26.8 |
-41 |
| Alpha Coronae |
15° 30' N. 27° 36' |
+20.3 |
+33 |
| Ahail |
19° 46' N. 36° S. |
-23.9 |
-38 |
These are a tenth part of all successfully ascertained.
Spectrum photography has contributed greatly to the convenience and accuracy of these critical observations.
Relation of Brightness to Distance of the Stars: Were the stars all of the same real size and brightness, their apparent magnitudes, combined with their direction from us, would make it possible to state their precise arrangement throughout the celestial spaces. But all assumptions of this character are unfounded, and lead to erroneous conclusions.
The very little yet known about the real dis
Stellar Distances
435
tances of the stars and their motions, when taken in con-
nection with their apparent magnitudes, proves conclusively
that many of the fainter stars are relatively near the solar
system; also that several of the brighter stars are exceed-
ingly remote, and therefore exceptionally large and massive.
Apparent brightness, therefore, is no certain criterion of
distance. This subject of investigation is so vast and
intricate that very little headway has yet been securely
made. What we really know may be put in a single brief
sentence: Only as a very general rule is it true that the
brighter stars are nearer and larger than the great mass
of fainter ones; and to this rule are conspicuous and im-
portant exceptions. Our knowledge is rather negative than
positive on this point. (1) The stars are far from equally distributed throughout space, and (2) they are far from alike in real brightness and diameter.
How Stellar Distances are found. — Recall the instance of
the earth and moon (page 237): we found the moon's dis-
tance from us by measuring her displacement among the
stars, as seen from two observatories at the ends of a diam-
eter of our globe, or as near its extremities as convenient.
But this earth is so small, that, as seen from a star, even its
entire diameter would appear as an infinitesimal; we must
therefore seek another base line. Only one is feasible;
and although 25,000 times greater, still it is hardly long
enough to be practicable.
Imagine a star situated by a huge sphere, whose circle equals our orbit round the sun. From the ends of a diameter, where we are at intervals of six months, we may measure the displacement of a star,
just as we measured the displacement of the moon from the two ob-
servatories at the ends of a diameter of our globe. We shall find the
star's parallax, just as half the moon's displacement gave the lunar
parallax. And just as in the case of moon, sun, and planets we em-
ploy the same method to determine their distances, so we shall employ
parallax the angle at the star subtended by the radius of earth's orbit.
Measurement of a star's annual parallax is one of the exceedingly diffi-
436
Stars and Cosmogony
cult problems that confront the practical astronomer; so small is the angle that its measurement is much as if a prisoner who could only look out of the window of his cell were given instruments of utmost pre-
cision and compelled to as-
sess the distance of a
mountain 20 miles away.
A Star's Parallactic Eli-
ipse. Situate a board on
the table and place the eye
about two feet from the side
of it. Hold the point of a
pencil at various distances of about 5, 10,
and 20 inches from the eye,
and draw a circle on the
book. For each position of
the pencil move the head
around in a nearly vertical
plane, keeping the pencil
diameter, noticing in each
case the size of the circle
projected upon the book.
To describe where projected
on the book. This con-
clusion is easily reached:
farther from the eye, from
the eye, the smaller this cir-
cle. Now imagine the eye
at the center of a circular
orbit (as at the bottom of
the diagram), the pencil by
moving around the orbit to
the farthest stars. Evidently the earth by traveling round the sun in an elliptic orbit describes ellipses whose eccentricities are de-
pendent upon their latitude. There are these two important differ-
The Nearest Star describes the Largest Apparent Ellipse among the Parthet Stars
elate is precisely proportioned inversely to their distance from the solar system. The eccentricity of a parallactic ellipse is equal to that of an ellipse having the same as that of its abscissal ellipse already figured on page 164;
a star at the pole of the ecliptic describes a circle, and those situated in the ecliptic only oscillate forth and back in a straight line. Stars in intermediate latitudes describe ellipses whose eccentricities are de-
pendent upon their latitude. There are these two important differ-
Stellar Distances 437
ences: (1) in the aberration ellipse, the star is always thrown go" forward of its true position, while in the parallactic ellipse, it is just 180° displaced; (2) the major axis of the aberration ellipse is the same for all stars, but in the parallactic ellipse its length varies inversely with the distance of the star from the earth's center. The parallactic ellipse affords the means of ascertaining how far away the star is, because the base line is the diameter of the earth's orbit. This is called the differ-
ential method of measuring stellar distances. It has been used by astronomers, but the difference between its parallax and that of the remotest star, assumed to be zero. Researches on stellar distances have been pro-
duced by Gill at Cape Town and Elkin at Yale Observatory with a high degree of accuracy.
The Distance of 6i Cygni. —The star known as 6i Cygni has become famous, because it is the first star whose distance was ever measured by means of stellar parallax. This measurement was taken about 1849 by the eminent German astronomer Bessel, often called the father of practical astronomy, because he introduced many facts into practice which had hitherto been only theoretical in astronomical results and methods. This star is a double star, standing at an angle with the hour circle (north-south), as the diagram shows.
Two small stars are in the same field of view, $\alpha$ and $\beta$, nearly at right angles to each other. The name of this double star, and Bessel had reason for believing that they were vastly farther away than 6i Cygni itself. In his opposite sessions of the year he meas-
ured with the heliometer the distances between each of the components of 6i Cygni and both the stars $\alpha$ and $\beta$. What he found on putting $b$ his measurements together was that these apparent distances change in the course of the year and that their rate of change was exactly what
the star's position relatively to the ecliptic led him to expect. The measured amount of that change, then, was the basis of calculation of the star's distance. Since Bessel's time, this differential pho-
tography has been successfully applied to researches of this character, with many advantages, including increased accuracy of the results,
particularly by means of photographic plates.
Illustration of Stellar Distances. —The nearest of all the fixed stars is Alpha Centauri, a bright star of the southern hemisphere. Its
Bessel's Measures of Distance of 6i Cygni
438
Stars and Cosmogony
parallax is 0°.75, and it is 270,000 times more distant from our solar system than the sun is from the earth. But there is little advantage in repeating a mere statement of numbers like this. Try to gain some conception of its meaning. First, imagine the entire solar system as represented by a sphere of radius one mile, and dot upon it a star. Even the sun itself, on this exceedingly reduced scale, could not be detected with the most powerful microscope ever made. But on the same scale the vast circle centered at the sun and reaching to Alpha Centauri would cover only about two square feet. The earth would be on the floor of a room to two feet square. Or the relative sizes of spheres may afford a better help. Imagine a sphere so great that it would include the earth, the moon, and all the planets within our solar system equal to Neptune's distance from the sun. Think of the earth in comparison with this sphere. Then conceive all the stars of the firmament as brought to this sphere as the nearest one, and in its surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface of sphere which is radius of the nearest one, we have in surface
The Unit Is the Light Year. — In expressing intelligently and conveniently a distance, the unit must not be taken too many times. We do not state the distance between New York and Chicago in inches, or even feet, but in miles. The earth's radius is a convenient unit for the distance
of
the
moon,
because
it has
to
be
taken
only
60
times;
but
it would be very inconvenient to use such a small unit as stating that New York and Chicago are 60 times apart.
By adopting light-years as units for astronomers,
the mean
radius
of
our
orbit
round
the
sun
is
the accepted unit
of measure
in
the solar system.
Similarly adopted unit
of stellar distance,
is,
not
the distance
of any planet nor
the distance
of any star,
but
the distance traveled by a light wave in a year. This unit is called
the light year.
The velocity
of light
is 186,300 miles per second,
and it travels from
the sun to
the earth
in 499 seconds.
The light year
is equal to
Distances of Well-known Stars 439
63,000 × 93,000,000 miles, because the number of seconds in a year is about 499 x 63,000 or, the light year is equal to $5\frac{1}{3}$ trillion miles. Obviously, as stellar parallax has a definite relation to distance, parallax must be related to the light year also as the distance of a star whose parallax is one second of arc is one light year. So that, by multiplying by the parallax (in seconds of arc), we shall have the star's distance in light years.
**Distances of Well-known Stars.** — Although the paralaxes of more than a hundred stars have been measured, only about 50 are regarded as well known. Twelve are given in the following table, together with their corresponding distance in light years:
| Stellar Distances and Parallaxes |
Approximate |
Proper |
PARALLAX |
LIGHT YEARS |
DISTANCE IN -- |
| Star's Name |
Measurements |
MOTION |
|
|
OF MILES |
| a Centauri |
-0.1 |
14.33 |
S 60 25 |
3.67 |
0.75 |
41 |
25 |
| 61 Cygni |
-2.1 |
21.2 |
N 38 15 |
5.16 |
0.45 |
71 |
43 |
| Astrolabus |
-0.1 |
28.8 |
N 29 29 |
1.25 |
0.27 |
13 |
71 |
| Ptolemy I |
-0.5 |
34.7 |
N 5 29 |
2.73 |
0.12 |
31 |
<
A diagram showing the positions and distances of various stars.
Most of these are bright stars, but a considerable number of faint stars have large parallaxes also. Relative distances and approximate directions from the solar system are shown in next illustration, for a few of the nearer and best deter-
440
Stars and Cosmogony
mined stars. The scale is necessarily so small that even the vast orbit of Neptune has no appreciable dimension.
The outer circle corresponds to a parallax o"'.t.
The distances of many stars have been ascertained by Sir Robert Ball. Various determinations often differ widely.
A diagram showing the relative positions of stars in relation to the Sun and Earth.
Distances of Stars from the Solar System in Light Years (according to Ranyard and Gregory)
Dimensions of the Stars. — After we had found the distance of the sun and measured the angle filled by his disk, it was possible to calculate his true dimensions. But this simple method is inapplicable to the stars, because their light is so feeble that it cannot be detected with an appreciable angle. Indirect means must therefore be employed to ascertain their sizes; and it cannot be said that any method has yet yielded very satisfactory results. Considering known distance with apparent magnitude, it appears that the most distant light-giving power of the following stars, that of the sun being unity—
A diagram showing the relative positions of stars in relation to the Sun and Earth.
Types of Stellar Spectra 441
| Sirian Stars |
Solar Stars |
| Procyon |
25 |
Aldebaran |
70 |
| Altair |
25 |
Polux |
170 |
| Sirius |
40 |
Polaris |
190 |
| Regulus |
300 |
Arcturus |
6200 |
| Vega |
2500 |
|
|
But these are far from indicating their real magnitudes; for amount of light is dependent upon intrinsic brightness of the radiating surface, as well as its extent. Among the giant stars are Arcturus, possibly a hundredfold the sun's diameter; also Vega and Capella, likewise much larger than the sun. The apparent size of the sun (page 49) is about the size of a millimetre, and its dark companion (page 49) is about the size of the sun -- results reached by means of the spectroscopist, which measures the rate of approach and recession of Algol when the invisible attendant is in opposition to the sun. The apparent size of a star is determined by the mean of the star and size of its orbit, so that the length of the eclipse tells how large the dark, eclipsing body must be.
**Types of Stellar Spectra.** — Sir William Huggins in 1864 first detected lines indicating the vapor of hydrogen, calcium, iron, and sodium in the atmospheres of the brighter stars. Stellar spectra have been classified in a variety of ways, but the division into four types, proposed in 1865 by Secchi, has obtained the widest adoption. They are illustrated on the next page:
Type I is chiefly characterized by the breadth and intensity of dark hydrogen lines; also a decided faintness or entire lack of metallic lines. Stars of this type are very abundant. They are blue or white; Sirius, Vega, Altair, and numerous other bright stars belong to this type, often called Sirian stars, a class embracing perhaps more than half of all the stars.
Type II is characterized by a multitude of fine dark, metallic lines, closely resembling the solar spectrum. They are yellowish like the sun; Capella and Arcturus (page 445) illustrate this type, often called the solar stars, which are rather less numerous than the Sirian stars. According to
442
**Stars and Cosmogony**
recent results of Kapteyn, absolute luminous power of first type stars exceeds that of second type stars sevenfold; and stars least remote from the sun are mostly of the second type.
| Violet |
W |
V |
F |
D |
C |
Red |
| Type I - Sirius |
| Type II - Capella and the Sun |
| Type III - Alpha Herculis |
| Violet |
Type IV - Old Schleierkopf |
| Sectsch's Four Types of Stellar Spectra |
| Red |
Type III is characterized by many dark bands, well defined on the side toward the blue, and shading off toward the red end of the spectrum—a 'colonnaded spectrum,' as Miss Clerke very aptly terms it. Orange and reddish stars, and a majority of the variables, fall into this category; Alpha Herculis, Mira, and Antares are examples of this type.
Stellar Spectrum Photography 443
Type IV is characterized by dark bands, or flutings as they are often technically called, similar to those of the previous type, only reversed as to shading — well defined on the side toward the red, and fading out toward the blue.
Stars of this type are few, perhaps so in number, faint, and nearly all blooded in tint. Their atmospheres con-
tain carbon.
Type V has been added to Secchi's classification by Pickering, and is characterized by bright lines. From two
French astronomers who first investigated objects of this
class, they are known as Wolf-Rayet stars. They are all
near the middle of the Galaxy, and their number is about
70. They are a type of stellar objects quite apart by
themselves, of which Campbell has made an especial
study. Many objects called planetary nebulae yield a
spectrum of this type.
A class of Wolf-Rayet combines Secchi's types III
and IV into a single type. It is not yet determined
whether these differences of spectra are due to different
stages of development, or whether they indicate real differ-
ences of stellar constitution. Most likely they are due to
a combination of these causes.
How a Star's Spectrum is commonly photographed. — The light of a fixed star comes to the earth from a definite point on the dome of the sky, so that its position can be marked upon a map. The focus of a telescope, is also a point. Now suppose that a glass prism is attached to the telescope in front of its objective, as was first done in 1824, by Fraunhofer, and consider what happens when the light of the star first passes through this prism. The object called the "object" is seen through the object glass, which brings the rays all to a focus. The star's image, however, is no longer a point, but spread out into a line, made up of many points. This line is then passed through the prism,
that the sensitive dry plate is inserted, and allowed to remain until the ex-
posure is judged sufficient to produce the desired impression. Perhaps three hours are required, and during all this time the adjustment of the
photographic telescope is continued so that when the plate is ex-
posed, the spectra of all the stars will appear, not as lines, but as tiny
444
Stars and Cosmogony
rectangular patches, or bits of ribbon with light stripes across them. A 25th part of such a negative is here pictured, as obtained with the Bache telescope of the Boyden Observatory, by exposure in 1893 to the stars of the catalogue of Mr. Fleming. The spectra show too spectra sufficiently distinct for classification.
The Draper Catalogue. — With an identical instrument, similarly equipped with prisms, stellar spectrum photography has been vigorously carried on at the Boyden Observatory since 1886. The prisms are mounted with their edges east and west, so that the dispersion is regulated according to the degree of dispersion employed, as well as the inclination of the prism plane in the photographic field. Upon a single plate are often many hundred spectra; and in studying them, the great advantage of such close juxtapositions is apparent. For example, the spectra of about 50 stars in the Pleiades show at a glance practical identity of chemical composition. These researches, conducted under the auspices of the Smithsonian Institution, charges of a fund provided by Mrs. Draper as a memorial to her husband, gave to astronomers in 1896 the "Draper Catalogue of stellar spectra," including more than 15,000 stars down to the eighth magnitude. Nearly all these plates were photographed by Mr. Fleming; some plates was performed by Mrs. Fleming, Miss Maury, and others. This comprehensive system of registering spectra naturally paved the way for a more detailed study of individual stars. The work done in subsequent work at the same observatory, has led to their division into about two groups. Also the peculiarities of spectra have led to the detection of numerous variable stars, and several new or temporary stars (see page 47).
Stellar Spectra of High Dispersion. — Vega is the first star whose spectrum was successfully photographed by Henry Draper in 1892. Brightness and color do not affect this photographing of stellar spectra, even after a high degree of dispersion by a train of several prisms, or by a diffraction grating. Multitudes of lines are thus re- corded, especially for stars of the solar type. A part of the photographic spectrum of Arcturus is shown on the next page, which indicate of the solar spectrum. In addition to the few results obtained at
Variable Stars 445
Cambridge by Pickering, and at South Kensington by Sir Norman Lockyer, must be mentioned those of Vogel and Scheiner at Potsdam, near Berlin; and of Deslandres at Paris, who has lately detected in the spectrum of Alhura a series of lines which he attributes to the elements hyd-
rogen and other bands. He regards them as indication that this star is enveloped by a gaseous medium like that of the solar chromosphere.
Variable Stars. — A star whose brightness has been observed to change is called a variable star, or simply a 'variable.' Nearly 1000 such objects are now recognized. This change may be either an increase or a decrease ; and it may take place either regularly or irregularly. Other classes of variables exhibit no regularity whatever, but exhibit several fluctuations of brightness in every complete period (like Beta Lyrae, a well known variable whose spectrum presents a complexity of hydrogen lines and helium bands now under investigation by Frost); some in simple periods only a few hours (the shortest at present known is U Pegasi, 5½ hours); others changing slowly through several months. In general the last, which are usually reddish in tint, change as rapidly when near minimum as when near maxi-
mum, their light-curves being like deep curves with sharp crests. Astronomers term these 'Ondu-
lents Ceti,' or 'Ceti waves.' The most famous of this name, also known as Mira, or 'the marvellous,' whose variability has been known for three cen-
turies. Their average period is about a year, and perhaps half of the recognized variables are of this type. Allied to them are the temporary stars described in a subsequent section. Of a type whose variation is the reverse of Mira are the
Patent No. 386739 - Spectrograph - Spectrum Analysis - 1893 - Norman Lockyer
446
Stars and Cosmogony
'Algol variables,' about 20 in number, whose light suddenly drops at regular intervals, as if some invisible body were temporarily to intervene.
Knowledge of the variable stars has been greatly advanced by the labors of Sir William Parsons, of Cambridge. Chandler's catalogues contain about 500 classified variables. Such an object, previously without a name, is designated by letters R, S, T, L, and so on, in order of discovery. The average range of the stars of this class is less than one magnitude. Distribution and Observation of Variables. — As to their distribution over the heavens, variable stars are most numerous in a zone inclined about 18° to the ecliptic. This is the region where the Sun is situated in the Galaxy occurs. Almost all the temporary stars are in this duplex region. A discovery of much significance was made by Bailey, in 1766, of an extremely faint star which he called Algol. In 1835, in a cluster of stars, more than 100 being found among the stars of a single cluster; and the mutations of magnitude are marked within a few hours. Variables are most interesting objects, and observations of great value may be made with small instruments. The cause of their variations of least brightness must be ascertained; these are given each year in the 'Companion' to The Observatory (edited by Turner and published at Greenwold), and in Popular Astronomy (published monthly by Payne at Northfield, Minnesota). Following are a few variables, easily found from star charts.
| Variable Stars |
Fourteen (14) (1920 c.) |
VARIATION |
TYPES OF VARIABLE |
| Star's Name |
R A Decl. Period RANGE |
|
|
| Omicron Ceti |
b n 2 14 s 26 d 33 h |
Days Magnitude |
1 to 7 |
| Ieta Persei |
a 2 14 s 26 d 33 h |
2 to 3 |
Mira. |
| Zeta Geminorum |
b n 2 14 s 26 d 33 h |
2 to 3 |
Algol. |
| R Leonis |
c n 2 14 s 26 d 33 h |
2 to 3 |
|
| Delta Librae |
d n 2 14 s 26 d 33 h |
2 to 3 |
Algol. |
| Alpha Herculis |
e n 2 14 s 26 d 33 h |
2 to 3 |
Iregular. |
| X Sagittae |
f n 2 14 s 26 d 33 h |
2 to 3 |
|
| Beta Lyrae |
g n 2 14 s 26 d 33 h |
2 to 3 |
|
| Delta Cephei |
h n 2 14 s 26 d 33 h |
2 to 3 |
|
A table listing Variable Stars with their positions and periods.
**Temporary, or New Stars**
A small telescope or opera glass is a distinct help in observing a variable. When its brightness is changing, repeated comparison and careful record of its magnitude with that of other stars in the same field, will make it possible to ascertain the time of maximum or minimum. Such observations are of use to the professional investigator of periods of variable stars.
**Temporary Stars, or New Stars.— A variable star which, usually in a few weeks' time, vastly increases in brightness, and then slowly wanes and disappears entirely, or nearly so, is called a temporary star.** Accounts of many such are contained in ancient historical records. In the Chinese annals is an allusion to such an outburst in Scorpio, B.C. 134; it was observed by Hipparchus, and led to his construction of the first known catalogue of stars, made with reference to the detection of similar phenomena in the future.
Tycho Brahe carefully observed a remarkable object of this class near Cassiopeia, which, in the latter part of 1572, surpassed the brightness of Jupiter, was for a while visible in broad daylight, and, in a year and a half, had completely disappeared. 1604–5 a new star at equal brightness was seen by Kepler at Ophirchus; it also disappeared. None were recorded in the 18th century. Similar and equally remarkable objects made their appearance, and passed through like stages near our own day in—
1866 in Corona Borealis;
1876 in Cygnus;
1885 in the Great Nebula in Andromeda;
1891 in Auriga.
Such a star is often called *Nova*, with the genitive of its constellation added, as Nova Cygni. Temporary stars remain unchanged in apparent position during their great fluctuations of brightness, and no new star has been found to have a measurable parallax. Probably Nova Andromedae was connected with the nebula in which it appeared. The new stars of 1866 and 1892, after dropping to a low tele-
448
Stars and Cosmogy
scopic magnitude, had a secondary rise in brightness,
though not to their original magnitude, after which they
faded to their present condition as very faint telescopic objects. Nova Aurigae has become a faint nebulous star.
Thorough search by Mrs. Fleming of the photographic charts and spectrum plates of the Harvard College Observatory, obtained in both hemispheres, has led to the detection of many new stars that would otherwise have escaped observation. Recent ones are Nova Normae (1891), Nova Carinae (1895), and Nova Centauri (1895). Following are spectra of temporary stars, showing hydrogen and calcium lines.
Spectra of New Stars (Pietzker)
Spectra of New Stars. — The spectroscope has proved itself a powerful adjunct in the observation of temporary stars. First employed on the Nova of 1863, it was used with success on the Novae of 1870 and 1871. Nova Cygni, ten years later, gave a similar spectrum, added to which were the lines of helium, long known in the sun, but only in 1895 identified as a terrestrial element. Nova Andromedae (1883) to the observers presented a complex spectrum, while Nova Lyrae (1890) gave a distinctly double and singularly complex spectrum. Many pairs of lines indicated clearly a community of origin as to substance, and accurate measurements showed that the relative velocity of these stars was nearly zero kilometers, or more than 500 miles per second; and this type of spectrum remained characteristic for more than a month. In each bright hydroxyl band there was a dark absorption band, about equally displaced toward the violet. It was as if the strange light were due to a solid
Variables of the Algol Type 449
globe moving swiftly away from us, and plunging into an irregular nebulous mass swiftly approaching us. Tests for parallax placed Nova Aurigae at the distance of the Galaxy, so that this marvelous celestial display must actually have occurred in space as remotely as the begin- ning of the world. The spectrum of this star is almost identical with that of Nova Aurigae, as shown in the photographs opposite, taken in Cambridge and Peru.
Imaginary variables are not numerous, but some of them are very remarkable; for example, Eta Argus, an erratic variable in the southern hemisphere (shown in the midst of the nebulosity on page 428). Halley, who visited Saint Helena in 1679, recorded its mag- nitude as 3.5; in 1700 it was 3.8; in 1710 it was 3.6; between the first and second magnitudes; but in 1838 the light became tripled, rivaling all the stars except Sirius and Canopus. In 1843 it was even brighter but since then it has been steadily declining to reach a magnitude of the 71 magnitude in 1886. Probably it has no regular period, although one of a half century has been suggested. Recently the brightness of Eta Argus has shown a slight increase for a few years, after which it has fallen again; though their fluctuations are confined to a much narrower range.
Variables of the Algol Type.—Algol is the name of the star Beta Persei, the best known object of this class.
As a rule, the periods of this type of variables are short, and they remain at maximum brightness during nearly the whole. Then almost suddenly they drop within a few hours to minimum light, remain there but a fraction of an hour, and almost as rapidly return to full brightness again. The spectra of all Algol variables are of the first type.
The diagram represents the light-curves (between maximum and minimum) of four stars of this type, as determined by C. Pickering at the Harvard Observatory. The star W Delphini, although telescopic, is the most pronounced object of this type so far discovered.
TODD'S ATROX—p. 29
A diagram showing light-curves near Minimum of Four Algol Variables (Pickering).
Light-Curves near Minimum of Four Algol Variables (Pickering)
450
**Stars and Cosmogony**
It remains at full brightness rather more than four days; then from the 9.3 magnitude (upper left-hand corner of the diagram) it drops in seven hours to the 12.0 magnitude, becoming so faint as to be invisible in a four-inch telescope. Algol, in 41 hours, drops a little more than 1 o magnitudes, and rises again in 67 hours, showing that its period, as the diagram shows, its period, or interval from one minimum to the next, is very accurately known; at present it is 2 di. 48 m. 54 s., and is very gradually lessening. At full brightness Algol is the 2.2 magnitude, and is visible with the naked eye at night, being seen at times even during daylight, lasting about 15 minutes. Algol is best observed from early autumn to the middle of spring. Belonging to a type regarded by some as new, though at first classified with the Cepheids, it was discovered by R. J. Mitchell in 1875, which was discovered by Paul in 1888. These compound stars would seem to constitute a binary system whose members swing round each other almost in contact (page 469).
**Causes of Variability.** — No general explanation seems possible covering the variety in mutations of brightness of all classes of variables. Those of the Algol type are readily accounted for by the smaller star revolving around the larger, and smaller than the primary, and traveling round it in an orbit lying nearly edgewise to us. The illustration shows this: in the upper figure the system appears as we look at it; in the lower, as it would appear if we could look vertically upon it. Gravitation of a massive dark companion would, by its movement round Algol, displace it alternately toward and from the earth, when in the positions $E$ and $F$; because the two bodies must revolve round their common center of gravity. Just such a movement Algol has been found to have by means of the spectroscopic method, proving that the star alternately recedes from and advances toward us at the rate of 26 miles per second, in a period synchronous with that of its variability.
For variables of other types, a comprehensive explanation is found in vast areas of spots, similar to spots on the sun, taken in connection with
A diagram illustrating the orbital motion of Algol's Dark Companion.
Orbits of Algol's Dark Companion
Double Stars 451
the star's rotation on its axis and a periodicity of the spots themselves.
The new stars are more likely due to tremendous outbursts of glowing hydrogen; perhaps in some cases to vaporization of dark bodies caused by their brushing past each other, or to a faint star's actual plunging through a gaseous region of space. Sir Norman Lockyer's theory for variable stars of this class is made clear by the illustration: variable stars are still in the midst of me-
teoric swarms; and the orbital revolution of lesser swarms around larger aggre-
gations results in multi-
tudes of collisions, periodically raising hosts of meteoric particles to a state of incan-
descence.
Double Stars. Many
stars which to the unas-
sisted eye look simply as one, are separated by the
telescope into more than one. According to the number,
these are called double, triple, quadruple, or multiple stars.
When the components of a pair appear to be associated together in space, it is catalogued as a double star. A few stars, however, are only apparently double, having no actual relation to one another in space, and only seeming in proximity because they happen to be nearly in the line of sight from the earth. They are remote from each other, as well as from the solar system. Such pairs of stars are called optical doubles.
Although a few double stars were known earlier, history of the dis-
covery and measurement of these objects may be said to have begun with Sir William Herschel. His father, John Her-
schel, Baron Dembowski, among others, have prosecuted these researches vigorously. More than 10,000 double stars are now known, and discov-
eries have been rapidly made in recent years, particularly by Burnham of Chicago. The next illustration shows a dozen of the easier doubles,
Sir Norman Lockyer's Meteoric Theory of Variables
452
Stars and Cosmogony
within reach of small telescopes. Instruments of greater diameter than six inches are necessary to divide the components of a double star whose apparent distance from one another is less than o'8". Bond and Gould were pioneers in the application of photography to observa-
tion of the wider 'doubles'; but here the assistance of this new method is not as yet very useful. The first binary stars observed by other European observers of double stars are Bigourdan of Paris and Glaseanp of Saint Petersburg; and in America A. Hall, Comstock, and Leavenworth.
Binary Stars. -- Careful and protracted observations are
necessary to determine the class to which any pair of
stars belongs. If the components of a 'double' are
A diagram showing two overlapping circles with lines connecting them, representing a binary star system.
found to revolve in a closed or elliptic orbit, they are
called a binary star. It is assumed, and doubtless rightly,
that this motion depends upon gravitation.
About 200 binaries are now known, and the orbits of perhaps so of
them are well ascertained. In his Researches on the Evolution of the
Stellar System (1869), See has presented a summary of present knowl-
edge of these bodies. According to Miss Everest's investigation, the
planes of their orbits sustain no definite relation to any fundamental
Twelve Typical Double Stars
A diagram showing twelve overlapping circles with lines connecting them, representing twelve different binary star systems.
About 200 binaries are now known, and the orbits of perhaps so of
them are well ascertained. In his Researches on the Evolution of the
Stellar System (1869), See has presented a summary of present knowl-
edge of these bodies. According to Miss Everest's investigation, the
planes of their orbits sustain no definite relation to any fundamenta
Masses of Binary Stars 453
plane of the heavens. The first known (star No. 883 discovered by Burnham) is the brightest known binary, its period being 162 years. The next two stars, which have been recognized, are components of which it is dark. These can be discovered only by the effect which the attraction of the dark star produces in the light of the other. The star Sirius is one of this kind, having a faint attendant only bright enough to be detected with large telescopes, and known as the companion of Sirius. Its orbit as determined by Burnham from observations 1862-66 is shown in the diagram (see also discussion by A. G. Clark in 1862), not only its existence but its true position had been predicted by Adams.
The companion's period is 52 years; and since the distance both from Sirius and from the solar system, show that the mass of the companion equals that of Sirius, while that of the Dog Star itself exceeds that of the sun 21 times.
But the best known binary system is the one first discovered (by Richaud in 1689). Al-pha Centauri, also the nearest of all fixed stars. Its components are of the same revolution is 81 years, the masses of the two components are very nearly equal, and their combined mass is twice that of the sun. The stars of a binary system are said to be in periastron when nearest to one another in space; and in apastron when farthest. At periastron the com-ponents of Alpha Centauri are about as far apart as Saturn is from the sun ; in apastron their distance from each other greatly exceeds that of Neptune from us.
Eccentricities and Masses of Binary Stars. The orbits of binary stars are remarkable for great eccentricity; also for the large mass-ratios of their components, always
A diagram showing the orbit of Sirius as determined by Burnham.
Orbit of Sirius (Burnham)
454
Stars and Cosmogony
comparable, and in some cases nearly equal. In these respects they differ greatly from the bodies of the planetary system, the orbits in which are nearly circular, and none of the planets have more than a small fraction of the sun's mass. See explains the exceptionally high eccentricity of binary orbits, according to the principles of tidal evolution, from orbits which were nearly circular in the beginning. Originally the system was a single rotating nebulous mass, which became modified into a dumb-bell figure as a result of its own contraction. The average eccentricity of the best known binaries is 0.48, while that of the planets and satellites in our system is less than 0.04, or only $\frac{1}{2}$ as great; and this extraordinary relation between the two classes of bodies is one of the fundamental law of nature. Recalling the principles by which the mass of a planet is compared with that of the sun, it is evident that a like method will give the mass of a binary system, also in terms of the sun. First we must measure the major axis of the orbit, and observe the period of revolution; also it is necessary to assume that the Newtonian law of gravitation governs their motion. Then :
| Moon's distance from earth |
Distance between components |
| of Alpha Centauri |
of Alpha Centauri |
| Moon's period (in months) |
Earth's mass |
Period of their revolution (in years) |
Sum of masses |
| period (in months) |
(in solar masses) |
(in years) |
(in solar masses) |
Masses of the few binary systems ascertained in this manner are about twofold or threefold that of the sun.
**Binaries discovered by the Spectroscope.** — It was Bessel who first wrote of the 'astronomy of the invisible,' and his prediction has been marvellously fulfilled by the recent discovery of spectroscopic binaries. They are binaries whose components are so near each other that the telescope cannot divide them, and whose spectra therefore overlie. As the orbits of binary systems stand at all pos
Multiple Stars 455
sible angles in space, a few will appear almost edge on.
Let the two components be in conjunction, as referred to
the solar system; clearly their spectra will be identical.
But when they reach quadrature, one will be receding
from the earth and the other coming toward it. A given
line in the compound spectrum, then, will appear double,
on account of displacement due to motion of the compo-
nents in opposite directions. Measure the displacement,
and observe the period of its recurrence. This gives the
velocity of the components relatively to each other, the
dimensions of their orbit, and their mass in terms of the
sun, always assuming that the same law of gravitation is
regnant among the stars.
The binaries so far discovered by this method have relatively short periods. The most remarkable is $\alpha^{\prime}$ Scorpius, only 35 hours. Beta Aurigae is a remarkable star of this class, the doubling of its
lines taking place at intervals of about eight nights, giving a period of four days: and the com-
bined mass of both stars is more than twice that of the sun. The region of its spectrum is here shown,
with lines for both components and single. New atoms of this
type are continually com-
ing to light; but it is
still impossible to see
the line which appears to be
the line of sight, the diphasity is not discoverable in this manner. The one first found by E.C. Pickering in 1880 is perhaps the most remarkable of all; it consists of two stars whose spectral lines become periodically double, indicating a period of about 52 days. The measured distance of the double lines gives a relative velocity of 100 miles per second, or nearly half the velocity of light. The next
ferry fold. Bode's recent investigations with the great Pulkowa refractor, prove that $\alpha^{\mathrm{~G~em~}}$, one of the component stars of Cas-
tor, also is a swift moving spectroscopic binary.
**Multiple Stars,** —Numerous stars have more than two
Beta Aurigae spectrum showing double lines.
BRIEVE DESCRIPTIVE NOTES ON THE SPECTRA OF THE STARS (Pickering).
456
Stars and Cosmogony
components in the same field of view. These are generally called multiple stars, though the terms *triple star* for three components, *quadruple* for four, and so on, are often used. In isolated instances a star may be optically multiple; that is, the components appear to be associated together, from the fact that they are in or near the line of sight, while in reality they are at vastly different distances from the sun, and are in no sense related to each other. Nearly all multiple stars are physically multiple; that is, connected together in a real system. Such a system is the star Epsilon Lyrae, the well-known fourth-magnitude star, near Vega. A keen eye, even without optical assistance, will split into a double star a small telescope will divide each of two components into two parts, demonstrating a tiful quadruple system; while large telescopes show at least three other faint stars, one of them very difficult, between the pairs. Not only do the two stars of each pair revolve round each other, in periods of several hundred years, but the pairs themselves have a grander orbital motion round each other in a vast period not yet determined. A multiple star having more than seven or eight components would be classed as a *star cluster*.
**Stellar Clusters.** — Seeming aggregations of stars in the sky are called stellar clusters, or simply clusters. Broadly speaking, these are divided into two classes. The open clusters, so called because the stars are not very thickly scattered, of which the Pleiades are a very conspicuous type; and the close clusters, in which the stars appear to be thickly aggregated. The Pleiades contain six stars visible to the ordinary naked eye, though seven, nine, and even as many as thirteen stars have in rare instances been seen in this group without a telescope. A medium glass shows about 100 stars, and a photographic plate exposed an hour displays more than 2000 stars in and close to the
Stellar Clusters
457
Pleiades. An exposure of six hours shows 4000 stars.
The longer the exposure, the more stars appear on the plate. By an exposure of 17 h. 30 m., continued on nine nights, and covering a region of four square degrees, nearly 7000 stars are counted in the Pleiades. Recent counts make them fewer in the immediate regions of the bright stars than in adjacent portions of the sky of equal area; and very much fewer than in many parts of the Milky Way. Also by photography Barnard has discovered extensive nebulosities surrounding the Pleiades, which the glare of the larger stars makes difficult to see with a telescope. They have crudely the shape of a horseshoe.
One type of close clusters is known as the globular cluster, in which the stars are compacted together as if in a seemingly circular area, or in space a nearly globular mass. The following picture is an excellent illustration of this type. The more nearly spherical a cluster appears older it is thought to be; for the individual components of clusters are no doubt subject to the laws of evolution and disintegration, and the more perfect approach to a spherical figure would indicate that the process of central forces had been longer continued. Thus it is possible to infer the maturity of a cluster from its apparent dis- position of its component numbers. One of the finest objects in the sky is the double cluster, excellently reproduced in the next photograph. It forms part of the Milky Way in Perseus, and each component approaches the globular form. The clusters are made up of stars of about equal magnitude, but they are not so closely packed as though no parallax of a cluster has yet been measured. In all, about zoo clusters and nebulae have been photographed, so that a half century hence it may be possible to ascertain what changes are taking place.
Globular Cluster 15 Pegasi (Roberts)
458
Stars and Cosmogony
The Galaxy, or Milky Way.—Lying diagonally across the dome of the sky, at varying angles and elevations in different seasons of the year, may be seen on clear, moonless nights an irregular belt or zone of hazy light of uneven brightness, about three times the breadth of the moon, and stretching from horizon to horizon. This is part of the Galaxy, or Milky Way. It is really a ring of light, reaching entirely round the celestial sphere, roughly in a great circle; and usually about half of it will be above the horizon and half below. It intersects the ecliptic near the solstices, at an angle of about 60°. Early in September
The Double Cluster in Perseus (photographed by Robert)
Stellar Distribution
459
evenings it nearly coincides with a vertical circle lying northeast and southeast. The Galaxy is fixed in relation to the stars, and part of it lies so near the south pole of the heavens that it can never be seen in our northern latitudes. From Cygnus to Scorpio it is a divided belt, or double stream. Even a small telescope shows at once that the Milky Way is composed of millions of faint stars, nearly every one of them individually too faint for naked-eye vision, but whose vast numbers give us collectively the gauzy impression of the Galaxy. On page 13 is an excellent reproduction from one of the finest of Barnard's photographs of the Milky Way, and equally striking photographs have been obtained by Wolf, and of the Southern Milky Way by Reusch. All these stars are faint, and probably comparable in size and constitution with the sun himself.
They are not evenly scattered, but in many regions are aggregated into close clusters of stars; for example, the double cluster in the sword hilt of Perseus, shown opposite. It is readily visible to the naked eye on clear, moonless nights in the position shown in diagram on page 66. According to its apparent dimensions, this cluster of stars is a sphere having but little depth in proportion to its diameter. Study of the photographs has led Maund to direct attention to "dark lanes" in the Milky Way, marking regions of rare bareness of stellar material, and perhaps indicating a galactic condensation progressing toward an ultimate globular cluster.
Distribution of the Stars.--As to their apparent distribution over the face of the sky, lack of uniformity is evident. The fact of their recognized division into constellations, even from the earliest ages, is proof of this. Clusters and starless vacuities are well known. Frequently there are found streams of stars, especially by exploration with the telescope. One general law is known to govern the apparent distribution in the heavens: at both poles of the Milky Way, the stars are scattered most sparsely;
A diagram showing a double cluster in the sword hilt of Perseus.
460
**Stars and Cosmogony**
and the number in a unit of surface of the stellar sphere increases on all sides uniformly toward the plane of the Milky Way itself. This important discovery was made by Sir William Herschel, through a laborious process of actually counting the stars, technically called 'star gauges.' In Coma Berenices, for example, near the north pole of the Milky Way, are perhaps five stars in a given area; half way to the Galaxy the number has doubled; and in the Milky Way itself the average number is found to exceed 120, thus increasing more rapidly as this basal plane of the sidereal universe is approached. Kapteyn, a recent investigator of this supreme problem, likens the general shape of the stellar universe to that of the great nebula in Andromeda. The sun is situated at the center of this cluster, belonging to the cluster to which the sun belongs, and its exterior rings the flattened layers of stars surrounded by the zone of the Galaxy.
The Nebula. — A nebula is a celestial object, often of irregular form and brightness, appearing like a mass of luminous fog. In all, about 8000 are now known, and their positions among the stars determined. They differ greatly in brightness, form, and appearance. Many of them are shown by the spectroscope to be glowing, incandescent gases, in large part hydrogen. These are greenish in tint; but a few whitish ones are resolvable; that is, composed of masses of separate stars too
A circular diagram showing a nebula with a central star and several rings around it.
Ring Nebula in Lyra (Roberta)
Remarkable Nebulae 461
faint to be seen individually. The nebulae appear like the residue of the materials of original chaos out of which the sun, his planets, and the stars have through many millions of years come into being. A few of them are variable in brightness.
**Classification of the Nebulae.**—It is usual to divide the nebula into five classes, based on their various forms:
(1) annular nebule, (2) spiral nebule, (3) planetary nebule,
(4) nebulous stars, (5) irregular nebule, for the most part large. A sixth class, elliptic nebule, is sometimes recognized; probably they are annular nebule seen edgewise, or nearly so. But some of the so-called annular nebule appear elliptic also. Every degree of eccentricity in their figure is recognized—some are merely oval, others are drawn out (page 409) into a mere line. Swift has made numerous nebulous discoveries, and the most extensive catalogue of nebulae is Dreyer's.
By powerful exposures fine photographs of the fainter nebulae have been obtained by von Gersdorff and others. A famous nebule in the irregular order surrounds the star Eta Argus (page 428). In recent years this space frequently photographed by Gill and Russell with exposures of many hours' duration, and changes in its brightness are plainly indicated.
**Remarkable Annular and Elliptic Nebulae.**—A fine object of this kind was discovered by Gale in 1864 in the southern constellation Grus; but the best-known annular nebule is in the constellation Lyra. A very faint object in small telescopes, the great ones
The Great Nebula in Andromeda (Roberts)
462
**Stars and Cosmogony**
reveal many stars within its interior spaces. The illustration on p. 460 is from a photograph of the nebula, but it does not show the complexity and irregularity of structure which some of the large telescopes indicate.
The star near its center is thought to be variable. Among elliptic nebulae, the signal object is the 'great nebula in Andromeda'. So bright is it that the stars in its vicinity are obscured by its light. In size, too, as seen in the telescope, is remarkable—about seven times the breadth of the moon, and its width more than half as great. The illustration on p. 461 shows this nebula as photographed by Van Ertu's splendid photographs in 1888. Apparently it is composed of a number of partially distinct rings, with knots of condensing nebulosity, as if companion stars in the making. Its spectrum shows that it is not gaseous, still no telescope has yet proved competent to resolve it.
**Spiral and Planetary Nebulae.** — The great reflecting telescope of Lord Rosse first brought to light the wonderful spiral nebula, the most conspicuous example of which is found in Canes Venatici. The structure is so complex that photography has a vast advantage in depicting it, as the adjacent illustration reveals. The convolutions of the spiral are filled with many star-like con- densations, themselves surrounded by nebulosity. The spectroscopic indicates its stellar character, though, like the Andromeda nebula, it is yet unresolved, except in planetary nebulae have this name because they exhibit a disk with pretty definite outlines, round or nearly so, like the large planets, though very much fainter. They are nearly all gaseous in composition. Nebulous stars are stars completely enveloped as if in hazy, nebulous fog. They are
Spiral Nebula in Canes Venatici (Roberts)
Spiral Nebula in Canes Venatici (Roberts)
Great Nebula in Orion 463
mostly telescopic objects, and very regular in form, some with nebulosity well defined, others less so. One has luminous rings surrounding it.
Spectra of the Nebula. — Sir William Huggins, who in 1864 first applied the spectroscopic method to nebular light lines to their spectra, indicated a community of chemical composition, due to glowing gas, in large part hydrogen. Helium has recently been added ; but other lines are due to substances not yet recognized as terrestrial elements. The spectrum of the great nebula is a peculiar sub- ule give the gaseous spectrum ; and exceedingly high temperatures are indicated, or else a state of strong electric excitement. Both tempera- ture and pressure appear to be high in the great nebula. Many substances yield bright lines; showing rather a continuous spectrum, prominently the great nebula of Andromeda. Lack of lines may be interpreted as due to gases under extreme pressure, or to ag- gravation of the light by the gas itself. The most striking feature is the great spiral nebula in Canes Venatici, well depicted in the photograph by Roberts (opposite); but no telescope has yet been able to resolve either of its components into separate stars. The nebula's photo- graph has revealed about 60 lines in the spectra of nebulae, and Keeler and Campbell have shown, in the case of the Orion nebula, that nearly every line in its spectrum is the counterpart of a prominent dark line in the spectra of the brighter stars of the same constellation.
The Great Nebula in Orion.—Just below the eastern end of Orion's belt is this greatest of all nebulae. So characteris- tically bright is this well-known object that it is readily visible to the naked eye without a telescope.
It was the first nebula ever photographed — by Henry Draper in 1880.
The spreading expanse of its nebulosity completely envelopes the multiple star
The Great Nebula in Orion : Roberts
464
Stars and Cosmogony
Theta Orionis, often called the 'trapezium' (not well shown in the photograph because the blur of the nebula overlaps it). In small instruments a very obvious feature is the wide opening at one side, or break in the general light, sometimes seen in photographs of this star. The con-
cuent structure is excellently shown in the best photo-
graphs, and a greenish tinge has been recognized in its
light. Extensive wisps of nebulosity reach out in many
directions, involving other stars. W. H. Pickering's plates
indicate an approach to the spiral figure in these outlying
filaments, and Robert's photographs show vortical areas
within the nebula. Its spectrum reveals incandescent
hydrogen and helium; also other substances not yet recog-
nized among terrestrial elements. The nebula is as remote
A diagram showing the path of Milky Way and distribution of Nebulae according to Proctor.
Path of Milky Way and Distribution of Nebulae (according to Proctor)
as the stars are; and, according to Keeler's observations,
its distance from the sun is increasing at the rate of 11
miles every second. Also they prove an intimacy of rela-
tion between the nebula and neighboring stars. There is
no conclusive evidence of change of form in any part of
the nebula, although Holden has investigated this question
The Cosmogony 465
fully. He found, however, fluctuations of brightness in several regions, which Stone is now studying critically.
Distribution of the Nebulae. It may be said that the nebulae are distributed over the sky in just the opposite manner from the stars; for their number has a definite relation to the Milky Way. Reference to the preceding figure will show this at a glance. The small dots represent nebulae, not stars; and it is at once evident that they are more strongly clustered the greater their angular distance from the Milky Way. The physical reason underlying this fact is not known. Neither is the distance of any nebula known. So that the distribution of the nebulae throughout space can only be surmised. Measurement of the distance of a few nebulae has been attempted with the disappointing outcome that their parallax is exceedingly small, and probably beyond our power ever to ascertain. They are, therefore, at distances from our solar system estimable in light years, like those of the stars. Keeler's spectroscopic observations prove that the nebulae are moving in space at velocities comparable with those of the stars; the bright nebula in Draco, for example, is coming toward the earth at the rate of 40 miles every second. None of the nebulae, however, have yet been discovered to partake of proper motion.
The Cosmogony. — Cosmogony is the science of the development of the material universe. It has nothing to do with the original matter; it is concerned only with its laws and properties and with the transformations resulting from them. The ancient philosophers avoided the question of the origin of matter by asserting that the universe always had its present form from eternity; many minds are still satisfied with a literal interpretation of the Old Testament account of the creation, that the Almighty Power, out of nothing, built the universe in six days, sub-
TODD'S ASTRON. — 30
466
Stars and Cosmogony
stantially as observed in our own age; according to the accepted cosmogony, the universe was in the beginning a widely diffused chaos, 'without form and void,' accord-
ing to the Scriptures. Out of it has been evolved, by the long-continued action of fixed natural laws, the present orderly system of the universe.
The Universe is exceedingly Old. — In outline, the ac-
cepted cosmogony is this: Once in the inconceivably remote past, many hundreds of millions of years ago,
all the matter now composing earth, sun, planets, and stars, was scattered very thinly through the untold vast-
ness of the celestial spaces. The universe did not then exist, except potentially. Then, as now, every particle of matter attracted toward its center of gravity by the
Newtonian law. Gradually centers of attraction formed,
and these centers pulled in toward themselves other par-
ticles. As a result of the inward falling of matter toward these centers, the collision of its particles, and their fric-
tion upon each other, the material masses grew hotter and
hotter. Nebulae seeming to fill the entire heavens were
formed — luminous fire
mist, like the filmy ob-
jects still seen in the
sky, though vaster, and
exceedingly numerous.
Stones arose from
Nebulous Fire Mist. —
Countless ages elapsed;
the process went on,
swifter in some regions of space than in others.
Millions upon millions of nebular nuclei began to form;
condensation progressed; because the particles could not fall directly toward their centers of attraction, vast nebular
A stylized depiction of a nebula with concentric rings.
Ideal Genesis of Planetary System
(Compare with actual nebula on page 463)
463
Nebular Hypothesis 467
whirlpools were set in motion; axial rotation began; and temperature rose inconceivably high at centers where condensation was greatest. The sun was one of these centers; earth and all the other planets had not yet a separate existence, but their matter was already there, and then were diffused through the great solar nebula. Every star, whether lucid or telescopic, was such a center, or became one in the gradual evolution and process of world building.
**Planets from Nebulous Stars.** — As contraction and condensation went on, the whirling became swifter, because gravitation brought the particles nearer to the axis round which they turned, and there was no loss of rotational moment of momentum. Centrifugal force gave the whole rotating mass the figure, first of an orange, then of a vast thickened disk shaped like a watch. Eventually the masses would become so dense that could no longer whirl round as swiftly as the more compact central mass; so a separation took place, the outlying nebulous regions being left or sloughed off as a ring, while all the central portion kept on shrinking inward from it. As shown opposite, the mass of the ring would rarely be distributed uniformly; but being lumpy, the more massive portions would in time draw in the less massive ones, and the ring would thus become a planet in embryo; and its time of revolution round the sun would be that of the parent ring. If still nebulous, the planet would itself pass through the stages of the solar nebula and form rings to gather its satellites or satellites. Meanwhile the parent nebula went on contracting, and leaving other rings, which in the lapse of ages developed into inner planets, and their rings as a rule into satellites.
**Early History of the Nebular Hypothesis.** — Such in bare outline is the nebular hypothesis. Note that it is merely a
468
Stars and Cosmogony
highly plausible theory; it has never been absolutely demon-
strated, and probably never can be. To its development
many great minds have contributed. The Englishman
Thomas Watson, the Swede Olof Celsius, Swedenborg, and the
German Immanuel Kant all, independently of each other, in
the 18th century, appear to have originated the hypothe-
sis under slightly variant forms. Of these, Kant's theory
was the most philosophic; but his greater renown as a
mental philosopher than as a physicist appears to have
hindered attention to his important speculation. When,
however, La Place lent the gravity of his great name to
an almost identical hypothesis, astronomers at once recog-
nized that it must be based on sound dynamic concep-
tions. Then came the giant telescopes of the Herschels,
father and son, and of Lord Rosse, adding the evidence of
observation, for they discovered in the sky nebule, some
globular in form, some disk-like, others annular, and still
others even spiral.
**Later Developments.** — But Lord Rosse's great telescope showed, too, that some at least of the nebule might be re-
solved into stars, thereby threatening the subversion of
the nebular hypothesis, especially if all the nebule could be so resolved. Within a few years, however, and just
after the middle of the 19th century, application of the
principles of spectrum analysis to the nebula proved
conclusively that many of them are composed of glowing
gas, and therefore cannot be resolved into stars. About
the same time von Helmholtz advanced the accepted theory
of the sun's constitution as a gaseous mass of solar heat; and Lane, an American, proved that a gaseous mass condensing as a result of gravitation might
actually grow hotter, in spite of its immense losses of heat.
Thus it was unnecessary to assume a high temperature of
the nebula in the beginning. Also the genius of Lord
Darwin and See 469
Kelvin, the eminent English physicist, strengthened the hypothesis by computations on the heat of the sun, and his probable duration of about 20,000,000 years in the past.
Recent Additions.—Then came Darwin, who, in the latter part of the 19th century, demonstrated mathematically the remarkable effects producible by tidal friction, which had been neglected in all previous researches. The gathering of a ring into an embryo planet was a process not easy to explain; and Darwin showed that probably the moon had never been a ring round the earth, but that she separated from her parent in a globular mass, in consequence of its too rapid whirling. He showed, too, how the mutual action of great tides in the two plastic masses would operate to push the moon away to her present remote distance ; the terrestrial tidal wave being in advance of the moon, owing to her tendency to draw forward; also, this wave would tend to pull the earth forward, thereby expanding her orbit, and increasing her mean distance from us. His researches cleared up, also, the enigma of the inner satellite of Mars, revolving round its primary in less time than Mars himself turns on his axis; and no less the newly discovered fact that Mercury and Venus keep a constant face to the sun, and satellites of Jupiter to their primary, just as the moon is to her parent earth. Later on, by adapting these principles to stellar systems,
See explained the fact of *Various Types of Double Nebula* (Lord Rose) the great eccentricity of the binary orbits as a result of the long-continued or secu-
| Mercury and Venus |
keep a constant face to the sun |
| Jupiter to its primary |
just as the moon is to her parent earth |
| by adapting these prin- |
principles to stellar systems. |
470
Stars and Cosmogony
lar action of tidal friction. The double stars, then, were originally double nebulae, separated by a process resembling "fission" in the case of protosols. Poincaré has proved mathematically that a virial nebula, under consequence of contraction, is liable to distortion into a pear-shaped or hour-glass figure, and to ultimate separation. And there is excellent observational proof in the double nebula (p. 469) found in different regions of the heavens.
Evidence supporting the Nebular Hypothesis. — To collect evidence from the entire universe, as at present known :—
(a) Scanning the heavens with the telescope, we find numerous nebulae of forms required by the theory.
(b) Spectrum analysis proves a general unity of chemical composition throughout the universe.
(c) Stellar evolution necessitates the supposition of birth, growth, and death. This arrangement met by the fact that types of stellar spectra differ greatly, possibly indicating a wide variation in age of the stars, although this is not yet clearly made out in all detail.
(d) Our sun is a star, and its corona resembles such wisps of nebulous light as theory would lead us to expect.
(e) The maintenance of solar heat is best explained on the basis of the sun's continual contraction.
(f) The planets revolve round the sun, and the satellites round the planets, in nearly the same plane (with few exceptions not difficult to account for).
(g) The planets all rotate on their axes (so far as is known), and they revolve in their orbits round the sun, in the same direction.
(h) The zone of small planets circling about the sun, and the triple ring surrounding the planet Saturn, are eminently suggestive and seemingly permanent illustrations of a single stage of the interrupted process of world building in accordance with the nebular hypothesis.
Other Universes 471
**Other Universes than Ours.** — When considering known stellar distances, we found stars immensely remote from the solar system in all directions; and everywhere scat-
tered among myriads remoter still, whose distances we can see no prospect of ever ascertaining. What is beyond? Outside the realm of fact, imagination alone can answer.
We cannot think of space except as unlimited. The con-
cept of infinite space precludes all possibility of a boun-
dary. But the number of stars visible with our largest
telescopes is far from infinite; for we should greatly over-
estimate their number in allowing but ten stars to every
human being on this earth, looking upon a little planet.
Are, then, these inconceivable vastnesses of space surround-
ed with other universes than the one our telescopes unfold?
We are driven to conclude that in all probability they are.
Just as our planetary system is everywhere surrounded by
a roomy, starless void, so doubtless our huge sidereal clus-
ters deep rest in an outer space everywhere enveloping
illimitably. So remote must be these external galaxies
that unextinguished light from them, although it speeds
eight times round the earth in a single second, cannot
reach us in millions of years. Verily, infinite space tran-
scends all human conception; and intelligence, bound
with Newton, as we began. 'Since his day,' wrote one
of England's greatest astronomers in his Cardiff address
(1891), 'our knowledge of the phenomena of Nature has
wonderfully increased; but man asks, perhaps more
earnestly now than then, what is the ultimate reality
behind the reality of the perceptions? Are they only the
pebbles of the beach with which we have been playing?
Does not the ocean of ultimate reality and truth lie
beyond?'
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
INDEX
Abble, E., Dic. Univ. Jena 1935 Ammonia, before its discovery by Lavoisier, 1780, 267 Ambrosius, 14th cent., 267 Ambrosius, Pliny the Elder, 1st cent., 267 Anatolica, 14th cent., 267 Anatolica, 15th cent., 267 Anatolica, 16th cent., 267 Anatolica, 17th cent., 267 Anatolica, 18th cent., 267 Anatolica, 19th cent., 267 Anatolica, 20th cent., 267 Anatolica, 21st cent., 267 Anatolica, 22nd cent., 267 Anatolica, 23rd cent., 267 Anatolica, 24th cent., 267 Anatolica, 25th cent., 267 Anatolica, 26th cent., 267 Anatolica, 27th cent., 267 Anatolica, 28th cent., 267 Anatolica, 29th cent., 267 Anatolica, 30th cent., 267 Anatolica, 31st cent., 267 Anatolica, 32nd cent., 267 Anatolica, 33rd cent., 267 Anatolica, 34th cent., 267 Anatolica, 35th cent., 267 Anatolica, 36th cent., 267 Anatolica, 37th cent., 267 Anatolica, 38th cent., 267 Anatolica, 39th cent., 267 Anatolica, 40th cent., 267 Anatolica, 41st cent., 267 Anatolica, 42nd cent., 267 Anatolica, 43rd cent., 267 Anatolica, 44th cent., 267 Anatolica, 45th cent., 267 Anatolica, 46th cent., 267 Anatolica, 47th cent., 267 Anatolica, 48th cent., 267 Anatolica, 49th cent., 267 Anatolica, 50th cent., 267 Anatolica, (51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-51st) (50-
474
Index
Camer, Julius, reforma calendaris 666
Calamity in sea 270, 271, 273, 285
Calcutta (India) 100, 101, 266, city
Calvino, Italo 189
Campbell, W. W., see Lack. 348
Carnegie, Andrew J. 199
Canada of Man 259
Canary Islands 135, impic. of 50
Canary (a) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (b) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (c) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (d) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (e) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (f) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (g) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (h) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (i) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (j) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (k) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (l) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (m) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (n) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (o) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (p) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (q) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (r) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (s) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (t) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (u) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (v) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (w) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (x) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (y) 135, impic. of 50
Canary (z) 135, impic. of 50
Caractacus (a) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (b) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (c) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (d) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (e) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (f) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (g) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (h) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (i) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (j) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (k) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (l) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (m) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (n) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (o) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (p) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (q) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (r) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (s) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (t) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (u) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (v) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (w) see Caractacus.
Caractacus (x) see Caractacus.
Caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico y gramatical de los caracteres de la lengua castellana y de las demás lenguas hispanicas en el siglo XVIII y principios del XIX: estudio critico...
474
Index
Camer, Julius, reforma calendaris 666
Calamity in sea 270, 271, 285
Calcutta (India) 100, 101, 266, city
Calvino, Italo 189
Canada of Man 259
Canada of Man p...
Carnegie, Andrew J. ...
Caracteres...
474
Index
Camer, Julius, reforma calendaris e...
Calamity in sea e...
Calcutta (India), e...
Calvino, Italo e...
Canada of Man e...
Canada of Man p...
Carnegie, Andrew J. e...
Caracteres d...
474
Index
Camer, Julius, reforma calendaris e...
Calamity in sea e...
Calcutta (India), e...
Calvino, Italo e...
Canada of Man e...
Canada of Man p...
Carnegie, Andrew J. e...
Caracteres d...
474
Index
Camer, Julius, reforma calendaris e...
Calamity in sea e...
Calcutta (India), e...
Calvino, Italo e...
Canada of Man e...
Canada of Man p...
Carnegie, Andrew J. e...
Caracteres d...
474
Index
Camer, Julius, reforma calendaris e...
Calamity in sea e...
Calcutta (India), e...
Calvino, Italo e...
Canada of Man e...
Canada of Man p...
Carnegie, Andrew J. e...
Caracteres d...
474
Index
Camer, Julius, reforma calendaris e...
Calamity in sea e...
Calcutta (India), e...
Calvino, Italo e...
Canada of Man e...
Canada of Man p...
Carnegie, Andrew J. e...
Caracteres d...
474
Index
Camer, Julius, reforma calendaris e...
Calamity in sea e...
Calcutta (India), e...
Calvino, Italo e...
Canada of Man e...
Canada of Man p...
Carnegie, Andrew J. e...
Caracteres d...
474
Index
Camer, Julius, reforma calendaris e...
Calamity in sea e...
Calcutta (India), e...
Calvino, Italo e...
Canada of Man e...
Canada of Man p...
Carnegie, Andrew J. e...
Caracteres d...
474
Index
Camer, Julius, reforma calendaris e...
Calamity in sea e...
Calcutta (India), e...
Calvino, Italo e...
Canada of Man e...
Canada of Man p...
Carnegie, Andrew J. e...
474
Index
Camer...
Index 475
Double omen (see Binary system) p. 303, b. h. n. 304, a10, c00000, 305, 306, 307, 308, 309, 310, 311, 312, 313, 314, 315, 316, 317, 318, 319, 320, 321, 322, 323, 324, 325, 326, 327, 328, 329, 330, 331, 332, 333, 334, 335, 336, 337, 338, 339, 340, 341, 342, 343, 344, 345, 346, 347, 348, 349, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 355, 356, 357, 358, 359, 360, 361, 362, 363, 364, 365, 366, 367, 368, Dugnang A. E., Llewellyn p. 246. f. t. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p. p.
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Dunsmore Alpina vio
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Ecclesiastical calendar (see Calendar) pp.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., dso., rso.
Fascicle solar sdy., d so ,r so .
Fascicle solar sdy . ,d so ,r so .
Fascicle solar sdy . ,d so ,r so .
Fascicle solar sdy . ,d so ,r so .
Fascicle solar sdy . ,d so ,r so .
Fascicle solar sdy . ,d so ,r so .
Fascicle solar sdy . ,d so ,r so .
Fascicle solar sdy . ,d so ,r so .
Fascicle solar sdy . ,d so ,r so .
Fascicle solar sdy . ,d so ,r so .
Fascicle solar sdy . ,d so ,r so .
Fascicle solar s dy . ,d so ,r so .
F ascic le sol ar sy dy dr ro
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p.p..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..pp..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Hale G.E.D.C.OsU Chicago,p..
Index
Index
476
Index
Holt, A. J. Die. Ole. Univ. Mich. 935.
Holt, A. J. Ole. Univ. Mich. 935.
Holt, A. J. Ole. Univ. Mich. 935.
Holt, A. J. Ole. Univ. Mich. 935.
Holt, A. J. Ole. Univ. Mich. 935.
Holt, A. J. Ole. Univ. Mich. 935.
Holt, A. J. Ole. Univ. Mich. 935.
Holt, A. J. Ole. Univ. Mich. 935.
Holt, A. J. Ole. Univ. Mich. 935.
Holt, A. J. Ole. Univ. Mich. 935.
Holt, A. J. Ole. Univ. Mich. 935.
Holt, A. J. Ole. Univ. Mich. 935.
Holt, A. J. Ole. Univ. Mich. 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich., 935.
Holt, A.J., Olea Univ., Mich,, 935.
Holt, A.J.. Olea Univ.. Mich,, 935.
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1802) (1784-1802). Gen.potl.d8
Kane', L (1766) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Kane', L (D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; 36;
Kane', L (D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; 36;
Kane', L (D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; 36;
Kane', L (D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; 36;
Kane', L (D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; 36;
Kane', L (D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; 36;
Kane', L (D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; 36;
Kane', L (D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; 36;
Kane', L (D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; 36;
Kane', L (D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; 36;
Kane', L (D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; 36;
Kane', L (D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; 36;
Kane', L (D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; 36;
Kane', L (D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; 36;
Kane', L (D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; 36;
Kane', L (D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; 36;
Kane', L (D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; 36;
Kane', L (D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; 36;
Kane', L (D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; 36;
Kane', L(D.D.) Allinghough Obs.: 246; . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Kanekal, S.R.(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)(S.R.Kanekal)
Karolus Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Linnaeus( Limnophila spinosa(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Linneaus(Limnophila spinosaLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLinneausLimnophila spinosaLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæusLinnæu...
Limnophila spinosa[Linneau][Linneau][Linneau][Linneau][Linneau][Linneau][Linneau][Linneau][Linneau][Linneau][Linneau][Linneau][Linneau][Linneau][Linneau][Linneau][Linneau][Linneau][Linneau][Linneau][Limnophila spinosa[Linneau] [Limnophila spinosa[Linneau] [Limnophila spinosa[Linneau] [Limnophila spinosa[Linneau] [Limnophila spinosa[Linneau] [Limnophila spinosa[Linneau] [Limnophila spinosa[Linneau] [Limnophila spinosa[Linneau] [Limnophila spinosa[Linneau] [Limnophila spinosa[Linneau] [Limnophila spinosa[Linneau] [Limnophila spinosa[Linneau] [Limnophila spinosa[Linneau] [Limnophila spinosa[Linneau] [Limnophila spinosa[Linneau] [Limnophila spinosa[Linneau] [Limnophila spinosa[Linneau] [Limnophila spinos...
Limnophila spinosa[Linneou][Limnophila spinos...
Limnophila spinosa[Linneou][Limnophila spinos...
Limnophila spinosa[Linneou][Limnophila spinos...
Limnophila spinosa[Linneou][Limnophila spinos...
Limnophila spinosa[Linneou][Limnophila spinos...
Limnophila spinosa[Linneou][Limnophila spinos...
Limnophila spinosa[Linneou][Limnophila spinos...
Limnophila spinosa[Linneou][Limnophila spinos...
Limnophila spinosa[Linneou][Limnophila spinos...
Limnophila spinosa[Linneou][Limnophila spinos...
Limnophila spinosa[Linneou][Limnophila spinos...
Limnophila spinosa[Linneou][Limnophila spinos...
Limnophila spinosa[Linneou][Limnophila spinos...
Limnophila spinosa[Linneou][Limnophila spinos...
Limnophila spinosa[Linneou][Limnophila spino...
limnothria spina[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](spina)[spina](s...
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothria spica]
limnothria spica[limnothri...
linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linum usitatissimum linuma...
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(linnun arvense)
linnum arvense(l...
linnum baccatum lindman lindman lindman lindman lindman lindman lindman lindman lindman lindman lindman lindman lindman lindman lindman lindman lindman lindman lindman lindman lindman lindma...
linnum baccatum[lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [lindmann] [linda...
Index 477
a Macdon, J. H. (medler) (1974-1983), Gen.
mt. 351
Magnum, in cometa 606, in sun 606
Magnetic disturbances, 277, 280, defined 275, laws
of 275, 280
Manessi, M. (man tsw), Fr. glas-maker
33
Maris, amorphose 246
marches, configurations 219, 220
in cometa 338, ellipticity 337, inclination 337,
logarithmic eccentricity 338, mean motion 338,
perihelion 338, aphelion 338, perihelion distance
339, aphelion distance 340, polar cap 340,
solar wind 340, solar wind density 340
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun 160
Mercury, in cometa 159, in sun
| 478 |
Index |
Pascal moon 368 Faul, J. (1950) S. Navey 368 Paul, M., W. D., The Cantor, G. H. Olm 368 Pegasus, Square of, Plate on, 66 Prodonis 368 Cygnus, C. A., Am. geom. by Conicoides 368 Perigee, moon's 331 Perseus, moon's 331 Perseveral proportion and oscillation at 270, 271 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 331 Persian, moon's 329-400 |
Role, celestial north defined; finding the $n$ Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.447) Rolling transversing ellipse by Pulsar (p.450), p.[A][B][C][D][E][F][G][H][I][J][K][L][M][N][O][P][Q][R][S][T][U][V][w][x][y][Z] |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Pascal moon $n$$\overline{2}$, Plate on $n$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$$\overline{2}$, $n$n+500000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
A small diagram showing a circle with a line segment drawn from its center to one of its points.
| Pascal moon $\pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$,$ \pi_-$,$ \pi_+$, |
Pascal moon $\alpha$, $\beta$, $\gamma$, $\delta$, $\epsilon$, $\zeta$, $\eta$, $\theta$, $\iota$, $\kappa$, $\lambda$, $\mu$, $\nu$, $\xi$, $\omega$, $\phi$, $\psi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$, $\chi$.
Index 479
Saegmiller, G. N. (one mile) 313
Sarabat, T. H., D.D., Wm. Col. Obs. 497
Watterson, J. B., D.D., Wm. Col. Obs. 497
Sato, cycle of eclipses 205
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 248-250
Saturn, planet of the solar system 313
Saxa (Virginia), Plant. Obs. Obs. Obs. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs. Obs. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Saxton (Virginia), Plant. Obs.
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile; one mile;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Scaliae viridifoliae var., plant in Virginia and North Carolina;
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishes
Schaeffer's starfishes: see Starfishs...
Schaeffer's starflies... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Schaeferiida... Sch...
Shawnee County - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas - Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas -Kansas ...
Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ... Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawnee County ...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Shawneecounty...
Index
480
Index
Tachini, P. (tick-ken-see), Dia. Olea Cal.
Rosa, 357
Pistacia, 66
Pistacia, 66, 67
Cypripedium, 292
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293, astronomy
Teleopera, achromia: 292, 293,
Variable species: variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species; variable species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: Variable Species;
Variable Species: VariableSpecies:
Venus xii., albedo xii., atmosphere xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii., chart xii.,
Venus XIX. albedo XXIX. atmosphere XXIX. charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX. Charts XXIX.
Venus XIX.: albedo XIX.; atmosphere XIX.; charts XIX.; charts XIX.; charts XIX.; charts XIX.; charts XIX.; charts XIX.; charts XIX.; charts XIX.; charts XIX.; charts XIX.; charts XIX.; charts XIX.; charts XIX.; charts XIX.; charts XIX.; charts XIX.; charts XIX.; charts XIX.;
Venus Xix.: albedo Xix.; atmosphere Xix.; charts Xix.; charts Xix.; charts Xix.; charts Xix.; charts Xix.; charts Xix.; charts Xix.;
Venus XVIII.: albedo XVIII.; atmosphere XVIII.; charts XVIII.; charts XVIII.;
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.; atmosphere XVII.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVI.: albedo XVI.;
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.; atmosphere XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVII.: albedo XVII.
Venus XVIII.: albedo xviii.; atmosphere xviii.
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophyes)
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophyes)
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophyes)
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophyes)
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophyes)
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophyes)
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophyes)
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophyes)
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophyes)
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophyes)
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophyes)
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophyes)
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophyes)
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophyes)
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophyes)
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophyes)
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophyes)
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophyes)
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophyes)
Xenophyes (xenophyes): Xenophyes (xenophye...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
Xeranthemum nobiles...
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv., retrograde motion xxiv.
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar
Astronomical Calendar...
Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg... Albion-Beg...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beck...
Albion-Beek...
Albions:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonian calendar:
Babylonic lunar month names:
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde motion xxiv.
and motion xxviii., retrograde movementxxvi..
Andrographis paniculata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variegata variega teta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varegateteta varega t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t ete t etcetera
1
A black page with a faint, horizontal line running across the middle. | | | | | | |