Name/Sirius/
Canopus/
Aquila/
Vega/
Cygnus/
Battea/
Cygno/
Procyon/
Acheron/
Beta/
Centaurus/
Boletus/
Altair/
Albireo/
Delphini/
Pollux/
Spica/
Antares/
Scorpius/
Fornax/
Deneb/
Cygno/
Regulus/
Constellation/
Carina/
Lym/
Taurus/
Bootes/
Gemini/
Virgo/
Sagittarius/
Ophiuchus/
Aquarius/
Orion/
Lyrae/
Puppis/
Scozia/
Magnitude
///
Dist.
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
Name/Sirius/
Canopus/
Aquila/
Vega/
Cygnus/
Battea/
Cygno/
Procyon/
Acheron/
Beta/
Centaurus/
Boletus/
Altair/
Albireo/
Delphini/
Pollux/
Spica/
Antares/
Scorpius/
Fornax/
Deneb/
Cygno/
Regulus/
Constellation/
Carina/
Lym/
Taurus/
Bootes/
Gemini/
Virgo/
Sagittarius/
Ophiuchus/
Aquarius/
Orion/
Lyrae/
Puppis/
Scozia/
Magnitude
///
Dist.
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
CL V, 80J THE CONSTELLATIONS 145
79. Number of Stars in the First Six Magnitudes. The number of stars in each of the first six magnitudes is given in Table II. The sum of the numbers is 5000.
| First Magnitude |
20 |
Fourth Magnitude |
425 |
| Second Magnitude |
65 |
Fifth Magnitude |
1100 |
| Third Magnitude |
190 |
Sixth Magnitude |
3200 |
There are, therefore, in the whole sky only about 5000 stars which are visible to the unaided eye. At any one time only half the sky is above the horizon, and those stars which are near the horizon are largely extinguished by the absorption of light by the earth's atmosphere. Therefore one never sees at one time more than about 2000 stars, although the number of stars seen can be increased.
It is seen from the Table II that the number of stars in each magnitude is about three times as great as the number in the preceding magnitude. This ratio holds approximately down to the ninth magnitude, and in the first nine magnitudes there are in all nearly 200,000 stars. Since a telescope 3 inches in aperture will show objects as faint as those obtained with a telescope of 1 inch aperture, this result has been obtained from optical instruments. Only a rough guess can be made respecting the number of stars which are still fainter, but there are probably more than 300,000,000 of them within the range of present visual and photographic instruments.
80. The Motions of the Stars. The stars have motions with respect to one another which, in the course of immense time, approach and change the relations of the constellations, but we have no reliable important alterations in the visible sky during historic times. Nevertheless, they are so large that they must be taken into account when using star catalogues in work of precision.
L
146
AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ca. v. 80]
One result of the motions of the stars is that they drift with respect to fixed reference points and lines. The yearly change in the position of a star with respect to fixed reference points and lines is called its proper motion. The largest known proper motion is that of an eighth-magnitude star in the southern heavens, whose annual motion across the sky is about 8 seconds of arc. The slight extent to which this star has moved since the star can change the appearance of the constellations is shown by the fact that even this star, whose proper motion is more than 100 times the average proper motion of the brighter stars, will not move over an apparent distance as great as the diameter of the moon in less than 220 years.
Another component of the motion of a star is that which is in the same direction with the earth. This component can be measured by the spectroscope (Art. 22), and is found to range all the way from a velocity of approach of 40 miles per second to one of recession with the same speed; and in some cases even higher velocities are encountered. In the course of immense time the changes in the distances of the stars will alter their magnitudes appreciably; but the distances of these stars are so great that there is probably no case where the change in magnitude from the earth will sensibly change its magnitude in 20,000 years.
**81. The Milky Way, or Galaxy.** —The Milky Way is a hazy band of light giving indications to the unaided eye of being made up of faint stars; it is on the average about 20° in width and stretches in nearly a great circle entirely around the sky. The telescope shows that it is made up of millions of stars, each moving independently only with optical aid. It is clear that because of its irregular form and great width its position cannot be precisely described, but in a general way its location is defined by the fact that it intersects the celestial equator at two places whose right ascensions are approximately 6 hours 40 minutes and 18 hours 40 minutes, and it has an inclination to the
CH. V, § 32
THE CONSTELLATIONS
147
equator of about 62°. Or, in other terms, the north pole of the Milky Way is at right ascension about 12 hours 40 minutes and at declination about + 28°. For a long distance it is divided more or less completely into two parts, and at one place in the southern heavens it is cut entirely across by the ecliptic. The region between the ecliptic and the northern latitudes is a singular dark region north of the star Deneb.
82. The Constellations and Their Positions. — The work on reference points and lines in the preceding chapter together with the discussions so far given in this chapter are sufficient to prepare for the study of the constellations with interest and profit, and the reader should not stop short of further acquaintance with them. The distinguishing stars and the principal constellations that are visible in his latitude. Table III contains a list of the constellations and gives their positions. The numbers at the top show the degrees of declination between which the constellations lie, the numerals at the left show their right ascensions, and the numbers placed in connection with the names of the constellations indicate their distances from the equator, both to the unaided eye. The constellations which lie on the ecliptic, or the so-called zodiacal constellations, are printed in italics.
The following maps show the constellations from the north pole to −50° declination. When Map I is held up toward the sky, facing north, with its center in the line joining the eye with the north pole, and with the hour circle having the right ascension of the meridian passed directly above its center, it shows the constellations connected with their true relations to one another and to the horizon and pole. The other maps are to be used, facing south, with their centers held on a line joining the eye to the celestial equator, and with the hour circle having the right ascension of the meridian held in the plane of the eye and the meridian. When they are placed in this way, they show the constellations to the south of the observer in their true relationships. In
148 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. v. 82
| TABLE III |
| R. L. |
Dio. |
-90° to -60° |
+90° to +180° |
+90° to +180° |
-90° to -60° |
+90° to +180° |
-90° to -60° |
|
Cassiopeia, 46. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| II-IV |
Cassiopeia, 46. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| V-AT |
Cassiopeia, 46. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| VI-VII |
Cassiopeia, 46. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| XV-XVI |
Cassiopeia, 46. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| III-XXI |
Cassiopeia, 46. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| XVII-XXV | Cassiopeia, 46. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18. | Coma Berenices, 25. | Laurae, 18.XVII-XXV |
R. L. Dio. -90° to -60° +90° to +180° +90° to +180° -90° to -60° +90° to +180° -90° to -60°
R. L. Dio. -90° to -60° +90° to +180° +90° to +180° -90° to -60° +90° to +180° -90° to -60°
R. L. Dio. -90° to -60° +90° to +180° +90° to +180° -90° to -60° +90° to +180° -90° to -60°
R. L. Dio. -90° to -60° +90° to +180° +90° to +180° -90° to -60° +90° to +180° -90° to -60°
R. L. Dio. -90° to -60° +90° to +180° +90° to +180° -90° to -60° +90° to +180° -90° to -60°
R. L. Dio. -90° to -60° +90° to +180° +90° to +180° -90° to -60° +90° to +180° -90° to -60°
| Cumulative Total (in millions) |
A star chart with various labeled stars and constellations.
| 1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
| 5 |
6 |
7 |
8 |
| 9 |
10 |
11 |
12 |
| 13 |
14 |
15 |
16 |
| 17 |
18 |
19 |
20 |
| 21 |
22 |
23 |
24 |
| 25 |
26 |
27 |
28 |
| 29 |
30 |
31 |
32 |
| 33 |
34 |
35 |
36 |
| 37 |
38 |
39 |
40 |
| 41 |
42 |
43 |
44 |
| 45 |
46 |
47 |
48 |
| 49 |
50 |
51 |
52 |
| 53 |
54 |
55 |
56 |
| 57 |
58 |
59 |
60 |
| 61
|
| II |
II |
II |
II |
| II |
II |
II |
II |
| II |
II |
II |
II |
| II |
II |
II |
II |
| II |
II |
II |
II |
| II |
II |
II |
II |
| II |
II |
II |
II |
| II |
II |
II |
II |
| II |
II |
II |
II |
| II |
II |
II |
II |
| II |
II |
II |
II |
| II |
II |
II |
II |
| II |
II |
II |
II |
| II |
II |
II |
II |
| AEREOUSIUM (CASSIOPEIA) |
| ANDROMEDAE (CASSIOPEIA) |
|---|
| PALLASEOLAND (CASSIOPEIA) |
|---|
| LUCES (CASSIOPEIA) |
|---|
| PIRCEE (CASSIOPEIA) |
|---|
| Y * * * * * * * * * * |
|---|
| GECOSI (CASSIOPEIA) |
|---|
| FORMAZ (CASSIOPEIA) |
|---|
| SOLARFORM (CASSIOPEIA) |
|---|
| PHOENIX (CASSIOPEIA) |
|---|
A star chart with various labels and symbols indicating constellations.
PAGE NUMBER: 3000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111112222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222233333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333334444444444444444444444444555555555555555555555555566666666666666666666666667777777777777777777777777888888888888888888888888899999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999
S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S. S.
S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.S.
S.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.
Ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.ss.
SsSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssSssS
SsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSSsSS
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
| 17001 |
17002 |
17003 |
17004 |
17005 |
17006 |
17007 |
17008 |
17009 |
17010 |
17011 |
17012 |
17013 |
17014 |
17015 |
17016 |
17017 |
17018 |
17019 |
17020 |
17021 |
17022 |
17023 |
17024 |
17025 |
17026 |
17027 |
17028 |
17029 |
17030 |
17031 |
17032 |
17033 |
17034 |
17035 |
17036 |
17037 |
17038 |
17039 |
17040 |
17041 |
17042 |
17043 |
17044 |
17045 |
17046 |
17047 |
17048 |
17049 |
17050 |
| 10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
| P.O. & T. L.S. |
| C.O.D. |
|
|
|
|
|
| CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
| CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
| CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
| CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
| CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
CHURCH STREET |
| CHAIRMAN'S TABLES |
| XII |
XII |
XI |
| IMM 1-6-20 |
Y V O O |
|
| OMA |
| CANS PENSAT |
LURSA MAJOR |
|
|
| COMA PERENNE |
LCO MINOR |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDIC | PERIDICLAMZICA
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
| CENTALUMUS
|
|
| XXI |
XXII |
XXIII |
XXIV |
A star map showing constellations and their names. |
A star map showing constellations and their names. |
A star map showing constellations and their names. |
A star map showing constellations and their names. |
| LAZZARA |
ASTORIGA |
|
|
| CANCERI |
CANCERI |
CANCERI |
CANCERI |
| AMORCIOSE |
AMORCIOSE |
AMORCIOSE |
AMORCIOSE |
| CANIS MAJORIS |
CANIS MAJORIS |
CANIS MAJORIS |
CANIS MAJORIS |
| COLUMBIA |
COLUMBIA |
COLUMBIA |
COLUMBIA |
| XXXV |
XXXVI |
XXXVII |
XXXVIII |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
| 100 |
100 |
1567899999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999
| 10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
| 10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
| 10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
| 10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
| 10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
| 10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
| 10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
| 10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
| 10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
| 10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
| 10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
| 10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
| 10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
| 10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
| C.S.E.D. |
| C.S.E.D. |
| C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. |
| C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. |
| C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. |
| C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. |
| C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. |
| C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. |
| C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. |
| C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. |
| C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. |
| C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. |
| C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. |
| C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. |
| C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. |
| C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. |
| C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. |
| C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. | C.S.E.D. |
C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.C.
|
C.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A. C.
A.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B.B. B.
B.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G.G. G.
G.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.H.
H.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.J.
J.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.K.
K.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.L.
L.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.M.
M.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.N.
N.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.O.
O.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.P.
P.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.Q.
Q.R.R.R.R.R.R.R.R.R.R.R.R.R.R.R.R.R.R.R.R.R.R.R.R.R.
R.T.T.T.T.T.T.T.T.T.T.T.T.T.T.T.T.T.T.T.T.T.T.T.T.
T.U.U.U.U.U.U.U.U.U.U.U.U.U.U.U.U.U.U.U.U.U.U.U.
U.V.V.V.V.V.V.V.V.V.V.V.V.V.V.V.V.V.V.V.V.V.V.V.
V.W.W.W.W.W.W.W.W.W.W.W.W.W.W.W.W.W.W.W.W.W.W.
W.X.X.X.X.X.X.X.X.X.X.X.X.X.X.X.X.X.X.X.X.X.X.
X.Y.Y.Y.Y.Y.Y.Y.Y.Y.Y.Y.Y.Y.Y.Y.Y.Y.Y.Y.Y.Y.Y.
Y.Z.Z.Z.Z.Z.Z.Z.Z.Z.Z.Z.Z.Z.Z.Z.Z.Z.Z.Z.Z.
Z.
&...
| III |
XIII |
XIV |
XV |
| MAJ 1 2 3 4 |
★ |
★ |
★ |
| LYRA |
| HERCULES |
| COMA |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
| XII |
XII |
XIII |
XIII |
| ? |
? |
? |
? |
| ? |
? |
? |
? |
| (CANES VENATICI) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| E - shark |
|
|
|
| BRODYSE |
|
|
|
| AFRICA |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| ? |
? |
? |
? |
| KINGO |
|
|
|
|
AFRICA |
|
|
|
|
COPRAZ |
COPRAZ |
| HYPHOK |
Africa
CENTRALOPSIS
AFRICA
COPRAZ
COPRAZ
Africa
CENTRALOPSIS
HYPHOK
Africa
COPRAZ
COPRAZ
Africa
CENTRALOPSIS
HYPHOK
Africa
COPRAZ
COPRAZ
Africa
CENTRALOPSIS
HYPHOK
Africa
COPRAZ
COPRAZ
Africa
CENTRALOPSIS
HYPHOK
Africa
COPRAZ
COPRAZ
Africa
CENTRALOPSIS
HYPHOK
Africa
COPRAZ
COPRAZ
Africa
CENTRALOPSISA map with various labeled points and lines.
| 1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
| 5 |
6 |
7 |
8 |
| 9 |
10 |
11 |
12 |
| 13 |
14 |
15 |
16 |
| 17 |
18 |
19 |
20 |
| 21 |
22 |
23 |
24 |
| 25 |
26 |
27 |
28 |
| 29 |
30 |
31 |
32 |
| 33 |
34 |
35 |
36 |
| 37 |
38 |
39 |
40 |
| 41 |
42 |
43 |
44 |
| 45 |
46 |
47 |
48 |
| 49 |
50 |
51 |
52 |
| 53 |
54 |
55 |
56 |
| 57 |
58 |
59 |
60 |
| 61 |
62 |
63 |
64 |
| 65 |
66 |
67 |
68 |
| TOTALS: | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
A scanned document with handwritten notes and diagrams.
PUBLICADO POR LA DIRECCIÓN DE INGENIERÍA Y CONSTRUCCIÓN DEL MINISTERIO DE OBRAS PÚBLICAS Y TRANSPORTES.
CORRESPONDIENTE A LA SECCIÓN DE CONSTRUCCIONES.
DIRECCIÓN DE INGENIERÍA Y CONSTRUCCIÓN DEL MINISTERIO DE OBRAS PÚBLICAS Y TRANSPORTES.
CORRESPONDIENTE A LA SECCIÓN DE CONSTRUCCIONES.
DIRECCIÓN DE INGENIERÍA Y CONSTRUCCIÓN DEL MINISTERIO DE OBRAS PÚBLICAS Y TRANSPORTES.
CORRESPONDIENTE A LA SECCIÓN DE CONSTRUCCIONES.
DIRECCIÓN DE INGENIERÍA Y CONSTRUCCIÓN DEL MINISTERIO DE OBRAS PÚBLICAS Y TRANSPORTES.
CORRESPONDIENTE A LA SECCIÓN DE CONSTRUCCIONES.
DIRECCIÓN DE INGENIERÍA Y CONSTRUCCIÓN DEL MINISTERIO DE OBRAS PÚBLICAS Y TRANSPORTES.
CORRESPONDIENTE A LA SECCIÓN DE CONSTRUCCIONES.
DIRECCIÓN DE INGENIERÍA Y CONSTRUCCIÓN DEL MINISTERIO DE OBRAS PÚBLICAS Y TRANSPORTES.
CORRESPONDIENTE A LA SECCIÓN DE CONSTRUCCIONES.
DIRECCIÓN DE INGENIERÍA Y CONSTRUCCIÓN DEL MINISTERIO DE OBRAS PÚBLICAS Y TRANSPORTES.
CORRESPONDIENTE A LA SECCIÓN DE CONSTRUCCIONES.
DIRECCIÓN DE INGENIERÍA Y CONSTRUCCIÓN DEL MINISTERIO DE OBRAS PÚBLICAS Y TRANSPORTES.
CORRESPONDIENTE A LA SECCIÓN DE CONSTRUCCIONES.
DIRECCIÓN DE INGENIERÍA Y CONSTRUCCIÓN DEL MINISTERIO DE OBRAS PÚBLICAS Y TRANSPORTES.
CORRESPONDIENTE A LA SECCIÓN DE CONSTRUCCIONES.
DIRECCIÓN DE INGENIERÍA Y CONSTRUCCIÓN DEL MINISTERIO DE OBRAS PÚBLICAS Y TRANSPORTES.
CORRESPONDIENTE A LA SECCIÓN DE CONSTRUCCIONES.
DIRECCIÓN DE INGENIERÍA Y CONSTRUCCIÓN DEL MINISTERIO DE OBRAS PÚBLICAS Y TRANSPORTES.
CORRESPONDIENTE A LA SECCIÓN DE CONSTRUCCIONES.
DIRECCIÓN DE INGENIERÍA Y CONSTRUCCIÓN DEL MINISTERIO DE OBRAS PÚBLICAS Y TRANSPORTES.
CORRESPONDIENTE A LA SECCIÓN DE CONSTRUCCIONES.
DIRECCIÓN DE INGENIERÍA Y CONSTRUCCIÓN DEL MINISTERIO DE OBRAS PÚBLICAS Y TRANSPORTES.
CORRESPONDIENTE A LA SECCIÓN DE CONSTRUCCIONES.
DIRECCIÓN DE INGENIERÍA Y CONSTRUCCIÓN DEL MINISTERIO DE OBRAS PÚBLICAS Y TRANSPORTES.
CORRESPONDIENTE A LA SECCIÓN DE CONSTRUCCIONES.
DIRECCIÓN DE INGENIERÍA Y CONSTRUCCIÓN DEL MINISTERIO DE OBRAS PÚBLICAS Y TRANSPORTES.
CORRESPONDIENTE A LA SECCIÓN DE CONSTRUCCIONES.
DIRECCIÓN DE INGENIERÍA Y CONSTRUCCIÓN DEL MINISTERIO DE OBRAS PÚBLICAS Y TRANSPORTES.
CORRESPONDIENTE A LA SECCIÓN DE CONSTRUCCIONES.
DIRECCIÓN DE INGENIERÍA Y CONSTRUCCIÓN DEL MINISTERIO DE OBRAS PÚBLICAS Y TRANSPORTES.
CORRESPONDIENTE A LA SECCIÓN DE CONSTRUCCIONES.
DIRECCIÓN DE INGENIERÍA Y CONSTRUCCIÓN DEL MINISTERIO DE OBRAS PÚBLICAS Y TRANSPORTES.
CORRESPONDIENTE A LA SECCIÓN DE CONSTRUCCIONES.
DIRECCIÓN DE INGENIERÍA Y CONSTRUCCIÓN DEL MINISTRO
| 1000 |
1000 |
1000 |
1000 |
| 1000 |
1000 |
1000 |
1000 |
| 1000 |
1000 |
1000 |
1000 |
| 1000 |
1000 |
1000 |
1000 |
| 1000 |
1000 |
1000 |
1000 |
| 1000 |
1000 |
1000 |
1000 |
| 1000 |
1000 |
1000 |
1000 |
| 1536 |
1536 |
1536 |
1536 |
| 768 |
768 |
768 |
768 |
| 384 |
384 |
384 |
384 |
| 256 |
256 |
256 |
256 |
| 128 |
128 |
128 |
128 |
| 64 |
64 |
64 |
64 |
| TOTALS: |
| Total Cost: | Total Cost: | Total Cost: | Total Cost: |
|---|
| $2,592,992.99 (2,592,992.99) | $2,592,992.99 (2,592,992.99) | $2,592,992.99 (2,592,992.99) | $2,592,992.99 (2,592,992.99) |
|---|
| Total Revenue: | Total Revenue: | Total Revenue: | Total Revenue: |
|---|
| $3,777,777.78 (3,777,777.78) | $3,777,777.78 (3,777,777.78) | $3,777,777.78 (3,777,777.78) | $3,777,777.78 (3,777,777.78) |
|---|
| Net Profit: | Net Profit: | Net Profit: | Net Profit: |
|---|
| $-1,184,884.84 (-1,184,884.84) | $-1,184,884.84 (-1,184,884.84) | $-1,184,884.84 (-1,184,884.84) | $-1,184,884.84 (-1,184,884.84) |
|---|
| Total Cost: |
|---|
| $2,592,992.99 (2,592,992.99) |
|---|
| Total Revenue: |
|---|
| $3,777,777.78 (3,777,777.78) |
|---|
| Net Profit: |
|---|
| $-1,184,884.84 (-1,184,884.84) |
|---|
| Total Cost: |
|---|
| $2,592,992.99 (2,592,992.99) |
|---|
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
A scanned document page with handwritten notes and a grid layout.
An image of an abstract design featuring geometric shapes in shades of blue on white background.
The image consists of various geometric shapes arranged in an abstract pattern.
There are several squares of different sizes scattered throughout the image.
Some squares are filled in solid blue color while others have dashed lines indicating their boundaries.
Additionally,
there are some triangles interspersed among the squares.
The overall composition creates an intricate yet balanced visual effect.
The use of blue tones gives the image depth,
while the contrasting white background enhances the visibility of the shapes.
This design could be used as an artistic element in various contexts such as graphic design,
logo creation,
or even as part of digital art projects.
It's worth noting that this image does not contain any text or specific symbols other than those inherent to the geometric shapes themselves.
The image is rectangular in shape,
with dimensions approximately 3 inches wide by 3 inches tall.
The edges are straight,
and the corners are sharp,
indicating that it was likely created digitally or printed on paper.
The image has no discernible focal point;
it appears symmetrical both horizontally
and vertically,
making it suitable for use as an abstract background or decorative element.
In summary,
this image is an abstract design featuring geometric shapes in shades of blue on white background.
It is rectangular in shape,
with dimensions approximately 3 inches wide by 3 inches tall.
The edges are straight,
and the corners are sharp,
indicating that it was likely created digitally or printed on paper.
The image has no discernible focal point;
it appears symmetrical both horizontally
and vertically,
making it suitable for use as an abstract background or decorative element.
The image is rectangular in shape,
with dimensions approximately 3 inches wide by 3 inches tall.
The edges are straight,
and the corners are sharp,
indicating that it was likely created digitally or printed on paper.
The image has no discernible focal point;
it appears symmetrical both horizontally
and vertically,
making it suitable for use as an abstract background or decorative element.
The image is rectangular in shape,
with dimensions approximately 3 inches wide by 3 inches tall.
The edges are straight,
and the corners are sharp,
indicating that it was likely created digitally or printed on paper.
The image has no discernible focal point;
it appears symmetrical both horizontally
and vertically,
making it suitable for use as an abstract background or decorative element.
The image is rectangular in shape,
with dimensions approximately 3 inches wide by 3 inches tall.
The edges are straight,
and the corners are sharp,
indicating that it was likely created digitally or printed on paper.
The image has no discernible focal point;
it appears symmetrical both horizontally
and vertically,
making it suitable for use as an abstract background or decorative element.
The image is rectangular in shape,
with dimensions approximately 3 inches wide by 3 inches tall.
The edges are straight,
and the corners are sharp,
indicating that it was likely created digitally or printed on paper.
The image has no discernible focal point;
it appears symmetrical both horizontally
and vertically,
making it suitable for use as an abstract background or decorative element.
The image is rectangular in shape,
with dimensions approximately 3 inches wide by 3 inches tall.
The edges are straight,
and the corners are sharp,
indicating that it was likely created digitally or printed on paper.
The image has no discernible focal point;
it appears symmetrical both horizontally
and vertically,
making it suitable for use as an abstract background or decorative element.
The image is rectangular in shape,
with dimensions approximately 3 inches wide by 3 inches tall.
The edges are straight,
and the corners are sharp,
indicating that it was likely created digitally or printed on paper.
The image has no discernible focal point;
it appears symmetrical both horizontally
and vertically,
making it suitable for use as an abstract background or decorative element.
The image is rectangular in shape,
with dimensions approximately 3 inches wide by 3 inches tall.
The edges are straight,
and the corners are sharp,
indicating that it was likely created digitally or printed on paper.
The image has no discernible focal point;
it appears symmetrical both horizontally
and vertically,
making it suitable for use as an abstract background or decorative element.
The image is rectangular in shape,
with dimensions approximately 3 inches wide by 3 inches tall.
The edges are straight,
and the corners are sharp,
indicating that it was likely created digitally or printed on paper.
The image has no discernible focal point;
it appears symmetrical both horizontally
and vertically,
making it suitable for use as an abstract background or decorative element.
The image is rectangular in shape,
with dimensions approximately 3 inches wide by 3 inches tall.
The edges are straight,
and the corners are sharp,
indicating that it was likely created digitally or printed on paper.
The image has no discernible focal point;
it appears symmetrical both horizontally
and vertically,
making it suitable for use as an abstract background or decorative element.
The image is rectangular in shape,
with dimensions approximately 3 inches wide by 3 inches tall.
The edges are straight,
and the corners are sharp,
indicating that it was likely created digitally or printed on paper.
The image has no discernible focal point;
it appears symmetrical both horizontally
and vertically,
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
| MAGN |
★★★★ |
| ANDROMEDA |
|
| Pegasus |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| CASSIOPEIA |
|
| SCULPTOR |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
| PERSEUS |
|
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart showing constellations and stars.
A star chart with various constellations labeled.
IIC
II.
A.IK
XIVII
Instructions to be taken in right angles to the horizontal line through the center of the chart.
CASSIOPEIA
PERSEUS
ORION
ARIES
Taurus
Gemini
Cancer
Leo
Virgo
Libra
Scorpio
Sagittarius
Capricornus
Aquarius
Pisces
ECLIPTIC
CAPRICORNUS
SAGITTARIUS
CANCER
ARIES
GEMINI
LEO
VIRGO
LIBRA
SCORPIO
ARIES
GEMINI
LEO
VIRGO
LIBRA
SCORPIO
ARIES
GEMINI
LEO
VIRGO
LIBRA
SCORPIO
ARIES
GEMINI
LEO
VIRGO
LIBRA
SCORPIO
| 10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
10 |
| CENTRO |
CENTRO |
CENTRO |
CENTRO |
CENTRO |
CENTRO |
CENTRO |
CENTRO |
CENTRO |
CENTRO |
CENTRO |
CENTRO |
CENTRO |
CENTRO |
CENTRO |
CENTRO |
| TAMASILLO |
TAMASILLO |
TAMASILLO |
TAMASILLO |
TAMASILLO |
TAMASILLO |
TAMASILLO |
TAMASILLO |
TAMASILLO |
TAMASILLO |
TAMASILLO |
TAMASILLO |
TAMASILLO |
TAMASILLO |
TAMASILLO |
TAMASILLO |
| CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) | CANTON DE TAMAULIPAS (TAM) |
ch. v, 83]
THE CONSTELLATIONS
149
order to apply the maps according to these instructions, it is necessary to know the right ascension of the meridian for the day and hour in question, and it can be computed with sufficient approximation by the method of Art. 69.
§ 53. Finding the Pole Star. The first step will be taken in finding the constellations, either from their right ascensions and declinations or from star maps, is to determine the north-and-south line. It is defined closely enough for present purposes by the position of the pole star.
The Big Dipper is the best known and one of the most conspicuous group of stars in the northern heavens. It is always above the horizon at an altitude server in latitude $40^\circ$ north, and, because of its definite shape, it can never be mistaken for any other group of stars. It is made up of 7 stars.
Fig. 56. — The Big Dipper.
of the second magnitude which form the outline of a great dipper in the sky. Figure 56 is a photograph of this group of stars distinctly showing the dipper. The stars Alpha and Beta are called the Pointers because they are almost directly in a line with the pole star, and because they are about two times as far apart as Beta, Fig. 55, go through Alpha, and continue about five times the distance from Beta to Alpha. At the point reached there will be found the second-magnitude star Polaris with no other one so bright anywhere in the neighborhood.
Besides defining the north-and-south line and serving as a guide for a study of the constellations in the northern heavens, there is another interesting object in several other respects. It has a faint companion of the ninth magnitude, distant from it about 15.5 seconds of arc. This
Fig. 56. — The Big Dipper.
150 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. v, 83
faint companion cannot be seen with the unaided eye because, in order that two stars may be seen as separate objects without a telescope, they must be distant from each other at least 3 minutes of arc, and, besides, they must not be too bright or too faint. The brighter of the two components of Polaris is also a double star, a fact which was discovered by means of the spectroscope in 1890. Indeed, it has turned out on more recent study at the Lick Observatory that the principal star of this system is really a triple sun.
84. Units for Estimating Angular Distances. — The distances between stars on the celestial sphere, are always given in degrees. There is, in fact, no definite content to the statement that two stars seem to be a yard apart. In order to estimate angular distances, it is important to have a few units of known length which can always be seen.
It is 90° from the horizon to the zenith, and one would suppose that it would be a simple matter to estimate half of this distance. As a matter of fact, few people place the zenith high enough. In order to test the accuracy with which one locates it, he should face the north and fix his attention on the star which he judges to be at the zenith, and then, keeping it in view, turn slowly around until he faces the south. The first trial is apt to furnish a surprise.
The latitude of any place on earth determines how far the observer, which is the United States, is from 25° to 50°. This unit is not so satisfactory as some others because it depends upon the position of the observer and also because it is more difficult to estimate from the horizon to a star than it is between two stars. Another large unit which can always be observed from northern latitudes is the distance between Alpha Ursae Majoris and Polaris, which is 28°. For smaller angles than 28°, between The Pointers in the Big Dipper and Polaris 5°-20° is convenient.
85. Ursa Major (The Greater Bear). — The Big Dipper, to which reference has already been made, and which is one
CH. V, §51
THE CONSTELLATIONS
151
of the most conspicuous configurations in the northern heavens, is in the eastern part,¹ of the constellation Ursa Major and serves to locate the position of this constellation.
The outline of the Bear extends north, south, and west of the bowl of the Dipper for more than 10°; but all the stars in this part of the sky are at the tremendous magnitude of fainter.
Thus, when the Great Bear and Zeus, the son of Juppiter into a bear in order to protect her from the jealousy of his wife Hera. While the transformed Callisto was wander- ing in the forest, she met her son Areas, who was about to slay her when Zeus intervened and saved her by placing them both among the stars, where they became the Greater and the Smaller Bears. Hera was still unsatisfied and prevailed on Oceanus and Thetis to cause them to pursue forever their course around the earth, so that they might never again waves. Thus was explained the circumpolar motions of those stars which are always above the horizon.
The Pawnee Indians call the stars of the bowl of the Dip- per a stretcher on which a sick man is being carried, and the first one in the handle is the medicine man.
The star at the bend of the handle of the Dipper, called Mizar by the Arabs, is a double one near it, which is known as Alcor. Moreover, between these two stars, and Alcor is of the fifth. Any one with reasonably good eyes can see the two stars as distinct objects, without optical aid. It is probable that this was the first double star that was discovered. The distance of 11.5' between them is so great, astronomically speaking, that it is no longer regarded as a true double star. It has been supposed by some writers that the word Alcor is derived from an Arabic word meaning the test, and the
¹ East and west on the sky must be understood to be measured along a line passing through north and south poles, and not in any other direc- tion with respect to the horizon. Above the pole, cast on the sky toward the eastern part of the horizon, while below the pole it is toward the western part. In this way all directions are indicated on maps drawn on globes; but in practice it is necessary to refer to directions on the sky unless otherwise indicated, and care must be taken not to understand them in any other sense.
152 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cu. v, 85]
Arabs are said to have tested their eyesight on it. The Pawnee Indians call it the Medicine Man's Wife's Dog.
The star Mizar itself is a fine telescopic double, the first one ever discovered; the two components are distant from each other 14'.6,and can be seen separately with a 3-inch telescope. The distance from the earth to Mizar, according to work by Lalande, is 4,800,000 light years, and the time required for light to come from it to us. The star appears to be faint only because of its immense distance, for, as a matter of fact, it indicates 115 times as much light as is given out by the sun. The actual distance even from Mizar to Alcor, which is barely discernible with the unaided eye, is 16,000 times as far as from the earth to the sun.
The discovery of this double star was made in 1783, but the first discovery was made by E. C. Pickering, in 1889, by spectroscopic observations of the brighter component of Mizar. It was found by methods which will be discussed in Arts. 285 and 286 that this star is itself a double in which the components are so close together that they cannot be distinguished separately with the aid of any existing telescope. Such a star is called a spectroscopic binary. The complete discussion showed that this bright star is composed of two great suns whose combined mass is many times that of our sun, and that they revolve about their common center of gravity at a distance of 25,000,000 miles from each other in a period of 20.5 days.
**86. Cassiopeia (The Woman in the Chair).** — To find Cassiopeia go from the middle of the handle of the Big Dipper through its second star and about 30° beyond. The constellation will be recognized because the principal stars of which it is composed, ranging in magnitude from the second to the fourth, form a zigzag, or letter W. When it is tilted in a particular way as it moves around the pole in its diurnal motion, it has some resemblance to the outline of a chair.
The brightest of the 7 stars in the W is the one at the bottom
cl. v, 88j
THE CONSTELLATIONS
153
of its second part, and a 2-inch telescope will show that it is a double star whose colors are described as rose and blue.
One of the most interesting objects in this constellation is the star Eta Cassiopeia, which is near the middle of the third stroke of the W and about 2° from Alpha. It is a fine double which can be separated with a 3-inch telescope. The two stars are not only apparently close together, but actually form a physical system revolving around their common center of gravity in perhaps less than 200 years. If there are planets revolving around these stars, their phenomena of night and day and their seasons must be very complicated.
In 1572 a new star suddenly blazed forth in Cassiopeia and became brighter than any other one in the sky. It caught the attention of Tycho Brahe, who was then young and had much to do with the early investigations into astronomy.
**87. How to Locate the Equinoxes.** It is advantageous to know how to locate the equinoxes when the positions of objects are defined by their right ascensions and declinations. To find the vernal equinox, draw a line from Polaris through the most westerly star in the W of Cassiopeia, and continue it 90°. The point where it crosses the equator is the vernal equinox, which, unfortunately, has no bright stars in its vicinity.
If the vernal equinox is below the horizon, the autumnal equinox may be conveniently used. One or the other of them is, of course, always above the horizon. To find the autumnal equinox, draw a line from Polaris through Delta Ursae Majoris, or the star where the handle of the Big Dipper joins the dipper, and continue it 90° to the equator. The autumnal equinox is Virgo. This constellation contains the firstrate magnitude 6.5 star which is about 10° south and 20° east of the autumnal equinox.
**88. Lyra (The Lyre, or Harp).** - Lyra is a small but very interesting constellation whose right ascension is about 18.7 hours and whose declination is about 40° north. It is,
A diagram showing the location of the vernal and autumnal equinoxes.
154
AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY (ch. v, 88)
therefore, about $50^{\circ}$ from the pole, and its position can easily be determined by using the directions for finding the vernal and autumnal equinoxes. Or, its distance east or west of the meridian can be determined by the methods of Art. 69. With an approximate idea of its location, it can always be found because it contains the brilliant bluish-white, first-magnitude star Vega. If there should be any doubt in regarding Vega as a first magnitude star, this is dis- pelled by the fact that this star, together with two fourth-magnitude stars, Epsilon and Zeta Lyrae, form an equilateral triangle whose sides are about $2^{\circ}$ in length. There are no other stars so near Vega, and there is no other con- figuration of this character in the whole heavens.
As was stated in Art. 47, the attractions of the moon and sun cause a change in the apparent position of the axis of the earth's equator, and therefore a change in the location of the pole of the sky. About 12,000 years from now the north pole will be very close to Vega. What a splendid pole star it will make! It is approaching us at the rate of 5.8 miles per second, but its distance is so enormous that even this high velocity will make no appreciable change in its brightness in the next 12,000 years. The distance of Vega from our line of sight is known but is probably more than 8,000,000 times as far from the earth as it is north from the sun. At its enormous distance the sun would ap- pear without a telescope as a faint star nearly at the limits of visibility. Another point of interest is that the sun with all its planets is moving nearly in the direction of Vega at the rate of about 100,000 miles a year.
The star Zeta Lyrae, which is about $2^{\circ}$ northeast of Vega, is an object which should always be observed. It is a double star in which the apparent distance between the two components is $207^{\prime\prime}$. They are barely distinguishable as separate objects with the unaided eye even by persons of perfect eyesight. It is a noteworthy fact that, so far as is known, this star was not seen to be a double by the Arabs,
A diagram showing a double star with two components separated by an angle of approximately 2 degrees.
ch. v. 88j
THE CONSTELLATIONS
155
the early Greeks, or any primitive peoples. A century ago astronomers gave their ability to separate this pair without the use of the telescope as proof of their having exceptionally keen sight. Perhaps with the more exacting use to which the eyes of the human race are being subjected, they are becoming imperfectly informed on the subject as commonly supposed.
Although the angular distance between the two components of Epsilon Lyrae seems small, astronomers regularly measure one two-thousandth of this angle. The discovery of Neptune on the fact that in 60 years it had passed Uranus from its perigalactic phase, as seen from the earth, is little more than half of the true distance between the components of this double star. When Epsilon Lyrae is viewed through a telescope of 3 or 6 inches aperture, it presents a great surprise. The two components are found to be so far apart in the telescope that they can hardly be seen at the same time, and a little close attention shows that each of them is also a double star. That is, the faint object Epsilon Lyrae is itself a double system of four stars.
About 2°'s south of Vega and 3° east of the third-magnitude star Beta Lyrae. It is a very remarkable variable whose brightness changes by nearly a magnitude in a period of 12 days and 22 hours. The variability of this star is due to the fact that it is a double whose plane of motion passes nearly through the earth so that twice in each complete revolution one star eclipses the other. A detailed study of the light curves of this and other variables shows that the components are stars whose average density is approximately that of the earth's atmosphere at sea level.
About 2°'s southeast of Beta Lyrae is the third-magnitude star Gamma Lyrae. On a line joining these two stars and about one third of the distance from Beta is a ring, or annular nebula, the only one of the few that are known that can be seen with a small telescope. It takes a large telescope, however, to show much of its detail.
156
AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch.v, §9
89. Hercules (The Kneeling Hero).—Hercules is a very large constellation lying west and southwest of Lyra. It contains no stars brighter than the third magnitude, but it can be recognized from a trapezoidal figure of 5 stars which are about 20° west of Vega. The star nearest, which is the brightest, is at the eastern extremity, about 8° long and contains two stars in the northeast corner which are of the third and fourth magnitudes. The star in the southeast corner is of the fourth magnitude, and the others are of the third magnitude. On the west side of the trapezoid, about one third of the distance from the north end, is one of the finest star clusters in the whole heaven, known as Messier's 17. It belongs to the constellation of Hercules in clear dark night, appearing as a little hazy star; but through a good telescope it is seen to be a wonderful object, containing more than 5000 stars (Fig. 171) which are probably comparable to our own sun in dimensions and brilliancy. The cluster was discovered by Halley (1656-1742), but derives its present name from the French comet hunter Messier (1730-1817), who did all of his work with an instrument of only 4 inches aperture.
90. Scorpius (The Scorpion).—There are 12 constellations, one for each month, which lie along the ecliptic and constitute the zodiac. Scorpius is the ninth of these and the most brilliant one of all. In fact, it is one of the finest group of stars that can be seen from our latitude. It is 60° straight south of Hercules and can always be easily recognized by its four first-class stars, Antares, Arcturus, Spica, and Vega. Its light-giving power, is equal to at least 200 suns such as ours. The word Antares means opposed to, or rivaling, Mars, the red planet associated with the god of war. Antares is represented as occupying the position of the heart of a scorpion. About 7° west of Antares is a faint green star of the sixth magnitude which can be seen through a 5° or 6-inch telescope under good atmospheric conditions. About 5° northwest of Antares is a very compact and fine cluster,
CH. V, 93J
THE CONSTELLATIONS
157
Messier 80. Scorpius lies in one of the richest and most varied parts of the Milky Way.
According to the Greek legend, Scorpius is the monster that killed Orion and frightened the horses of the sun so that Phaëton was thrown from his chariot when he attempted to drive them.
91. Corona Borealis (The Northern Crown).—Just west of the great Hercules lies the little constellation Corona Borealis. It is easily recognized by the semicircle, or crown, of stars of the fourth and fifth magnitudes which opens toward the northeast. The Pawnee Indians called it the camp circle, and it is not difficult to imagine that the stars of warriors sitting at a semicircle around a central campfire.
92. Boötes (The Hunter).—Boötes is a large constellation lying west of Corona Borealis, in right ascension about 14 hours, and extending from near the equator to within 35° of the pole. It always can be easily recognized by its bright first-magnitude star Areturus, which is about 20° southwest of Corona Borealis. This star is a double star, and Areturus is one of the finest stars in the northern sky. It is so far away that 100 years are required for its light to come to the earth, and in radiating power it is equivalent to more than 500 suns like our own.
The constellation Boötes is represented as leading his hunting dogs in their pursuit of the bear across the sky.
93. Leo (The Lion).—Leo lies about 60° west of Areturus and is the sixth zodiacal constellation. It is easily recognized by the fact that it contains 7 stars which form the outline of a sickle. In the photograph, Fig. 57, only the 5 brightest stars are shown. The most southerly star of
Fr. 57.—The sickle in Leo, as seen when it is on the meridian.
158
158 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [CH. V, 93
The Great Andromeda Nebula, photographed by Ritchey with the two-foot reflector of the Yerkes Observatory.
Fig. 58. — The Great Andromeda Nebula. Photographed by Ritchey with the two-foot reflector of the Yerkes Observatory.
**cu. v, 95)**
THE CONSTELLATIONS
159
the sickle is Regulus, at the end of the handle. The blade of the sickle opens out toward the southwest. One of the most interesting things in connection with this constellation is that the meteors of the shower which occurs about November 14 seem to radiate from a point within the blade of the sickle (Art. 204).
The star Regulus is at the heart of the Nemean lion which, according to classic legend, was killed by Hercules as the first of his twelve labours. 94 Andromeda (The Woman Chained). — Andromeda is a large constellation just south of Cassiopeia. It contains no first-magnitude stars, but it can be recognized from a line of 3 second-magnitude stars extending northeast and southwest. The most interesting object in this constellation is the Great Andromeda Nebula Fig. 38, the brightest nebula in the sky. It is about 15° north of south of Alpha Cassiopeiae and it is visible only on a very dark moonless night as a hazy patch of light. When viewed through a telescope it falls a part of the sky nearly 2° long and 1° wide. In its center is a star which is probably variable. The analysis of its light with the spectroscope seems to indicate that it is composed of solid or liquid material surrounded by cooler gases. It has been suggested that, in addition to its own light, it may contain a mass of gas comparable to the Galaxy, but so distant from us that it apparently covers an insignificant part of the sky.
95 Perseus (The Champion). — Perseus is a large constellation in the Milky Way directly east of Andromeda. Its brightest star, Alpha, is in the midst of a star field which presents the finest spectacle through field glasses or a small telescope in the whole sky. The second brightest star in this constellation is Beta, Alcor (the Demon). Alcor is about 9° south and a little west of Alpha Persei, and varies in magnitude from 2.2 to 3.4 in a period of 2.867 days. That is, at its minimum it loses more than two thirds of its light. There is also a remarkable
160 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. v, 95]
double cluster in this constellation about 10° east of Alpha Cassiopeiae.
Algol, together with the little stars near it, is the Medusa's head which Perseus is supposed to carry in his hand and which he used in the rescue of Andromeda. He is said to have strangled her in the heavens in his haste, and it now appears as the Milky Way.
96. Auriga (The Charioteer).— The next constellation east of Perseus is Auriga, which contains the great first-magnitude star Capella. Capella is about 40° from the Big Dipper and nearly in a line from Delta through Alpha Ursae Majoris. It is also distinguished by the fact that near it are three stars known as The Kids, the name Capella meaning "She-gift." It is reckoning from us at the rate of 20 miles per second, or about 7800 times that of the earth from the sun. It was found at the Lick Observatory, in 1889, to be a spectroscopic binary with a period of 104.2 days. The computations of Maunder show that it radiates about 200 times as much light as is given out by the sun.
97. Taurus (The Bull).— Taurus is southwest of Auriga and contains two conspicuous groups of stars, the Pleiades and the Hyades besides the brilliant red star Aldebaran.
Among the many mythical stories regarding this constellation there is one which describes the bull as charging down on Orion. According to a Greek legend, Zeus took the form of a bull when he captured Europa, the daughter of Agenor.
While playing in the meadows with her friends, she leaped upon the back of a beautiful white bull, which was Zeus himself disguised into different forms and rushed away to Crete. Only its head and shoulders are visible in the sky because, when he swims, the rest of his body is covered with water.
The Pleiades group, Fig. 59, consists of 7 stars in the form of a little dipper about 30° southeast of Capella and nearly 20° south of, and a little east of, Algol. Six of them,
A diagram showing the positions of stars in Taurus.
CH. V. 97]
THE CONSTELLATIONS
161
which are of the fourth magnitude, are easily visible without optical aid ; but the seventh, which is near the one at the end of the handle in the dipper, is more difficult. There seems to have been considerable difficulty in seeing the faintest one in ancient times, for it was frequently spoken of as
Fig. 59. — The Pleiades. Photographed by Wallace at the Yerkes Observatory.
having been lost. There is no difficulty now, however, for people with good eyes to see it, while those with exceptionally keen sight can see 10 or 11 stars.
No group of stars in all the sky seems to have attracted greater popular attention than the Pleiades, nor to have been mentioned more frequently, not only in the classic writings of the ancients, but also in the stories of primitive peoples. The Seven Sisters are known to the Semites and Greeks. The Many Little Ones of the ancient Babylonians, The Hen and Chickens of the peoples of many parts of Europe, The Little Eyes of the savage tribes of the South Pacific Islands, and The Seven Brothers of some of the tribes of North American Indians. They cross the meridian at midnight in November, and many primitive peoples began their year
W
162 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. v. 97
at that time. It is said that on the exact date, November 17, no petition was ever presented in vain to the kings of ancient Persia. These stars had an important relation to the religious ceremonies of the Aztecs, and certain of the Australian tribes held dances in their honor.
Because we can see all the stars of the Pleiades as observed without a telescope, there are at least 100 others in the group which can be seen with a small instrument. While their distance from the earth is not known, it can scarcely be less than 10,000,000 times that of the sun. It follows that these stars are apparently small only because they are so remote. A star among them equal to the sun in brilliancy would appear to us as having only about one-hundredth magnitude. The larger stars of the group are at least from 100 to 200 times as great in light-giving power as the sun.
About $8^{\circ}$ southeast of the Pleiades is the Hyades group, a cluster of small stars scarcely less celebrated in mythology. They have been found recently to constitute a cluster of stars, occupying an enormous space, all of which move in the same direction with almost exactly equal speeds (Art. 27). The members of this group are beyond our present imagination. Individually they range in luminosity from 5 to 100 times that of the sun, and the diameter of the space which they occupy is more than 2,000,000 times the distance from the earth to the sun.
98. Orion (The Warrior).—Southeast of Taurus and directly south of Auriga is the constellation Orion, lying across the sky between the fifth and sixth hours of right ascension. This is the finest region of the whole sky for observation without a telescope.
The legends regarding Orion are many and in their details conflicting. But in all of them he was a giant and a mighty hunter who, in the sky, stands facing the bull (Taurus) with a child in his right hand and a lion's skin in his left.
About $7^{\circ}$ north of the equator and $15^{\circ}$ southeast of Aldebaran is the ruddy Betelgeuze. About $20^{\circ}$ southwest of
CH. V, 98] THE CONSTELLATIONS 163
Betelgeuze is the first-magnitude star Rigel, a magnificent object which is at least 2000 times as luminous as the sun. About midway between Betelgeuze and Rigel and almost on the equator is a row of second-magnitude stars running northwest and southeast, which constitute the Belt of Orion, and whose distance from the sun is about 500 times that of the latter stars reaches off to the southwest, nearly in the direction of
Fig. 60.—Orion. Photographed at the Yerkes Observatory (Hughes).
Rigel. These stars constitute the Sword of Orion. The central one of them appears a little fuzzy without a telescope, and with a telescope is found to be a magnificent nebula, Fig. 61. In fact, the Great Orion Nebula impresses many observers as being the most magnificent object in the whole heavens. It covers more than a square degree in the sky, and the spectroscope shows it to be a mass of glowing gas whose distance is probably several million times as great as that to the sun, and whose diameter is probably as great as
164
AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [CH. V, 98]
the distance from the earth to the nearest star. The stars in this region of the sky are generally supposed by astronomers to be in an early stage of their development ; most of them
The Great Orion Nebula, photographed by Ritchey with the two-foot reflector of the Yerkes Observatory.
Fig. 61. — The Great Orion Nebula. Photographed by Ritchey with the two-foot reflector of the Yerkes Observatory.
are of great luminosity, and a considerable fraction of them are variable or double.
CH. V, 100J THE CONSTELLATIONS 165
99. Canis Major (The Greater Dog). — The constellation Canis Major is southeast of Orion and is marked by Sirius, the brightest star in the whole sky. Sirius is almost in a line with the Belt of Orion and a little more than 20° from it. It is bluish white in color and is supposed to be in an early stage of its evolution, though it has advanced somewhat from the condition of the Orion stars. Sirius is comparatively near to us, being the third star in distance from the sun. Nevertheless, 8.4 years are required for its light to come to us, and this means that 37,000,000 miles must be passed in approaching it at the rate of 5.6 miles per second; or, rather, it is overtaking the sun, for the solar system is moving in nearly the opposite direction.
The history of Sirius during the last two centuries is very interesting, and furnishes a good illustration of the value of the deduced period method making discoveries. First, Halley found, in 1718, that Sirius moved with respect to fixed reference points and lines; then a little more than a century later, Bessel found that this motion is slightly variable. He inferred from this, on the basis of the laws of motion, that Sirius and an unseen companion were traveling around their common center of gravity which was moving with uniform speed in a straight line. This companion actually was discovered by Alvan G. Clark, in 1882, while observing through his 24-inch refractor at Yerkes Obser- vatory, at Evanston, Ill. The distance of the two stars from each other is 1,800,000,000 miles, and they complete a revolution in 48.8 years. The combined mass of the two stars is about 3.4 times that of the sun. The larger star is only about twice as massive as its companion but is 20,000 times brighter; together they radiate 48 times as much light as is emitted by the sun.
100. Canis Minor (The Lesser Dog). — Canis Minor is directly east of Orion and is of particular interest in the present connection because of its first-magnitude star Procyon, which is about 25° east and just a little south of Betel-
166 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. v, 100
genue. The history of this star is much the same as that of Sirius, the fainter companion having been discovered in 1806 by Schaeberle at the Lick Observatory. The period of revolution of Procyon and its companion is 39 years, its distance is a little greater than that of Sirius, its combined mass is about 1.3 that of the sun, and its luminosity is about 10 times that of the sun. The orbits of the systems Sirius and Procyon and their fainter companions are alike to the sun's because the brighter components would be regularly eclipsed and they would be variable stars of the Algol type (Art. 288), though with such long periods and short times of eclipse that their variability would probably not be discovered.
101. Gemini (The Twins) — Gemini is the fourth zodiacal constellation and lies directly north of Canis Minor. It has been known since the Talmud that the two stars are twins because its two principal stars, Castor and Pollux, are almost alike and only 4.5° apart. These stars are about 25° north of Procyon, and Castor is the more northernly of the two. Castor is a double star which can be separated by a small telescope. In 1900 Bélopolsky, of Pulkowa, found that its fainter companion is a spectroscopic binary with a period of 2.9 days. In 1906 Curtis, at the Lick Observatory, found a bright companion to Castor which is a spectroscopic binary with a period of 9.2 days. Thus this star instead of being a single object as it appears to be without telescope and spectroscopic aid, is a system of four suns. The two pairs revolve about the common center of gravity of the four stars in a long period which probably lies between 250 and 2000 years.
Castor is called Alpha Geminorum, because probably in ancient times it was a little brighter than, or at least as bright as, Pollux. Now Pollux is a little brighter than Castor.
About 10° southeast of Pollux is the large open Praesepe (The Beehive) star cluster which can be seen on a clear, moonless night without a telescope.
CIV. V, 102J THE CONSTELLATIONS 167
**102. On Becoming Familiar with the Stars.** — The discussion of the constellations will be closed here, not because all have been described, or, indeed, any one of them adequately, but because enough has been said to show that the sky is full of objects of interest which can be found and enjoyed with very little optical aid. The reader is expected to observe all the objects which have been described, so far as he can do so without exceeding his command. If he does this, the whole subject will have a deeper and more lively interest, and it will be a pleasure to make constant appeals to the sky to verify statements and descriptions.
The general features of the constellations are very simple, but the whole subject cannot be mastered in an evening. One should go over it several times with no greater optical aid than that furnished by a field glass.
**VIII. QUESTIONS**
1. Show why about 22,000 plates will be required to photograph the whole sky as described in Art. 70.
2. Find the brightness of the stars in Table I compared to that of Sirius (Table II).
3. Find the amount of light received from the sun compared to that received from a first-magnitude star.
4. Find how much light would come from a first-magnitude star as unity, and compute the amount of light received from each of the first six magnitudes (Table II).
5. If the ratio of the number of stars from one magnitude to the next is as given in art. 81, what is in Table II, how many stars would there be in the first 20 magnitudes?
6. At what time of the year is the most northern part of the Milky Way on the meridian at 8 p.m.? What are its altitude and azimuth?
7. What constellations are within two hours of the meridian at 8 p.m.-to-night? Identify them.
8. If Leo is visible at a convenient hour, test your eyes on Epsilon Lyrae.
9. If Leo is visible at a convenient hour, test your eyes by finding which star in the skelie has a very faint star near it.
| 1. |
Show why about 22,000 plates will be required to photograph the whole sky as described in Art. 70. |
| 2. |
Find the brightness of the stars in Table I compared to that of Sirius (Table II). |
| 3. |
Find the amount of light received from the sun compared to that received from a first-magnitude star. |
| 4. |
Find how much light would come from a first-magnitude star as unity, and compute the amount of light received from each of the first six magnitudes (Table II). |
| 5. |
If the ratio of the number of stars from one magnitude to the next is as given in art. 81, what is in Table II, how many stars would there be in the first 20 magnitudes? |
| 6. |
At what time of the year is the most northern part of the Milky Way on the meridian at 8 p.m.? What are its altitude and azimuth? |
| 7. |
What constellations are within two hours of the meridian at 8 p.m.-to-night? Identify them. |
| 8. |
If Leo is visible at a convenient hour, test your eyes on Epsilon Lyrae. |
| 9. |
If Leo is visible at a convenient hour, test your eyes by finding which star in the skelie has a very faint star near it. |
168 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. v. 102
10. If Andromeda is visible at a convenient hour, find the great nebula.
11. How many stars can you see in the bowl of the Big Dipper?
12. If Perseus is visible at a convenient hour, identify Algol and verify its variability.
13. If the Pleiades are visible, how many stars can you see?
14. If Orion is visible at a convenient hour, identify the Belt and Sword and notice that the great nebula looks like a fuzzy star.
CHAPTER VI
TIME
103. Definitions of equal Intervals of Time. — It is impossible to give a definition of time in terms which are simpler and better understood than the word itself ; but it is profitable to consider what it is that determines the length of an interval of time. The subject may be considered from the standpoint of the intellectual experience of the individual, which varies greatly from time to time and which differs from one person to another, and also treated with reference to independent physical phenomena.
Consider first the definition of the length of an interval of time or, rather, the equality of two intervals of time, from the psychological point of view. If a person has had a number of intellectual experiences, he is not only conscious that they were distinct, but he has them arranged in his memory as being separate and distinct. He remembers each experience and notes their distinctness, number, and order, and he feels that they have occurred in time; that is, he has the perception of time. An interval in which a person has had many and acute intellectual experiences seems long; and two intervals of time are of equal length, psychologically, when the individual has had in them an equal number of equally intense intellectual experiences. For example, in youth when life is full of new experiences, a month seems long and the years seem to pass slowly; on the other hand, with increasing age when life reduces largely to routine, the years slip away quickly. Or, to take an illustration within the range of the experience of many who are still young, a month of travel, or the first month in college, seems longer than a whole year in the accustomed routine of preparatory school life.
169
170 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. vi, 103]
It follows from these considerations that the true measure of the length of the life of an individual from the psychological point of view, which is the one in which he has greatest interest as a thinking being, is the number, variety, and intensity of his intellectual experiences. A man whose life has been full, who has become acquainted with the world's history, who is familiar with the wonders of the universe, who has read and experienced again the finest thoughts of the best minds of all ages, who has seen many places and come into contact with many people, will have originated ideas and initiated intellectual movements of his own. He has had a long life, however few may have been the number of revolutions of the earth around the sun since he was born.
But since men must deal with one another, it is important to have some definition of the equality of intervals of time that will be independent of their varying intellectual life. This definition, or its consequences, must be capable of being applied at any time and place, and yet it need not agree too radically with the psychological definition. Such a definition is given by the first law of motion (Art. 40), or rather a part of it, which for present purposes will be reworded as follows:
**Two intervals of time are equal, by definition,** if a moving body which is subject to no forces passes over equal distances in those two intervals; and experience shows that it makes no difference what amount of force is used or at what rate it moves, for they all give the same result.
**104. The Practical Measure of Time.** — A difficulty with the first law of motion and the resulting definition of equal intervals of time arises from the fact that it is impossible to find a body which is absolutely uninfluenced by exterior forces. Therefore, instead of using the law itself, we can deduce from it certain conclusions. From this law, together with the other laws of motion, that a solid, rotating sphere which is subject to no exterior forces turns at a uniform rate. There is no rotating body which
A diagram showing a rotating sphere.
CH. VI. 105j
TIME
171
is not subject to at least the attraction of other bodies; but the simple attraction of an exterior body has no influence on the rate of rotation of a sphere which is perfectly solid. Therefore the earth rotates at a uniform rate, according to the definition of uniformity implied in the first law of motion, except for the slight and altogether negligible modifying influences which were enumerated in Art. 45, and hence can be neglected for all practical purposes.
If the rotation of the earth is to be used in the measurement of time, it is only necessary to determine in some way the angle through which it turns in any interval under consideration. This can be done by observations of the position of the meridian with reference to the stars. Since the stars are extremely far away and do not move appreciably with respect to one another during a short interval of a day, the rotation of the earth can be measured by reference to any of them. Let it be remembered that, though the rate of the rotation of the earth is subject to some possible slight modifications, its uniformity is far beyond that of any clock ever made.
105. Sidereal Time. — Sidereal time is the time defined by the rotation of the earth with respect to the stars. A sidereal day is the interval between the passage of the earth across a given star and its next succeeding passage across the same star. Since the earth rotates at a uniform rate, all sidereal days are of the same length. The sidereal day is divided into 24 sidereal hours, which are numbered from 1 to 24, the hours are divided into 60 minutes, and the minutes into 60 seconds. The sidereal time of a given place on the earth is zero when its meridian crosses a given star.
Since the definition of sidereal time depends upon the meridian of the observer, it follows that all places on the earth having the same longitude have the same sidereal time, and that those having different longitudes have differ- ent sidereal time. It follows from the uniformity of the
172 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. vi, 105]
earth's rotation that equal intervals of sidereal time are equal according to the first law of motion.
106. Solar Time. — Solar time is defined by the rotation of the earth with respect to the sun. A solar day is the interval of time between the passage of a meridian across the center of the sun and its next succeeding passage across the center of the sun. Since the sun's apparent movement eastward among the stars is solar day, the solar day is less than the sidereal day. The sun makes an apparent revolution of the heavens in 365 days, and therefore, since the circuit of the heavens is $360^\circ$, it moves eastward on the average a little less than 1° a day. The earth turns 15° in 1 hour, and 1° in 4 minutes, from which it follows that the solar day is nearly 4 minutes longer on the average than the sidereal day.
107. Variations in the Length of Days. — In apparent motion of the sun eastward among the stars were uniform, each solar day would be longer than the sidereal day by the same amount; and since all sidereal days are all of equal length, the solar days also would all be of equal length. But the eastward apparent motion of the sun is somewhat variable because of two principal reasons, which will now be explained.
The earth moves in its elliptical orbit around the sun in such a way that the law of areas is fulfilled. The angular distance the sun appears to move eastward among the
Fig. 62.—Solar days are longer than sidereal days.
uniform, each solar day would be longer than the sidereal day by the same amount; and since all sidereal days are all of equal length, the solar days also would all be of equal length. But the eastward apparent motion of the sun is somewhat variable because of two principal reasons, which will now be explained.
The earth moves in its elliptical orbit around the sun in such a way that the law of areas is fulfilled. The angular distance the sun appears to move eastward among
CH. VI, 107]
TIME
173
stars equals the angular distance the earth moves forward in its orbit. This is made evident from Fig. 62, in which $E_1$ represents the position of the earth when it is noon at $A$. At the next noon at $A$, solar time, the earth has moved forward in its orbit through the angle $E_2SE_1$ (of course the distance $S$ is at $E_1$ the direction of a star is $E_S$). When the earth is at $E_2$, the same direction is $ES'$. The sun has apparently moved through the angle $S'ES'$, which equals $E_2SE_1$.
Since the earth moves in its orbit in accordance with the law of areas, its angular motion is fastest when it is nearest to the sun. Consequently, when the earth is at its perihelion, the sun's apparent motion eastward is fastest, and the solar days, so far as this factor alone is concerned, are then the longest. The earth is at its perihelion point about the first of January and at its aphelion point about the first of July. Consequently, the time from noon to noon, so far as it depends upon the eccentricity of the earth's orbit, is longest about the first of January and shortest about the first of July. The length of the solar days, so far as they depend upon the eccentricity of the earth's orbit, are shown by the broken line in Fig. 63.
The second important reason why the solar days vary in length is that the sun moves eastward along the ecliptic and not along the equator. For simplicity, neglect the eccentricity of the earth's orbit and the lack of uniformity of the angular motion of the sun along the ecliptic. Consider
Fig. 63.—Length of solar days. Broken line gives effects of eccentricity; dotted line, inclination; full line, the combined effects.
The sun's apparent motion eastward is fastest, and the solar days, so far as this factor alone is concerned, are then the longest. The earth is at its perihelion point about the first of January and at its aphelion point about the first of July. Consequently, the time from noon to noon, so far as it depends upon the eccentricity of the earth's orbit, is longest about the first of January and shortest about the first of July. The length of the solar days, so far as they depend upon the eccentricity of the earth's orbit, are shown by the broken line in Fig. 63.
The second important reason why the solar days vary in length is that the sun moves eastward along the ecliptic and not along the equator. For simplicity, neglect the eccentricity of the earth's orbit and the lack of uniformity of the angular motion of the sun along the ecliptic. Consider
174 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. vi, 107
the time when the sun is near the vernal equinox. Since the ecliptic intercepts the equator at an angle of 23°5, only one component of the sun's motion is directly eastward. However, the reduction is somewhat less than might be imagined for so large an inclination and amounts to only about 1°. At the autumnal equinox the situation is the same except that, at this time, one component of the sun's motion is toward the south.
At these two times in the year the sun's apparent motion eastward is less than it would otherwise be, and, consequently, the solar days are shorter than the average. At the solstices, midway between these two periods, the sun is moving approximately along the arc of small circles 23°5 from the equator, and its angular motion eastward is considerably greater than it would otherwise be. Thus, so far as the inclination of the ecliptic is concerned, the solar days are longest about December 21 and June 21, and shortest about March 21 and September 23. The lengths of the solar days, so far as they depend upon the inclination of the ecliptic, are shown by the dotted curve in Fig. 63.
Now consider the combined effects of the eccentricity of the earth's orbit and the inclination of its axis on the lengths of the solar days. Of these two influences, the inclination of the ecliptic is considerably the more important. On the first of January they both make the solar day longer than the average. At the vernal equinox the eccentricity has only a slight effect on the length of the solar day, while the obliquity of the ecliptic makes it shorter than the average. Hence, in view of the effect of eccentricity is to make the solar day shorter than the average, and that of obliquity is to make it longer than the average. At the autumnal equinox the eccentricity has only a slight importance and the obliquity of the ecliptic makes the solar day shorter than the average.
The two influences together give the following result: The longest day in the year, from noon to noon by the sun,
A diagram showing variations in solar day lengths throughout a year.
cm. vi, 108]
TIME
175
is about December 22, after which the solar day decreases continually in length until about the 26th of March; it then increases in length until about June 21; then it decreases in length until the shortest day in the year is reached on September 17; and then it increases in length continually until December 22. On December 22 the solar day is about 4 minutes and 3 seconds mean of solar time [Art. 108] longer than the sidereal day, and at midwinter no 38 seconds longer; on June 21 it is 4 minutes 9 seconds longer; and on September 17 it is 3 minutes and 35 seconds longer. The combined results are shown by the full line in Fig. 63. The difference in length between the longest and the shortest day in the year is, therefore, about 51 seconds of mean solar time. While this difference for most purposes may be neglected, yet its presence gives rise to what is known as the equation of time (Art. 100).
It might seem that it would be sensible for astronomers to neglect the differences in the lengths of the solar days, especially as the change in length from one day to the next is very small. Only an accurate clock would show the disparity in their lengths, and their slight differences would be of no importance in ordinary affairs. But if astronomers use a clock based upon the earth's with respect to the sun as defining equal intervals of time, they would employ a varying standard and they would find apparent irregularities in the revolution of the earth and in all other celestial motions which they could not bring under any fixed laws. This illustrates the extreme sensitiveness of astronomical theories to even slight errors.
108. Mean Solar Time.--Since the ordinary activities of mankind depend largely upon the period of daylight, it is desirable for practical purposes to have a unit of time based in some way upon the rotation of the earth with respect to the sun. On the other hand, it is undesirable to have a unit of variable length. Consequently, the mean solar day, which has the average length of all the solar days
176 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cu. vi. 108
of the year, is introduced. In sidereal time its length is 24 hours, 5 minutes, and 56.552 seconds.
The mean solar day is divided into 1 mean solar hours, the hours being made up of solar minutes, and the minutes into 60 mean solar seconds. These are the hours, minutes, and seconds in common usage, and ordinary timepieces are made to keep mean solar time as accurately as possible. It would be very difficult, if not impossible, to construct a clock that would keep true solar time with any high degree of precision.
109. The Equation of Time. — The difference between the true solar time and the mean solar time of a place is called the equation of time. It is taken with such an algebraic sign that, when it is added to the mean solar time, the true solar time is obtained.*
The date on which noon by mean solar time and true solar time shall coincide is arbitrary, but it is so chosen that the
Graph showing the equation of time over a period of about 3 months.
Fig. 64. — The equation of time.
differences between the times in the two systems shall be as small as possible. On the 24th of December the equation of time is zero. — It then becomes negative and increases numerically until February 11, when it amounts to about 14 minutes and 25 seconds; it then increases and passes through zero about April 15, after which it becomes positive and reaches a value of 3 minutes 48 seconds on May 14; it then decreases and passes through zero on June 14 and becomes —6 minutes and 20 seconds on July 26; it then
*This is the present practice of the American Ephemeris and Nautical Almanac ; it was formerly the opposite.
CH. VI, 110J
TIME
177
increases and passes through zero on September 1 and becomes 16 minutes and 21 seconds on November 2, after which it continually decreases until December 24. The results are given graphically in Fig. 64. The dates may vary a day or two from those given because of the leap year, and the amounts by a few seconds because of the shifting of the dates.
Some interesting results follow from the equation of time. For example, on December 24 the equation of time is zero, but the solar day is about 30 seconds longer than the mean solar day. Consequently, the next day the sun will be about 30 seconds slow; that is, noon by the mean solar clock has shifted about 30 seconds with respect to the sun. As the sun has just passed the winter solstice, the period from sunrise to sunset for the northern hemisphere of the earth is slowly increasing, so the exact amount depends upon the latitude. For latitudes less than 40° this increase in forenoon resulting from the earlier rising of the sun is less than the loss from the shifting of the time of the noon. Consequently, almanacs will show that the forenoons are getting shorter at this time of the year, although the whole period between sunrise and sunset is increasing. The difference in the lengths of the forenoons and afternoons may accumulate until it amounts to nearly half an hour.
The difference in local time at any place other than a meridian is called its local time. All places having the same longitude have the same local time, but places having different longitudes have different local times. The circumference of the earth is nearly 25,000 miles and 15° correspond to a difference of one hour in local time. Consequently, at the earth's equator, 17 miles in longitude give a difference of about one minute in local time. In latitudes 40° to 45° north or south 13 to 12 miles in longitude give a difference of one minute in local time.
If every place along a railroad extending east and west should keep its own local time, there would be endless con-
178 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. vi. 110
fusion and great danger in running trains. In order to avoid these difficulties, it has been agreed that all places whose local times do not differ more than half an hour from that of some convenient meridian shall use the local time of that meridian. Thus, while the extreme difference in local time of places using the local time of the same meridian may be about an hour, neither of them differs more than about half an hour from its standard time. In this manner a strip of country about 750 miles wide in latitudes 35° to 45° uses the same time, and at each place the difference with an hour different, is zero. The local time of the standard meridian of each strip is the standard time of that strip.
At present standard time is in use in nearly every civilized part of the earth. The United States and British America are of such great extent in longitude that it is necessary to use four hours of standard time. The eastern portion uses what is called Eastern Time. It is the local time of the meridian which passes through New York City, through Philadelphia, and in this city local time and standard time are identical. At places east of this meridian it is later by local time than by standard time, the difference being one minute for 12 or 13 miles. At places west of this meridian, but in the Eastern Time division, it is earlier by local time than by standard time. The next division to the westward is called Central Time. It is the local time of the meridian 6 hours west of Greenwich, which passes through St. Louis. The next time division is called Mountain Time. It is the local time of the meridian 7 hours west of Greenwich. This meridian passes through Denver. The last time division is called Pacific Time. It is the local time of the meridian 8 hours west of Greenwich. This meridian passes about 100 miles east of San Francisco.
At first when distances were used, the boundaries between one time division and the next would be 7°5' east and west of the standard meridian. As a matter of fact, the boundaries are quite irregular, depending upon the convenience of
ce. vi. 111j
TIME
179
railroads, and they are frequently somewhat altered. The change in time is nearly always made at the end of a railway division; for, obviously, it would be unwise to have rail-road time change during the run of a given train crew. As a result the actual boundaries of the several time divisions are quite irregular and vary in many cases radically from the
Map of the United States showing standard time divisions.
Fig. 65. — Standard time divisions in the United States.
ideal standard divisions. Moreover, many towns near the borders of the time zones do not use standard time.
111. The Distribution of Time. — The accurate determination of time and its distribution are of much importance. There are several methods by which time may be determined, but the one in common use is to observe the transits of stars across the meridian and thus to obtain the mean solar time. By observing the motion of the earth's motion it is then possible to compute the mean solar time. It might be supposed that it would be easier to find mean solar time by observing the transit of the sun across the meridian, but this is not true. In the first place, it is much
180 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY for vi, 111
more difficult to determine the exact time of the transit of the sun's center than it is to determine the time of the transit of a star; and, in the second place, the sun crosses the meridian but once in 24 hours, while many stars may be observed. In the third place, observations of the sun give true solar time instead of mean solar time, and the computation of sidereal time is very laborious and difficult as it is to change from sidereal time to mean solar time.
It remains to explain how time is distributed from the places where the observations are made. In most countries the time service is under the control of the government, and the time signals are sent out from the national observatory. For example, in the United States, the chief source of time for railroad companies is from the Coast and Geodetic Survey Observatory at George Washington Heights, Washington D.C. There are three high-grade clocks keeping standard time at this observatory. Their errors are found from observations of the stars; and after applying corrections for these errors, the mean of the three clocks is taken as giving the true standard time for the successive 24 hours. At 5 minutes before noon, Eastern Time, the Western Union Telegraph Company sends out a signal which comes over ordinary business lines and throw their lines into electrical connection with the standard clock at the Naval Observatory. The connection is arranged so that the sounding key makes a stroke every second during the 5 minutes preceding noon except the twenty-ninth second of each minute, the last 5 seconds of the fourth minute, and the last 10 seconds of the fifth minute. This gives many opportunities of determining the error of these clocks. The telegraph circuits are connected so as to be automatically regulated by these signals, and there are at present more than 30,000 of them in use in this country. The time signals are sent out from the Naval Observatory with an error usually less than 0.2 of a second; but frequently this is considerably increased when a system of relays must be used to reach great distances.
CH. VI. 113]
TIME
1SI
These noon signals also operate time balls in 18 ports in the United States. This device for furnishing time, chiefly to boat captains, consists of a large ball which is dropped at noon Eastern Time, from a considerable height at con-
tinuous intervals, by means of electrical connection with the Naval Observatory.
Time for the extreme western part of the United States is distributed from the Mare Island Navy Yard in California ; and besides, a number of college observatories have been furnishing time to particular railroad systems. Naturally most observatories regularly determine time for their own use, but the necessity for the distribution of time from Washington the need for this work is disappearing except in certain special problems of star positions.
112. Civil and Astronomical Days. — The civil day begins at midnight, for then business is ordinarily suspended and the date can be changed with least inconvenience. The astronomical day of the same date begins at noon, 12 hours later; because of the change made at midnight, errors are frequently found necessary to correct observations in the midst of a set of observations. It is true that many observa-
tions of the sun and some other bodies are made in the daytime, but of course most observational work is done at night. The hours of the astronomical day are numbered up to 24, just as in the case of sidereal time.
113. Place of Change of Dates. — If one should start at any point on the earth and entirely around it westward, the number of times the sun would cross his meridian would be one less than it would have been if he had stayed at home.
Since it would be very inconvenient for him to use fractional dates, he would count his day from midnight to midnight, whatever his longitude, and correct the increasing difference from the time of his starting point by arbitrarily changing his date once every 24 hours. In practice this is done. That is, he would omit one date and day of the week from his reckoning. On the other hand, if he were going around the
182 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [icv.vi. 113
earth eastward, he would give two days the same date and day of the week. The change is usually made at the 180th meridian from Greenwich. This is a particularly fortunate selection, for the 180th meridian seems to pass through a great land surface at all, and then only small islands. One can easily see how troublesomeome matters would be if the change were made at a meridian passing through a thickly populated region, say the meridian of Greenwich. On one side
A map showing the Earth's rotation and the change of date line.
Fig. 66. The change-of-date line.
of it people would have a certain day and date, for example, Monday, December 24, and on the other side of it a day later, Tuesday, December 25.
The place of actual change of date does not strictly follow the 180th meridian from Greenwich, for travelers going eastward from Europe, lose half a day, while those going westward from Europe and America arrive in the same
CH. VI, 116]
TIME
183
longitude with a gain of half a day; hence their dates differ by one day. The change-of-date line is shown in Fig. 66.
**114. The Sidereal Year.** — The sidereal year is the time required for the sun apparently to move from any position with respect to the stars, as seen from the earth, around to its original position again. This period is called the sidereal year, and it is the time required for the earth to make a complete revolution around the sun, directions from the sun being determined by the positions of the stars. Its length in mean solar time is 365 days, 6 hours, 9 minutes, 9.54 seconds, or just a little more than 365.25 days.
**115. The Anomalous Year.** — The anomalous year is the time required for the sun to move from the perihelion of its orbit around to the perihelion again. If the perihelion point were fixed, this period would equal the sidereal year. But the attraction of the other planets causes the perihelion point to move forward at such a rate that it completes a revolution in about 108,000 years; and the consequence is that the anomalous year is a little longer than the sidereal year. It follows from the period of revolution that the perihelion moves through 27° 29' every 12' anomaly. Since the earth moves, on the average, about a degree daily, it takes it about 4 minutes and 40 seconds of time to move 12'. The actual length of the anomalous year in mean solar time is 365 days, 6 hours, 13 minutes, 53.01 seconds.
**116. The Tropical Year.** — The tropical year is the time required for the sun to move from a tropic around to the equinoxes once in a year. This determination, from an equinox to the same equinox again. Since the equinoxes regress about $50\frac{1}{2}$ annually, the tropical year is about 20 minutes shorter than the sidereal year. Its actual length in mean solar time is 365 days, 5 hours, 48 minutes, 45.02 seconds.
The seasons depend upon the sun's place with respect to the equinoxes. Consequently, if the seasons are always to occur at the same time according to the calendar, the
184 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. vi. 116
tropical year must be used. This is, indeed, the year in common use and, unless otherwise specified, the term poor man's tropical year.
115 The Calendar. — In very ancient times the calendar was based largely on the motions of the moon, whose phases determined the times of religious ceremonies. The moon does not make an integral number of revolutions in a year, and hence it was occasionally necessary to interpolate a month in order to keep the year in harmony with the seasons.
The week was another division of time used in antiquity. The number of days in this period varied according to the custom upon which the various celestial bodies which were then known. Thus, Sunday was the sun's day; Monday, the moon's day; Tuesday, Mars' day; Wednesday, Mercury's day; Thursday, Jupiter's day; Friday, Venus's day; and Saturday, Saturn's day. The names of the days of the week, when traced back to the tongues from which English has been derived, show that these were their original names.
In 70 B.C., Julius Caesar, Roman emperor, who had fallen into a state of great confusion, was reformed by Julius Caesar under the advice of an Alexandrian astronomer, Sosigenes. The new system, called the Julian Calendar, was entirely independent of the moon; in it there were 3 years of 365 days each and then one year, the leap year, of 366 days. This mode of reckoning, which makes the average age of the sun 985.25 days, was put into effect at the beginning of our era.
It is seen from the length of the tropical year, which was given in Art. 116, that this system of calculation involves a small error, averaging 11 minutes and 14 seconds yearly. In the course of 128 years the Julian Calendar gets one day behind. To remedy this small error, in 1582, Pope Gregory XIII introduced a slight change. Ten days were omitted from October 5th to October 15th inclusive; and then after October 4th, and it was decreed that 3 leap years out of every 4 centuries should henceforth be omitted. This again
CH. VI, 118J
TIME
185
is not quite exact, for the Julian Calendar gets behind 3 days in 3 × 128 = 384 years instead of 400 years; yet the error does not amount to a day until after more than 3300 years have elapsed.
To simplify the application, every year whose date number is exactly divisible by 4 is a leap year, unless it is exactly divisible by 100. Those years whose date numbers are divisible by 100 are not leap years unless they are exactly divisible by 400, when they are leap years. Of course, the rule which determines whether a year is to be declared a leap year for the leap years when the date number is exactly divisible by 100, but there is no immediate need for it.
The calendar originated and introduced by Pope Gregory XIII in 1582, and known as the Gregorian Calendar, is now in use in all civilized countries except Russia and Greece, although it was not adopted in England until 1752. At that time it was found to be too far from the year causing considerable disturbance for many people beginning to observe it were in some way being out of step with what much of the world thought was the true year. The Julian Calendar is now 13 days behind the Gregorian Calen- dar. The Julian Calendar is called Old Style (O.S.), and the Gregorian, New Style (N.S.).
In certain astronomical work, such as the discussion of the observations of variable stars, the difference in time of the occurrence of phenomena is a point of much interest, the Julian Day is used. The Julian Day is simply the number of the day counting forward from January 1, 4713 c. E. This particular date from which to count time was chosen because that year was the first year in several subsidiary cycles, which will not be considered here.
118. Finding the Day of the Week on Any Date. — An ordinary year of 365 days consists of 52 weeks and one day, and a common year has 52 weeks and 2 days. Conse- quently, in succeeding years the same date falls one day later in the week except when a twenty-ninth of February intervenes; and in this case it is two days later. These
186 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. vi, 118]
facts give the basis for determining the day of the week on which any date falls, after it has been given in a particular year.
Consider first the problem of finding the day of the week on which January 1 falls. In the year 1900 January 1 fell on Monday. To fix the ideas, consider the question for 1915.
If every year had been an ordinary year, January 1 coming on this date later than the beginning of the year, it would have fallen, in 1915, 13 days, or 2 weeks and one day, after Monday; that is, on Tuesday. But, in the meantime there were 3 leap years, namely, 1004, 1008, and 1012, which put the date 3 additional days forward in the week, or on Friday. Similarly, it is seen in general that the rule for finding the day of the week on which January 1 falls is as follows: take the number of the year in the century (15 in the example just treated), divide into the number of leap years which have passed (which is given by dividing the number of the year by 4 and neglecting the remainder), divide the result by 7 to eliminate the number of weeks which have passed, and finally, count forward from Monday the number of days given by the remainder. For example, in 1935 the number of the year is 35, therefore leap years is 9, so the sum of $3 \times 4 + 3 = 15$, thus dividing by 7 gives a remainder of $1$. Hence, in 1935, January 1 will be one day later than Monday; that is, it will fall on Tuesday.
In order to find the day of the week on which any date of any year falls, find first the day of the week on which January 1 falls; then take the day of the year, which can be obtained by adding the number of days in the year up to the desired date. Subtract from this sum twice the remainder; i.e., a number of days that must be added to that sum which January 1 falls in order to obtain the day of the week. For example, consider March 21, 1935. It has been found that January 1 of this year falls on Tuesday. There are 79 days from January 1 to March 21 in ordinary years. If 79 is
| January | February | March | April | May | June | July | August | September | October | November | December |
| 0 | 3 | 6 | 9 | 12 | 15 | 18 | 21 | 24 | 27 | 30 | 33 |
| 0 | 3 | 6 | 9 | 12 | 15 | 18 | 21 | 24 | 27 | 30 | 33 |
| 0 | 3 | 6 | 9 | 12 | 15 | 18 | 21 | 24 | 27 | 30 | 33 |
| 0 | 3 | 6 | 9 | 12 | 15 | 18 | 21 | 24 td>
| Total: 79 days. |
Therefore March 21 is a Wednesday.
CH. VI. 118J
TIME 187
divided by 7, the quotient is 11 with the remainder of 2. Consequently, March 21, 1935, falls 2 days after Tuesday, that is, on Thursday.
IX. QUESTIONS
1. Give three examples where intervals of time in which you have lived are shorter than your intellectual experiences now seem briefer than ordinary intervals of the same length. Have you had any contradictory experiences?
---2. If the sky were always covered with clouds, how should we measure time?
---3. What is your sidereal time to-day at 8 p.m.?
4. What would be the relations of solar time to sidereal time if the earth rotated in the opposite direction?
---5. What is the length of a sidereal day expressed in mean solar time?
6. What is the standard time of a place whose longitude is 80° west? What is its local time when the sun is at the vernal equinox?
---7. What is the local time of a place whose longitude is 112° west of Greenwich when its standard time is 8 p.m.?
---8. Suppose a person were able to travel around the earth in 2 days, what would be his number of days and nights if he traveled from east to west?
---9. If the sidereal year was in ordinary use, how long before Christmas would occur when the sun is at the vernal equinox?
10. On what days of the week will your birthday fall for the next 12 years?
CHAPTER VII
THE MOON
119. The Moon's apparent Motion among the Stars.—
The apparent motion of the moon can be determined by observation without any particular reference to its actual motion. In fact, the anciet Greeks observed the moon with great care and learned much of the important peculiarities of its appearance but they did not know its distance from the earth and had no accurate ideas of the character of its orbit. The natural method of procedure is first to find what the appearances are, and from them to infer the actual facts.
The moon has a diurnal motion westward which is produced, of course, by the eastward rotation of the earth. Every day familiarly known that the sun rises in the east; goes across the sky westward, and sets in the west. Those who have observed it except in the most casual way, have noticed that it rises at various points on the eastern horizon, crosses the meridian at various altitudes, and sets at various points on the western horizon. They have also noticed that the interval between its successive passages across the meridian is somewhat more than 24 hours.
Observations made during several consecutive hours will show that it is moving eastward among the stars. When its path is carefully traced out during a whole revolution, it is found that its apparent orbit is a great circle which is inclined to the ecliptic at an angle of $5^{\circ} 0'$. The point at which the moon, in its motion eastward, crosses the ecliptic from south to north is called the ascending node of its orbit, and the point where it crosses the ecliptic from north to south is called the descending node of its orbit. The attraction of the
188
CH. VII, 120J
THE MOON 189
sun for the moon causes the nodes continually to regress on the ecliptic; that is, in successive revolutions the moon crosses the ecliptic farther and farther to the west. The period of revolution of the line of nodes is 18.6 years.
120. The Moon's Synodical and Sidereal Periods. — The synodical period of the moon is the time required for it to move from any apparent position with respect to the sun back to the same position again. The most accurate means of determining this by observation is by the transit of a modern eclipse of the sun, or, at a time of a solar eclipse, the moon is exactly between the earth and the sun. The advantages of this method are that, in the first place, at the epochs used the exact positions of the moon with respect to the sun are known; and, in the second place, in a long interval during which no failure has been humanly observed thousands of revolutions around the earth, the errors in the determination of the synodical period of the earth are relatively unimportant because they are divided by the number of revolutions the moon has performed. It has been found in this way that the synodical period of the moon is 29 days, 12 hours, 44 minutes, and 2.8 seconds; or 29,530.688 days, with an uncertainty of less than one tenth of a second.
The sidereal period of the moon is the time required for it to move from any apparent position with respect to the stars back to the same position again. This period can be found by direct observations; or, it can be computed from the synodical period and the period of the earth's revolution around the sun. Let $S$ represent the moon's synodical period, $M$ its sidereal period, and $E$ the period of the earth's revolution around the sun, all expressed in the same units as, say, days. Then we have from equation (1) that the moon moves eastward in one day, $1/E$ is the fraction of a revolution that the sun moves eastward in one day, and $1/M - 1/E$ is, therefore, the fraction of a revolution that the moon gains on the sun in its eastward motion in one day. Since the moon gains one complete revolution on the sun in
190 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. vii, 120
$S$ days, $1/S$ is also the fraction of a revolution the moon gains on the sun in one day. Hence it follows that
$$\frac{1}{S} = \frac{1}{M} - \frac{1}{E}$$
from which $M$ can be computed when $S$ and $E$ are known.
It is easy to see that the sidereal period is longer than the sidereal. Suppose the sun, moon, and certain stars are at a given instant in the same straight line as seen from the earth. After a certain number of days the moon will have made a sidereal revolution and the sun will have moved eastward among the stars a certain number of degrees. Since additional time is required for the moon to overtake it, the synodic period is greater than the sidereal.
It has been found by direct observations, and also by the equation above, that the moon's sidereal period is 27 days, 7 hours, 43 minutes, and 11.5 seconds, or 27.32166 days. When the period of the moon is referred to, the sidereal period is meant unless otherwise stated.
The periods which have been given are averages, for the moon deviates from its mean in its orbital orbit, primarily because of the attraction of the sun, and to a lesser extent because of the oblateness of the earth and the attractions of the planets. The variations from the average are sometimes quite appreciable, for the perturbations, as they are called, may cause the moon to depart from its undisturbed orbit about 1.5°, and may cause its period of revolution to vary by as much as 20 hours.
A diagram showing eight positions of the moon in its orbit with the sun's rays coming from the right in lines which are essentially parallel because of the great distance of the sun. The left-hand side of the earth is the night side, and similarly the left side of the moon is the dark side.
121 THE PHASES OF THE MOON. — The moon shines entirely by reflected sunlight, and consequently its appearance as seen from the earth depends upon its position relative to the sun. Figure 67 shows eight positions of the moon in its orbit with the sun's rays coming from the right in lines which are essentially parallel because of the great distance of the sun. The left-hand side of the earth is the night side, and similarly the left side of the moon is the dark side.
CH. VII, 121]
THE MOON
191
The small circles whose centers are on the large circle around the earth as a center show the illuminated and unilluminated parts of the moon as they actually are; the accompanying small circles just outside of the large circle show the moon as it is seen from the earth. For example, when the moon is at $M_4$, its dark side toward the earth and sun, its dark side is toward the earth. In this position it is said to be in conjunction, and the phase is first quarter.
At $M_3$ half of the illuminated part of the moon can be seen from the earth, and it is in the first quarter. In this position the moon is said to be in quadrature. Between the new moon and the first quarter the illuminated part of the moon as seen from the earth is of crescent shape, and its convex side is turned toward the sun.
When the moon is at $M_2$ the illuminated side is toward the east; it is in opposition, and the phase is full. If an observer were at the sunset point on the earth, the sun would be setting in the west and the full moon would be rising in the east. At $M_1$ the moon is again in quadrature, and the phase is third quarter.
To summarize: The moon is new when it has the same right ascension as the sun; it is at the first quarter when its right ascension is 6 hours greater than that of the sun; at third quarter it has a right ascension 18 hours greater than that of the sun; and it is at the third quarter when its right ascension is 18 hours greater than that of the sun.
It is observed from the diagram that the earth would have phases if seen from the moon. When the moon is
Fro. 67. — Explanation of the moon's phases.
A diagram showing different positions of a celestial body relative to Earth and Sun.
NOT READY
192 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [CH. VII, 121
new, as seen from the earth, the earth would be full as seen from the moon. The phases of the earth corresponding to every other position of the moon can be inferred from the diagram. The phases of the moon and earth are supplementary; that is, the illuminated portion of the earth as seen from the earth plus the illuminated portion of the earth as seen from the moon always equals 180°.
When the moon is nearly new, and consequently, the earth is nearly full, as seen from the moon, the dark side of the moon is somewhat illuminated by sunlight reflected from the earth, as is shown in Fig. 68.
**122. The Diurnal Circles of the Moon.** — Suppose first that the moon moves along the ecliptic and consider its diurnal circles. Since they are parallel to the celestial equator (if the motion of the moon in declination between rising and setting is neglected), it is sufficient, in view of the discussion of the sun's diurnal circles (Art. 58), to give the places where the moon crosses the meridian. Let $VAP$, Fig. 69, represent the celestial equator spread out on a plane, and $VSAWP$ the ecliptic. Suppose, for example, that the time of the year is March 21. Then the sun is at $V$. If
Fig. 68.—The moon partially illu-
minated by light reflected from the
earth, as seen from the moon. By Barraud
at the Yerkes Observatory.
Fig. 69.—The equator and ecliptic.
equator (if the motion of the moon in declination between rising and setting is neglected), it is sufficient, in view of the discussion of the sun's diurnal circles (Art. 58), to give the places where the moon crosses the meridian. Let $VAP$, Fig. 69, represent the celestial equator spread out on a plane, and $VSAWP$ the ecliptic. Suppose, for example, that the time of the year is March 21. Then the sun is at $V$. If
CH. VII, 122]
THE MOON
193
the moon is new, it is also at $V$, because at this phase it has the same right ascension as the sun. Since $V$ is on the celestial equator, the moon crosses the meridian at an altitude equal to $90^\circ$ minus the latitude of the observer. In this case it rises in the east and sets in the west. But if the moon is at the first quarter, its right ascension is $45^\circ$. At this phase it is 6 hours east of the sun. It is then $23^\frac{1}{2}$ north of the equator, and consequently, it crosses the meridian $23^\frac{1}{2}$ above the equator. In this case it rises north of east and sets north of west. If the moon is full, it is at $A$, and if it is in the third quarter, it is at $W$. In the former case it is on the equator and in the latter $23\frac{1}{2}$ south of it.
Suppose the sun is at the summer solstice, $S$. Then it rises in the northeast, crosses the meridian $23\frac{1}{2}$ north of the equator, and sets in the northwests. At the same time the full moon is at $W$, it rises in the southeast, crosses the meridian $23\frac{1}{2}$ south of the equator, and sets in the southwest. That is, when sunshine is most abundant, the light from the full moon is the least. On the other hand, when the sun is at the winter solstice $W$, the full moon is at $S$ and gives the most light. The other positions of the sun and moon are intermediate between these two similar cases.
Suppose the ascending node of the moon's orbit is at the vernal equinox (Fig. 70), and consider the altitude at which
A diagram showing a lunar orbit with nodes labeled "MOON'S NODE" and "EQUATOR". The diagram includes labels for different phases of the moon: New Moon (N), First Quarter (Q), Full Moon (F), Third Quarter (T). The diagram also shows a line labeled "Equator" and a point labeled "Node".
**Fig. 70.** — Ascending node of the moon's orbit at the vernal equinox.
the moon crosses the meridian when full at all times of the winter solstice. The sun is at $W$ and the full moon is in its orbital $5^\circ$ north of $S$. If the latitude of the observer is $40^\circ$, the moon then crosses her meridian at an altitude of $50^\circ + 23\frac{1}{2} + 5^\circ = 78\frac{1}{2}^\circ$. That is, under these circumstances she
$$a$$
194 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. vi, 122
full moon crosses the meridian higher in the winter time than it would if its orbit were coincident with the ecliptic. On the other hand, in the summer time, when the sun is at $S$ and the full moon is at $W$, the moon crosses the equator farther south than it would if it were on the ecliptic. Under these circumstances, therefore, the moon would be lower in the winter and less in the summer than there would be if the moon were always on the ecliptic.
Now suppose the descending node is at $A$ and the ascending node is at $V$, Fig. 71. For this position of its orbit the moon crosses the meridian lower in the winter than it would if it moved along the ecliptic. The opposite is true when the sun is at $S$ in the summer. Of course, the ascending node of the moon's orbit might be at any other point on the ecliptic.
It is clear from this discussion that when the sun is on the part of the ecliptic south of the equator, the full moon is near the part of the ecliptic which is north of the equator, and vice versa. Therefore, when there is least sunlight there is most moonlight, and there is the greatest amount of moonlight when the moon's ascending node is at the vernal equinox. When it is continuous night at a pole of the earth, as at $O_1$, light is dispelled by the moon which is above the horizon that half of a month in which it passes from its first to its third quarter.
123. The Distance of the Moon. — One method of determining the distance of the moon is by observing the difference in its directions as seen from two points on the earth's surface, as $O_1$ and $O_2$ in Fig. 72. Suppose, for simplicity, that $O_1$ and $O_2$ are on the same meridian, and that the moon
A diagram showing a line labeled "ECLIPTIC" with a curve labeled "MOON'S ORBIT" above it. The curve starts high on one side (winter) and gradually decreases to a low point (summer), then increases again.
Fig. 71. — Ascending node of the moon's orbit at the autumnal equinox.
moon crosses the meridian lower in the winter than it would if it moved along the ecliptic. The opposite is true when the sun is at $S$ in the summer. Of course, the ascending node of the moon's orbit might be at any other point on the ecliptic.
It is clear from this discussion that when the sun is on the part of the ecliptic south of the equator, the full moon is near the part of the ecliptic which is north of the equator, and vice versa. Therefore, when there is least sunlight there is most moonlight, and there is the greatest amount of moonlight when the moon's ascending node is at the vernal equinox. When it is continuous night at a pole of the earth, as at $O_1$, light is dispelled by the moon which is above the horizon that half of a month in which it passes from its first to its third quarter.
123. The Distance of the Moon. — One method of determining the distance of the moon is by observing the difference in its directions as seen from two points on the earth's surface, as $O_1$ and $O_2$ in Fig. 72. Suppose, for simplicity, that $O_1$ and $O_2$ are on the same meridian, and that the moon
CH. VII, 123
THE MOON
195
is in the plane of that meridian. The observer at $O_1$ finds that the moon is the angular distance $Z_O M$ south of his zenith; and the observer at $O_2$ finds that it is the angular distance $Z_O M$ north of his zenith. Since the two observers know their latitudes, they know the angle $O_1 O_2 E$, and since the angles $O_1 O_2 E$ and $O_2 O_1 E$ are each equal to $90^\circ - \theta$, we have, by adding $Z_O M$ plus $E O_1 O$ and $Z_O M$ plus $E O_2 O$, from $180^\circ$, the angles $M O_1 O_2$ and $M O_2 O_1$ are obtained. Since the size of the earth is known, the distance $O_1 O_2$ can be found. Then, in the triangle $O_1 M O_2$ two angles and the included side are known, and all the other parts of the triangle can be computed by trigonometry. Suppose $O_1 M$ has been found;
A diagram showing a globe with a line drawn from a point on the surface of the earth to a point on the moon's surface, labeled "ME". Another line is drawn from this point on the moon's surface to another point on the surface of the earth, labeled "EM". A third line connects these two points on the surface of the earth.
Fig. 72. Measuring the distance to the moon.
then, in the triangle $E O_1 M$ two sides and the included angle are known, and the distance $EM$ can be computed. In general, the relations and observations will not be so simple as those assumed here, but in no case are serious mathematical or observational errors likely to occur. It is to be noted that the result obtained is not guesswork, but that it is based upon measurements, and that it is in reality given by measurements in the same sense that a distance on the surface of the earth may be obtained by measurement. The percentage of error in the determination of the moon's distance is actually much less than that in most of the ordinary distances on the surface of the earth.
196 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cr. vr. 123]
The mean distance from the center of the earth to the center of the moon has been found to be 238,802 miles, and the circumference of its orbit is therefore 1,500,818 miles. On dividing the circumference by the moon's sidereal period expressed in hours, it is found that its orbital velocity averages 260 miles per second.
A body at the surface of the earth falls about 16 feet the first second; at the distance of the moon, which is approximately 60 times the radius of the earth, it would, therefore, fall $16 \div 60^{\circ} = 0.004$ feet, because the earth's attraction varies inversely as the square of the distances from its center. Therefore, in going 3357 feet, or nearly two thirds of a mile, the moon deviates from a straight-line path only about $\frac{1}{2}$ of an inch.
124. The Dimensions of the Moon. — The mean apparent diameter of the moon is $31^{\circ} 5' 2''$. Since its distance is known, its actual diameter can be computed. It is found that the distance straight through the moon is 2100 miles, or a little greater than one fourth the diameter of the earth. Since the surface of spheres are equal other than their volumes, if they have equal areas, it is found that the surface area of the earth is 33 times that of the moon; and since the volume of spheres are to each other as the cubes of their diameters, it is found that the volume of the earth is 49.3 times that of the moon.
It has been stated that the mean apparent diameter of the moon is $31^{\circ} 5' 2''$. The apparent diameter of the moon varies because its distance from the center of the earth varies, also because when the moon is on the observer's meridian, he is nearly 400 miles nearer to it than when it is on his horizon. In the observations of other celestial objects the small distance of 4000 miles makes no appreciable difference in their appearance; but, since the distance from the earth to the moon is, in round numbers, only 240,000 miles, the radius of the earth is $\frac{1}{2}$th of the whole amount.
CH. VII, 1261
THE MOON
197
In spite of the fact that the moon is nearer the observer when it is on his meridian than when it is on his horizon, every one has noticed that it appears largest near the horizon and smallest when near the meridian. The reason that the moon appears to us to be larger when it is near the horizon than when it gives us the impression that it is very distant, and this influences our unconscious estimate of its size.
**125. The Moon's Orbit with Respect to the Earth.** — The moon's distance from the earth varies from about 225,746 miles to 251,978 miles, causing a corresponding variation in its apparent diameter. Its orbit is an ellipse, having an eccentricity of 0.0540, except for slight deviations from this value caused by the planets, and by the partial bulge of the earth. The moon moves around the earth, which is at one of the foci of its elliptical orbit, in such a manner that the line joining it to the earth sweeps over equal areas in equal intervals of time. This statement requires a slight correction because of the perturbations produced by the attractions of the sun and planets. The period of revolution of the moon round the earth is called its *perige*, and the farthest point is called its *apothe*.
**126. The Moon's Orbit with Respect to the Sun.** — The distance from the earth to the sun is about 400 times that from the earth to the moon. Consequently, the oscillations of the moon back and forth across the earth's orbit as the two bodies pursue their motion around the sun are so small as to be imperceptible, and they amount to a maximum of only 30 seconds. As a consequence of the relative nearness of the moon and its comparatively long period, its orbit is always concave toward the sun. If the orbit of the moon were at any time convex toward the sun, it would be when it is moving from a position between the earth and sun to opposition, that is, from $A$ to $B$, Fig. 73. It takes 14 days for the moon to move from the former position to the latter, and during this time its distance from the sun increases by about 480,000
198 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. vii, 126
miles; but, in the meantime, the earth moves forward about 14" in its orbit from $P$ to $Q$, and it, therefore, is drawn by the sun away from the straight line $PT$ in which it was originally moving by a distance of about 3,000,000 miles.
S 125°
Fig. 73. — The orbit of the moon is concave to the sun.
That is, in the 14 days the moon actually moves in toward the sun away from the original line of the earth's motion 3,000,000 — 480,000 = 2,520,000 miles, and its orbit, which is represented by the broken line $s$, is, therefore, concave toward the sun at every point.
As a matter of fact, it is the center of gravity of the earth and moon that describes what is called the earth's elliptical orbit around the sun, and the earth and moon both describe ellipses around this point as it moves on its elliptical path around the sun. Since the earth's mass is very large compared to that of the moon, as will be seen in Art. 127, the center of the earth is always very near the center of gravity of these two bodies.
**LZT. The Mass of the Moon.** — Although the moon is comparatively near the earth, its mass cannot be obtained so easily as that of many other objects farther away.
One of the best methods of finding the mass of the moon depends upon the fact that the center of gravity of the earth and moon describes an elliptical orbit around the sun in accordance with the law of areas. Sometimes the earth is ahead of the center of gravity, and at other times behind it. When this happens, we say that a retrograde motion takes place. If we could see a retrograde motion of any star behind a bright sun will be seen behind the position it would apparently occur if it were not for the moon. On the other hand,
A P
CH. VII, 127]
THE MOON
199
when the earth is behind the center of gravity, the sun will be displaced correspondingly ahead of the position it would otherwise apparently occupy. That is, the sun's apparent motion eastward among the stars is not strictly in accordance with the law of areas, for it sometimes is a little ahead of, and at other times a little behind, the position it would have except for the moon. From what has been said above it is evident that this apparent displacement is in this way about 6'4". Since the distance of the sun is known, the amount of displacement of the earth in miles necessary to produce this apparent displacement of the sun can be computed. It has been found in this way that the distance of the center of gravity of the earth and moon from the center of the earth is 2886 miles.
Let us consider the problem of finding the ratio of the mass of the earth to that of the moon. In Fig. 74 let $E$ represent the earth, $C$ the center of gravity of the earth and moon, and $M$ the moon. Let the distance $EC$ be represented by $x$, and the distance $EM$, $238,862$ miles, by $r$. Since the mass of the earth multiplied by the distance of its center from the center of gravity of the earth and moon equals the mass of the moon multiplied by its distance from the center of gravity of the earth and moon, it follows that
$$x \times E = (r - x) M.$$
Since $x = 2886$ miles and $r = 238,862$ miles, it is found that
$$E = 81.8\ M.$$
In round numbers the mass of the earth is 80 times that of the moon.
Since the orbit of the moon is inclined 5° 9' to the plane of the ecliptic, the earth is sometimes above and sometimes
Fig. 74 — Center of gravity of the earth and moon.
200 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. vii, 127]
below this plane. This causes an apparent displacement of the sun from the ecliptic in the opposite direction. From the amount of the apparent displacement of the sun in latitude, as determined by observations, and from the inclination of the moon's orbit and the distance of the sun, it is possible to compute, just as from the sun's apparent displacement in longitude, the mass of the moon relative to that of the earth.
128. The Rotation of the Moon.—The moon always presents the same side toward the earth, and therefore, as seen from some point other than the earth or moon, it rotates on its axis once in a sidereal month. For, in Fig. 67, when the moon is at $M_1$, a certain part is on the left toward the earth, but when it has moved to $M_2$ the same side is on the right toward the earth. The angle between these two positions is the same as that of its revolution, or from west to east. The plane of its equator is inclined about 1° 32' to the plane of the ecliptic, and the two planes always intersect in the line of nodes of the moon's orbit.
It follows from what has been stated that the moon's sidereal day is the same as its sidereal month, or 27.32166 mean solar days. Its solar day is of the same length as its synodic month or time between successive solar days; because its synodical month is equal to its period with respect to the earth and sun. Other things being equal, the temperature changes from day to night on the moon would be much greater than on the earth because its period of rotation is so much longer; but the seasonal changes would be very slight because of the small inclination of the plane of its equator to the plane of its orbit.
It is most remarkable fact that the moon rotates at precisely such a rate that it always keeps the same face toward the earth. It is infinitely improbable that it was started exactly in this way; and, if it were not so started, there must have been forces at work which have brought about this peculiar relationship. It has been suggested that
A diagram showing a lunar orbit around Earth.
vii, 120j
THE MOON
201
the explanation lies in the tidal reaction between the earth and moon. Since the moon raises tides on the earth, it is obvious that the earth also raises tides on the moon unless it is absolutely rigid. Since the mass of the earth is more than 80 times that of the moon, the tides generated by the earth on the moon, other things being equal, would be much less than those raised by the moon on the earth. If a body is rotating faster than it revolves, and in the same direction, one of the effects of the tides is to slow up its rotation and to tend to bring the periods of rotation and revolution to an equality. It has been generally believed that the tides raised by the earth on the moon during millions of years, part of which time it may have been in a plastic state, have brought about the condition which now exists. The theory of this explanation (Art. 263), and it seems probable that the earth and moon are connected by forces not yet understood.
129. The Librations of the Moon. — The statement that the moon always has the same side toward the earth is not true in the strictest sense. It would be true if planes of its orbit and of its equator were the same, and if it moved at a perfectly uniform rate with respect to the earth.
The inclination of the moon's orbit to the ecliptic averages about $5^{\circ} 9'$ and the inclination of the moon's equator to the ecliptic is about $1^{\circ} 32'$. The three planes are so related that the inclination of the moon's equator to the plane of its orbit is $5^{\circ} 9'+1^{\circ} 32'=6^{\circ} 41'$. The sun shines alternately over two poles of the earth because of the inclination of the plane of the equator to the plane of its orbit. If we imagine a transparent body it would shine $6^{\circ} 41'$ over one pole and $41'$ over the other. Instead of shining on them (except by reflected light), the tilting of the moon's axis of rotation enables us to see $6^{\circ} 41'$ over the poles. This is the *libration* in latitude.
The moon rotates at a uniform rate, — at least the departures from a uniform rate are absolutely insensible. It
202 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. vn, 129
would take inconceivably great forces to make perceptible short changes in its rate of rotation. On the other hand, the moon revolves around the earth at a non-uniform rate, for it moves in such a way that the law of areas is fulfilled. Consequently, the moon's period of revolution is not about 6.5 days, or considerably less than one quarter of its period, for the moon to revolve through 90°; and, therefore, the angle of rotation is considerably less than 90°. The result is that the part of the moon on the side toward the perigee, that is, the western edge, is brought partially into view. On the opposite side of the orbit, the eastern edge of the moon is brought partially into view. This is the libration in longitude.
In addition to this, the moon is not viewed from the earth's center. When it is on the horizon, the line from the observer to the moon makes an angle of nearly 1° (the parallax of the moon) with that from the earth's center to the moon. This enables the observer to see nearly 1° farther around its side than he could if it were on his meridian.
The reason why the moon is librated is that there is only 41 per cent of its surface which never sets again, while 41 per cent is always in sight, and 88 per cent of it is sometimes visible and sometimes invisible.
130. The Density and Surface Gravity of the Moon.—
The volume of the earth is about 50 times that of the moon and its mass is 81.8 times that of the moon. Therefore the density of the moon is somewhat less than that of the earth. It is found from the relative volumes and masses of the earth and moon that the density of the moon on the water standard is about 3.4.
If the radius of the moon were the same as that of the earth, gravity at its surface would be less than $\frac{1}{6}$th that at the surface of the earth; but the small radius of the moon tends to increase the attraction at its surface. If its mass were the same as that of the earth, its surface gravity would be nearly 16 times that of the earth. On taking the two
cu. vn, 131]
THE MOON
203
factors together, it is found that the surface gravity of the moon is about 4 that of the earth. That is, a body on the earth weighs by spring balances about 6 times as much as it would weigh on the moon.
If a body were thrown up from the surface of the moon with a velocity equal to that which would ascend 6 times as high as it would if thrown up from the surface of the earth with the same velocity. Perhaps this is the reason why the forces to which both the earth and moon have been subjected have produced relatively higher elevations on the moon than on the earth. Also it would be possible for mountains of a given material to be 6 times as high on the moon as on the earth before the rock of which they are composed would be cracked by the force of gravity.
131. The Question of the Moon's Atmosphere. — The moon has no atmosphere, or at the most, an excessively rare one. Its absence is proved by the fact that, at the time of an eclipse of the sun, the moon's limb is perfectly dark and sharp, with no apparent distortion of the sun due to refraction. Similarly, when a star is occulted by the moon, it disappears suddenly and not somewhat gradually as it would if its light were being more and more extinguished by an atmosphere.
Besides this, if the moon had an atmosphere, its refraction would keep a star visible for a little time after it had been occulted, just as the earth's atmosphere keeps the sun visible about 2 minutes after it has actually set. In a similar way, the star would become visible a short time before it sets and disappear shortly after it does so. The whole effect would be to make the time of occultation shorter than it would be if there were no atmosphere.
If the moon had an atmosphere of any considerable extent, there would be the effect of erosion on its surface; but so far as can be determined, there is no evidence of such action. Its surface consists of a barren waste, and it is, perhaps, much cracked up because of the extremes of heat
204 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. vii, 131
and cold to which it is subject. But there is nothing resembling soil except, possibly, volcanic ashes. There can be no water on the moon; for, if there were, it would be at least partly evaporated, especially in the long day, and form an atmosphere.
One cannot refrain from asking why the moon has no atmosphere. It may be that it never had any. But the evidence of great surface disturbances makes it not altogether improbable that vast quantities of vapors have been emitted from its interior. If this is true, they seem to have disappeared. There are two explanations of this disappearance which may be explained one by the other. One is that they have united chemically with other elements on the moon. As a possible example of such action it may be mentioned that there are vast quantities of oxygen in the rocks of the earth's crust, which may, perhaps, have been largely derived from the atmosphere.
The second explanation is that, according to the kinetic theory of gases, the moon may have lost its atmosphere by the escape of molecules under the influence of gravity and control. This might be a relatively rapid process in the case of a body having the low velocity of escape of 1.5 miles per second (Art. 33), especially if its days were so long that its surface became highly heated.
It seems probable, therefore, that the moon could not retain an atmosphere if it had one, and that whatever gases it may have acquired from volcanoes or other sources were swiftly lost.
132. The Light and Heat received by the Earth from the Moon.—The average distances of the earth and the moon from the sun are about the same; and, consequently, the earth and the moon receive about equal amounts of light and heat per unit area. The amount of light and heat that the earth receives from the moon depends upon how much inclination there is between their axes of rotation and upon its distance from the earth, and its phase. It is easy to see that, if all the light the moon receives were reflected, the
cn. vn. 1353
THE MOON
205
amount which strikes the earth could be computed for any phase as, for example, when the moon is full. It is found by taking into account all the factors involved that, if the moon were a perfect mirror, it would give the earth, when it is full, about $\frac{1}{6}$ as much light as the earth receives from the sun. But the moon is not a perfect mirror, nor by no means a perfect reflector, and the amount of light it sends to the earth is very much less than this quantity.
It is not easy to compare moonlight with sunlight by direct measurements, and the results obtained by different observers are somewhat divergent. The measurements of Zöllner, which are commonly accepted, show that sunlight is 618,000 times greater than the light received from the full moon. This ratio is too great by the nearly smaller ratio of 465,000. At other phases, the ratio gives not only correspondingly less light, but less than would be expected on the basis of the part of the moon illuminated.
For example, at first quarter the illuminated area is half that at full moon, but the amount of light received is less than one eighth that at full moon. This phenomenon is doubtless due to the roughness of the moon's surface. Moreover, at third quarter the reflected light from the new first quarter is somewhat greater than that received at the corresponding phase at third quarter, the difference being due to the dark spots on the eastern limb of the moon. On taking into consideration the whole month, the average amount of light and heat which the moon furnishes the earth cannot exceed $\frac{1}{6}$ as much of that received from the sun. In other words, the moon receives as much light and heat from the sun in 13 seconds as it receives from the moon in the course of a whole year.
133. The Temperature of the Moon. — The temperature of the moon depends upon the amount of heat it receives, the amount it reflects, and its rate of radiation. About 7 per cent of the heat which falls on the moon is directly reflected, and this has no effect upon its temperature. The
remaining 93 per cent is absorbed and raises the temperature of its surface. The rate of radiation of the moon's surface materials for a given temperature is not known because it depends upon the chemical constitution and physical condition. Nevertheless, it can be determined, at least roughly, at the time of a total eclipse of the moon.
Consider the moon when it is nearly full and just before it is eclipsed by passing into the earth's shadow, as at $N$, Fig. 81. The side toward the earth is subject to the perpendicular rays of the sun and has a higher temperature than any other part of its surface. It is now possible to measure somewhat approximately the amount of heat received from the moon, but it is not easy to determine what part of this is reflected and what part is radiated. Now suppose the moon passes on into the earth's shadow so that the direct rays of the sun are cut off. Then all the heat received from the moon is that radiated from a surface recently exposed to the sun's rays. This can be measured, and, from the amount received and from the temperature of the moon, continuous, it is possible to determine approximately the rate at which the moon loses heat by radiation, and from this the temperature to which it has been raised. The observations show that the amount of heat received from the moon diminishes very rapidly after the moon passes into the earth's shadow. This means that its radiation is very rapid and that probably its temperature does not rise very high. It is safe to say that the mean temperature is between the freezing and boiling points. The recent work of Very leads to the conclusion that the surface is heated at its highest to a temperature of 200° Fahrenheit.
It is now possible to get a more or less satisfactory idea of the temperature conditions of the moon. It must be remembered, in the first place, that its day is 28.5 times as long as that of the earth. In order to keep its atmospheric envelope to keep out the heat in the daytime and to retain it at night. Consequently, when the sun rises
206 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [CH VII, 133
cn. vn, 135j
THE MOON
207
for a point on the moon, its rays continue to beat down upon the surface, which is entirely unprotected by clouds or air, for more than 14 of our days. During this time the temperature rises above the freezing point and it may even go up to the boiling point. When the sun sets, the darkness of midnight immediately follows because there is no atmosphere to produce twilight, and therefore the entire expanse of space between the horizon of one and that of another is covered with a layer of two or three tenths of an inch of water. The temperature of the surface probably falls below the freezing point, and in the course of a day or two it may descend to 100° below zero. It will either remain there or descend still lower until the sun rises again 14 days after it has set.
The climatic conditions on the moon illustrate in the most striking manner the effects of the earth's atmosphere and its relation to the surface of the moon.
**134. General surface Conditions on the Moon.** — On the whole, the surface of the moon is extremely rough, showing no effects of weathering by air or water. It is broken by several mountain chains, by numerous isolated mountain peaks, and by more than 30,000 observed craters. There are several large, comparatively smooth and level areas, which were called marit (seas) by Galileo and other early observers. These are shown in Fig. 74. The instruments show that they not only contain no water but are often rather rough. The smooth places are the areas which are relatively dark as seen with the unaided eye or through a small telescope. For example, the dark patch near the bottom of Fig. 75 and a little to the left of the center with a rather sharply defined lower edge is known as Mare Tranquillitatis (Sea of Tranquility). It is looking out from the right of it and just under the larger crater Copernicus is the Apennine range of mountains. The most conspicuous features which are visible with an ordinary inverting telescope are shown on the map, Fig. 76.
**135. The Mountains on the Moon.** — There are ten ranges of mountains on the part of the moon which is visible
208 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. vii, 135]
from the earth. The mountains are often extremely slender and lofty, in some cases attaining an altitude of more than 20,000 feet above the plains on which they stand. If the
The moon at 91 days. Photographed at the Yerkes Observatory.
Fro. 75. — The moon at 91 days. Photographed at the Yerkes Observatory.
mountains on the earth were relatively as large, they would be more than 15 miles high. The height of the lunar mountains is undoubtedly due, at least in part, to the low surface
CH. VII, 135]
THE MOON
209
gravity on the moon, and to the fact that there has been no erosion by air and water.
The height of a lunar mountain is determined from the length of its shadow when the sun's rays strike it obliquely.
A diagram showing the outline map of the moon.
For example, in Fig. 77 the crater Theophilus is a little below the center, and in its interior are three lofty moun-
tains whose sharp, spirelike shadows stretch off to the left.
Since the size of the moon and the scale of the photograph are both known, the lengths of the shadows can easily be
Figu. 76. — Outline map of the moon.
210 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. vii, 135]
The crater Theophilus and surrounding region (Bitchey).
Fig. 17. — The crater Theophilus and surrounding region (Bitchey).
determined. There is also no difficulty in finding the height of the sun in the sky as seen from this position on the moon when the picture was taken. Consequently, it is possible from these data to compute the height of the mountains.
en. vii, 136)
THE MOON
211
In the particular case of Theophilus, the mountains in its interior are more than 16,000 feet above its floor. On the earth the heights of mountains are counted from the sea level, which, in most cases, is far away. For example, Pike's Peak is about 14,000 feet above the level of the ocean, which is only about 7,000 feet above the sea. In this respect that height above the plateau on which it rests. The shadows of the lunar mountains are black and sharp because the moon has no atmosphere, and they are therefore well suited for use in measuring the heights of objects on its surface.
**136. Lunar Craters.** — The most remarkable and the most conspicuous objects of the lunar topography are the craters, of which many thousands have been discovered. They have been successive stages in their formation, for new ones in many places have broken through and enrobeded upon the old, as shown in Fig. 78. Sometimes the newer ones are precisely on the rims of the older, and sometimes they are entirely in their interiors. The newer craters have deeper floors and steeper and higher rims than the older, and one of the most interesting features of them is that they very often contain within their centers lofty and spirelike pillars.
The term crater at once carries the impression to the mind that these objects on the moon are analogous to the volcanic craters on the earth. There is at least an immense difference in their dimensions. Many lunar craters are from 50 to 60 miles in diameter, and, in a number of cases, their diameters exceed 100 miles. Ptolemy is 115 miles across, while Copernicus is 110 miles in diameter and 3,500 feet deep. The lofty peak in the great crater Copernicus towers 11,000 feet above the plains from which it rises. Some of these craters are on such an enormous scale that their rims would not be visible from their centers because of the curvature of the surface of the moon.
The explanation of the craters is by no means easy, and universal agreement has not been reached. If they are of
212 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. vii, 136
The great crater Clavius with smaller craters on its rim and in its interior. Photographed by Ritchey with the 40-inch telescope of the Yerkes Observatory.
Fig. 78. - The great crater Clavius with smaller craters on its rim and in its interior. Photographed by Ritchey with the 40-inch telescope of the Yerkes Observatory.
213
THE MOON
volcanic origin, the activity which was present on the moon normally surpassed anything now known on the earth.
In view of the fact that there are no lava flows, and that in most cases the material around a crater would not fill it, the volcanic theory of their origin seems very improbable and has been abandoned. Another suggestion is that the craters have been formed by the bursting out of great masses of gas which gathered under the surface of the moon and became heated and subject to great tension because of its contraction. According to this theory, the escaping gas produced large quantities of material which covered it and thus made the rims of the craters. But it is hard to account for the mountains which are so often seen in the interiors of craters.
Gilbert suggested that the lunar craters may have been formed by the impacts of huge meteorites, in some cases many miles across. It is certain that such bodies, weighing hundreds of pounds and thousands of tons, now fall upon the earth. It is supposed that at one time you could see these of these wandering masses with the earth and moon were much more frequent than they are at the present time. When they strike the earth, their energy is largely taken up by the ejection of the earth's atmosphere; when they strike the moon, they plunge in upon its surface and spread from 50 to 100 times that of a cannon ball. It does seem impossible that materials which move across and weighing millions of tons might produce spashes in the surface of the moon, even though it be solid rock, analogous to the craters which are now observed. The heat generated by the impacts would be sufficient to liquify the materials immediately under the place where the meteorites struck, and might even cause very great explosions. The mountains in the centers might be due to a sort of re-arrangement of matter caused by the shock produced by the collision. At any rate, numerous experiments with projectiles on a variety of substances have shown that pits
214 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. vii, 136
closely resembling the lunar craters are very often obtained.
This view as to the cause of the craters is in harmony with the theory that the earth and moon grew up by the accretion of widely scattered material around nuclei which were originally of much smaller dimensions (Art. 250).
An obvious objection to the theory that the craters on the moon were produced by meteores is that the earth has no similar formations. Since the earth and moon are closely associated in their revolution around the sun, it is clear that the cratered surface of the moon must have been formed at about the same time as the moon. The answer to this objection is that, for millions of years, the rains and snows and atmosphere have disintegrated the craters and mountains on the earth, and their powdered remains have been carried away into the valleys.
Whatever irregularities of this character the earth's surface may have had in its early stages, all traces of them disappeared millions of years ago. On the other hand, since air was rare almost from the absent presence of water, the celestial body has preserved for us the records of the forces to which it, and probably also the earth, were subject in the early stages of their development.
Probably the most serious objection to the impact theory of the craters on the moon is that they nearly all appear to have been made by bodies falling straight toward the moon's center. This would be so only if they fell directly toward it, which would in a majority of cases be struck glancing blows by wandering meteores. The attraction of the moon would of course tend to draw them toward its center, but their velocities are so great that this factor cannot seriously have modified their motions. The only escape from this objection, so far as suggested, is that the heat generated by the impacts may have been sufficient to liquify the material in which they impacted, thus preventing the meteorite track, and thus to destroy all evidence of these collisions by the blow.
137 Rays and Rills. — Some of the large craters, particularly Tycho and Copernicus, have long light streaks,
CH. VII, 137]
THE MOON
215
called rays, radiating from them like spokes from the axle of a wheel. They are not interfered with by hill or valley, and they often extend a distance of several hundred miles. They cast no shadows, which proves that they are at the same level as the adjacent surface, and they are most con-
The full moon. Photographed at the Yerkes Observatory (Wallace).
Fig. 79. — The full moon. Photographed at the Yerkes Observatory (Wallace).
pecious at the time of full moon. They are easily seen in Fig. 79. It has been supposed by some that they are lava streams and by others that they were great cracks in the surface, formed at the time when the craters were produced, which have since filled up with lighter colored material from below.
216 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. vii, 157]
The rills are cracks in the moon's surface, a mile or so wide, a quarter of a mile deep, and sometimes as much as 150 miles in length. They are very numerous, more than 1000 having been so far mapped. The only things at all like them on the earth are such chasms as the Grand Can-
yon of Colorado, which is about 100 miles long. But these gorges are the work of erosion, which has probably been entirely absent from the surface of the moon. At any rate, it is incredible that the rills have been produced by erosion. The most plausible theory is that they are cracks which have been caused by violent volcanic action, or by the rapid cooling and shrinking of the moon.
The rills and ryes are very puzzling lunar features which seem to be fundamentally unlike anything in terrestrial topography. Their nearest neighbors thus differ very radically from the earth.
138. The Question of Changes on the Moon. — There have been no observed changes in the larger features of the lunar topography, although, from time to time, minor alterations have been suspected. The most probable change of any natural physical feature is in the small crater Limnë, in Mare Tranquilitatis, mentioned about 1st century B.C., but in 1866 was said by Schmidt to be entirely invisible. It is now visible as on the original maps. It is generally believed that the differences in appearance at various times have been due to slightly different conditions of illumination.
Since the moon's orbit is constantly shifting because of the attraction of the sun, and since the month does not contain integral number of days, it follows that an observer never gets a complete view of the same part of the view of the moon. W. H. Pickering has noticed changes in some small craters, depending upon the phase of the moon, which he interprets as possibly being due to some kind of vegetation which flourishes in the valleys where he supposes heavier gases, such as carbon dioxide, might collect. Some of his observations have been verified by other astronomers, but
CH. VII. 139J
THE MOON
217
his rather bold speculations as to their meaning have not been accepted.
It is altogether probable that the moon long ago arrived at the stage where surface changes practically ceased. The only known influences which could now disturb its surface are the feeble tidal strains to which it is subject, and the extremes of temperature between night and day. While it would be too much to say that slight disintegration of the surface rocks may not still be taking place, yet it is certain that, on the whole, the moon is a body whose evolution is complete. The sun's light and heat are constant, but there is alternately for two weeks the blinding glare of the sunlight, never tempered by passing clouds or even an atmosphere, and the blackness and frigidity of the long lunar night. Month succeeds month, age after age, with no important variations in these phenomena.
139. The Effects of the Moon on the Earth. — The moon reflects a relatively small amount of sunlight and heat to the earth, and it is this reflection that the sun it produces the tides. These are the only influences of the moon on the earth that can be observed by the ordinary person. It has a number of very minor effects, such as causing minute variations in the magnetic needle, the precession of the equinoxes, and slight changes in the motion of the earth; but they are all so small that they can be detected only by rare observers.
There are a great many ideas popularly entertained, such as that it is more liable to rain at the time of a change of the moon, or that crops grow best when planted in certain phases, which have no scientific foundation whatever. It follows from the fact that more light and heat are received from the sun in 13 seconds than from the moon in a whole year, that during this period there is no appreciable difference in temperature. The passing of a feecy cloud, or the haze of Indian summer, cuts off more heat from the sun than the moon sends to the earth in a year. Consequently, it is entirely
218 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [CH. VII, 139
unreasonable to suppose that the moon has any important climatic effects on the earth. Besides this, recorded observations of temperature, the amount of rain, and the velocity of the wind, in many places, for more than 100 years, fail to show with certainty any relation between the weather and phases of the moon.
The phenomena of storms themselves show the essential independence of the weather and the phases of the moon. Storm centers move across the country in a northeasterly direction at the rate of 400 to 500 miles per day, and sometimes they can be followed entirely around the earth. Consequently, if a storm should pass one place at a certain phase of the moon, it would pass another a few thousand miles eastward in quite another phase. The thesis that a storm occurred at a certain phase of the moon would then be verified for one longitude and would fail of verification at all the others.
140. Eclipses of the Moon. — The moon is eclipsed whenever it passes into the earth's shadow so that it does not receive the direct light of the sun. In Fig. 80, $E$ represents the earth and $PQR$ the earth's shadow, which comes to a point at a distance of $870,000$ miles from the earth's center. The only light received from the sun within this cone is that small amount which is refracted into it by the earth's atmosphere in the zone $QR$. In the regions $TQP$ and $SRP$ the sun is partially eclipsed, the light being cut off more and more as the shadow cone is approached. The shadow cone $PQE$ is called the umbra, and the parts $TQP$ and $SRP$, the penumbra.
A diagram showing an eclipse of the moon.
- The left side shows a circle representing the Earth.
- The right side shows a circle representing the Moon.
- A line segment labeled "SUN" extends from outside both circles.
- Inside the Earth circle, there is a smaller circle labeled "E".
- Inside the Moon circle, there is a smaller circle labeled "Q".
- A line segment labeled "PQ" connects points on both circles.
- A line segment labeled "PR" connects points on both circles.
- A line segment labeled "QR" connects points on both circles.
Fig. 80. — The condition for eclipses of the moon and sun.
cz. vii, 140j
THE MOON
219
When the moon is about to be eclipsed, it passes from full illumination by the sun gradually into the penumbra, where at first only a small part of the sun is obscured, and it then proceeds steadily across the shadow of increasing density until it arrives at $A$, where the sun's light is entirely cut off. The distance across the earth's shadow is so great that the moon is totally eclipsed for nearly 2 hours while it is passing through the umbra, and the time from the first contact with the umbra until the last is about 5 hours and 45 minutes. It will be seen from this that the moon would be eclipsed every time it is opposite the sun. In this figure the moon is drawn to show the relation of one looks perpendicularly on the plane of the ecliptic, neglecting the inclination of the moon's orbit. Figure 81 shows another section in which
A diagram showing a circle representing the moon's orbit around the Earth, with a line MN perpendicular to the page. A smaller circle represents the Earth's shadow. The diagram shows how the moon can pass through or be outside of the Earth's shadow.
Fig. 81. — Condition in which eclipses of the moon and sun fall.
the plane of the moon's orbit, represented by $MN$, is perpendicular to the page. It is obvious from this that, when the moon is in the neighbourhood of $F$ (fig. 81), it may pass through the earth's shadow instead of instead through it. The proportions in the figure are by no means true to scale, but a detailed discussion of the numbers involved shows that usually the moon will pass through opposition to the sun without encountering the earth's shadow. But when the earth is 90° in its orbit from the position shown in the figure, that is, when the earth as seen from the sun is at a node of the moon's orbit, then its orbit will pass through both sun and consequently the moon will be eclipsed. At least, the moon will be eclipsed if it is full when the earth is at or near the node. The earth is at a node of the moon's orbit at two times in the year separated by an interval of six
220 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. vii, 140
months. Consequently, there may be two eclipses of the moon a year; but because the moon may not be full when the earth is at one of these positions, one or both of the eclipses may be missed.
Since the sun apparently travels along the ecliptic in the sky, the moon will be on the ecliptic 180° from the sun. The places where the moon crosses the ecliptic are the nodes of its orbit, and, consequently, there can be an eclipse of the moon only when it is near one of its nodes. Since the nodes continually regress as a consequence of the sun's attraction for the moon, the eclipses occur earlier year after year, completing a cycle in 18.6 years.
One scientific use of eclipses of the moon is that when they occur, their duration by the observer after it has just been exposed to the perpendicular rays of the sun gives an opportunity, as was explained in Art. 133, of determining its temperature. Also, at the time of a lunar eclipse, the stars in the neighborhood of the moon can easily be observed, and it is a simple matter to determine the exact instant at which the moon passes in front of a star and cuts off its light. Since the positions of the stars are well known, such an observation enables us to determine with great accuracy what time the observation is made. It is imaginable that the moon may be attended by a small satellite. If the moon is not eclipsed, its own light or that of the sun will make it impossible to see a very minute body in its neighborhood; but at the time of an eclipse, a satellite may be exposed to the rays of the sun while the neighboring sky will not be illuminated by the moon. Only at such a time would there be any hope of discovering a small body revolving around the moon. A search for such an attendant has been made, but has so far proved fruitless.
**141. Eclipses of the Sun.** — The sun is eclipsed when the moon is so situated as to cut off the sun's light from at least a portion of the earth. The apparent diameter of the moon is only a little greater than that of the sun, and, con-
THE MOON
221
ch. vn, 141]
sequently, eclipses of the sun last for a very short time.
This statement is equivalent to saying that the shadow cone of the moon comes to a point near the surface of the earth, as is shown in Fig. 80. It is also obvious from this diagram that the sun is eclipsed as seen from only a small part of the earth. As the moon moves around the earth in its orbit and the earth rotates on its axis, the shadow cone of the moon describes a streak across the earth which may be somewhat curved.
It follows from the fact that the path of the moon's shadow across the earth is very narrow, as shown in Fig. 82, that a
A diagram showing the path of the total eclipse of the sun, August 29-30, 1905.
Fig. 82. — Path of the total eclipse of the sun, August 29-30, 1905.
total eclipse of the sun will be observed very infrequently at any given place. On this account, as well as because it is a startling phenomenon for the sun to become dark in the daytime, eclipses have always been very noteworthy occurrences. In former times, when our knowledge of chronology was very uncertain, writers referred to eclipses in connection with certain historical events, and astronomers, calculating back across the centuries, have been able to
222 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. vi, 141
identify the eclipses and thus fix the dates for historians in the present system of counting time. The infrequency of eclipses at any particular place is evident from Fig. 83, which gives the paths of all the total eclipses of the sun from 1804-1973. In this long period the greater part of these eclipses have been observed.
So far the discussion has referred only to total eclipses of the sun; but in the regions on the earth's surface which are
Path of Total Eclipses from 1804 to 1973.
**Fig. 83.** — Paths of total eclipses of the sun. (From Todd's Total Eclipses.)
near the path of totality, or in the penumbra of the moon's shadow, which is entirely analogous to that of the earth, there are partial eclipses of the sun. The region covered by the penumbra is many times that where an eclipse is total; and, consequently, partial eclipses of the sun are not very infrequent phenomena.
There is not an eclipse of the sun every time the moon is in conjunction with the sun because of the inclination of its orbit. For example, when it is near M, Fig. 81, its shadow
141
cz. vii, 142]
THE MOON
223
passes north of the earth. In fact, eclipses of the sun occur only when the sun is near one of the moon's nodes, just as eclipses of the moon occur only when the earth's shadow is near one of the moon's nodes. Consequently, eclipses occur twice a year at intervals separated by 6 synodical months. Since the moon's nodes regress, making a revolution in 18.6 years, eclipses occur, on the average, about 20 days earlier each year than on the preceding year.
The distance $UV$, Fig. 50, within which an eclipse of the sun may take place is $AB$, within which an eclipse of the moon can occur. Therefore it is not necessary that the sun shall be as near the moon's node in order that an eclipse of the sun may result as it is in order that there may be an eclipse of the moon. When the relations are worked out fully, it is found that there will be at least one solar eclipse each time the sun passes the moon's node, and that there will be at least one lunar eclipse each time the moon passes the sun's node. Consequently, there may be two, three, or four eclipses of the sun. If there are only two eclipses, the moon's shadow is likely to strike somewhere near the center of the earth and give a total eclipse. On the other hand, if there are two eclipses while the sun is passing a single node of the moon's orbit, they must occur, one when the sun is some distance from the node on one side of it and when it is some distance from the node on the other side. In this case the moon's shadow, or at least its penumbra, strikes first near one pole of the earth and then near the other. These eclipses are generally only partial.
142 Phenomena of total Solar Eclipses. — A total eclipse of the sun is a startling phenomenon. It always occurs precisely at new moon, and consequently the moon is invisible until it begins to obscure the sun. The first indication of a eclipse is a black spot appearing in front of the outer edge of the sun by the moon which is passing in front of it from west to east. For some time the sunlight is not diminished enough to be noticeable. Steadily the moon
224 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY CR. VII, 142
moves over the sun's disk; and, as the instant of totality draws near, the light rapidly falls, animals become restless, and everything takes on a weird appearance. Suddently a shadow rushes across the surface of the earth at the rate of more than 1300 miles an hour, the sun is covered, the stars disappear, and a brilliant red light appears. Then, in a few minutes, the sun-colored prominences (Art. 236) of vaporous material forced up from the sun's surface to a height of perhaps 200,000 miles, and all around the sun, extending out as far as half its diameter, are the streamers of pearly light which constitute the sun's corona (Art. 238). After about 7 minutes, at the very most, the western edge of the sun is uncovered, daylight suddenly reappears, and the phenomena of a partial eclipse are thus reversed.
Total eclipses of the sun afford the most favorable conditions for searching for small planets within the orbit of Mercury, and it is only during them that the sun's corona can be observed.
X. QUESTIONS
1. Verify by observations the motion of the moon eastward among the stars, and its change in declination during a month.
2. For an observer on the moon describe: (a) the apparent motions of the stars; (b) the motion of the sun with respect to the stars; (c) the motion of the earth with respect to the sun; (d) the diurnal motion of the earth; (e) the librations of the earth.
Describe the phases the moon would have throughout the year if the plane of its orbit were perpendicular to the plane of the ecliptic.
What would be the moon's synodic period if it revolved around the earth from east to west in the same sidereal period?
Show by a diagram that, if the moon always presents the same face toward the earth, it rotates on its axis and its period of rotation equals one month.
Is it possible that the moon has an atmosphere and water on the side remote from the earth?
Suppose you could go to the moon and live there a month.
CH. VII, 142J
THE MOON
225
Give details regarding what you would observe and the experiences you would have.
8. What are the objections to the theory that lunar craters are of volcanic origin? That they were produced by meteorites?
9. How do you interpret rays and rills under the hypothesis that lunar craters were produced by meteorites?
10. If the earth's reflecting power is 4 times that of the moon, how does earthshine on the moon compare with moonshine on the earth?
q
CHAPTER VIII
THE SOLAR SYSTEM
I. THE LAW OF GRAVITATION
143. The Members of the Solar System.--The members of the solar system are the sun, the planets and their satellites, the planetoids, the comets, and the meteors. It may possibly be that some of the comets and meteors, coming in toward the sun from great distances and passing on again, are parts of the sun itself. But the sun is by far the one preeminent body. Its volume is nearly a thousand times that of all the other bodies combined, its mass is so great that it controls all their motions, and its rays illuminate and warm them. It is impossible to treat of the planets without taking into account their relations to the sun, but the constitution and evolution of the sun are quite inde- pendent of these planets.
The eight known planets are, in the order of their distance from the sun, Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune. The first six are conspicuous objects to the unaided eye when they are favorably located, and they have been known from prehistoric times; Uranus and Neptune were discovered in 1781 and 1846, respectively. The planetoids (often called the small planets) and sometimes the meteoric bodies are also included among the planets. They revolve around the sun between the orbits of Mars and Jupiter. The comets are bizarre objects whose orbits are very elongated and lie in every position with respect to the orbits of the planets. Probably at least a part of the meteors are the remains of disintegrated comets; they are visible only when they strike into the earth's atmosphere.
220
CH. VIII, 144]
THE SOLAR SYSTEM
227
**144. The Relative Dimensions of the Planetary Orbits.** —
The distance from the earth to the sun is called the **astronomical unit**. The distances from the planets to the sun can be determined in terms of the astronomical unit without knowing its value in miles.
Consider first the planets whose orbits are interior to that of the earth. They are called the **inferior planets**. In Fig. 84 let $S$ represent the sun, $V$ the planet Venus, and $E$ the planet Mercury.
The angle $SEV$ is called the **elongation** of the planet, and may vary from zero up to a maximum which depends upon the size of the triangle $SEV$. When $SEV$ is a right angle, the elongation is greatest, the angle at $V$ is a right angle. Suppose the elongation of $V$ is determined by observation day after day until it reaches its maximum value. Then when this maximum elongation is measured and the angle at $V$ is 90°, the shape of the triangle is determined, and $SEV$ can be computed by trigonometry in terms of $SE$.
Now consider the planets whose orbits are outside that of the earth. They are called the **superior planets**. Suppose the periods of revolution of the earth and Mars, for example, have been determined from long series of observations. Then we know everything about their actual or relative distances. For, in the first place, the earth's period can be obtained from observations of the apparent position of the sun with respect to the stars; and then the period of Mars can be found from the time re-
A diagram showing three points labeled S (sun), V (planet Venus), and E (planet Mercury). The angle SEV represents the elongation of Venus.
**Fig. 84. — Finding the distance of an inferior planet.**
227
228 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. viii, 144
quired for it to move from a certain position with respect to the sun back to the same position again. For example, when a planet is exactly $180^\circ$ from the sun in the sky, as seen from the earth, it is said to be in opposition. The period from opposition to opposition is called the *synodic period* (compare Art. 120). Let the sidereal period of the earth be represented by $E$, the sidereal period of the planet by $P$, and its synodic period by $S$. Then, analogous to the case of the moon in Art. 120, $P$ is defined by
$$\frac{1}{P} = \frac{1}{E} - \frac{1}{S}$$
Now return to the problem of finding the distance of a superior planet in terms of the astronomical unit. In Fig. 85, let $S$ represent the sun, and $E_1$ and $M_1$ the positions of the earth and Mars at their first oppo- sition. Let $E_2$ and $M_2$ represent the positions of the earth and Mars when the angle at $E_2$ is, for example, a right angle. Mars is then said to be in quadrature, and the time required for this position can be determined by observation. The angles $M_1SE_2$ and $M_2SM_1$ can be determined from the periods of the earth and Mars and the interval of time required for the earth and Mars to move from $E_1$ and $M_1$ respectively to $E_2$ and $M_2$. The difference of these two angles is $M_1SE_2$, from which, together with the known value of $\frac{1}{S}$, the distance $SM_1$ in terms of $SE_2$ can be computed by trigonometry.
A little complication in the processes which have been described arises from the fact that the orbit of the earth is
A diagram showing a circle with three points labeled E1, M1, E2, M2. The points are connected by lines forming angles.
Fig. 85.—Finding the distance of a superior planet.
CH. VII, 145]
THE SOLAR SYSTEM
229
not a circle. But the manner in which the distance of the earth from the sun varies can easily be determined from observations of the apparent diameter of the sun, for the apparent diameter of an object varies inversely as its distance. After the variations in the earth's distance have been found, the results can be applied to the moon, similarly to a sphere, whose diameter adopted is half the length of the earth's orbit, and is called its mean distance, though it is a little less than the average distance to the sun.
145. Kepler's Laws of Planetary Motion. — The last great observer before the invention of the telescope was the Danish astronomer Tycho Brahe (1546-1601). He was an energetic and most painstaking observer, who catalogued many stars, but he also observed comets, proving they are beyond the earth's atmosphere, and obtained an almost continuous record for many years of the positions and motions of the sun, moon, and planets.
Tycho Brahe's successor was his pupil Kepler (1571-1630), who spent more than 20 years in attempting to find from the observations of his master the manner in which the planets actually move. The results of an enormous amount of careful observation are contained in the following laws of planetary motion:
I. Every planet moves so that the line joining it to the sun sweeps over equal areas in equal intervals of time, whatever their length. This is known as the law of areas.
II. The orbit of every planet is an ellipse with the sun at one of its foci.
Fig. 86. — Johann Kepler.
229
230 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. viii, 145]
III. The squares of the periods of any two planets are proportional to the cubes of their mean distances from the sun.
All the complexities of the apparent motions of the planets are explained by Kepler's three simple laws when taken in connection with the periods of the planets and the positions of their orbits.
146. The Law of Gravitation. — Newton based his greatest discovery, the law of gravitation, on Kepler's laws. From each one of them he drew an important conclusion.
Newton was led to a similar mathematical discussion, based on his laws of motion, that it follows from Kepler's first law that every planet is acted upon by a force which is directed toward the sun. This was the first time that the sun and planets were shown to be connected dynamically. Before Newton's time it was generally supposed that there was some force acting on the planets in the direction of their motion, but no one had thought of this idea.
The first law of Kepler led to the conclusion that the planets are acted on by forces directed toward the sun, but gave no information whatever regarding the manner in which the forces depend upon the position of the planet. The second law furnishes a basis for the answer to this question, and from it Newton proved that the force acting on each planet exactly depends upon its distance from the sun.
The law of the inverse squares is encountered in many phenomena besides gravitation. For example, it holds for magnetic and electric forces, the intensity of light and of sound, and the magnitudes of water and earthquake waves.
The reason it holds for the radiation of light is easily understood. The area of the spherical surface which the rays cover in proceeding from a point is proportional to the square of the distance from that point. Since the illumination is inversely proportional to the illuminated area, it is inversely as the square of the distance. If gravitation in some way depended on lines of force extending out from matter radially,
Signature
CH. VII, 147] THE SOLAR SYSTEM 231
it would vary inversely as the square of the distance, but nothing is positively known as to its nature.
Another interesting question remains, and that is whether the gravitation of a body is strictly proportional to its inertia, regardless of its constitution and condition, or whether it depends upon its position, temperature, and other characteristics. All other known forces such as magnetism, depend upon other things than mass, and it might be expected the same would be true of gravitation. But it follows from Kepler's third law that the sun's attraction for the several planets is independent of their different constitutions, motions, and physical conditions. Since the same law holds for the 800 planetoids as well, in which there is opportunity for great diversities, it is concluded that gravitation is independent of all except the masses and the distances of the attracting bodies.
Suppose the attraction between unit masses at unit distance is taken as unity, and consider the attraction of a body composed of many units for another of many units. To fix the ideas, suppose one body has 5 units of mass and the other 4 units; the problem is to find the number of units exerted by these two bodies at unit distance. Each of the 5 units exerts a unit of force on each of the 4 units. That is, each of the 5 units exerts all together 4 units of force on the second body. Therefore, the entire first body exerts $5 \times 4 = 20$ units of force on the second body; or, the whole force is proportional to the products of the masses.
On uniting the results obtained from Kepler's three laws and assuming that they hold always and everywhere, the universal law of gravitation is established.
Every particle of matter in the universe attracts every other particle with a force which is proportional to the product of their masses, and which varies inversely as the square of the distance between them.
147. The Importance of the Law of Gravitation. — The importance of a physical law depends upon the number of
A diagram showing Kepler's three laws.
232 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. viii, 147]
phenomena it coordinates and upon the power it gives the scientist of making predictions. Consider the law of gravitation in these respects. In his great work, *Philosophiae*
An engraved portrait of Isaac Newton.
Fig. 87. — Isaac Newton.
*Naturæ Principia Mathematica* (The Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy), commonly called simply the *Principia*, showed such that all known phenomena of the motions, shapes, and tides of the solar system could be explained by the law of gravitation. That is, the elliptical
cr. viii, 147
THE SOLAR SYSTEM
233
paths of the planets and the moon, the slow changes in their orbits produced by their slight mutual attractions, the oblateness of rotating bodies, the precession of the equinoxes, and the countless small irregularities in planetary and satellite motions that can be detected by powerful telescopes, are all phenomena which, according to the law of gravitation, and which once seemed to be a hopeless task, belong to an orderly system. All the discoveries in this direction for more than 200 years have confirmed the exactness of the law of gravitation until it is now by far the most certainly established physical law.
Not only is the law of gravitation operative in the great phenomena where its effects are easy to detect, but also in those where they are difficult to detect. It has been found on reflection that all phenomena depend either directly or indirectly upon the motion of matter, for even changes of the mental state of an individual are accompanied by corresponding changes in the structure of his brain. When a person moves, his changed relation to the remainder of the universe causes a corresponding change in the gravitational stress by which he is connected with it; indeed, when he thinks, the gravitational forces between him and other alterations in the gravitational forces between it and matter even in the remotest parts of space. These effects are certainly real, though there is no known means of detecting them.
The law of gravitation became in the hands of the successors of Newton one of the most valuable laws discovered. Until recently some mathematicians as Laplace and Lagrange, using it as a basis, predicted things which had not then been observed, but which invariably were found later to be true. But scientific men are not contented with simply making predictions and finding that they come true. On the basis of their established laws they seek to foresee what will happen in the almost indefinite future, even beyond the time when the human race shall
234 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. viii, 147]
have become extinct, and, similarly, what the conditions were back before the time when life on the earth began.
The law of gravitation was undoubtedly Newton's greatest discovery, and the importance of it and his other scientific work is indicated by the statements of competent judges.
The brilliant German scholar, Leibnitz (1646-1716), a contemporary of Newton and his greatest rival, said, "Taking mathematics from the beginning of the world to this very day, Newton has been the most fortunate." The French mathematician, Lagrange (1707-1813), one of the greatest masters of celestial mechanics, wrote, "Newton was the greatest genius that ever existed, and the most fortunate, for we cannot find more than once a system of the world to establish." The English writer on the history of science, Whewell, said, "It [the law of gravitation] is indubitably incomparable among great scientific discoveries; for it involves all that is involved in it, whether it involved, the extent of the truth disclosed, or the fundamental and satisfactory nature of this truth." Compare these splendid and deserved eulogies with Newton's own estimate of his efforts to find the truth: "I do not know what I may appear to the world; but to myself I seem to have been only like a boy playing on the seashore, and dropping pebbles here and there in consideration of a prettier shell than ordinary, while the great ocean of truth lay all undiscovered before me." There is every reason to believe that this is the sincere and unaffected expression of a great mind which realized the magnitude of the unknown as compared to the known.
In Westminster Abbey, in London, Newton lies buried amidst the nobility, the greatest English dead, and over his tomb on a tablet there is inscribed, "Mortals, congratulate yourselves that so great a man has lived for the honor of the human race."
**148. The Conic Sections.** — After having found that, if the orbit of a body is an ellipse with the center of force at a
CH. VIII, 148J THE SOLAR SYSTEM 235
focus, then the force to which it is subject varies inversely as the square of its distance, Newton took up the converse problem. Under the assumption that the attractive force varies inversely as the square of the distance, he proved that any curve described by a body moving under such a force must be a conic section, an example of which is the ellipse.
The conic sections are highly interesting curves first studied by the ancient Greeks. They derive their name from the fact that they can be obtained by cutting a circular cone with a plane. Fig. 88 shows a double circular cone whose vertex is at $V$. A plane section perpendicular to the axis of the cone gives a circle $C$. An oblique section gives an ellipse $E$; however, the plane must cut both sides of the cone. When the plane is parallel to one side, or element, of the cone, it parallels $P$ isobola. When the plane cuts two branches of the cone, the two branches of an hyperbola $HH$ are obtained. There are in addition to these figures certain limiting cases. One is that in which the intersecting plane passes only through vertices, giving a straight line; another case is that in which the intersecting plane touches only one element of the cone, giving a single straight line; and the last is that in which the intersecting plane passes through the vertex $B$ and cuts both branches of the cone, giving two intersecting straight lines.
The character of the conic described depends entirely upon the central force and the way in which the body is started. For example suppose a body is started from $O$, Fig. 89, in the direction $OT$, perpendicular to $OS$. If the initial velocity of the body is zero, it will fall straight to
The conic sections.
Fig. 88. — The conic sections.
CH. VIII, 148J
230 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. vm, 148
S. If the initial velocity is not too great, it will describe the ellipse $E$, and $O$ will be the aphelion point. If the initial velocity is just great enough so that the centrifugal acceleration balances the attraction, the orbit will be the circle $C$. If the initial velocity is a little greater than that in the circle, the body will describe the ellipse $E_1$, with its perihelion point. If the initial velocity is exactly $\sqrt{2}$ times that for the circular orbit, the body will move in the parabola $P$. If the initial velocity is still greater, the orbit will be an hyperbola $H$. And finally, if the initial velocity is infinite, the path will be a straight line whose direction is $OT$. If the initial direction of motion is not perpendicular to $OS$, the results are analogous, except that there is then no initial velocity which will give a circular orbit.
It is clear from this discussion that it is a natural for a body to move in one conic section as in another. Some of the satellites move in orbits which are very nearly circular; the planets move in ellipses with varying degrees of elongation; many comets move in orbits which are sensible parabolas; and there may possibly be others.
149 The Question of other Laws of Force. — Many other laws of force than that of the inverse squares are conceivable. For example, the intensity of a force might vary inversely as the third power of the distance. The character of the curve described by a body moving subject to any such force can be determined by mathematical processes.
Fig. 89. — Different cones depending on the initial velocity.
148
CH. VII, 150J THE SOLAR SYSTEM 237
It is found that, if the force varied according to any other power of the distance than the inverse square, except directly as the first power, then (save in special initial conditions) the orbits would be curves leading either into the center of force or out to infinity. Such a law would of course be fatal to the permanence of the planetary system.
If the force varied directly as the distance, the orbits would all be exactly ellipses, in spite of the mutual attractions of the planets, the sun would be at the center of all the orbits and all the periods would be the same. This would indicate a perfect system for the geometrical.
**150. Perturbations.** — If the planets were subject to no forces except the attraction of the sun, their orbits would be strictly ellipses. But, according to the law of gravitation, every planet attracts every other planet. Their mutual attractions are small compared to that of the sun because of their relatively small masses, but they cause sensible deviations from strict elliptical motion, which are called **perturbations**.
The mutual perturbations of the planets are sometimes regarded as blemishes on what would be otherwise a perfect system. Such a point of view is quite unjustified. Each body is subject to certain forces, and its motion is the result of its initial position and velocity and these forces. If the masses of the planets were not so small compared to that of the sun, their orbits would have been perfectly elliptical.
The problems of the mutual perturbations of the planets and those of the perturbations of the moon are exceedingly difficult, and have taxed to the utmost the powers of mathematicians. In order to obtain some idea of their nature consider the case of only two planets, $P_1$ and $P_2$. The forces that $P_1$ and $P_2$ would exert upon each other if they both moved in circular orbits about their common center could be calculated without excessive difficulty, and the results of these forces can be determined. But the resulting departures from elliptical motion cause corresponding alterations in the forces,
A diagram showing two planets orbiting around a central point.
238 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. viii, 150
which produce new perturbations. These new perturbations in turn change the forces again. The forces give rise to new perturbations, and the perturbations to new perturbing forces, and so on in an unending sequence. In the solar system where the masses of the planets are small compared to that of the sun, the perturbations of the planets increase very rapidly in importance. If the masses of the planets were large compared to the sun so that Kepler's laws would not have been even approximately true, it is doubtful if even the genius of Newton could have extracted from the intricate tangle of phenomena the master principle of the celestial motions, the law of gravitation.
Although the perturbations may be small, the question arises whether they may not be extremely important in the long run. This question was treated by Lagrange and Laplace toward the end of the eighteenth century. They proved that the mean distances, the eccentricities, and the inclinations of the planetary orbits oscillate through relatively narrow ranges, at least for a long time. If these results were not true, the stability of the system would be imperilled, for with extreme variation of especially the first two of these quantities, the configuration of all other orbits would be entirely changed. On the other hand, the perihelion points and the places where the planes of the orbits of the planets intersect a fixed plane not only have small oscillations, but they involve terms which continually change in one direction. Examples of perturbations of precisely this sort already encountered are the precession of the equinox (Art. 119) and the revolution of the moon's line of nodes (Art. 119).
**151. The Discovery of Neptune.** — Not only can the perturbations be computed when the positions, initial motions, and the masses of the planets are given, but the converse problem can be treated with some success. That is, if the perturbations are furnished by the observations, the nature of the forces which produce them can be inferred. The most
cn. VIII, 151]
THE SOLAR SYSTEM
239
celebrated example of this converse problem led to the dis-
covery of the planet Neptune.
In 1781 William Herschel discovered the planet Uranus while carrying out his project of examining every object in the heavens that had been observed for some time its orbit was computed. In order to predict its position exactly it was necessary to compute the perturbations due to all known bodies. This was done by Bouvard on the basis of the mathematical theory of Laplace. But in 1820 there were unmistakable discordances between theory and observation; by 1830, they were still more serious; by 1840, they had become intolerable. This does not mean that Newton assigned the planet to one part of the sky and observation found it in a far different one; for, in 1840, its departure from its calculated position amounted to only two thirds the apparent distance between the sun and the star Epsilon Lyrae (Art. 88), a quantity invisible to the unaided eye. It seems incredible that so slight a discordance between theory and observation after 60 years of accumulation could have led to any valuable results.
By 1820 it began to be suggested that the discrepancies in the motion of Uranus might be due to the attraction of a more remote unknown planet. The problem was to find the unknown planet. Such excessive mathematical difficul-
William Herschel.
Fig. 90. — William Herschel.
240 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. vii, 151
ties were involved that it seemed insoluble. In fact, Sir George Airy, Astronomer Royal of England, expressed him-
self later than 1840 as not be-
lieving the problem could be solved. However, a young Englishman, Adams, and a young Frenchman, Leverrier, with all the enthusiasm of youth quickly developed tools to
up the problem about 1845.
Adams finished his work first
and communicated his results
both to Challis, at Cambridge,
and to Airy, at Greenwich.
To say the least, they took
no very active interest in the
matter and altered the search for
the supposed body to be postponed. Adams continued
his work and made five separate
and very laborious computa-
tions. In the meantime Le-
verrier completed his work and
sent the results to the famous
German astronomer, Galle.
Impatiently Galle waited for
the night and the stars. On
the first evening after receiv-
ing Leverrier's letter, Septem-
ber 23, 1846, he looked for
the unknown body, and found
it within half a degree of
the position assigned to it by
Leverrier, which agreed
substantially with that indicated by Adams.
Neptune is nearly three thousand millions of miles from the
Fig. 91. — John Couch Adams.
Fig. 92. — Joseph Leverrier.
cn. viii, 152)
**THE SOLAR SYSTEM**
241
earth, beyond the reach of all our senses except that of sight, and it can be seen only with telescopic aid.; its distance is so great that more than four hours are required for its light to come to us, yet it is bound to the remainder of the sys- tem by the invisible bonds of gravitation. But its attra- tion slightly influenced the motions of Uranus, and from these slight disturbances its existence and position were inferred. Notwithstanding the fact that both Adams and Leverrier made assumptions respecting the distance of the planet Neptune, which were somewhat in error, their work stands as a monument to the reasoning powers of human mind, and to the perfection of the theory of the motions of the heavenly bodies.
**152. The Problem of Three Bodies.** — While the prob- lem of two mutually attracting bodies presents no serious mathematical troubles, because the motion is always in some kind of a cone section, that of three bodies is one of the most formidable difficulties. It has been supposed that it has not been solved, and perhaps it cannot be solved. Such an idea is incorrect, as will now be explained.
The theory of the perturbations of the planets is really a problem of three, or rather of eight, bodies, and has been completely solved for an interval of time not too great. That is, while the positions of the bodies have been described for an interval of time sufficient that they are not closed curves but wind about in a very complicated fashion. Nevertheless it is possible to compute their positions with any desired degree of precision for any time not too remote. There- fore, in a perfectly real and just sense the problem has been solved.
There are particular solutions of the problem of three bodies in which the motion can be described for any period of time however long. This was shown at first discovered by Lagrange, who found two special cases. In one of them the bodies move so as to remain always in a straight line, and in the other so as to be always at the vertices of an equi-
R
242 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. viii, 152]
lateral triangle. In both cases the orbits are conic sections.
In 1878 an American astronomer, Hill, in connection with his work on the motion of the moon, discovered some less simple but immensely more important special cases. Since 1890 Poincaré, universally regarded as the greatest mathematician of our time, has shown that there exist an infinite number of these special cases called periodic solutions.
In all of them the problem is exactly solved. Still more recently Sundman, of Helsingfors, Finland, has in an important mathematical sense solved the general case. However, in spite of all the results that have been achieved, the problem still presents to the mathematician unsolved questions of great interest.
153 The Tides and the Tides.—So far in the present discussion only the effect of one body on the motion of another, taken as a whole, has been considered. There remains to be considered the distortion of one body by the attraction of another. These deformations give rise to the tides.
Before proceeding to a direct discussion of the tidal problem it is necessary to state an important principle, namely, if two bodies are subject to equal parallel accelerations, their relative positions are not changed. The truth of this proposition follows from the laws of motion, but it is better understood from an illustration. Suppose two bodies of the same or different dimensions are dropped from the top of a high tower. They have initially a certain relation to each other and they are subject to equal parallel accelerations, namely those produced by the earth's attraction. In their descent they fall nearer and faster; but, neglecting the effects of the resistance of the air, they preserve the same relations to each other.
Let $E$, Fig. 93, represent the earth, and $O$ and $O'$ two points on its surface. Consider the tendency of the moon $M$ to displace $O$ on the surface of the earth. The moon attracts the center of the earth $E$ in the direction $EM$. Let
cn. viii, 133)
THE SOLAR SYSTEM
243
its acceleration be represented by $EP$. In the same units $OA$ represents the acceleration of $M$ on $P$ in direction and amount. The line $OA$ is greater than $EP$ because the moon is nearer to $O$ than it is to $E$. Now resolve $OA$ into two components, one of which, $OB$, shall be equal and parallel to $EP$. The other component is $OC$. Since $OB$ and $EP$ are equal and parallel, it follows from the principle stated
Fig. 93. - Resolution of the tide-raising forces.
at the beginning of this article that they do not change the relative positions of $E$ and $O$. Therefore $OC$, the outstanding component, represents the tide-raising acceleration both in direction and amount.
The case for $O'A'$ is analogous, and the tide-raising force $O'C'$ is directed away from the moon because $O'A'$ is shorter than $EP$. Figure 94 shows the tide-raising ac-
Fig. 94. - The tide-raising forces.
celerations around the whole circumference of the earth. This method of deriving the tide-raising forces is the elementary geometrical counterpart of the rigorous mathe-
244 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. vii, 153
matical treatment], and it can be relied on to give correctly all that there is in this part of the subject.
A more detailed discussion than can be entered into here shows that the tide-raising forces are about 5 per cent greater on the side of the earth which is toward the moon than on the other side. The force due to the moon from the surface of the earth in the line of the moon are of almost twice as great as those which are directed inward 90° from this line. The tidal forces due to the sun are a little less than half as great as those due to the moon; no other bodies have sensible tidal effects on the earth.
164. The Masses of Celestial Bodies.--The masses of celestial bodies are determined from their attractions for a planet. Suppose a satellite revolving around a planet in an orbit of measured dimensions in an observed period. From these data it is possible to compute the acceleration of the planet for the satellite because the attraction balances the centrifugal acceleration. It is possible to determine what the earth's attraction would be at the same distance, and, consequently, the relation of its mass to that of the other planet. There has been much difficulty in finding the masses of Mercury and Venus, owing to their known satellites. Their masses have been determined with considerable reliability from their perturbations of each other and of the earth, and from their perturbations of certain comets that have passed near them.
A useful formula for the sum of the masses of any two bodies $m_1$ and $m_2$ which attract each other according to the law of gravitation, for example, the two components of a double star, is
$$m_1 + m_2 = \frac{a^2}{P^2}$$
where $a$ is the distance between the bodies expressed in
An analytical discussion proves that the tide-raising force is proportional to $r^{-3}$, where $r$ is the distance between body and the disturbed body, and inversely proportional to the cube of the distance between the disturbing and disturbed bodies.
ch. viii, 155]
THE SOLAR SYSTEM
245
terms of the earth's distance from the sun as unity, and where $P$ is the period expressed in years. The sum of the masses is expressed in terms of the sun's mass as unity.
**155. The Surface Gravity of Celestial Bodies.** — The surface gravity of a celestial body is an important factor in the determination of its surface conditions, and is fundamental in the question of its retaining an atmosphere. The surface gravity of a spherical body depends only upon its mass and dimensions.
Let $m$ represent the mass of the earth, $g$ its surface gravity, and $r$ its radius. Then by the law of gravitation
$$g = k^{\frac{m}{r^2}}$$
where $k^2$ is a constant depending on the units employed. Let $M$, $G$, and $R$ represent in the same units the corresponding quantities for another body. Then
$$G = k^{\frac{M}{R^2}}$$
On dividing the second equation by the first, it is found that
$$\frac{G}{g} = \frac{M}{m} \left(\frac{r}{R}\right)^2$$
$$g = \frac{m}{M} \left(\frac{R}{r}\right)^2$$
from which the surface gravity can be found in terms of that of the earth when the mass and radius of $M$ are given.
It is sometimes convenient to have the expression for the ratio of the gravities of two bodies in terms of their densities and dimensions. Let $d$ and $D$ represent the densities of the earth and the other body respectively. Then, since $m = \frac{1}{3} \pi d^3$ and $M = \frac{4}{3} \pi D^3$, it is found that
$$\frac{G}{g} = \frac{d}{D} \cdot \frac{R}{r}$$
That is, the surface gravities of celestial bodies are proportional to the products of their densities and radii. A small density may be more than counterbalanced by a large radius, as, for example, in the case of the sun, whose density is only one fourth that of the earth but whose surface gravity is about 27.6 times that of the earth.
246 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. viii, 155]
XI. QUESTIONS
1. If the sidereal period of a planet were half that of the earth, what would be its period from greatest eastern elongation to its next succeeding greatest eastern elongation? If the synodical period of a planet were twice that of the earth, what would be its period from opposition to its next succeeding opposition?
2. What would be the period of a planet if its mean distance from the sun were twice that of the earth?
3. What would be the mean distance of a planet if its period were twice that of the earth?
4. On what does the moon around the earth satisfy (nearly) Kepler's first two laws. What are the respective conclusions which follow from them?
5. The law of gravitation varies directly as the product of the masses. Show that the acceleration of one body with respect to another, both being free to move, is proportional to the sum of their masses. From this use both the second and third laws of motion.
In Lagrange's two laws we have seen that whether three bodies the law of areas is satisfied for each body separately with respect to the center of gravity of the three. What conclusion follows from this fact? How does the force toward the center of gravity vary?
II. THE ORBITS, DIMENSIONS, AND Masses OF THE PLANETS
166. Finding the actual Scale of the Solar System. — It was seen in Art. 144 that all these dimensions of the solar system can be determined without knowing any actual distance. It follows from this that if the distance between any two bodies can be found, all the other distances can be computed.
The problem of finding the actual scale of the solar system is of great importance, because the determination of the dimensions of all its members depends upon its solution, and the distance from the earth to the sun is involved in many astronomical calculations. In 1700 it was shown that by means of observations made in 1700 had it been solved with any considerable degree of approximation, but the distance from the earth to the sun
247
cn. vin, 156]
THE SOLAR SYSTEM
is now known with an error probably not exceeding one part in a thousand.
The direct method of measuring the distance to the sun, analogous to that used in case of the moon (Art. 123), is of no value because the apparent displacement to be measured is very small, the sun is a body with no permanent surface markings, and its heat and light disturb the instruments when it has been seen (Art. 144). The distance from the earth to any other member of the system is equally useful, and in some cases the measurement of the distances to the other bodies is feasible.
Gill, at the Cape of Good Hope, measured the distance of Mars with considerable success, but its disk and red color introduced difficulties. These difficulties do not arise when the sun is considered, since it is a body like points of light, but their great distances decrease the accuracy of the results by reducing the magnitude of the quantity to be measured. However, in 1898, Witt, of Berlin, discovered a planetoid whose orbit lies largely within the orbit of Mars and which approaches closer to the earth than any other celestial body save the moon. Its nearness, its minuteness, and its absence of marked color all unite to make this object a valuable means for testing the scale of the solar system by the direct method. Hinks, of Cambridge, England, made measurements and reductions of photographs secured at many observatories, and found that the parallax of the sun, or the angle subtended by the earth's radius at the mean distance of the sun is $8^{\prime\prime}.8$, corresponding to a distance of 92,857,000 miles from the earth to the sun. This parallax shows that the sun can also be found from the aberration of light. The amount of this aberration depends upon the velocity of light and the speed with which the observer moves across the line of its rays. The velocity of light has been found with great accuracy from experiments on the surface of the earth. The amount of the aberration has been determined by observations of the stars. From
248 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cfr.vii., 150
the two sets of data the velocity of the observer can be computed. Since the length of the year is known, the length of the earth's orbit can be obtained. Then it is an easy matter, making use of the shape of the orbit, to compute the mean distance from the earth to the sun. The results obtained in this way agree with those furnished by the direct method.
Another and closely related method depends upon the determination of the earth's motion in the line of sight (Art. 226) by means of the spectroscope. Spectroscopic technique has been so highly perfected that when stars begin to set for a given position on the meridian, observations are made at short intervals until the earth's speed with its high degree of accuracy. Its velocity and period furnish the distance to the sun, as in the method depending upon the aberration, and the results are about as accurate as those furnished by any other method.
There are several other methods for finding the distance to the sun which have been employed with more or less success. One of these depends upon transit of Venus across the sun's face. Another involves the attraction of the sun for the moon. But none of them is as accurate as those which have been described.
157. The Elements of the Orbits of the Planets.---The position of a planet at any time depends upon the size, shape, and position of its orbit, together with the time when it was at a particular position, as the perihelion point. These quantities are called the elements of an orbit, and when they are given it is possible to compute the position of the planet at any time.
The size of an orbit is determined by the length of its major axis. It is an interesting and important fact that the period of revolution of a planet depends only upon the major axis of its orbit, and not upon its eccentricity or any other element. The shape of an orbit is defined by its eccentricity. This quantity is equal to one minus the ratio between the distance in its plane and the relation of its plane to some standard plane of reference. The longitude of the perihelion point
CH. VII, 157] THE SOLAR SYSTEM
define the orientation of an orbit in its plane. The plane of reference in common use is the plane of the ecliptic. The position of the plane of the orbit is defined by the location of the line of its intersection with the plane of the ecliptic and the angle between the two planes. The distance from the vernal equinox eastward to the point where the orbit of the body crosses the ecliptic from south to north is called the longitude of the ascending node, and the angle between this point and the plane of the ecliptic and the plane of the orbit is called the inclination.
In Fig. 95, $VQ$ represents the plane of the ecliptic and $SNP$ the plane of the orbit. The vernal equinox is at $V$, so that when $VQ$ is drawn through $N$, it intersects $SNP$ at $S$. Since $V$ is at the vernal equinox, the angle $VSN$ is the longitude of perihelion, and since $S$ is at the ascending node, the angle $VSN + NSP$ is the longitude of perihelion, and the angle $QNP$ is the inclination of the orbit.
The elements of the orbits of the planets, which change very slowly, are given for January 1, 1916, in Table IV.
| Planet |
Diameter |
Period |
Eccentricity |
Inclination |
Longitude |
Locus |
Longitude |
Locus |
| Mercury |
36.0 |
0.81 |
0.05620 |
7° 0' 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" |
47°29' N |
76°9' S |
334°2' |
55°58' N |
49°49' S |
334°2' |
55°58' N |
49°49' S |
334°2' |
55°58' N |
49°49' S |
334°2' |
55°58' N |
49°49' S |
334°2' |
55°58' N |
49°49' S |
334°2' |
55°58' N |
49°49' S |
334°2' |
55°58' N |
49°49' S |
334°2' |
55°58' N |
49°49' S |
334°2' |
55°58' N |
49°49' S |
334°2' |
55°58' N |
49°49' S |
334°2' td
|
**TABLE IV**
| Planet | Diameter (Millions of Miles) | Period (Years) | Eccentricity | Inclination (Degrees) | Longitude (Degrees) | Locus (Degrees) | Longitude (Degrees) | Locus (Degrees) |
|---|
| Mercury | 36.1 | 1.81 | -1.66e-11 | 7.7e-11 N | -7.7e-11 S | -7.7e-11 N | -7.7e-11 S |
|---|
| Venus | 46.7 | 2.26 | -1.66e-11 | 7.7e-11 N | -7.7e-11 S | -7.7e-11 N | -7.7e-11 S |
|---|
| Earth - Moon System* | 36.6 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 ± .2 +
250 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. viii, 157
To the elements of the orbits of the planets must be added the direction of their motion in order to be altogether complete. The result is very simple, for they all revolve in the same direction, namely, eastward.
The most interesting and important element of the planetary orbits is the mean distance. The distance of Neptune from the sun is 30 times that of the earth and nearly 80 times that of Mercury. Since the amount of light and heat received by any planet varies inversely as the square of its distance from the sun, it follows that if the units are chosen so that the amount received by the earth is unity, then the respective amounts received by the several planets are: Mercury, 6.66; Venus, 1.91; Earth, 1.00; Mars, 0.43; Jupiter, 0.037; Saturn, 0.011; Uranus, 0.0027; Neptune, 0.0011. It is seen that the average receives more than 900 times as much light and heat per unit area as Neptune does. This means that the ratio between the mean distances of these planets and Neptune's is more than 6000. Obviously, other things being equal, the climatic conditions on planets differing so greatly in distance from the sun would be enormous.
As seen from Neptune the sun presents a smaller disk than Venus does to us when nearest to the earth. It is sometimes supposed that Neptune is far away in the night of space, but this is not true. For instance, if Neptune is far from the truth, for, since the sunlight received by the earth is 600,000 times full moonlight, and Neptune gets $\frac{1}{\pi}$ as much light as the earth, it follows that the illumination of Neptune by the sun is nearly 700 times that of the earth by the brightest full moon. Another erroneous idea frequently held is that Neptune is so far away from the sun that it gets a considerable fraction of its light from other sources than the sun itself. But this is not true. For instance, if Neptune is distant from Neptune as Neptune is from the sun, consequently Neptune receives more than 80,000,000 times as much light and heat as it would if the sun were at the distance of the nearest star.
CH. VII, 157]
THE SOLAR SYSTEM
251
It is almost impossible to get a correct mental picture of the enormous dimensions of the solar system, and there are often misconceptions in regard to the relative dimensions of the orbits of the various planets. To assist in grasping these distances, suppose one has traveled sufficiently to have obtained a good knowledge of the earth's surface. Then he is in a position to attempt to appreciate the distance to the moon, which is so far that in spite of the fact it is more than 2000 miles in diameter, it is apparently covered by a one-cent piece held at the distance of 6.5 feet. In terms of the earth's dimensions, its distance is about 10 times the circumference of the earth. It is so remote that about 14 days would be required for sound to come from it to the earth. Now consider the distance to the whole distance to transmit it at the rate of a mile in 5 seconds.
Now consider the distance to the sun; it is 400 times that to the moon. If the earth and sun were put 4 inches apart on such a diagram as could be printed in this book, on the same scale the distance from the earth to the moon would be $\frac{1}{400}$ of an inch. If sound could come from the sun to the earth with the speed at which it travels in air, 15 years would be required for it to reach us. But light travels across the earth and sun. Some one, having found out at what rate motions travel along the nerve fibers from the hand to the brain, proved by calculation that if a small boy with a sufficiently long arm should reach out to the sun and burn his hand off, the sensation would not arrive at his brain so that he would be aware of his loss unless he lived to be more than 15 years of age.
The relative dimensions of the orbits of the planets can be best understood from diagrams. Unfortunately, it is not possible to represent them to scale all on the same diagram. Figure 96 shows the orbits of the first four planets, together with that of Eros, which occupies a unique position, and which has been used in getting the scale of the system. Figure 97 shows the orbits of the planets from Mars to Neptune on a
A diagram showing the relative sizes and positions of various celestial bodies.
252 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. vii, 157
scale which is about $\frac{1}{30}$ that of the preceding figure. The most noteworthy fact is the relative nearness of the four
A diagram showing the orbits of the four inner planets: Mercury, Venus, Earth, and Mars.
Fig. 96. — Orbits of the four inner planets.
inner planets and the enormous distances that separate the outer ones.
158. The Dimensions, Masses, and Rotation Periods of the Planets. — The planets Mercury and Venus have no known satellites and their masses are subject to some uncertainties. The rotation periods of Mercury and Venus are very much in doubt because of their unfavorable positions for observation, while the distances of Uranus and Neptune are so great that so far it has been impossible to
CH. VII, 139j THE SOLAR SYSTEM 255
eight planets to the same scale. It is apparent from this diagram how insignificant the earth is in comparison with the larger planets, and how small they are all together in comparison with the sun.
169. The Times for Observing the Planets. — Mercury and Venus are most decidedly suitable for observations when they are at their greatest elongations, for then they are not dimmed by the more brilliant rays of the sun. When they are east of the sun they can be seen in the evening, and when they are west of the sun they are observable only in the morning. Ordinarily the evening is more convenient for making observations than the morning, and therefore the results will be given only for this time.
Those planets whch are farther from the sun than the earth are never visible in opposition, or 180° from the sun, for then they are nearest the earth and their illuminated sides are toward the earth. When a planet is in opposition it crosses the meridian at midnight, and it can be observed late in the evening in the eastern or southern sky.
The problem arises of determining at what times Mercury and Venus are at greatest eastern elongation, and at what times the other planets are in opposition. If at the time which a planet has its greatest eastern elongation is once given, the dates of all succeeding eastern elongations can be obtained by adding to the original one multiples of its synodical period. If $S$ represents the synodical period of an inferior planet, $T$ its sidereal period, and $E$ the earth's period, the synodical period is given by (Arts. 120, 144)
$$\frac{S}{S + E} = \frac{1}{P}$$
and in the case of a superior planet the corresponding formula for the synodical period is
$$\frac{S}{S + E} = \frac{1}{P}$$
On the basis of the sidereal periods given in Table IV, these
256 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. viii, 159
formulas, and data from the American Ephemeris and Nauti-
cal Almanac, the following table has been constructed:¹
| PLANET |
EASTERN ELONGATION
(TOO OR OPPOSITION) |
SYNODIC PERIOD |
| Mercury |
Sept. 9, 1916 |
0 yr. 3 mo. 24.2 d. = 0.31726 yr |
| Venus |
April 23, 1916 |
1 yr. 7 mo. 5.7 d. = 1.39882 yr |
| Mars |
Oct. 23, 1916 |
1 yr. 7 mo. 31.4 d. = 1.40000 yr |
| Jupiter |
Oct. 23, 1916 |
1 yr. 0 mo. 3.1 d. = 1.09062 yr |
| Saturn |
Jan. 4, 1916 |
1 yr. 0 mo. 12.6 d. = 1.03514 yr |
| Uranus |
Aug. 4, 1916 |
1 yr. 0 mo. 4.3 d. = 1.01835 yr |
| Neptune |
Jan. 22, 1916 |
1 yr. 0 mo. = 1 yr. |
The superior planets are most brilliant when they are in opposition ; the inferior planets are brightest some time after their greatest eastern elongation because they are then relatively approaching the earth and their decrease in distance more than offsets their diminishing phase. For example, in 1916 Venus was at its greatest eastern elongation April 23, but kept getting brighter until May 27.
Mercury is so much nearer the sun than the earth that its greatest elongation is only about $2^{\circ}$ though it varies from $18^{\circ}$ to $28^{\circ}$ because of the eccentricity of the orbit of the planet. Consequently, it can be observed only for a very short time after the sun is far enough below the horizon for the brightest stars to be visible. Mercury at its brightness is somewhat brighter than a first-magnitude star. There is no difficulty in observing any of the other planets except Uranus which is too faint to be seen with the naked eye and invisibility without optical aid, and Neptune being still beyond them.
Venus is brilliantly white and at its brightest quite surpasses every other celestial object except the sun and moon.
Mars is of the first magnitude and decidedly red.
¹ In this table the tropical year is used and $30$ days are taken as constituting a month.
A table showing the eastern elongation dates and synodic periods for various planets.
CH. VII, 100] THE SOLAR SYSTEM 257
Jupiter is white and next to Venus in brilliancy. Saturn is of the first magnitude and slightly yellowish.
160. The Planetoids. — On examination it is found that the distance of each planet from the sun is roughly twice that of the preceding, with the exception of Jupiter, whose distance is about 3.5 times that of Mars. In 1772 Titius derived a series of numbers by a simple law which gave the distances of the planets (Uranus and Neptune were not known then) with considerable accuracy, except that there was a number for the vacant space between Mars and Jupiter. This law was as follows: Let $x$ be the sum of the num-
bers 0, 3, 6, 12, 24, 48, the sums thus obtained are nearly proportional to the distances of the planets from the sun.
This law, commonly called Bode's law, because the writings of Bode made it widely known, rests on no scientific basis and entirely breaks down for Neptune, but it played an important rôle in two discoveries. One of these was that both Adams and Leverrier assigned to each planet elements of its orbit from perturbations of Uranus (Art. 151). The other discovery to which Bode's law contributed was that of the planetoids.
Toward the end of the eighteenth century the idea became widespread among astronomers that there was probably an undiscovered planet between Mars and Jupiter. In this time there were five members of the Bode series. In 1800 a number of German astronomers laid plans to search for it, but before their work was actually begun Piazzi, at Palermo, on January 1, 1801, the first day of the nineteenth century, made the discovery when he noticed an object (apparently a star) where none had previously been seen. Piazzi called the new planet, which was of small dimensions, Ceres.
After the discovery of Ceres had been made, but before any further observations could be made owing to lack of communication of those days, the philosopher Hegel published a paper in which he claimed to have proved by
s
258 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. viii, 160
the most certain and conclusive philosophical reasoning that there were no new planets, and he ridiculed his astronomical colleagues for their folly in searching for them.
Piazzi observed Ceres for a short time and then he was taken ill. By the time he had recovered, the earth had moved forward in its orbit to a position from which the planetoid could no longer be seen. In a little less than a year the earth was again in a favorable position for observa-tions of Ceres, but the problem of picking it up out of the countless stars that fill the sky remained. The difficulty is distinguished except by what its motions was, almost as difficult as that of making the original discovery. The difficulty was entirely overcome by Gauss, then a young man of 24, but later one of the greatest mathematicians of his time, for, under the stimulus of this special problem, he devised a procedure for determining the elements of the orbit of a planet from only three observations. After the ele-ments of the orbit of a body known, its position can be computed at any time. Gauss determined the elements of the orbit of Ceres, and his calculation of its position led to its rediscovery on the last day of the year.
On March 28, 1802, Olbers discovered a second planetoid, which he named Pallas; on September 2, 1804, Harding found Juno; and on March 29, 1807, observers picked up a fourth planetoid, which they named Icarus. In 1814 Olbers discovered Astraea, after a long search of 15 years. In 1847 three more were discovered, and every year since that time at least one has been discovered.
In 1891 a new epoch was started by Wolf, of Heidelberg, who discovered a planetoid by photography. The method is simply to expose a plate two or three hours with the telescope pointed at a star. When the plates are joined but the planetoids leave short trails, or streaks, Fig. 99, because they are moving among the stars. There are now all together more than 800 known planetoids.
After the first two planetoids had been discovered it was
CH. VIII, 160] THE SOLAR SYSTEM 259
supposed that they might be simply the fragments of an original large planet which had been torn to pieces by an explosion. If such were the case, the different parts in their orbits around the sun would all pass through the position occupied by the planet at the time of the explosion; therefore, for some time the search for new planetoids was largely confined to the regions about the points where the orbits of Ceres and Pallas intersect. But this theory of their origin has been completely abandoned. The orbits of Eros and two other planetoids are interior to the orbit of Mars, while many are within 75,000,000 miles of this planet; on the other hand, many others are nearly 300,000,000 miles farther out, and the aphelia of four are even beyond the orbit of Jupiter. These orbits vary in shape from almost perfect circles to elongated ellipses. Their eccentricities are 0.83 to 0.40. The average eccentricity of their orbits is about 0.14, or approximately twice that of the orbits of the planets. Their inclinations to the ecliptic range all the way from zero to $35^\circ$, with an average of about $9^\circ$.
Fig. 99.—Photograph of stars showing a planetoid (Egeria) trail in the center of the plate. Photographed by Parkhurst at the Perkins Observatory.
A photograph showing a planetoid (Egeria) trail in the center of a plate.
260 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cr. vii, 160
The orbits of the planetoids are distributed by no means uniformly over the belts which they occupy. Kirkwood long ago called attention to the fact that the planetoids are infrequent or entirely lacking in the distances at which their periods would be $1$, $2$, $3$, . . . of Jupiter's period. The numerous discoveries since the application of photography have still further emphasized the existence of these remarkable gaps. It is supposed that the perturbations by Jupiter during indefinite ages have cleared these regions of the bodies that may once have been circulating in them, but the question has not yet been definitely settled.
The diameters of Ceres, Pallas, Vesta, and Juno were measured by Barnard with the 36-inch telescope of the Lick Observatory, and he found that they are respectively 485, 304, 243, and 118 miles. There are probably a few more whose diameters exceed 100 miles, but the great majority are undoubtedly much smaller. Probably the diameters of the fainter of those which have been photographed do not exceed a mile.
By 1898 the known planetoids were so numerous and their orbits caused so much trouble, because of their large perturbations by Jupiter, that astronomers were on the point of neglecting them, when Witt, of Berlin, found one within the orbit of Mars, which he named Eros. At once great interest was aroused in this new discovery. Photographs had been taken at the Harvard College Observatory in 1893, 1894, and 1896, the image of Eros was found several times, and from these positions a very accurate orbit was computed by Chandler. The mean distance of Eros from the sun is 135,500,000 miles, but its distance varies considerably because its orbit has the high eccentricity of 0.22; its inclination to the ecliptic is about 11°. At its nearest, Eros comes within 7 million miles of Earth, and then conditions are particularly favorable for getting photographs of the solar system (Art. 156); and at its aphelion it is 24,000,000 miles beyond the orbit of Mars (Fig. 96).
CL VIII. 131]
THE SOLAR SYSTEM
261
Not only is Eros remarkable because of the position of its orbit, but in February and March of 1901 it varied in brightness both extensively and rapidly. The period was 2 hr. 38 min., and at minimum light was less than one half that at maximum. By May, variability increased.
Several suggestions were made for explaining this remarkable phenomenon, such as that the planetoid is very different in reflecting power on different parts, or that it is really composed of two bodies very near together, revolving so that the plane of their orbit at certain times passes through the earth, but the cause of this remarkable variation in brightness has not been discovered.
**161 The Question of Undiscovered Planets.** — The great planets Uranus and Neptune have been discovered in modern times, and the question arises if there may not be others at present unknown. Obviously any unknown planets must be either very small, or very near the sun, or beyond the orbit of Neptune, for otherwise they already would have been seen.
The revolution of the orbit of Mercury moves somewhat faster than it would if this planet were acted on only by known forces. One explanation offered for this peculiarity of its motion is that it may be disturbed by the attraction of a planet whose orbit lies between it and the sun. A planet in this position would be observed only with difficulty because of its elongation from the sun would always be small, and a planet of this size could not exist without the existence of an intra-Mercurian planet; and several times it was supposed one had been observed. But photographs have been taken of the region around the sun at all recent total eclipses, and in no case has any object within the orbit of Mercury been found. It is reasonably certain that there is no object in this region more than 20 miles in diameter.
This fact makes the existence of a smaller Jupiter-like planet even more interesting and much more difficult to answer. There is no reason to suppose that Neptune is the most re-
262 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ca. viii, 161
mote planet, and the gravitative control of the sun extends enormously beyond it. There are two lines of evidence, besides direct observations, that bear on the question. If there is any mass of considerable mass beyond the orbit of Neptune, it will in all probability be found either by the observations of Neptune. Since Neptune was discovered it has made less than half a revolution, and the fact that its observed motion so far agrees with theory is non conclusive evidence against the existence of a planet beyond. In fact, there are some very slight residual errors in the theory of the motion of Uranus, and from them Tödler inferred that there is probably a planet revolving around the sun about 50 astronomical units in a period of about 350 years. The conclusion is uncertain, though it may be correct. A much more elaborate investigation has been made by Lowell, who finds that the slight discrepancies in the motion of Uranus are notably reduced by the assumption of the existence of a planet at the distance of 44 astronomical units (period 250 years) whose mass is greater than that of the earth and less than that of Venus.
It will be seen (Art. 160) that planets sometimes capture comets and reduce their orbits so that their aphelia are near the orbits of their captors. Jupiter has a large family of comets, and Saturn and Uranus have smaller ones. As far back as 1880, Forbes, of Edinburgh, inferred from a study of the orbits of those comets whose aphelia are beyond the orbit of Saturn that they had removed from most of the solar family revolving at the distances of 100 and 300 astronomical units in the immense periods of 1000 and 5000 years. W. H. Pickering has made an extensive statistical study of the orbits of comets and infers the probable existence of three or four trans-Neptunian planets. The data are so uncertain that the correctness of the conclusion is much in doubt.
162. The Zodiacal Light and the Gegenschein.---The zodiacal light is a soft, hazy wedge of light stretching up
cn. viii, 162] THE SOLAR SYSTEM 263
from the horizon along the ecliptic just as twilight is ending or as dawn is beginning. Its base is 20° or 30° wide and it generally can be followed 90° from the sun, and sometimes it can be seen as a narrow, very faint band 3° or 4° wide entirely around the sky. It is very difficult to decide precisely where the zodiacal light begins or ends, but it usually comes from an illumination perhaps a little brighter than the Milky Way into the dark sky.
The best time to observe the zodiacal light is when the ecliptic is nearly perpendicular to the horizon, for then it is less interfered with by the dense lower air. In the spring the sun is very near the vernal equinox. At this time of year the ecliptic comes up after sunset from the western horizon and sets before sunrise from the eastern horizon. Consequently, the spring months are most favorable for observing the zodiacal light in the evening, and for analogous reasons the autumn months are most favorable for observing it in the morning. It cannot be seen in strong moonlight.
The gegenschein, or counterglow, is a very faint patch of light in the sky on the ecliptic exactly opposite to the sun. It is in form, from 5° to 20° in length along the ecliptic, and about half as wide. It was first discovered by Broersen in 1854, and later it was found independently by Backhouse and Barnard. It is so excessively faint that it has been observed by only a few people.
The cause of the gegenschein is not certainly known. It has been suggested that it is a sort of swelling in the solar atmosphere which may be a continuation of the zodiacal light. This explanation calls for an explanation of the zodiacal light, which, of course, might well be independently asked for. The zodiacal light is almost certainly due to the reflection of light from a great number of small particles circulating around the sun in the plane of the earth's orbit, and extending a little beyond the orbit of the earth. An observer at O, Fig. 100, would see a considerable num-
A diagram showing an observer at point O looking towards a bright object in space.
264 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. viii, 162
ber of these illuminated particles above his horizon $H$; and with the conditions as represented in the diagram, the zodi-
Fig. 109. — Explanation of the zodiacal light.
acal band would extend faintly beyond the zenith and across the sun.
It is not clear from this theory of the zodiacal light why there should be a condensation exactly opposite the sun. But at a point 930,000 miles from the earth, which is beyond the apex of its orbit, there is no such region. This is in consequence of the combined forces of the earth and sun, wandering particles tend to circulate in a sort of dynamic whirlpool. It has been suggested that the circulating parti-
cles which produce the zodiacal light are caught in this whirl and are virtually condensed enough to produce the observed phenomenon of the gegenschein.
XII. QUESTIONS
1. Which of the methods of measuring the distance from the earth to the sun depend upon our knowledge of the size of the earth, and which are independent of it?
2. Make a single drawing showing the orbits of all the planets to the same scale. On this scale, what are the diameters of the earth and of each planet?
3. If the sun is represented by a globe 1 foot in diameter, what would be the diameters and distances of the planets on the same scale?
4. How long would it take to travel a distance equal to that from the sun to the earth at the rate of 60 miles per hour? How much would it cost at 2 cents per mile?
5. The diameter of Jupiter as seen from the earth is 26.7. What is its magnitude as seen from Neptune? As seen from Neptu-
ne, how many times brighter is the sun than Sirius?
6. If Jupiter were twice as far from the sun, how much fainter would it be when it is in opposition?
A diagram showing a circle representing Earth's orbit around Sun, with a smaller circle representing Jupiter's orbit around Earth. The Sun is at one end of both circles, and Jupiter is at another end of its orbit. The diagram also shows a line extending from Jupiter's position on its orbit to Earth's position on its orbit, indicating their relative positions.
CH. VIII, 163]
THE SOLAR SYSTEM
265
7. How great are the variations in the distances of the planets from the sun which are due to the eccentricities of their orbits?
8. Suppose the earth and Neptune were in a line between the sun and the nearest star, how much farther would they appear from Neptune than from the earth?
9. In what respects are all the planets similar? In what respects are they different? How are they similar and different from the four outer planets? In what respects are the four outer planets similar and different from the four inner planets?
10. Find the velocities with which the planets move, assuming that they travel in perfect circles.
11. Find the next dates at which Mercury and Venus will have their greatest eastern elongations, and at which Mars, Jupiter, and Saturn will be in opposition.
12. If possible, observe the zodiacal light and describe its location and characteristics.
CHAPTER IX
THE PLANETS
I. MERCURY AND VENUS
163. The Phases of Mercury and Venus. — The inferior planets Mercury and Venus are alike in several respects and may conveniently be treated together. Their both have phases somewhat analogous to those of the moon. When they are in inferior conjunction, that is at $A$, Fig. 101, their dark side is toward the earth and their phase is new. Since the orbits of these planets are inclined somewhat to the plane of the ecliptic, they do not in general pass across the sun's disk. If they do not make a transit, they present an extremely thin crescent when they have the same longitude as the sun. As they move out from $A$ toward $B$ their crescents increase and their disks, seen from the earth, become half illuminated at their greatest elongation at $B$. During their motion from inferior conjunction at $A$ to their greatest elongation at $B$, and on to their superior conjunction at $C$, their distances from the earth constantly increase, and this increase of distance to a considerable extent offsets the advantage arising from the fact that a larger part of their illuminated areas are visible. In order that an inferior planet may be seen, not only must its illuminated side be at least partly
Fig. 101. — Phases of an inferior planet.
295
CH. IX, 163]
THE PLANETS
267
toward the earth, but it must not be too nearly in a line with the sun. For example, a planet at C, Fig. 101, has its illuminated side toward the sun, but it is invisible because it is on the same side as the sun.
The variations in the apparent dimensions of Venus are greater than those of Mercury because, when Venus is near- est the earth, it is much nearer than the closest approach of Mercury, and when it is farthest from the earth, it is much farther than the most remote point in Mercury's orbit.
At the time of inferior conjunction the distance of Venus is 25,700,000 miles, while that of Mercury is 65,000,000 miles;
at the opposition respectively distances are 160,100,000 and 128,900,000 miles. These numbers are modified somewhat by the eccentricities of the orbits of these three bodies, and especially by the large eccentricity of the orbit of Mercury.
Mercury and Venus transit across the sun's disk only when they pass through inferior conjunction with the sun near one or other node of their orbits. The sun is near the node of Mercury's orbit in May and November, and consequently this planet transits the sun only if it is in inferior conjunction at one of these times. Since there is no simple relation between the period of Mercury and that of the earth, the transits of Mercury do not occur very frequently. A transit of Mercury is followed by another at the same node of its orbit after an interval of 7, 15, or 46 years, according to whether we consider its revolution to be nearly 22, 41, and 146 synodic revolutions of the planet. Moreover, there may be transits also when Mercury is near the other node of its orbit. The next transit of Mercury will occur on May 7, 1924, and on November 8, 1927. Mercury is so small that its transits can be observed only with a telescope.
The transit of Venus, which occur in June and December, are even more infrequent than those of Mercury. The transits of Venus occur in cycles whose intervals are, starting
268 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. ix, 163
with a June transit, $s$, 105.5, 8, and 121.5 years. The last two transits of Venus occurred on December 8, 1874, and on December 24, 1882. The next two will occur on June 8, 2004, and on June 5, 2012.
The chief scientific use of the transits of Mercury and Venus are that they give a means of determining the positions of these planets, they make it possible to investigate their atmospheres, and they were formerly used indirectly for determining the scale of the solar system (Art. 156).
164. The Albedoes and Atmospheres of Mercury and Venus.
The albedo of a body is the fraction of light which it reflects to that which it absorbs. The amount of light reflected depends to a considerable extent upon whether or not the body is surrounded by a cloud-filled atmosphere. A body which has no atmosphere and a rough and broken surface, like the moon, has a low albedo, while one covered with an atmosphere, especially if it is filled with partially condensed water vapor, has a higher reflecting power. Every day is familiar to us with the fact that the sun's rays are often reflected from the summer sky shine as white as snow when illuminated fully by the sun's rays. It was found by Abbott that their albedo is about 0.65. If an observer could see the earth from the outside, its brightest parts would undoubtedly be those portions of its surface which are covered with snow.
The albedo of Mercury, according to the careful work of Müller, of Potsdam, is about 0.07, while that of Venus is 0.60. This is presumptive evidence that the atmosphere of Mercury is either very thin or entirely absent, and that that of Venus is abundant.
It follows from the kinetic theory of gases (Art. 32) and the low surface gravity of Mercury (Art. 158, Table V) that Mercury probably does not have sufficient gravitational con- straint to retain any appreciable quantity of gas in its atmosphere. This inference is confirmed by the fact that, when Mercury transits the sun, no bright ring is seen around it such as would
CIL IX. 165f.
THE PLANETS
269
be observed if it were surrounded by any considerable atmosphere. Moreover, Müller found that the amount of light received from Mercury at its various phases proves that it is reflected from a solid surface of the planet. This fact leads to the conclusion that Mercury has an extremely tenuous atmosphere, or perhaps none at all.
The evidence regarding the atmosphere of Venus is just the opposite of that encountered in the case of Mercury. Its considerable mass and surface gravity, approximating those of the earth, naturally lead to the conclusion that it can retain an atmosphere comparable to our own. But the arguments which have been adduced in support of this argument, for, when Venus transits the sun, its disk is seen to be surrounded by an illuminated atmospheric ring. Besides this, when it is not in transit, but near inferior conjunction, the illuminated ring of its atmosphere is sometimes seen to extend considerably beyond the horns of the crescent. Also, the brilliancy of Venus decreases somewhat from the center toward the margin of its disk where the absorption of light takes place. These and other meteorological observations, which are as yet somewhat doubtful, point to the conclusion that the atmosphere of Venus contains water vapor. Taking all the evidence together, we are justified in the conclusion that Venus has an atmospheric envelope corresponding in extent, and possibly in composition, to that of the earth.
**Surface Markings and Rotation of Mercury.** — The first astronomer to observe systematically and continuously the surface markings of the sun, moon, and planets was Schröter (1745-1816). He was an astronomer of rare enthusiasm and great patience, but seems sometimes to have been led by his lively imagination to erroneous conclusions.
Schröter concluded from observations of Mercury made in 1800, that the period of rotation of this planet is 24 hours and 4 minutes. This result was quite generally accepted
270 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cu. ix, 165]
until after Schiaparelli took up his systematic observations of the planets, at Milan, about 1880. Schiaparelli found that Mercury could be much better seen in the daytime, when it was near the meridian than at night, owing to the illumination of the sky being found to be a much less serious obstacle than the absorption and irregularities of refraction which were encountered when Mercury was near the horizon. His experience in this matter has been confirmed by later astronomers.
Schiaparelli came to the conclusion, from elusive and vague markings on the planet, that its axis is essentially perpendicular to the plane of its orbit, and that its periods of rotation and revolution are the same. These results are agreed to by Lowell, who has carefully observed the planet with an excellent 24-inch telescope at Flagstaff, Ariz. Although the observations are very difficult, we are perhaps entitled to conclude that the same face of Mercury is always toward the sun.
**165. The Seasons of Mercury.** — If the period of rotation of Mercury is the same as that of its revolution, its seasons are due entirely to its varying distance from the sun and the varying rates at which it moves in its orbit in harmony with the law of areas. The eccentricity of the orbit of Mercury is so great that at perihelion its distance from the sun is only two thirds of that at aphelion. Since the amount of light and heat the planet receives inversely as the square of its distance from the sun, it follows that the illumination of Mercury at aphelion is only four thirds of that at perihelion. It is obvious that this factor alone would make an important seasonal change.
Whatever the period of rotation of Mercury may be, its rate of rotation must be essentially uniform. Since it moves in its orbit so as to fulfill the law of areas, its motion is continuous, and nothing like a sudden acceleration or deceleration can occur. The result of this is that not exactly the same side of Mercury is always toward the sun, even if its periods
A diagram showing the orbit of Mercury around the sun.
CL. IX, 107]
THE PLANETS
271
of revolution and rotation are the same. The mathematical discussion shows that, at its greatest, it is 23°7 ahead of its mean position in its orbit, and consequently, at such a time, the sun shines around the surface of Mercury 23°7 beyond the point its rays would reach if its orbit were strictly a circle. Similarly, the earth is 23°4 ahead of its mean position in its orbit.
There is, Mercury has a libration (Art. 129) of 23°7. If Mercury's period of rotation equals its period of revolution, there are, therefore, 132°6 of longitude on the planet on which the sun always shines, an equal amount on which it never shines, and two zones 47°4 wide in which there is alternating day and night with a period equal to the period of the planet's revolution around the sun.
If the periods of rotation and revolution of Mercury are almost equal, the planet is continually subject to its burning rays, which are approximately ten times as intense as they are at the distance of the earth, and, moreover, they are never cut off by clouds or reduced by an appreciable atmosphere. The only possible conclusion is that the temperature of this portion of the planet's surface is very high. On the side on which the sun never shines the temperature must be extremely low, for there is no atmosphere to carry heat from one part of the surface to another in that which may be condensed from the surface into the interior of the planet. The intermediate zones are subject to alternations of heat and cold with a period equal to the period of revolution of the planet, and every temperature between the two extremes is found in some zone.
107. The Surface Markings and Rotation of Venus.
The observations made concerning Venus and the conclusions regarding its rotation are almost the same as in the case of Mercury. As early as 1740 J. J. Cassini inferred from the observations of his predecessors that Venus rotates on its axis in 23 hours and 20 minutes. About 1790 Schröter concluded that its rotation period is about 23 hours and 21 minutes, and that the inclination of the plane of its equator
272 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. ix, 167]
to that of its orbit is $3^\circ$. These results were generally accepted until 1880, when Schiaparelli announced that Venus, like Mercury, always has the same face toward the sun.
The observations of Schiaparelli were verified by himself in 1895, and they have been more or less definitely confirmed by Perrotin, Tacchini, Massefi, Carulli, Lowell, and others. However, it must be remarked that the amount of interference with the rotation of Venus which these observers seem to have observed is very doubtful. Moreover, recent direct observations by a number of experienced astronomers point to a period of rotation of about 23 or 24 hours.
The spectroscopy can also be applied under favorable conditions to determine the rate at which a body rotates. In 1900 Belpolinsky concluded from observations of this sort that the period of rotation of Venus was about 24 hours. The observations by Sipher, at the Lowell Observatory, show no evidence of a short period of rotation. The preponderance of evidence seems to be in favor of the long period of rotation, but the conclusion is at present very uncertain.
**168. The Seasons of Venus.** — The character of the seasons of Venus depends very much upon whether the planet's period of rotation is approximately 24 hours or is equal to its orbital period. If it is equal to its orbital period, then the shorter period and if its equator is somewhat inclined to the plane of its orbit, the seasons must be quite similar to those of the earth, though the temperature is probably some what higher because the planet is nearer to the sun. On the other hand, if the same face of Venus is always toward the sun, then the conditions must be more like those on Mercury, though the temperature cannot be so extreme because its atmosphere reduces the temperature on one side toward the sun and raises it on the opposite side by carrying heat from the warmer side to the cooler.
Suppose the periods of rotation and revolution of Venus are equal. Since the orbit of Venus is very nearly circular, it is subject to only a small libration and only a very narrow zone
CH. IX, 109]
THE PLANETS
273
around it has alternately day and night. The position of the sun in its sky is nearly fixed and the climate at every point on its surface is remarkably uniform. There must be a system of atmospheric currents of a regularity not known on the earth, and it has been suggested that all the water on Venus is condensed into a single atmosphere which circulates and precipitated there so long. This conclusion is not necessarily true, for it seems likely that the air would ascend on the heated side and lose its moisture by precipitation before the high currents which would go to the dark side had proceeded far on their way.
Considered as a whole, Venus is more like the earth than any other planet; and, so far as can be determined, it is in a condition in which life might exist. In fact, if any other planet in our solar system is inhabited, that one is probably Venus. It must be added, however, that there is no direct evidence whatever to support the supposition that there is life upon its surface.
II. Mars
169. The Satellites of Mars. — In August, 1877, Asaph Hall, at Washington, discovered two very small satellites revolving eastward around Mars, sensibly in the plane of its equator. They are so minute and so near the bright planet that they can be seen only with a large telescope, and usually it is advantageous, when observing them, to obscure Mars by a small screen placed in the focal plane. These satellites are called Phobos and Deimos. The only way to determine their distance from the earth is by finding how much they reflect to the earth. Though Phobos is considerably brighter than Deimos, its diameter probably does not exceed 10 miles.
Not only are the satellites of Mars very small, but in other respects they present only a rough analogy to the moon revolving around the earth. The distance of Phobos from the center of Mars is only 5850 miles, while that of Deimos is 14,565 miles. That is, Phobos is only 3860 miles from the
A diagram showing the relative sizes and distances of Phobos and Deimos from Mars.
274 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cc. ix, 169
surface of the planet. The curvature of the planet's surface is such that Phobos could not be seen by an observer from latitudes greater than 68° 15' north or south of the planet's equator. The relative dimensions of Mars and the orbits of its satellites are shown in Fig. 102.
As was seen in Art. 194, the period of a satellite depends upon the mass of the planet around which it revolves and upon its distance from the planet's center. Notwithstanding the small mass of Mars, its satel- lites are so close that their periods of revolution are very short, the period of Phobos being 7 hrs. 39 m., and that of Deimos being 30 hrs. 18 m. Since Mars ro- tates on its axis in 24 hrs. and 37 m., Phobos makes more than 3 revolutions during one rotation. It therefore rises in the west, passes eastward across the sky, and sets in the east. Here is an example in which the direction of apparent motion and actual motion are the same. The period of Phobos from meridian to meridian is 11 hrs. and 7 m. On the other hand, Deimos rises in the east and sets in the west, a period from meridian to meridian of 131 hrs. and 14 m.
**170. The Rotation of Mars.** — In 1660 Hooke, an English observer, and Casini, at Paris, saw dark streaks on the ruddy disk of Mars, and these features of the planet's sur- face are so definite and permanent that even to-day astrono- mers can recognize the objects which these men observed and drew. Some of them are shown in Fig. 103, which is a
Mars with orbits of Deimos and Phobos.
Fig. 102.—Mars and the orbits of its satellites.
ix
CL IX, 170]
THE PLANETS
275
series of 9 photographs, taken one after the other at short intervals, by Barnard, at the Yerkes Observatory. By comparing observations at one time with those made at a later date the period of rotation of the planet can be found. The period of rotation is observable in the short interval covered by the photographs in Fig. 103. Hooke
A series of six photographs of Mars, showing its phases.
Fig. 103. — Mars. Photographed by Barnard with the 60-inch telescope of the Yerkes Observatory, Sept. 28, 1900.
and Cassini soon discovered that Mars turns on its axis in a period of a little more than 24 hrs. By comparing their observations with those of the present day it is found that its period of rotation is 24 hrs. 37 m. 22.7 secs. The high order of accuracy of this result is a consequence of the fact that the importance of the errors of the observations diminishes as the time over which they extend increases.
The inclination of the plane of the equator to Mars' to the plane of its orbit is between 25° and 24°. The inclination cannot be determined as accurately as the period of
276 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch ix, 170
rotation because the only advantage of a long series of observations consists in their number. But, in spite of its uncertainty, the obliquity of the ecliptic of Mars to its equator is certainly approximately equal to that of the earth, and, consequently, the seasonal changes are qualitatively similar. The only real difference is that the period of Mars is about 23 months, and, therefore, while its day is only a little longer than that of the earth, its year is nearly twice as long. It is not meant to imply by these statements that the climate of Mars is similar to that of the earth. Its distance from the sun is so much greater that the amount of light and heat it receives per unit area is only about 0.43 of that which the earth receives.
171. The Albedo and Atmosphere of Mars. — According to the observations of Müller, the albedo of Mars is 0.15, which indicates probably a thin atmosphere on the planet.
The surface gravity of Mars is only 0.36 that of the earth, and, consequently, it would be expected on the basis of the kinetic theory of gases that it might retain some atmosphere, though this has never been observed. The observations of the planet confirm this conclusion. In this first place, its surface can nearly always be seen without appreciable interference from atmospheric phenomena. If the earth were seen from a distant planet, such as Venus, not only would the clouds now and then entirely shut off its surface from view, but the reflection and absorption of light in regions where there were no clouds would probably make it impossible to see it directly anything like as well as it does.
The fact that Mars has a rare atmosphere is also proved by the suddenness with which it cuts off the light from stars when it passes between them and the earth. Those planets which have extensive atmospheres, such as Jupiter, extinguish the light from the stars more gradually. If the atmosphere of Mars, relatively to its mass, were of the same density as that of the earth, it would be rarer at the surface
CH. IX, 172]
THE PLANETS
277
of the planet than our atmosphere is at the top of the loftiest mountains.
A number of lines of evidence have been given for the conclusion that the atmosphere of Mars is not extensive. The question occasionally arises whether it has any atmospheres at all, because faint clouds, possibly of dust or mist, have often been observed on its surface. They are very common along the borders of the bright caps which cover its poles. Another related phenomenon which is very remarkable and not easy to explain is that, sometimes for considerable periods, the planet's whole disk is dim and obscure as though covered by a thin mist.
As to the cause of this obscuri- tion is not known, it is supposed that it is a phenomenon of the atmosphere of the planet.
Fig. 104. Barnard's drawings of Mars.
These show this Mars undergoes seasonal changes, not only in the polar caps, which will be considered in the next article, but also even in conspicuous markings of other types. Figure 104 gives three drawings of the same side of Mars by Barnard, on September 23, October 22, and October 28, 1894, showing notable temporary changes in its appearance.
172. The Polar Caps and the Temperature of Mars.—The surface of Mars appears to be uniformly covered in color, but its polar regions during their winter seasons are covered with snow-white mantles. One of these so-called polar caps sometimes develops in the course of two or three days over an area reaching down from the pole 25° to 35°; it remains undiminished in brilliancy during the long winter of the planet; and, as the spring advances, it gradually
A black and white drawing of a Martian landscape with polar caps.
A black and white drawing of a Martian landscape with polar caps.
A black and white drawing of a Martian landscape with polar caps.
278 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. ix, 172
diminishes in size, contracting first around the edges; it then breaks up more or less, and it sometimes entirely disappears in the late summer.
After the southern polar cap has shrunk to the dimensions given by Barnard's observation of August 13, 1894, Fig. 105, a elongated white patch is found to be left behind the retreating white sheet. The same thing was observed in the same place at the corresponding Martian season in 1892, and also at later oppositions. This means that the phenomenon is not an accident, but that it depends upon the nature of the surface of Mars. Barnard has suggested that there may be an elevated region in the plane of the polar sphere observed where the snow or frost remains until after it has entirely disappeared in the valleys. At any rate, this phenomenon strongly points to the conclusion that there are considerable irregularities in the surface of Mars, though on the whole it is probably much smoother than the earth.
This is an important point which must be borne in mind in interpreting other things observed upon the surface of the planet.
Fig. 105. — Disappearance of polar cap of Mars (Barnard).
|
MAY 21 |
JULY 2 |
JULY 8 |
JULY 29 |
AUG. 7 |
AUG. 13 |
SEPT. 7 |
OCT. 7 |
|
1904 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
MAY 21 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
JULY 2 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
JULY 8 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
JULY 29 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
AUG. 7 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
AUG. 13 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
SEPT. 7 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
OCT. 7 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
CH. IX, 172]
THE PLANETS
279
The polar cap around the south pole of Mars has been more thoroughly studied than the one at the north pole because the south pole is turned toward the earth when Mars is in opposition near the perihelion point of its orbit. The eccentricity of the orbit of this planet is so great that its aphelion (which is near the aphelion of the earth's orbit) is more than 23,000,000 miles less than when it is at its perihelion. However, in the course of immense time the mutual perturbations of the planets will so change the orbit of Mars that its northern polar region will be more favorably situated for observations from the earth than its southern.
If the polar caps of Mars are due to snow, there must be water vapor in their composition. The spectroscope is an instrument which under suitable conditions enables the astronomer to determine the constitution of the atmosphere of a celestial body from which he receives light. Mars is not well adapted to the purpose because, in the first place, the light received from it is only reflected sunlight which may have traversed more or less of its shallow and tenuous atmosphere before reaching us. In addition, much of the earth itself contains usually a large amount of water vapor. It is not easy to make sure that the absorption spectral lines (Art. 225) may not be due altogether to the water vapor in the earth's atmosphere.
The early spectroscopic investigations of Huggins and Vogel pointed toward the existence of water on Mars; the later ones by Keeler and Campbell, with much more powerful instruments, have failed to confirm this hypothesis; have the opposite result; but the spectrograms obtained by Slipher at the Lowell Observatory, under exceptionally favorable instrumental and climatic conditions, again indicate water on Mars. In view of the difficulties of the problem, a negative result could scarcely be regarded as being conclusive evidence of the entire absence of water on Mars, while evidence of a small amount of water vapor in its atmosphere
280 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cc. ix, 172]
is not unreasonable and is quite in harmony with the phenomena of its polar caps.
The distance of Mars from the sun is so great that it receives only about 0.43 as much light and heat per unit area as is received by the earth. The question then arises whether its atmosphere, if any, will, partly, or entirely, disappear, while the poles of the earth are perpetually buried in ice and snow. The responses to this question have been various, many of them ignoring the fundamental physical principles on which a correct answer must be based.
In the first place, consider the problem of determining what the average temperature of Mars would be if its atmosphere were entirely absent. We may suppose those like those of the earth. That is, let us find what the temperature of the earth would be if its distance from the sun were equal to that of Mars. The amount of heat a planet radiates into space on the average equals that which it receives, for otherwise its temperature would continually increase or diminish. Therefore, the amount of heat Mars radiates per unit area is on the average 0.43 as much as that which the earth does. Now the amount of heat a body radiates depends on the character of its surface and on its temperature. In this calculation the surfaces of Mars and the earth are assumed to be alike. According to Stefan's law, which has been verified both theoretically and experimentally, the radiation of a black body varies as the fourth power of its absolute temperature. Or, the absolute temperature of two black bodies are as the fourth powers of their mean temperatures.
Now apply this proportion to the case of Mars and the earth. On the Fahrenheit scale the mean annual surface temperature of the whole earth is about 60°, or 28° below freezing. The absolute zero on the Fahrenheit scale is 491 below freezing. Therefore, the mean temperature of the earth on the Fahrenheit scale counted from the absolute zero is about 491 - 28° = 463°. Let $x$ represent the absolute temperature of Mars; then, under the assumption
cx. ix. 172j
THE PLANETS
281
that its surface is like that of the earth, the proportion becomes
$$z : 519 = \sqrt{63} : \sqrt{1},$$
from which it is found that $z = 420$. That is, under these hypotheses, the mean surface temperature of Mars comes out $491^\circ - 420^\circ = 71$ below freezing, or $71^\circ - 32^\circ = 39^\circ$ below zero Fahrenheit.
The results just obtained can lay no claim to any particular degree of accuracy because of the uncertain hypotheses on which they rest. But it does not seem that the hypothesis that the surfaces of Mars and the earth radiate similarly can be enough in error to change the results by very many degrees. If the atmosphere of Mars were of the same consistence as that of the earth, and had the same density, its actual temperature would be lower than that found by the computation. On the other hand, if the atmosphere of Mars contained an abundance of gases which strongly absorb and retain heat, such as water vapor and carbon dioxide, its mean temperature might be considerably above $-39^\circ$. But, taking all these possibilities into consideration, it seems to be certain that the mean temperature of Mars is considerably below zero Fahrenheit. The question then arises how its polar cap can almost, or entirely, disappear each summer.
The fundamental principles on which precipitation and evaporation depend can be understood by considering these phenomena in ordinary meteorology. If there is a large quantity of water vapor in the air, and the temperature falls so low that condensation begins, but the freezing point has not been reached, and the result is rain. On the other hand, if the amount of water vapor in the air is small, there is no precipitation until after the temperature has descended below the freezing point of water. In this case when precipitation occurs it is in the form of snow or frost.
The reverse process is similar. Suppose the temperature of snow is slowly being increased. If there is only a very
282 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. ix, 172]
little water vapor in the air surrounding it, the snow evaporates into water vapor without first melting. On the other hand, if the atmosphere contains an abundance of water vapor, the snow does not evaporate until after its temperature has risen above the freezing point. But at the freezing point, all the water vapor is water.
The gist of the whole matter is this: If the water vapor in the atmosphere is abundant, precipitation and evaporation take place above the freezing point; and if it is scarce, precipitation and evaporation take place below the freezing point. The temperature at which these processes begin depends only on the density of water vapor present and not at all upon the constitution and density of the remainder of the atmosphere. For example, snow evaporates (or sublimates) at $-35^{\circ}$ Fahrenheit when its pressure is less than 0.00018 of ordinary atmospheric pressure; or, if this is the water-vapor pressure and the temperature falls below $-35^{\circ}$, snow is precipitated. Similarly, water evaporates at $80^{\circ}$ Fahrenheit if the pressure of the water above it is less than 0.034 of atmospheric pressure; or, with this pressure of water vapor present, if the temperature falls below $80^{\circ}$. This explains why the earth's atmosphere in the whole is much dryer in the winter than in the summer.
The application to Mars is simple. Suppose its polar caps are actually due to snow or hoar frost, as they appear to be. The fact that they nearly or entirely disappear in the long summers means only that the atmosphere is dry enough for evaporation to take place at the temperature which prevails in the plant. If at temperatures of $-35^{\circ}$ were known, the amount of water vapor in its atmosphere could be computed from the phenomena of the polar caps; and conversely, if the amount of water vapor in the atmosphere of Mars were known, its temperature could be computed.
Some direct considerations on the possible temperature of Mars have been given, and reference has been made to
A diagram showing a graph with two curves labeled "A" and "B". Curve A starts at a high point on the left side and decreases gradually towards the right. Curve B starts at a low point on the left side and increases gradually towards the right.
172
THE PLANETS
283
the possibility of determining the water content of its atmosphere by means of the spectroscope. There is an additional line of evidence which bears on the question in hand. The surface of the planet is largely of a brick-red color, and is interpreted as being in a desert condition. While there may be some water in the form of ice, there is to be marshes, there are certainly no large bodies of water on its surface comparable to the oceans and seas upon the earth. These things confirm the conclusion that water is not abundant on Mars and that its mean temperature may be below zero ; but, in the equatorial regions in the long summers, the temperature may rise for a considerable time even above the freezing point.
The Canals of Mars. - In 1877, Schiaparelli, an Italian observer of Milan, made the first of a series of important discoveries respecting the surface markings of Mars. Although he had only a modest telescope of 8.75 inches aperture, he found that the brick-red regions, which had been supposed to be continental areas, were crossed and recrossed by many straight, dark, greenish streaks which always appeared to be double lines known as " canali," or channels. These streaks were of various lengths, extending from uniform widths from a few hundred miles up to three or four thousand miles. While they appeared to be very narrow, they must have been at least 20 miles across. Schiaparelli called them " canali" (channels), which was translated as "canals," a designation unfortunately too suggestive, for they have no analogy to anything on the earth. When a number of them intersect, they form a special polygonal connection which is called a " lake." Sometimes a number of them intersect at a single point ; and, according to Lowell, the junctions of canals are always surrounded by lakes, while lakes are found at no other places.
In the winter of 1881-82 Mars was again in opposition, though not so near the earth as in 1877. Schiaparelli not only verified his earlier observations, but he also found the
284 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cc. ix, 173
remarkable fact that a number of the canals had doubled; that is, that, in a number of cases, two canals ran parallel to each other at a distance of from 200 to 400 miles, as shown on Lowell's map in Fig. 106, which is a photograph of the globe on which the canals are drawn by the American observer. The doubling was found to depend upon the sea-
A circular diagram showing markings on the surface of Mars.
Fig. 106. — Lowell's map of Mars.
sons and to develop with great rapidity when the sun was at the Martian equinox.
The history of the observations of the markings of Mars since the time of Schiaparelli is filled with the most remarkable contradictions. The observations of the keen-eyed Italian have been confirmed by a number of other astronomers, but many may be identified with Prof. and M.Donlon, of Nice, Williams, of England, W. H. Pickering, of Harvard, and especially Lowell, who has a large 24-inch telescope
cn. ix, 174j
THE PLANETS
285
favorably located at Flagstaff, Arizona. On the other hand, many of the foremost observers working with the very larg-
est telescopes, such as Antoniadi, with the 32-75-inch Meu-
nster refractor, at the Lick observatory, with the great 36-inch
telescope, Barnard, with the 40-inch Yerkes telescope, and
Hale, with the 60-inch reflector of the Solar Observatory at
Mt. Wilson, California, have been entirely unable to see the
canals. This does not mean that they have not seen mark-
ings on Mars, for they
have observed many of
them; but they did not
see the sharply straight
lines observed by Schia-
parelli, Lowell, and
others. In Fig. 107 four
views of Mars are shown
as seen by Barnard with
the great telescope of the
Lick Observatory in 1894.
Fig. 108 is a photograph
made with the 60-inch reflecting telescope of the
Mt. Wilson Solar Ob-
servatory. In the midst of these conflicting results it is difficult to draw any certain conclusion; but it must be remembered in considering such a subject that reliable positive evidences ought to outweigh a large amount of nega-
tive evidence.
**174. Explinations of the Canals of Mars.** — The explana-
tions of the canals of Mars have been extremely varied.
Many astronomers believe they are illusions of some sort.
They think the eye in some way integrates the numerous
straight lines into a single line, or that they are due to light
lines and geometrical figures. The experiments of Maunder
and Evans and the more recent ones of Newcomb of having
Fig. 107. — Drawings of Mars in 1894 by Barnard at the Lick Observatory.
Frac.
286
AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY (ch. ix, 174)
a number of persons make drawings of what they could see on a disk covered with irregular marks and held slightly beyond the limits of distinct vision, strikingly confirm this conclusion. Antonini states in the most unequivocal terms that the observations of Mars at the opposition of 1908 give
Fig. 108. — Photograph of Mars (the 60-inch reflector of the Mt. Wilson Solar Observatory).
to the theory of the objective existence of canals on Mars an unanswerable confutation. Other astronomers hold that such a network of markings on a planet whose surface is completely unknown, and whose inherent improbability, and should not be accepted without the most conclusive evidence.
At the other extreme stands Lowell, who maintains that
cl. ix, 174
THE PLANETS
287
not only are the canals real but that they prove the existence on the planet of highly intelligent beings. He argues for the reality of the canals on the ground that they always appear at well-defined positions on the planet and that they change in a systematic way with the seasons. He argues that the canals exhibit a remarkable regularity because several of them sometimes cross at a point with the utmost precision, and because in many cases two of them run perfectly parallel for more than a thousand miles. Obviously this remarkable regularity could not be the result of such processes as the erosion of rivers or the cracking of the surface.
W. H. Pickering first suggested that the canals may be due to vegetation, and Lowell's theory is an elaboration of this idea. He supposes the streams, known as canals, are strips of vegetation 20 or more miles wide, which grow on a region irrigated by lateral ditches from a large central canal. This explains their seasonal character. Moreover, he finds the streaks first developing near the dark (marshy?) regions and extending gradually out from them even across the equator of the planet to regions having the opposite season. The explanation given by these plans is that when the water in the canals evaporates, the resulting first water collects in the marshes and is led thence into out into the waterways which extend through the centers of the canals.
The observations of Lowell show that, according to his explanation, water must flow along the canals at the rate of 2.1 miles per hour. He infers from the elaborate system of irrigated regions that Mars is inhabited by creatures possessing a high degree of intelligence.
Although Lowell's theory seems highly improbable and may be altogether wrong, life may nevertheless exist upon Mars. But if there is life on this planet, the creatures which inhabit it must be very different physically from those on the earth, because it would be necessary for them to be adapted to an entirely different environment. On Mars the surface gravity
288 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. ix, 174]
is less than on the earth, the light and heat received from the sun are less and the temperature is probably far lower, the atmosphere is much less abundant, and it may be quite different in constitution, and the seasonal changes are nearly twice as long. The plants and animals which inhabit the earth have been adapted to the conditions existing on its surface, and the conditions have not been made to fit them, as was once generally believed. Similarly, life on other planets must be adapted to the environment in which it is placed or it would shortly perish.
Further, if Mars or any other world is inhabited, there is no reason to suppose that its highest intelligence has reached the precise stage attained by the human race. The most interesting fact about Mars is that it is in a condition corresponding to that in which our ancestors were when they lived in caves and ate uncooked food; or, millions of years ago they may have passed through the stage of strife and deadly competition in which the human race is to-day.
It is a curious fact that those who know but little about astronomy are nearly always very much interested in the question whether other worlds are inhabited, while as a rule astronomers themselves do not ask this question. The experts scarcely give the question of the habitability of other planets a thought. Astronomers are doubtless influenced by the knowledge that such speculations can scarcely lead to certainty, and they are deeply impressed by the fundamental laws which they find operating in the universe. Nevertheless, there seems to be no good reason why we should not now ask these questions. We know that there are no forests only on the other planets of the solar system, but also on the millions of planets that possibly circulate around other suns. Such speculations help to enlarge our mental horizon and to give us a better perspective in contemplating the origin and destiny of the human race, but we should never forget that they are speculations.
CH. IX, 175]
THE PLANETS
289
III. Jupiter
175. Jupiter's Satellite System. — The first objects discovered by Galileo when he pointed his little telescope to the sky in 1610 were the four brightest moons of Jupiter. They are barely beyond the limits of visibility without optical aid and, indeed, could be seen with the unaided eye if they were not obscured by the dazzling rays of Jupiter. No other satellite of Jupiter was discovered until 1892, when Barnard, then at the Lick Observatory, caught a glimpse of a fifth one very close to the planet. It is so small and so buried in the rays of the neighboring brilliant planet that it can be seen only by expert observers aided with the aid of the most powerful telescopes in the world.
Early in 1905 Perrine found by photography that Jupiter has still two more satellites which are more remote from the planet than those previously known. Their distances from Jupiter are both about 7,000,000 miles and their periods of revolution are about 0.75 of a year. The eccentricities of their orbits are considerable and their paths actually loop through an angle of nearly mutual inclination and their orbits is 28° and they do not pass nearer than 2,000,000 miles of each other.
The seven satellites so far enumerated revolve around Jupiter from west to east, but two more have been discovered whose motion is in the opposite direction. The eighth was found by Mclntire, at Greenwich, England, in 1847. Its revolution around Jupiter is at an mean distance of approximately 14,000,000 miles in a period of about 740 days. Its orbit is inclined to Jupiter's equator by about 28°. The ninth was discovered by S. B. Nicholson, in July, 1914, at the Lick Observatory. Its mean distance from Jupiter is about 15,400,000 miles and its period nearly 3 years. These two satellite satellites are very small and faint, the ninth being of the nineteenth magnitude, and the eighth about one magnitude brighter.
u
290 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [en: ix, 175]
The first four satellites discovered are numbered I, II, III, IV in the order of their distance from Jupiter. The fifth, although it is very close to Jupiter, was given the number V. The orbits of these five satellites, shown in Fig. 109, are nearly circular and lie in the plane of Jupiter's equator. Their periods of revolution are about 11 hours, 36 minutes, 18 hours, 14 minutes, and 24 hours respectively. Their dimensions and their diameters have been determined by Barnard, the results being given in the following table:
| Satellite |
Diameter from Center of Jupiter |
Period of Revolution |
Diameter |
| Y (Unnamed) |
112,500 mi. |
6d. 11h. 57m. |
about 100mi. |
| I (To) |
261,000 mi. |
1d. 18h. 28m. |
2452mi. |
| I (Europa) |
415,000 mi. |
5d. 13h. 14m. |
2045mi. |
| II (Ganymede) |
463,000 mi. |
16d. 16h. 32m. |
3345mi. |
| VI (Callisto) |
1,167,000 mi. |
about 260 days |
small |
| VU (Unnamed) |
7,300,000 mi. |
about 260 days |
very small |
| VII (Unnamed) |
14,000,000 mi. |
about 740 days |
very small |
| VIII (Unnamed) |
15,400,000 mi. |
nearly 3 years |
very small |
| XIX (Unnamed) |
|
|
|
**176. Markings on Jupiter's Satellites.** — The great dis- tance of Jupiter makes it difficult to detect any but large and distinctly colored markings on its satellites. In 1890 Barnard found satellite I to be elongated parallel to the equator of Jupiter when transiting its darker portions and elongated perpendicular to the opposite side when passing over its brighter parts. He interpreted this as meaning that the poles of the satellite are dark and that the equatorial belt is light colored. The accompanying drawing, Fig. 110, showing the satellite transiting a light region above and a dark one below, exhibits the observed appearance at the left and the probable actual condition at the right. When held at some distance from the eye, the two appear the same.
A diagram showing a satellite transiting a light region above and a dark one below, with labels indicating the observed appearance at the left and the probable actual condition at the right.
CH. IX, 177]
THE PLANETS
291
Some observers have thought that satellites III and IV are somewhat elliptical in shape, but Barnard has observed them repeatedly with the great Liek and Yerkes telescopes and has been quite unable to account for their departures from strict sphericity. Various markings have been at times observed on the satellites, and Douglas inferred from his observations of the satellites that their period of rotation is about 7 hours. At present these are matters of speculation.
177. Discovery of the Finite Velocity of Light — A very important discovery was made in connection with observations of Jupiter's satellites.
The periods of revolution of the four largest satellites naturally were determined when Jupiter was in opposition, when they nearest the earth. Since the satellites are in the plane of Jupiter's equator, which is only slightly inclined to the ecliptic, they pass behind Jupiter. From their periods of revolution the times at which they will be eclipsed can be predicted.
Suppose the periods of revolution of the satellites and the
Fig. 109. — Orbits of first four satellites of Jupiter.
Fig. 110. — Barnard's drawings of Jupiter's satellite I.
Illustration showing Barnard's drawings of Jupiter's satellite I.
292 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. ix, 177
times at which they are eclipsed are determined when the earth is in the vicinity of $E_1$, Fig. 111. Six months later, when the earth has arrived at $E_2$, its distance from Jupiter is greater by approximately the diameter of the earth's orbit, and then the eclipses of the satellites are found to be behind those predicted by the time required for light to travel across the earth's orbit. From such observations in 1674, a Danish astronomer Römer inferred that it takes light 600 seconds to travel a distance equal to that from the sun to the earth. Later observations have shown that the correct time is 498.58 seconds. When the distance
A diagram showing three points labeled L, S, and X, with a line connecting S and X.
Fig. 111. — Discovery of velocity of light from eclipses of Jupiter's satellites.
from the earth to the sun has been determined by independent means, the velocity of light can be found from this interval, which is called the light equation.
At the present time the velocity of light can be determined much more accurately by physical experiments on the surface of the earth than it can from observations of Jupiter's satellites. In 1862, M. Michelson and A. A. Newton showed that it is very approximately 386,324 miles per second. From this velocity and the light equation of 498.58 seconds, the distance to the sun can be computed.
**178. The Rotation of Jupiter.** — The surface of Jupiter is covered with a great number of semi-permanent markings from which its rotation can be determined. The period
4
CH. IX. 179]
THE PLANETS
203
of rotation for spots near the equator has been found to be about 9 hrs. and 50 m., and for those in higher latitudes about 9 hrs. and 57 m., with an average of 9 hrs. and 54 m.; that is, between the equatorial zone and high latitudes there is a decrease in the period of about $\frac{1}{4}$ of the whole period. In 85 rotations the eccentricity of Jupiter is greatest at the higher latitudes. Moreover, as Barnard has found, the rates of rotation in corresponding northern and southern latitudes are quite different in several zones.
The circumference of Jupiter is nearly 300,000 miles, and it follows from this and its rate of rotation that the motion at its equator is about 90,000 miles per hour. Consequently, if two spots separated by 7 minutes were both near the equator, they would pass each other with the relative speed of $30,000 + 85 = 35$ miles per hour. Though spots whose periods differ by 7 minutes are probably in no case in approximately the same latitude, yet they must have large relative motions. Compare these results with the speed of from 70 to 100 miles per hour with which the planets move along the orbit of the earth.
The fact that the eccentric belt of Jupiter rotates in a shorter period than its higher latitudes is a most remarkable phenomenon. If it were an isolated case, one would naturally suppose that the peculiarity was due to irregularities of motion inherited from the time of its origin. Such currents in a body in a fluid condition would be destroyed by friction only very slowly; but the same phenomenon is observed also on the Saturnian ring, so that it can hardly be supposed that the three are mere coincidences. If they are not, the implication is that these peculiarities of rotation have been produced by similar causes. It has been suggested, as will be explained in Arts. 253, 254, that the cause may be the impacts of circulating meteors or other material.
179. Surface Markings of Jupiter. — The characteristic markings of Jupiter are a series of conspicuous dark and
294 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [col. ix, 179
bright belts which stretch around the planet parallel to its equator as shown in Figs. 112, 113, and 114. The central equatorial belt is usually very light and about 10,000 miles wide; on each side is a belt of reddish-brown color generally of about the same width. These belts alternate in light and dark belts can be made out in higher latitudes, though not as distinctly as the equatorial belts, partly, at least, because they are observed obliquely. The belts vary considerably in width from year to year as the drawings, Fig. 114, by Hough show. On the whole, the southern dark belt of Jupiter is more extensive and more conspicuous than the northern one.
A good telescope under favorable atmospheric conditions reveals in it both many details which continually change as though what we see is cloudlike in structure.
From the low mean density of the planet and the almost certain central concentration that its exterior parts, to a depth of many thousands of miles, must have a very low density; and it is improbable that anything which is visible from the earth approaches the solid state.
Dark spots often appear on Jupiter, especially in the northern hemisphere, which gradually turn red and finally vanish. The most remarkable and permanent spot so far known appeared in 1878 just beneath the southern dark belt. When first discovered it was a pinkish oval about 7000 miles across in the direction perpendicular to the equator, and about
Foto. 112 — Jupiter, Sept. 7, 1913 (Barnard).
Fig. 112 — Jupiter, Sept. 7, 1913 (Barnard).
**CR. IX. 179]**
THE PLANETS
30,000 miles long parallel to the equator. In a year it had changed to a bright red color and was by far the most conspicuous object on the planet. It has since then been known that it has undergone many changes, both in color and brightness. At the present time it has become rather inconspicuous, and the material of which it is
Fig. 113. — Photographs of Jupiter (E. C. Slipher, Lowell Observatory).
composed seems to be sinking back beneath the vapors which surround the planet.
A very remarkable thing in connection with the red spot was that its period of rotation increased 7 seconds the first eight years following its discovery, but it has remained essentially constant since that time. Possibly the increase in period of rotation of the red spot, which was somewhat longer than that of the surrounding material which continually moved by it, was due to its being elevated so that its distance from the axis of rotation of the planet was increased. Under these conditions the rate of rotation would be reduced
296 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [CH. IX, 179
in harmony with the principle of the conservation of moment of momentum (Art. 45). At any rate, changes in rotation are always accompanied by considerable changes in color and visibility of the satellite system.
180. The Physical Conditions and Seasonal Changes of Jupiter. — In considering the physical condition of Jupiter it should be remembered that it has the low average density of 1.25 on the water standard, that its surface markings are not permanent, and that there are variations in the distribution of its visible parts. All these things indicate that Jupiter is largely gaseous near its surface.
The surface gravity of Jupiter is 3.52 times that of the earth, and this produces a pressure gradient in its atmosphere at moderate depths. These pressures are sustained by the expansive tendencies of the interior gases which may be composed of light elements which may have high temperatures. It has sometimes been supposed that the surface of Jupiter is very hot and that it is self-luminous, but such cannot be the case, for the shadows cast on the planet by the satellites are perfectly black, and when a satellite passes into the shadow of Jupiter it does not emit light.
In conclusion, we shall probably not be far from the truth if we infer that Jupiter is still in an early stage of its
Fig. 114.—Drawings of Jupiter showing variations in widths of dark belts (Hough).
179
179
179
179
179
179
179
179
cr. ix, 181
THE PLANETS
297
evolution, rather than far advanced like the terrestrial planets, that it contains enormous volumes of gases which are in rapid circulation both along and perpendicular to its surface, and that possibly the energy of its internal fires gives rise to violent motions.
The eccentricity of Jupiter's orbit is very small and the plane of its equator is inclined only $3^{\circ}5'$ to the plane of its orbit. The factors which produce seasonal changes are, therefore, unimportant in the case of this planet. Its dis- tance from the sun is so great that it receives per unit area only $\frac{1}{4}$ as much light and heat as is received by the earth ; and, consequently, its surface must be cold unless it is warmed by internal heat.
IV. SATURN
181. Saturn's Satellite System. — Saturn, like Jupiter, has satellites. The largest one was discovered by Huyghens in 1655; four more were found between 1671 and 1684, two by William Herschel in 1789, one by G. P. Bond and Lassell in 1848, and the ninth by W. H. Pickering in 1899. Pickering suspected the existence of a tenth in 1905, but the supposed discovery has not been confirmed.
Saturn is so remote that the dimensions of its satellites are not sufficiently known to tell them apart or to brighten. All their masses are unknown except that of Titan, which, from its perturbation of its neighboring satellite Hyperion, was found by Hill to be $\frac{1}{4}$ that of Saturn. The seven satellites which are nearest to Saturn resolve sensibly in the plane of its equator, while the orbit of the eighth, Japetus, is inclined about $10^{\circ}$, and that of the ninth about $20^{\circ}$.
When the eighth satellite, Japetus, is on the western side of Saturn it always appears considerably brighter than when it is on the eastern side. This difference in brightness is undoubtedly due to the fact that this satellite, like the moon, always has the same side toward the planet around which
298 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. ix, 18]
it revolves, and that its two sides reflect light very unequally. Similar, but less marked, phenomena have been observed by Lowell and E. C. Slipher in connection with the first two satellites, and the explanation is the same as in the case of Jupiter.
Table VIII gives the list of Saturn's satellites, together with their mean distances from its center, their periods, and their approximate diameters. It will be observed that an enormous gap separates the first eight from the ninth. Figure 115 gives to scale the orbits of Saturn's satellites, with the exception of the ninth, which is too remote to be shown. The first satellite, which revolves from west to east, the direction in which it rotates, but the ninth, like the eighth and ninth satellites of Jupiter, revolves in the retrograde direction. This satellite was the first object discovered in the solar system having retrograde motion, and it aroused great interest. These retrograde revolutions have a fundamental bearing on the question of the origin of the satellite systems.
| Satellite |
Distance from Center of Saturn |
Period of Revolution |
Diameter |
| I (Mimas) |
117,000 mi. |
04.22 37m. |
About 600 mi. |
| II (Epimetheus) |
186,000 mi. |
21 18 |
About 1200 mi. |
| III (Tethys) |
288,000 mi. |
2 17 41 |
About 1100 mi. |
| IV (Dione) |
377,000 mi. |
15 22 41 |
About 3000 mi. |
| V (Rhea) |
771,000 mi. |
21 6 39 |
About 500 mi. |
| VII (Hyperion) |
934,000 mi. |
546 12 |
About 200 mi. |
| VIII (Titan) |
976,000 mi. |
546 12 |
About 200 mi. |
The question may be asked why the remote satellites of both Jupiter and Saturn revolve in the retrograde direction. This question cannot be answered with certainty at the
CL IX, 182]
THE PLANETS
299
present time. But it is certain that the farther a satellite is from a planet, the less securely it is held under the gravitative control of its primary; and there is a distance beyond which a satellite cannot permanently revolve because it would be drawn into the planet in obedience to the greater attraction of the sun. A mathematical discussion of the subject shows that, at a given distance from a planet, motion in the retrograde direction is "much more stable than in the forward direction," and consequently, out near the region where instability begins, it would be expected that only retrograde satellites would be found. The orbit of the ninth satellite of Saturn is in the region of stability even for direct motion, but Jupiter's eighth and ninth satellites would have their orbits unstable if they moved in the forward direction at the same distances from Jupiter.
**182. Saturn's Ring System.** — Saturn is distinguished from all the other planets by three wide, thin rings which extend around it in the plane of its equator. They were first seen by Galileo in 1610, but their true character was not known until the observations of Huyghens in 1655. The dimensions of Saturn and its ring system according to the extensive measurements of Barnard are given in Table IX.
Orbit of Jupiter.
Orbit of Saturn.
Figs. 115.— Orbit of Saturn's satellites.
300 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. ix. 182.
|
|
| Equatorial radius of Saturn |
38,235 miles |
| Center of Saturn to inner edge of crase ring |
44,100 miles |
| Center of Saturn to outer edge of bright ring |
57,600 miles |
| Center of Saturn to outer edge of bright ring |
73,000 miles |
| Center of Saturn to inner edge of outer ring |
75,240 miles |
| Center of Saturn to outer edge of outer ring |
80,300 miles |
The distance from the surface of Saturn to the inner edge of the thin, faint ring, known as "the crase ring," is nearly 6000 miles. The width of the crase ring is about 11,000 miles. Outside of the crase ring is the main bright ring, whose width is about 18,000 miles. Its brightness increases
Saturn with rings tilted at greatest angle (drawing by Barnard).
from its junction with the crase ring outward nearly to its outer margin. At its brightest place it is as luminous as the planet itself. Beyond the main bright ring is a dark gap about 2200 miles across. It is known as "Cassini's Division" because it was first observed by Cassini. Outside of this dark space is the outer bright ring with a width of
CH. IX, 182] THE PLANETS 301
about 11,000 miles. The distance across the whole ring system from one side to the other is about 172,600 miles.
The rings of Saturn are inclined about 27° to the plane of the planet's orbit and about 2° to the plane of the ecliptic. Consequently they are observed at different angles, and their apparent size varies greatly. When their inclination is high, Saturn and its ring system present through a good telescope one of the finest sights in the heavens, as is evident from Figs. 116 and 117. When their plane passes through the earth, they appear to be a very thin line and even entirely disappear from view for a few hours, as Barnard found when observing them with the great 40-inch telescope in 1907. It follows that the rings must be very thin, their thickness probably not exceeding 50 miles. When the rings were nearly edgewise to the earth, Barnard could see them faintly; but when they were nearly direct, when they are slightly inclined to the earth, were found to be brighter than the places where the rings are really brilliant (Fig. 118). Barnard
Fig. 117.—Saturn. Photographed Nov. 19, 1911, with the 60-inch telescope of the Mount Wilson Solar Observatory.
116
302 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. ix, 18]
made the suggestion that this appearance is due to the fact that light shining from the sun through the open regions is reflected back from the interior edges of the denser parts of the rings.
168. The Constitution of Saturn's Rings.--The bright rings of Saturn have the same appearance of solidity and continuity as the planet itself. It was generally believed until about a century ago that they were solid or fluid. Yet since 1715, when J. Cassini first mentioned the possibility, it has frequently been suggested that the rings may be simply
Rings of Saturn, December 12, 1907 (drawing by Barnard).
Fig. 118. -- Rings of Saturn, December 12, 1907 (drawing by Barnard).
swarms of meteors, or exceedingly minute satellites, revolving around the planet in the plane of its equator. Such bodies would be subject to the slight gravitational influences upon one another, and their orbits would be sensibly independent of one another except for collisions.
The meteoric theory of the constitution of Saturn's rings was first rendered probable by Laplace, who showed that a symmetrical, solid ring would be dynamically unstable. That is, solid rings would be something like spans of enormous bridges, whose ends do not rest upon the planet but upon other portions of the rings. They would have to be composed of inconceivably strong material to withstand the
CE. IX, 1831
THE PLANETS
303
strains due to their motion and the gravitational forces to which they would be subjected. In 1857, Clerk-Maxwell proved from dynamical considerations that the rings could be regarded as a fluid, and that they were, therefore, composed of small independent particles. Now, if they are meteoric, those parts which are nearest the planet must move fastest, just as those planets which are nearest the sun move fastest; while, if they are solid, the opposite must be the case. In 1895, Keeler showed by line-of-sight observations with the spectroscope (Art. 226) that the inner parts not only move faster than the outer parts, but also move more slowly than they would move if they were made up of totally disconnected particles, the innermost particles of the crape ring performing their revolution in about 5 hours, while the outermost particles of the outer bright ring require 137 hours to complete a revolution. Moreover, Barnard found that they do not cast perfectly black shadows, for he saw Jupiters faintly illuminated by the light of the sun when observed from this planet; and it may be considered as firmly established that the rings of Saturn are swarms of meteors.
Rings are strange substitutes for satellites, but a probable explanation of their existence in place of satellites is at hand. A planet ejects tidal strains upon satellites in its vicinity, and these tendencies to rupture increase very rapidly as the distance between the satellite decreases. Harkness proved that the tidal strains break up a fluid similar to the same density as the planet around which it revolved if its distance were less than 2.44 ... radii of the planet. The limit would be less for denser satellites, and a little less for solid satellites, but not much less if they were of large dimensions. It is seen from the numbers in Table IX, or from Fig. 116, that the rings are within this limit. It is not supposed that they are the pulverized remains of some former satellite, but it is possible that the material of which they are composed is subject to such forces that the mutual gravitation of the separate
304 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. ix, 183
particles can never draw them together into a single body. If they should unite into a satellite, it would probably be small, for they are not massive enough to have produced by their attraction any appreciable change of the motions of the satellites which can so far be observed.
One more interesting thing remains to be mentioned. If a meteor were to revolve in the vacant space between the rings known as Cassini's division, its period would be nearly commensurable with the periods of four of the satellites, and would be one half that of Mimas. Kirkwood called attention to this relation, which is entirely analogous to that found by him in the case of the planets. Many astronomers have suspected that there is a narrow division between the crape ring and the inner edge of the bright ring, where the period of a revolving meteor would be one third that of Mimas. More recently Lowell has been convinced by his observations at Flagstaff of the existence of several very narrow divisions at places where the periods of revolution of planets are approximately commensurable with the periods of Mimas or Enceladus. But in order to secure perfect commensurability he was led to the conclusion that Saturn is composed of layers of different den-
sities, and that the inner ones are more oblate, and, therefore, rotate faster, than the outer ones.
184. On the Permanency of Saturn's Rings. — The question at once arises whether the meteoric constitution of the rings is such that these numerous particles will for all time be a permanent one. The fact that the rings exist and are separated from the planet by a number of thousands of miles, while beyond them there are 9 satellites, indicates that they are not transitory in character. The only circumstance that distinguishes them dynamically from the satellites is the possibility of their collisions. If a collision occurred between two particles, energy would be liberated at the expense of their energy of motion. When the revolutionary energy of a body is decreased, its orbit diminishes in size.
CL. IX, 1851
THE PLANETS
305
Therefore, when two of the small bodies of which Saturn's ring is composed collide, the orbit of at least one of them must be diminished in size. These collisions with the accompanying degradation of energy are probably taking place at the same time that the particles are falling back to the surface of the planet. It may be that the cage ring is the result of particles whose orbits have been reduced from the larger dimensions of the bright ring by collisions with other particles.
**185. The Surface Markings and the Rotation of Saturn.**
The surface markings of Saturn are much like those of Jupiter, though some of them are seen so well because of their distance from this planet. There are a bright equatorial belt and a number of darker and broader belts in the higher latitudes, though they are less conspicuous than the belts on Jupiter.
It has been rather difficult for observers to find spots on Saturn conspicuous and lasting enough to enable them to determine the period of its rotation. From observations made by Herschel, it was found that its period of rotation is 10 hrs. and 16 m.; Halley's observation of a bright equatorial spot in 1876 gave for this spot a period of 10 hrs. and 14 m. This was generally adopted as the period of Saturn's rotation, particularly after it had been verified by a number of other observers.
But, in 1903, Barnard discovered some bright spots in northern latitudes, and his observations of them, together with those of several other astronomers, showed that these spots were moving around Saturn at 10 km. and 38 m. This difference in period means that there is a relative drift between the material of Saturn's equatorial belt and that of its higher latitudes of 800 or 900 miles per hour.
In sharp contrast to the planet Jupiter, the plane of the equator of Saturn is inclined to the plane of its orbit by an angle of 27°. This is a still further indication than those found in the case of the earth and Mars, and would hardly be expected in so large a planet as Saturn after finding that
A diagram showing Saturn's rotation period.
306 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. ix, 185
the axis of Jupiter is almost exactly perpendicular to the plane of its orbit.
186. The Physical Condition and Seasonal Changes of Saturn. The obliquity of Saturn is about 0.63 on the water standard. Consequently, it must be largely in a gaseous condition. Probably no considerable portion of it is purely gaseous, for it seems more likely, in view of the fact that it is opaque, that the gases of which it is composed are filled with minute liquid particles, just as our own atmosphere becomes charged with globules of water, forming clouds.
The remarkable relative motions of the different parts of the northern hemisphere of Saturn have been observed in this state, and that it is a place of the wildest turmoil. Doubtless it is a world whose evolution has not yet sufficiently advanced to give it any permanent markings, much less to fit it as a place in any way suitable for the abode of even the lowest forms of life.
The high inclination of the plane of Saturn's equator to that of its orbit gives it marked seasonal changes. Moreover, its orbit is rather more eccentric than the orbits of the other large planets. But it is so far from the sun that it receives only $\frac{1}{6}$th as much light and heat per unit area as the earth receives; and it follows that its surface is very cold unless it has an atmosphere of remarkable properties, or unless a large amount of heat is conveyed to it from a hot interior.
A consequence of the rapid rate of rotation and low density of Saturn is that its polar cap is thin. The distance be- between its equatorial and polar diameters is nearly 7000 miles, or about 10 per cent of its whole diameter. Its oblateness is so great that it is conspicuous even through a telescope of 6 inches' aperture.
V. Uranus and Neptune
187. The Satellite Systems of Uranus and Neptune. — Uranus has four known satellites, two of which were discovered by William Herschel, in 1787, and the other two
307
THE PLANETS
by Lassell, in 1851. Their distances are respectively 120,000, 167,000, 273,000 and 365,000 miles, and their periods of revolution are respectively 2.5, 4.1, 8.7, and 13.5 days.
Their diameters probably range between 500 and 1000 miles. They all move sensibly in the same plane, but this plane is inclined about 98° to the plane of the planet's orbit; that is, if the plane of the orbits of the satellites is thought of as having been turned up from that of the planet's orbit, the rotation has been continued 8° beyond perpendicularity, and the satellites revolve in the retrograde direction.
Neptune was one of the first planets discovered by Lassell, in 1846. It revolves at a distance of 221,500 miles in a period of 5 days 21 hours. Its diameter is probably about 2000 miles. The plane of its orbit is inclined about 145° to that of the planet's orbit; that is, the inclination between the two planes is about 35° and the satellite revolves in the retrograde direction.
187. Atmospheres of Albedoes of Uranus and Neptune
— Very little is known directly respecting the atmospheres of Uranus and Neptune. Their low mean densities imply that their exterior parts are largely in the gaseous state. As confirmatory of this conclusion, the spectroscope shows that the light which we receive from them must have passed through an extensive absorbing medium in addition to the atmosphere itself. This medium absorbs all but such a small part of the light from all planets passes. The absorbing effects of the element hydrogen and water vapor are shown in the spectra of both planets, but, according to the recent results of Slipher, more strongly in the case of Neptune than in that of Uranus. A number of other absorption bands are due to unknown substances.
The albedo of Uranus is 0.63, and that of Neptune, 0.73.
188. The Periods of Rotation of Uranus and Neptune
— Surface markings have been seen on Uranus by Buffham, Young, the Andre brothers, Perrotin, Holden, Keeler, and other observers, but they have been so indefinite and fleeting
308 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [en. ix, 189
that it has not been possible to draw any certain conclusions from them. Nevertheless, so far as they go, they indicate that the period of rotation of Uranus is 10 or 12 hours, and that the plane of its equator is inclined something like $10^{\circ}$ to $30^{\circ}$ to the plane of the orbits of the satellites. In 1894, Barnard detected a slight flattening of the disk, with the equatorial diameter inclined $28^{\circ}$ to the plane of the orbits of the satellites. Finally, in 1912, V. M. Slipher, at the Lowell Observatory, found by spectroscopic means that Neptune rotates in the direction of revolution of its satellites in a period of 10 days, 56 minutes. This result is entitled to considerable confidence.
No certain markings have been seen on Neptune, and consequently, its rate of rotation has not been found by direct means. But by indirect processes both the position of the equator and the inclination of its axis have been found, at least approximately. The dimensions and mass of Neptune are known with considerable accuracy. Now, if the rate of rotation were known, the equatorial bulging could be computed. Suppose the plane of the orbit of the satellite were inclined to that of the planet's equator. Then the equatorial bulge would perturb the motion of the satellite; in particular, it would cause a revolving of its nodes, and the rate could be computed.
The first determination of the rate of rotation of Neptune is about the converse of that which has just been described. The nodes of the orbit of its satellite revolve, and the manner of their motion shows the existence of a certain equatorial bulge inclined about $20^{\circ}$ to the plane of the satellite's orbit. The bulging, or ellipticity, of the planet is $\frac{1}{2}$, indicating, according to the work of Tisserand and Newcomb, that Neptune rotates only as compared to the rates of rotation of Jupiter and Saturn.
**190. Physical Condition of Uranus and Neptune.** — We can infer the physical conditions of Uranus and Neptune only from that of other planets which are more favorably situated.
309
THE PLANETS
for observation. They are probably in much the same state as Jupiter and Saturn, though, possibly, somewhat further advanced in their evolution because of their smaller dimensions. One thing to be noticed is that they receive relatively little light and heat from the sun. The amounts per unit area are about $\frac{1}{25}$th and $\frac{1}{25}$th that received by the earth. If their capacity for absorbing and radiating heat were the same as that of the earth, their temperatures (Art. 172) would be respectively about $-349^{\circ}$ and $-364^{\circ}$ Fahrenheit. Nevertheles, however, the amount of radiation received only feeble illumination from the sun. Although the sun, as seen from that vast distance, would subtend a smaller angle than Venus does to us when nearest the earth, the noonday illumination would be equal to 700 times our ordinary moonlight.
XIII. QUESTIONS
1. Find by the method of Art. 172 what the mean temperatures of the earth would be at a distance of 80 million miles from Venus and Mercury.
2. If the earth always presented the same face towards the sun, and if there were no distribution of heat by the atmosphere, what would be the mean temperature of its illuminated side? What would be the result if the earth were at the distance of Venus from the sun?
3. If the mean temperature of the equatorial zones of the earth is $85^{\circ}$, and if it receives, per unit area, 2.5 times as much heat as the sun's rays reach Venus in her polar regions, neglecting the transfer of heat by the atmosphere?
4. What would be the mean temperature of the equatorial zones of Mars if it received half as much heat as Venus?
5. Suppose the mean temperature of the Thibetan plateau at a height of 15,000 feet above sea level is $40^{\circ}$; what would it be if the earth were at the distance of Mars from the sun? Would this difference in temperature be proportional to its surface gravity; how does the atmosphere of Mars compare with that of the earth at an altitude of 15,000 feet above sea level?
6. Waving the temperature difficulties in the hypothesis regarding the habitability of Mars, what reasonable explanation can
310 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. ix, 190
you give for the fact that the canals are always along the arcs of great circles?
8. Try the experiment of Maunder and Evans.
What would be the area of the "marshes" having an average width of 20 miles and an average length of 300 miles? Suppose to irrigate this area for a season a foot of water is required; how much would this water weigh on the earth? On Mars? Suppose all of this water to be pumped out by a pump which delivers the necessary rate; suppose it is necessary to pump the water out of the "marshes" to a higher level to get the fall; suppose the pumps work 10 hours a day for 300 days; how many horsepower of work must they deliver?
A diagram showing a canal with a width of 20 miles and a length of 300 miles.
CHAPTER X
COMETS AND METEORS
I. Comets
191. General Appearance of Comets. — The planets are characterized by the invariability of their form, the simplicity of their motions, and their general similarity to one another. In strong contrast to these relatively stable bodies are the comets, whose bizarre appearance, complex motions, and unpredictable nature have attracted the attention of men to them a great amount of attention. Until the last two centuries they were objects of superstitious terror which were supposed to portend calamities. At least so far as their motions are concerned, they are now known to be as lawful as the other members of the solar system.
The typical comet is composed of a head, or coma, a bright nucleus at the center, and a tail often starlike in appearance, and a tail streaming out in the direction opposite to the sun. The apparent size of the head may be anywhere from almost starlike smallness to the angular dimensions of the sun. The nucleus is usually very small and bright, but the tail often extends many degrees from the head before it gradually fades out into the darkness of the sky. What makes this the distinctive part of the comet, for it is always present and forms a part of its own nebula. Either the nucleus or tail, or both, may be absent, especially if the comet is a small one. Comets vary in brightness from those which are so faint that they are barely visible through large telescopes to those which are so bright that they may be observed in full daylight, even when almost in the direction of the sun. In spite of their being sometimes very 511
312 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. x, 191
Foto. 119.—Brooks' Comet, Oct. 19, 1911. Photographed by Barnard at the Yerkes Observatory.
Photograph by Barnard at the Yerkes Observatory.
CH. X, 192]
COMETS AND METEORS
313
bright, they are so nearly transparent that faint stars are visible through them without the slightest appreciable diminution of their light.
There are now about 400 comets having been seen before the invention of the telescope, in 1609, and more than the same number have been observed since that date. Astronomers now keep a close watch of the sky, and only very faint ones can escape their notice. From 3 to 10 are found yearly. They are lettered for each year $a$, $b$, $c$, $\ldots$ in the order of their discovery, and are numbered I, II, III, $\ldots$ in the order that they pass their perihelion. Besides these, there are many others discovered by observers.
192. The Orbits of Comets.--In ancient times it was supposed that comets were malevolent visitors prowling through the earth's atmosphere, bent on mischief. Kepler supposed they moved in straight lines, but Dörfel showed that the comet of 1681 moved in a parabola around the sun as its focus. In 1689 Newton invented a graphical method of computing orbits from three complete observations of their apparent positions. Better methods have been devised by Lambert, Laplace, Gauss, and later astronomers, and now there is usually no difficulty in determining the elements of an orbit from three complete observations which are separated by a few days.
The orbits of about 400 comets have been computed, and as nearly as can be determined from the imperfect observations where they have been made, all of them are parabolic. In fact, they are so generally parabolic, or at least extremely elongated, that it has been customary in the preliminary computations to assume they are parabolas. Of the remaining cometary orbits, nearly 100 have been shown to be distinctly elliptical in shape.
A comet is said to be hyperbolic if its eccentricity is less than unity, a parabola if its eccentricity equals unity, and an hyperbola if its eccentricity exceeds unity. Since a body
314 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. x, 192]
moving subject to gravitation may describe any one of these three classes of orbits, and since the eccentricity of a parabola is the limiting case between that of an ellipse and that of an hyperbola, it is infinitely improbable that the orbit of any comet shall pass through this class.
It is important to determine whether the eccentricities of the orbits of comets are slightly less than unity or slightly greater than unity. In the former case comets are permanent members of the solar system; in the latter, they are only temporary visitors. The difficulty in answering the question is not theoretical, but practical. In the first place, comets are more distant than planets and it would be difficult to locate their positions of the centers of gravity. In the second place, they are observed during only a very small part of their whole periods while they are in the neighborhood of the earth's orbit. Generally they are not seen much beyond the orbit of Mars and very rarely at the distance of Jupiter. For such a small arc the motion is essentially the same in a very elongated ellipse, in a parabola, and in an hyperbola when their eccentricity is near unity; as is evident from Fig. 120.
More than 80 comets move in orbits whose major axes are so short that they will certainly return to the sun. The remainder move in exceedingly elongated orbits, and the character of their motion is less certain. But it is significant that the recent computations of Strömgren show that in all cases in which comets have been suddenly observed to go into accretion, they have either entered or were moving in ellipses when they entered the solar system. At the present time there is no known case of a comet which was well observed for a long time whose orbit was hyperbolic, and astronomers are becoming united in the opinion that they are permanent members of the solar system.
The orbits of all the planets are nearly in the same plane; on the other hand, the planes of the orbits of the comets lie in every possible direction and exhibit no tendency to parallel
CH. X, 192]
COMETS AND METEORS
315
Lelism. The perihelia of the orbits of comets are distributed all around the sun, but show a slight tendency to cluster in the direction in which the sun is moving among the stars, a fact which probably has some connection with the sun's motion.
Some comets have perihelion points only a few hundred thousand miles from the surface of the sun, and when nearest
A diagram showing the orbits of Jupiter and Earth, with a comet's orbit marked as "Orbit of Comet." The comet's orbit is shown as an ellipse, with its perihelion (closest point to the sun) near the Earth's orbit.
Fic. 120. — Similarity of elongated ellipses, parabolas, and hyperbolas in the vicinity of the orbit of the earth.
the sun they actually pass through its corona (Art. 238). About 25 comets pass within the orbit of Mercury ; nearly three fourths of them, while having perihelion within the orbit of the earth, very few so far seen are permanently without the orbit of Mars, and all known comets
316 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cu. x. 192
come within the orbit of Jupiter. This does not mean that there are no comets with perihelion distances, or even those with perihelion distances greater than the distance from the earth to the sun are very numerous. Comets are relatively inconspicuous objects until they come considerably within the orbit of Mars. Sometimes their brightness increases a hundred thousandfold while they move from the orbit of Mars to that of Mercury. Consequently, even if comets whose perihelia are beyond the orbit of Mars were very numerous, not many of them would be observed.
In 1813, Herschel computed the orbits of comets which had been observed since 1750. The orbits of comets have been computed so that their distances from the earth are known, their actual dimensions can be determined from their apparent dimensions. It has been found that the head of a comet may have any diameter from 10,000 miles up to more than 1,000,000 miles. The most remarkable thing about the head of a comet is that it rarely always contracts as the comet approaches the sun, and expands again when it recedes from it. The variation in size is very great, the ratio of the largest to the smallest sometimes being as great as 100,000 to 1. John Herschel suggested that the contraction may be only apparent, the outer layers of the comet becoming transparent as it approaches the sun. This suggestion contradicts the appearances and seems to be extremely unlikely.
The nucleus of a comet may be so small as to be scarcely visible, say 100 miles in diameter, or it may be as large as the earth. For example, William Herschel observed the great comet of 1811 when its head was more than 500,000 miles in diameter, while its nucleus measured only 328 miles across. The nuclei vary in size during the motion of comets, but the change is quite irregular and no law of variation has been discovered.
The tails of comets are inconceivably large. Their diameters are counted by thousands and tens of thousands of miles where they leave the heads of comets, and by tens of
CH. X, 194]
COMETS AND METEORS
317
thousands or hundreds of thousands of miles in their more remote parts. They vary in length from a few million miles, or even less, up to more than a hundreded millions of miles. In volume, the mass of comets are thousands of times greater than the sun and all the planets together.
The strangest thing about them is that they point almost directly away from the sun whichever way the comet may be going. That is, when the comet is approaching the sun, the tails trail behind like the smoke from a locomotive; when the comet is receding, they are drawn back like the rays from the head light on a misty night. When a comet is far from the sun, its tail is small, or may be entirely absent; as it approaches the sun, the tail develops in dimensions and splendor, and then diminishes again as it recedes from the sun.
194. The Masses of Comets
Comets give visible evidence of remarkable tenacity, but their volumes are so great that, if their densities were one ten-thousandth of that of air at the surface of the earth, their masses in many cases would be comparable to the masses of the planets.
The reason of comets' being deterred by their attractions for other bodies (Arts. 19, 154). Or, rather, their lack of appreciable mass is shown by the fact that they do not produce observable disturbing effects in the motions of bodies near which they pass. Many comets have had their orbits entirely changed by planets without producing any sensible effects in return. Since, according to the third law of motion, action between two bodies is equal and opposite, and since this force is very small, probably not exceeding one millionth that of the earth.
One of the most striking examples of the feeble gravita-
A diagram showing a comet's tail extending away from the sun.
Fig. 121.—The tails of comets are always directed away from the sun.
317
318 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. x, 194
tional power of comets was furnished by the one discovered by Brooks in 1889. It had passed through Jupiter's satellite system in 1886 without interfering sensibly with the motions of those bodies, although its own orbit was so transformed that its path would have been from 27 to 50 degrees.
**195. Families of Comets.** Notwithstanding the great diversities in the orbits of comets, there are a few groups whose members seem to have some intimate relation to one another, or to the planets. There are two types of these groups, and they are known as **comet families**.
Families of the first type are made up of comets which pursue nearly identical orbits. The most celebrated family of this type is composed of the great comet of 1668, 1843, 1880, and 1882. A much smaller one seen in 1887 probably should be added to this list. Their orbits were not only nearly identical, but the comets themselves were very similar in every respect. They came to the sun from the direction of Sirius; that is, from the direction away from which the sun is moving with respect to the stars; and except for their positions observed in 1887, they remained until they were near perihelion. They passed half way around the sun in a few hours at a distance of less than 200,000 miles from its surface, moving at the enormous velocity of more than 350 miles per second. Their tails extended out in dazzling splendor 100,000,000 miles from their heads.
One might think that the various members of a family follow each other successively approaching the same comet; but such is not the case, for the observations show that though their orbits may be ellipses, their periods are at least 600 or 800 years. This means that they recede to something like five times the distance of Neptune from the sun. The most plausible theory seems to be that they are the separate parts of a great comet which at an earlier visit to the solar system broke up by tidal disturbances.
Families of the second type are made up of comets whose orbits have their aphelion points and the ascending and
CH. X, 190]
COMETS AND METEORS
319
descending nodes of their orbits near the orbits of the planets.
About 30 comets have their aphelion near Jupiter's orbit,
and are known as Jupiter's family of comets, Fig. 122.
Their orbits are, of course, all elliptic, and their periods are
from 3 to 8 years. They move around the sun in the same
direction that the planets revolve. Half of them have been
A diagram showing the orbits of comets in Jupiter's family.
Fig. 122. — Jupiter's family of comets (Popular Astronomy).
seen at two or more perihelion passages. These comets are
all inconspicuous objects and entirely invisible to us except
when they are near the earth.
Saturn has a family of 2 comets, Uranus a family of 3,
and Neptune a family of 6 members. The terrestrial planets
do not possess comet families. There are, according to the
statistical study of W. H. Pickering, two or three groups of
320 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. x, 195
comets whose aphelia are several times the distance of Nept-
une from the sun, suggesting, possibly, the existence of planets at these respective distances.
189 The Capture of Comets. - A very great majority of comets have presumably parabolic orbits whose positions have no special relations to the positions of the orbits of the planets. But the orbits of nearly all those comets which are elliptical and not exceedingly elongated lie near the plane of the planetary orbits and have their aphelia near the orbits of the planets. These facts suggest that the orbits of comets moving in these ellipses have been changed from parabolic or hyperbolic to elliptical by being captured into the planes near whose orbit their aphelion points lie. This question of the transformation of orbits of comets was first discussed by Laplace, who found that if a comet which is approaching the sun on a parabolic or elongated elliptical orbit passes closely in front of a planet, its motion will be retarded so that it will subsequently move in a shortened elliptical orbit, at least until it is disturbed again.
Suppose a comet approaches the sun in a sensibly para-
bolic orbit and passes closely in front of a planet so that its orbit is reduced to an ellipse. It is then said to have been captured. It will in the course of time pass near the planet again, when its orbit may be still further reduced ; or, its orbit may be elongated and it may possibly be driven from the heliocentric system on a parabolic or a hyperbolic orbit.
It is apparent therefore that the members of the cometary families of various consecutive years have been captured by the method described. Jupiter has a larger family of comets than any other planet because of its greater mass and also because, if a comet were captured originally by any planet beyond the orbit of Jupiter, it would yet be possible for Jupiter to reduce its orbit still further. On the other hand, when Jupiter has captured a comet and made it a member of its own family, it is far within the orbit of the
321
**ce. x, 160)**
**COMETS AND METEORS**
remoter planets and is no longer subject to capture by them.
The planets beyond the orbit of Jupiter have a few comets each, and the clustering of the aphelia of comets at still more remote distances has suggested the existence of planets as yet undiscovered (Art. 161). The terrestrial planets have much less mass than the sun, compared to that of the sun, and partly because comets cross their orbits at very great speed.
The masses of the planets are not great enough to reduce a parabolic comet to membership in their own families at one disturbance. The matter is illustrated by Brooks' comet, 1859-V, whose period, according to the computations of Chandler, was reduced by Jupiter in 1886, from 27 years to 17.6 years. Leverrier's 1770, furnishes another example of a disturbance of the opposite character. In 1770 it was moving in an elliptical orbit with a period of 5.5 years; but in 1779 it approached near to Jupiter, its orbit was enlarged, and it has never been seen again.
When a planet captures a comet, the former reduces the dimensions of the orbit of the latter, but the latter still remains in an elliptic orbit. It arises whether a planet might not capture a comet in a more fundamental sense; that is, reduce its orbit so that it would become a satellite of the planet. It has been repeatedly suggested that the planets may have captured their satellites in this manner. The answer to this suggestion is that a planet cannot capture a comet and make it into a satellite simply by its own gravitation and that of the sun. The only possibility is that the planet can emit some resistance in every special direction, and even then the problem presents serious difficulties. No small resistance would be sufficient because the motion of a comet around the sun in a parabolic orbit is much greater than it would be in a satellite orbit; and, in order that resistance should reduce the velocity by the required amount, it would be necessary for the comet to encounter so much material that its mass would grow several fold.
A diagram showing the orbits of two planets and a comet.
322 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ca. x, 197]
197. On the Origin of Comets. — The similarities of the motions of the various planets point to the conclusion that they had a common origin, and the agreement of their elliptical orbits with those of the sun indicates that they have been associated with the sun throughout their whole evolution. This line of reasoning does not lead to the inference that the comets belong to the planetary family. They may have had quite a different origin; at any rate, most of them recede from the sun to regions several times as remote as the planet Neptune.
It was formerly supposed that comets are very small, waterless bodies which pass through space without visiting our sun but once. The intervals of time required for such excursions are enormously greater than has generally been supposed. For example, the great comet of 1882 came almost exactly from the direction of Sirius and returned again in the same direction. Suppose the comet moved under the attraction of Sirius until it had passed over half the distance from Sirius to the sun; and suppose this motion occurred solely under the influence of Sirius. Although Sirius is one of the nearest known stars in all the sky, it is found that it would take 70,000,000 years to describe this part of its orbit. About twice this period of time would be required for it to come from Sirius to the sun, and eight times this immense interval for a comet to come from a star four times as far away. These figures do not disprove the theory that comets move from star to star, but they show that if this hypothesis is true, then comets spend most of their time in traveling and but little in visiting.
If the comets moved from star to star, their orbits with respect to the sun would never be elliptical until after they had been captured; they would, indeed, nearly always be strongly hyperbolic because the stars are moving with respect to each other with velocities which correspond to hyperbolic speed for comets at such great distances. The fact that no comet out of the hundreds whose orbits have been
co. x, 198] COMETS AND METEORS 323
computed has moved in a sensibly hyperbolic orbit pointe strongly to the conclusion that comets have been permanent members of the solar system. They are possibly the remains of the far outlying masses of a nebula from which the solar system may have been developed. With increasing proof that they are actually permanent members of the solar sys- tem, their importance in connection with the question of its origin and evolution continually increases.
198. Theories of Comets' Tails. — The fact that the tails of comets usually project almost directly away from the sun suggests that some force acts upon them in some way acted upon by a repelling force emanating from the sun. The intensity of this repulsion has been computed in a number of cases by Barnard and others from the accelerations which have been observed in the comets' tails, gone which were receding from the heads of comets along their tails. These accelerations have been determined by comparing photographs of the comets taken at different times separated by short intervals.
It was suggested by Olbers as early as 1812 that the repul- sion of the sun towards which comets produce the tails of comets may be electrical in character. This theory has been taken up and systematically developed by Bredichin, of Moscow.
According to it, the sun and comet nuclei both repel the material of which the tails of comets are composed. Those particles which leave the nuclei in the direction away from the sun continue on in straight lines; those which leave in other directions are gradually bent back by the force from behind and form the outer parts of the tail, as shown in Fig. 123. These tailings are especially if they are very long, are slightly curved because the motion of the comet is somewhat atwhart the line along which the repelled par-
A diagram showing a comet's tail being repelled by a force emanating from the sun.
Fig. 123. The repulsion theory of the origin of comets' tails.
323
324 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. x, 198
ticles move, that is, the line from the sun through the nucleus (see Fig. 121).
Electrical repulsion acts on the surfaces of particles, while gravitation depends on their masses. Therefore, while large masses are attracted by the sun more than they are electrically repelled, the opposite may be true for small particles, and the electrical repulsion is relatively stronger the smaller they are. Consequently, the tails which are produced out of small particles will be more nearly straight than those which are composed of larger particles. Brahein advanced the theory that the long, thin tails of comets due to hydrogen gas, the ordinary slightly curved tails to hydrocarbon gases, and the short, stubby, and much curved tails to vapors of metals. Spectroscopic observations have to a considerable extent confirmed these conclusions. Some comets have tails of more than one type, as for example Delavant's comet (Fig. 124).
If the electrical repulsion theory is adopted, the question at once arises why the sun and the materials of which the tails of comets are composed are similarly electrified. A plausible answer to this question can be given. At least the hydrogen in the sun's atmosphere seems to be negatively electrified. Suppose a comet approaches the sun from a remote part of space without an electrical charge. Laboratory experiments show that the hydrogen rays from the sun, striking on the nucleus of the comet, will probably drive off negatively charged particles which will be repelled by the negative charge of the sun, and they will thus form a tail for the comet. The repulsion will depend upon the size of the particles and the electrical potential of the sun.
After the negatively electrified particles have been driven off, the nucleus will be positively charged and, consequently, will be electrically attracted by the sun. But since the particles composing a comet are only very small particles of whole comet, this attraction will not be great enough sensibly to alter the comet's motion.
CH. X. 198] COMETS AND METEORS 325
A photograph of a comet with a long, straight tail and one having considerable curvature (Herschel).
FIG. 124. — Delavan's comet, Sept. 28, 1914, showing a long straight tail and one having considerable curvature (Herschel).
326 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cw. x, 198]
Another theory which merits careful attention is that the particles which constitute comets' tails are driven off by the pressure of the sun's light. According to Clerk-Maxwell's electromagnetic theory, light exerts a pressure upon bodies upon which it falls which is proportional to the light energy in a unit of space. For bodies of considerable magnitude the pressure is relatively very small, though it has been detected by Nichols and Hall; but for minute bodies, say a ten-thousandth inch in diameter, the pressure may greatly exceed the sun's attraction. For still smaller bodies the light pressure becomes relatively larger until their diameters are approximately equal to a wave length of light, say, one fifty-thousandth of an inch. Then, as Schwarzschlad has shown, the light pressure decreases relatively to the force of gravitation. Consequently, if the particles are very much smaller than this limit, they will be driven away.
But it has been shown more recently by Lebedew that there is light pressure upon gases, in which the diameters of the molecules are always a very small fraction of a wave length of light, and that the pressure is proportional to the amount of energy which the gas absorbs. Consequently, it is not necessary to assume that the particles of which the tails of comets are composed are larger than molecules; it is generally agreed by astronomers that both electrical repulsion and light pressure are factors in the production of comets' tails. Nevertheless, there are outstanding phenomena which these theories do not explain. In the first place, there is no adequate explanation of the luminosity of comets' tails. As comets approach the sun, their tails increase in brightness much more rapidly than they should if they were shining only by reflected light. The luminosity of comets' tails is greater than for bodies whose density is double less far less than that in the best vacuum tubes. Moreover, at present time can scarcely be explained by a temperature effect. And still more embarrassing to these theories are the facts that comets' tails do not always point directly away from
CH. X, 1901
COMETS AND METEORS
327
the sun, and that sometimes they change their direction by a number of degrees in a very short time. For example, Barnard took photographs of Brooks' comet, 1893-IV, on November 2 and November 3. In this interval the comet moved forward in the course of about 1° and apparently, according to the theory of the direction of its tail should have changed about 1°. But there was an actual change of direction of the tail of 16° which has not been explained. There are also sudden and great changes in the character and luminosity of comets' tails which no theory explains. Sometimes secondary tails are developed with great rapidity, making an angle of as much as 45° with the line joining the head to the tail. Obviously some remains to be learned in connection with the tails of comets.
199. The Disintegration of Comets. — The particles that leave the head of a comet to form its tail never unite with it again. In this way, at each reappearance of a comet, that part of the material which goes to form its tail is dispersed into space; and, as the quantity remaining becomes increased, the tail becomes longer and longer. Possibly this is one of the reasons why Halley's comet in 1910 was not such a remarkable object as it seems to have been in some of its earlier apparitions.
There is another way in which comets disintegrate. Since their masses are very small, the mutual attractions of their parts are not sufficient to hold them together if they are subjected to strong disturbing forces. When they come near the sun, they may be torn apart by enormous tides. In fact, if they pass within Roche's limit (Art. 183), the tidal forces exceed their self gravitation unless they are as dense as the sun. Comets have such exceedingly low density that the limits of tidal disintegration for them must be very great. Consequently, when a comet passes near the sun, the tidal forces to which it is subject tend to tear it into fragments; which, of course, may be assembled again by their mutual gravitation after they have receded far from the sun. But on
328 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. x, 199
their way out they may pass near a planet which will exert analogous forces, and may so disorganize them that they will never again be united into a single body.
The theory which has just been outlined is clear. Now what have been the observed facts? Bial's comet was broken into two parts by some unknown forces, and the two components subsequently traveled in independent paths. The great comet of 1882 was seen to have a number of outlying fragments when it was in the vicinity of the sun, and many other comets have exhibited analogous phenomena.
Another class of disturbances in which comets are subject is the scattered meteoric material which may more or less fill the space among the planets. The phenomenon of the zodiacal light gives an almost certain proof of its extensive existence. Such scattered particles would have little effect on a dense body like a planet, but might cause serious disturbances in a luminous comet. In fact, there are many instances where comets have been subjected to unknown exterior forces. They are now and then more or less broken up, and occasionally the tails of comets have been apparently cut off and brushed aside.
Many comets which have been observed at two or three perihelion passages have been found to be fainter at each successive return than they were at the preceding, and some have even disappeared entirely. This leads to the conclusion that comets are slowly disintegrated under the disturbing forces of the sun and planets and the resisting meteoric material which they may encounter. As confirmation of this view, it may be noted that the members of Jupiter's family have small tails or none at all; that this comet family does not contain as many members as might be expected; and that a number of comets have totally disappeared after their first visitations.
200. Historical Comets. - In this article some of those comets will be briefly described which have exhibited phenomena of unusual interest. The enumeration of their
328
ch. x, 200] COMETS AND METEORS 329
peculiarities will illustrate the general statements which have preceded, and will give additional information respecting these remarkable objects.
The Comet of 1680. The comet of 1680 was the first one whose orbit was computed on the basis of the law of gravitation. Newton made the calculations and found that its period of revolution was about 600 years. It is one of the family of comets mentioned in Art. 195. At its perihelion it passed through the sun's corona at a distance of only 140,000 miles from its surface. It flew along this part of its orbit at the rate of 370 miles per second, and with its tail, 100,000,000 miles long, changed its direction to correspond with the motion of the comet in its orbit.
The Great Comet of 1811. The great comet of 1811 was visible from March 26, 1811, until August 17, 1812, and was carefully observed by William Herschel. He discovered from the changes in its brightness, that it shone partly by its own light; for its brilliancy increased as it approached the sun more and more rapidly than it would have done if it had been shining entirely by reflection. At this time its tail was 100,000,000 miles long and 15,000,000 miles in diameter. The phenomena connected with it suggested to Olbers the electrical repulsion theory of comets' tails.
Encke's Comet (1819).—Encke's comet was the first member of Jupiter's family to be discovered, and it has a shorter period (3.3 years) than any other known comet. At first sight it appeared to be very bright (Fig. 125), but it is noted for the fact that its period was shortened, presumably by encountering some resistance,
Encke's Comet (Barnard).
Fro. 125.—Encke's comet (Barnard).
330 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. x, 200
about 2.5 hours at each revolution until 1868; since that time the change in the period of revolution has been only one half as great. The change in volume of Eneke's comet at its perihelion was about 180,000 miles, or 135,000,000 miles from the sun and had a diameter of 312,000 miles; on December 24, its distance was 50,000,000 miles from the sun, and its diameter was only 14,000 miles; while at its perihelion passage, on December 17, 1838, at a distance of 32,000,000 miles, its diameter was only 3000 miles.
That is, at one time its volume was more than a million times greater than it was at another. Bode's Comet (1835) and the comet is also a small member of Jupiter's family and has a period of about 6.6 years. At its appearance in 1846, it presented no unusual phenomena until about the 20th of December, when it was considerably elongated. By the first of January it had separated into two distinct parts which traveled along in parallel orbits at a distance of about 160,000 miles from each other.
At this time the two parts were undergoing considerable changes in brightness and almost immediately after they were connected by a faint stream of light. At their appearance in 1852 the two components were 1,500,000 miles apart, and they have never been seen again, although searched for very carefully. De Vico's comet, of 1844, and Broersen's comet, of 1846, are also comets which have disappeared, the former having been observed but once, and the latter but twice before its disappearance.
Donati's Comet (1855)—Donati's comet was one of the greatest comets of the nineteenth century. It was visible with the unaided eye for 112 days, and through a telescope for more than 9 months. Its tail, which was more than 54,000,000 miles long, at one time subtended an angle of more than $3^{\circ}$ as seen from the earth. It moved in the retrograde direction in an orbit with a period of more than 2500 years, and at its aphelion its distance from the sun was more than 5.3 times that of Neptune.
CH. X, 200] COMETS AND METEORS 331
**Tebbutt's Comet (1861).** — Tebbutt's comet was of great dimensions, but is noteworthy chiefly because the earth passed through its tail. As could have been anticipated from the excessive tenacity of comet's tails, the earth experi-
enced considerable perturbations by the comet. The earth
must have passed through the tails of comets many times in
geological history, and there is no evidence whatever that it
has ever been disturbed by them. In fact, if a comet should
strike the earth, head on, it is probable that the result would
not be disastrous to the earth.
The **Great Comet of 1880 and 1882.** — The comets of 1880
and 1882 were two quite remarkable members of the most remark-
able family of comets which travel in the same orbit.
Both of these comets, as well as the earlier members of the
same family, are noteworthy for their vast dimensions, their
great brilliancy, and their close approach to the sun. The
comet of 1882 was observed both before and after peri-
helion passage. Although it swept through several hundred
degrees around the sun in its course, its orbit was not noticeably
altered. Yet it gave rise to a halo effect subject to violent disrupting forces. After perihelion passage it was
observed to have as many as 5 nuclei, while Barnard and other observers saw in the immediate vicinity as many as
6 or 8 small comet-like masses, apparently broken from the
large body, traveling in orbits parallel to it.
**Mercury's Comet (1908).** — On September 1, 1908,
Morison at the Yerkes Observatory discovered the third
comet of the year. It was found on photographic plates taken for other purposes, and is one of the few examples in
which comets have been discovered by photography. This
comet was never bright, but was one of the most remarkable
comets ever observed in the extent and variety of its activi-
ties. It was well situated for observation, and Barnard was able to follow it with his telescope for nearly a month. The
material which went into the tail of the comet was often
evolved with the most startling rapidity. For example, on
332 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [sec. x, 200
the 30th of September, in the early part of the night, the comet presented an almost normal appearance. Before the night was over, the tail had become cyclonic in form and extended to the horizon, where it was very fine and bright, like, by a very slender, curved, tapering neck. On the succeeding night the material that then constituted the tail was entirely detached from the head. On October 5, there was another large outbreak of material which was shown by successive photographs to be swiftly receding from the comet (fig. 128).
Not only was Messier's comet noteworthy for the extraordinary activities exhibited by its tail, but it changed in brightness in a very remarkable manner. It was generally considerably below the limits of visibility with the unaided eye, but now and then it would flash up, without apparent reason, for a day or so until it could be seen very faintly without a telescope. While a number of larger comets have been observed in recent years, no other has given evidence of such remarkable changes in the forces that produce comets' tails, and none other has exhibited such mysterious variations in brightness.
201. Halley's Comet. — Halley's comet is the most celebrated one in all the history of these objects. It is named after Halley, not because he discovered it, but because he computed its orbit from observations made in 1682 by the method which had been developed by his friend Newton. Halley found that this orbit was practically identical with the orbits of the comets of 1661 and 1531. He came to the conclusion that these various comets were only different appearances of the same one which was revolving around the sun in a period of about 75 years. The records of comets in 1456, 1301, 1145, and 1066 confirmed this view because these dates differ from 1682 by nearly integral multiples of 75 or 76 years. From his computations Halley predicted that the comet would appear again and pass its perihelion point on March 13, 1759.
cn. x, 201] COMETS AND METEORS 333
Fig. 126. — Morehouse's comet, Oct. 15, 1908. Photographed by Barnard at the Yerkes Observatory.
A starry night sky with a bright comet-like object in the center.
334 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cu. x, 20]
Many of Halley's contemporaries were very skeptical regarding this prediction. The law of gravitation had only recently been discovered and the certainty with which it had been established was not yet fully comprehended. Halley was accused by skeptics of seeing notoriety by making a prophecy and cleverly putting forward the date of its fulfillment, so far that he would be dead before his failure became known. However, before the 75 years had passed away, the law of gravitation had been firmly established, and many mathematical processes employed in astronomical work had become so well understood, that astronomers, at least, had implicit faith in the correctness
A diagram showing the orbit of Halley's comet.
Fig. 127.—The orbit of Halley's comet.
of Halley's prediction; although since its last appearance the comet had been invisible for the lifetime of a man and had gone out 3,000,000 miles from the sun to beyond the orbit of Neptune. There was great popular interest in the comet as the date for its return approached. It actually passed its perihelion within one month of the time predicted by Halley. The slight error in the prediction was due to the imperfect observations of its positions in 1682, and to the perturbations by planets which were then unknown. This was the first verification of such a prediction; and the difficulty of predicting it, which it was, had been entirely unapproached in the case of all the prophecies which the world had known up to that time.
Halley's comet passed the sun again in 1835. At this
CH. X, 201] COMETS AND METEORS 335
time it was so accurately observed that its subsequent orbit could be computed with a high degree of precision. If it had made its next revolution in the same period as the one
A comet visible against a dark sky.
Fig. 128. —Halley's comet, May 20, 1910. Photographed by Barnard at the Yerkes Observatory.
ending in 1835, it would have passed its perihelion in July, 1912. Instead of this, it passed its perihelion on April 19, 1910. The perturbations of the remote planets reduced its
336 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ex. x, 201
period by more than two years. The most accurate com-
putations of its orbit and predictions of the time of its re-
turn were made by Cowell and Crommelin, of Greenwich,
who missed the time of perihelion passage by only 2.7 days.
Their computations were so accurate that even this small
discrepancy could not be the result of accumulated errors,
and they believe that the comet has been subject to some
A diagram showing the orbits of various planets around the Sun. The Sun is at the center, with Earth, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune, and Pluto depicted as ellipses around it. The orbits are labeled with their respective months (FEBRUARY, MARCH, APRIL, MAY) and distances (in millions of miles). The diagram also shows the comet's path around the Sun, which is depicted as a curved line connecting the positions of the comet at different times.
Fig. 129.—The relations of the sun, earth, and Halley's comet in 1910.
unknown forces. Its next return will be about 1985, and Fig. 127 shows the position in its orbit for various epochs during this interval. In order to get the precise time of its return, it will be necessary to take into account the pertur-
bations of the planets.
While Halley's comet is a very large one (Fig. 128), its latest appearance was somewhat disappointing, especially to
the general public, who had been led to expect that it would
337
COMETS AND METEORS
cii: x, 202]
rival the sun in brightness. One of the reasons for the dis-
appointment was that the earth was not very near the comet
when it was at its perihelion where it was brightest and had
the longest tail. The orbit of the earth around the sun and
sun in this part of its orbit are shown in Fig. 129, drawn by
Barnard. On May 5, the length of the comet's tail was
37,000,000 miles. On May 18 the comet passed between
the earth and the sun and was entirely invisible when pro-
jected on the sun's disk. This shows that even its nucleus
was extremely tenuous and transparent. At this time the
earth passes through almost the outlying part of its tail.
Neither at this time nor at another did the comet have any
sensible influence upon the earth. On the whole, it was
altogether devoid of interesting features.
II. Meteors
202. Meteors, or Shooting Stars. An attentive watch
of the sky on almost any clear, moonless night will show one
or more so-called "shooting stars." They are little flashes
which have the appearance of a star darting across
the sky and disappearing. Instead of being actual stars,
which are great bodies like our sun, they are, as a matter
of fact, tiny masses so small that a person could hold one
in his hand. Under certain circumstances of motion and
position, they dash into the earth's atmosphere at a speed
from 10 to 40 miles per second, and the heat generated
by friction vaporizes the air before them and blows them
up. The products of the combustion and pulverization slowly
fall to the earth if they are solid, or are added to the atmos-
phere if they are gaseous. Since it is misleading to call them
"shooting stars," they will always be called "meteors"
hereafter.
The distances of meteors were first determined in 1798
by Bode and Benzinger at Göttingen. They made simultaneous observations of them from positions separated by a few miles, and from the differences in their apparent
A diagram showing the orbit of Earth around the Sun.
2
338 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. x, 202
directions they computed their altitudes above the surface of the earth (Art. 29). Their observations and those of many succeeding astronomers show whom may be mentioned Denning of England, and Olbers of Germany, have shown that meteors rarely, if ever, become visible at altitudes as great as 100 miles, and nearly all of them dis- appear before they have descended to within 30 miles of the earth's surface.
The velocity with which a meteor enters the atmosphere can be found by determining the point at which it becomes visible, the point at which it disappears, and the interval of time during which it is visible. The amount of energy given out by a meteor can be determined from its apparent brightness, its distance from the observer, and the time during which it is radiant. The energy radiated by a meteor has its source in the heat generated by the friction of the meteor with the earth's atmosphere, and it cannot exceed the kinetic energy of the meteor when it entered the atmosphere. This is true for all the kinetic energy of a meteor is transformed into light. This statement is not quite true, but it will be approximately true for matter moving with the high speed of a meteor. Then, since the energy of motion of a body is one half its mass multiplied by the square of its velocity, the mass of the meteor can be com- pleted because its light energy and velocity can be deter- mined directly from observations by the methods which have been described. By such means it has been found that ordinarily the masses of meteors do not exceed a few tenths of an ounce. However, the observations are difficult to determine and the subject has received relatively less attention than it deserves. Consequently, no great reliance should be placed on the precise numerical results.
203. The Number of Meteors.—If a person scans the sky in an hour or so and finds that he can see only a few meteors, he is tempted to draw the conclusion that the number of them which strike the earth's atmosphere daily is not very
CU. X, 204] COMETS AND METEORS 339
large. He bases his conclusion mostly on the fact that half of the celestial sphere is within his range of vision, but a diagram representing the earth and its atmosphere to scale will show him that he can see by no means half the meteors which strike the earth's atmosphere. As a matter of fact, he can see the atmosphere over only a few square miles of the earth.
From very many counts of the number of meteors which can be seen from a single place during a given time, it has been computed that between 10 and 20 millions of them strike into the earth's atmosphere daily. There are probably several times this number which are so small that they escape observation. Often when astronomers are working with telescopes they see faint meteors dart across the field of vision which would be quite invisible to the unaided eye.
The places where they strike the earth and the velocities of their encounter depend both upon their own velocities and also upon that of the earth around the sun. The side of the earth which is ahead in its motion encounters more meteors than the opposite, for it receives not only those which it meets, but also those which it overtakes, while the rear side of the earth encounters fewer meteors than those which overtake it. The meridian is on the forward side of the earth in the morning and on the rearward side in the evening. It is found by observation that more meteors are seen in the morning than in the evening, and that the relative velocities of impact are greater.
**204. Meteoric Showers.** Occasionally unusual numbers of meteors are seen, and then it is said that there is a meteoric shower. There have been a few instances in which meteors were so numerous that they could not be counted, but usually not more than one or two appear in a minute.
At the time of a meteoric shower the meteors are not only more numerous than usual, but a majority of them move so that when their apparent paths are projected back-
340 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. x. 204
ward, they pass through, or very near, a point in the sky. This point is called the *radiant point* of the shower, for the meteors all appear to radiate from it. A number of meteor trails which clearly define a radiant point are shown in Fig. 130.
The most conspicuous meteoric showers occur on November 15 and November 24 yearly. The former have their radiant in Leo, within the sickle, and are called the *Leonids*.
Meteor trails defining a radiant point (Oliver).
From the position of this constellation (Arts. 82, 93), it follows that they can be seen only in the early morning hours. The latter have their radiant in Andromeda, and are called the *Andromidae*. They can be seen only in the early part of the night. The Leonids and Andromidas are not equally numerous every year. Great showers of the Leonids occurred in 1833 and 1866, and have remarkable ones, though rare, at intervals since 1872. The Andromidae appear in unusual numbers every thirteen years.
Besides these meteoric showers, according to Denning,
130
cu. x, 206]
COMETS AND METEORS
341
nearly 3000 other less conspicuous ones have been found.
The Perseids appear for a week or more near the middle of August, the Lyrids on or about April 20, the Orionids on or about October 20, etc.
205. Explanation of the Radiant Point. — In 1834 Olm-
sted showed that the apparent radiation of meteors from a point is due to the fact that they move in parallel lines,
and that we see only the projection of their motion on the
celestial sphere. Thus, in Fig. 131, the actual paths of the meteors are AB, but their apparent paths as seen by an
observer at O are AC. When these lines are all continued
A diagram showing the radiant point of meteors. The path of a meteor is shown as a line AB, which appears to originate from point A when observed from point O. The actual path of the meteor is AC, while its apparent path is AB.
backward, they meet in the point which is in the direction
from which the meteors come.
It follows that the meteors which give rise to the meteoric
showers are moving in vast swarms along orbits which inter-
sect the orbit of the earth. When the earth passes through
the swarm, a shower occurs; if it encounters no meteorite and
a shower occurs. Thus, the orbit of the Leonids touches
the orbit of the earth at the point which the earth occupies on
November 14. In this case the earth meets the meteors
(Fig. 132), while the Andromids overtake the earth.
206. Connection between Comets and Meteors. — The
fact that the volatile material of which comets' tails are
composed gradually becomes invisible, and that, at times,
comets themselves become invisible, and the fact that
meteoric showers are due to wandering swarms of small
Fig. 131.—Explanation of the radiant point of meteors.
131
342 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. x, 206]
particles which revolve around the sun in elongated elliptical orbits, suggest the hypothesis that comets and meteors are related. The hypothesis is confirmed and virtually proved by the identity of the orbits of certain meteoric swarms and comets.
In 1866 Schiaparelli showed that the August meteors move in the same orbit as Tuttle's comet of 1862. That is, in addition to the comet, which is a member of Saturn's family, there are many other small bodies (meteors) traveling in the same orbit. In 1875 G. H. Carruth found that the Leonidae move in the same orbit as Tempel's comet of 1862, while Weiss showed that the meteors of April 20 and the
Diagram showing the orbits of various celestial bodies.
132 — Orbit of the Leonid meteors.
comet of 1861 move in the same orbit, and that the paths of the Andromedids and Biesla's comet were likewise the same.
It has also been claimed that the Aquarid meteors of early May have an orbit almost identical with that of Halley's comet.
While it is not possible to be certain as to the origin of comets, the history of their later evolution and final end is tolerably clear. The elongated orbits in which they may have originally moved are reduced when they are captured by the planets. Their periods of revolution are subsequently altered by perturbations from other planets, their tails, and the remaining material is scattered along their orbits by the dispersive forces to which they are subject.
343
COMETS AND METEORS
If these orbits cross the orbit of a planet, the remains of the comets are gradually swept up by the larger body. If an orbit of a comet does not originally cross the orbit of a planet, the perturbations of the planets will, in general, in the course of time, cause it to do so. The result will be that the planets sweep up more and more of the remains of disintegrated comets, and gradually increase in mass in this manner.
**207. Effects of Meteors on the Solar System.**
The most obvious effect of the numerous meteors which swarm in the solar system is a resistance both to the rotations and the revolutions of all the bodies. As was stated in Art. 45, the effects of meteors upon the rotation of the earth are at present exceedingly slight, and it is very probable that their influences upon the rotations of the other members of the solar system are still less. But since the perturbing rotatory motion of a body causes its orbit to decrease in size. Hence, so far as the meteors affect the planets in this way, they cause them continually to approach the sun.
Another effect of meteors upon the members of the solar system is to increase their masses by the accretion of matter which may have come originally from far beyond the orbit of Neptune. When the meteors fall into such bodies, increasing their mutual attractions increases and the orbits of the planets become smaller. Looking backward in time, we are struck by the possibility that the accretion of meteoric matter may have been more rapid in former times, and that it may have been an important factor in the growth of the planets from much smaller bodies.
**208. Meteorites.** Sometimes bodies weighing from a few ounces to several hundred pounds, or even a few tons, dash into the earth's atmosphere, glow brilliantly from the heat generated by the friction, roar like a waterfall, occasionally produce violent detonations, and end by falling on the earth. Such bodies are called **meteorites**, **sidérites**, or **aérolites**.
About two or three meteorites are seen to fall yearly; but,
cx. x, 208
344 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. x, 208
since a large part of the earth is covered with water or is uninhabitable for other reasons, it is probable that in all at least 100 strike the earth annually. The outside of a meteorite during its passage through the atmosphere is subjected to intense and sudden heating, and the rapid expansion of its surface layers often breaks it into many fragments. The surface is fused and on striking cools rapidly. The result is that it has a black, glossy structure, usually with many small pits where the less refractive material has been melted.
out.
Since meteors pass entirely through the atmosphere in a few seconds, only their surfaces give evidence of the extremes of heat and pressure to which they have been subjected.
Most meteors are composed of stone, though it is often mixed with some metallic iron. Even where pure iron is not present, some of its compounds are usually found. About three or four out of every hundred are nearly pure iron with a little nickel. All together about 30 elements which occur elsewhere on the earth have been found in meteorites, but no strange ones. Yet in some respects their structure is quite different from that of terrestrial substances. They
Fig. 13.—Stony meteorite which fell at Long Island, Kansas; weight, 700 pounds (Farnkotoun).
344
CH. X., 209j
COMETS AND METEORS
345
have peculiar crystals, they show but little oxidation and no action of water, and they contain in their interstices relatively large quantities of occluded gases, some of which are combustible. According to Farrington, some meteors give evidence of fragmentation and recementation, others show faulting (fracture and sliding of one surface on another) with recementation, and others, veins where foreign material has been slowly deposited.
209. Theories respecting the Origin of Meteorites. — If it were known that meteorites are but meteors which are so large that they reach the earth before they are completely
Fig. 134.—Iron meteorite from Cazon Diablo, Arizona; weight, 265 pounds (Farrington).
Fig. 135.—Durango, Mexico. Meteorite showing peculiar crystallisation characteristic of certain meteorites (Farrington).
346 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. x, 209
oxidized and pulverized, we might justly conclude that they are probably the remains of disintegrated comets. This would enable us to learn certain things about comets which cannot be settled yet. But no meteorite is known certainly to have been a member of any meteoric swarm. However, two meteorites have fallen during the last century, one, near Paris, in France in 1854, the other, the Lyrids in 1905, and the other in Mexico, just before the Andromedids in 1885.
The structure of some meteorites is more like that of lava from deep volcanoes than anything else found on the earth. An old theory was that they have been ejected by volcanic explosions from the moon, planets, or perhaps the sun. This theory would account for some of their characteristics, and would explain why they contain only familiar elements, at least those found on the earth; but it does not at all explain the fragmentation, faulting, and veins, for forces great enough to produce ejections would scarcely be found without heat enough to produce at least fusion.
Chamberlin has maintained that meteorites may be the débris of bodies, perhaps planetary dimensions, which have been broken up by tidal strains when they have passed some larger mass within Roche's limit. When sins pass by other bodies, they are torn into fragments intermingled with each other near each other that their planets (if they have any) are broken up. More rarely, the suns themselves may be disintegrated. Indeed, this may be the origin of all cometary and meteoric matter. Whether it is or not, there is here a possibility of disintegration which must be taken into account in any theory of cosmic evolution.
The present desiderata are more accurate determinations of comet orbits and velocities. Often these are really hyperbolic, more accurate determinations of the velocities of meteors to find whether they ever come into our system on parabolic or hyperbolic orbits, and finally the answer to the question whether meteors and meteorites are really related.
cn. x, 206) COMETS AND METEORS 347
The suggestion that a meteorite may be a fragment of a world which was disrupted before the origin of the earth makes some demands on the imagination, but it seems no more incredible to us than seemed the suggestion to our predecessors a century ago that great mountains have been utterly destroyed by the rains and snows and winds.
XIV. QUESTIONS
1. What observations would prove that comets are not in the earth's atmosphere, as the ancients supposed they were?
2. Suppose two small masses are moving around the sun in the same direction, yet, both being attracted equally towards it, one ahead of the other.
How would their motions depart vary with their positions (their orbit - use the law of areas)? Does this suggest an explanation of the variations in the dimensions of comets' heads?
3. The aphelion point of a comet's parabolic orbit is inversely as the square root of its distance from the sun. At the distance of the earth a comet has a velocity of about 25 miles per second. What is the distance between the comets of 1843 and 1882 when they reach their aphelion points? What is their period?
4. Suppose the particles of which a comet is composed have almost exactly the same perihelion point but somewhat different aphelion points. How would the dimensions of the comet vary with these differences?
5. By means of Kepler's third law compute the period of a comet whose aphelion point is at a distance of 140,000 astronomical units from the sun.
6. What objections are there to the theory that originally all comets had an aphelion distance equal to that of Neptune, and that the orbits of some have been increased and others diminished by the action of perturbing planets?
7. On the repulsion theory should a comet's tail be equally long when it is approaching the sun and when it is receding?
8. Draw the diagram mentioned in the first paragraph of Art. 203.
9. Counting up all comets you can observe in an hour on some clear, moonless night.
10. If possible, observe the Leonid or Andromedan meteors.
11. Make a list of the fairly well-established cometary phenomena, and of those for which no satisfactory theory exists.
Fig. 136. — The tower telescope of the solar observatory of the Carnegie Institution of Washington, Pasadena, California.
368
CHAPTER XI
THE SUN
I. THE SUN'S HEAT
210. The Problem of the Sun's Heat. — The light and heat radiated by the sun are essential for the existence of life on the earth, and consequently the question of the source of the sun's energy, how long it has been supplied, and how long it will last are of vital interest. Not only are these questions of importance because the sun is the dominant member of the solar system, governing the motions of the planets and illuminating and heating them with its abundant rays, but also because the sun is a star, and the only one known to us in our immediate vicinity, so that its surface can be studied in detail.
Obviously the first thing to do in studying the heat of the sun is to measure the amount received from it by the earth; then, the amount which the sun radiates can be computed. The amount of heat given out by the sun gives the basis for determining its temperature. This naturally follows the question of the origin of the sun's heat. The answers to this question are of great importance in considering the evolution of the solar system and the stars.
211. The Amount of Radiant Energy received by the Earth from the Sun. — Light is a wave motion in the ether whose waves lengths vary from about $\frac{4}{5}$000 of an inch, in the violet, to about $\frac{4}{5}$000 of an inch, in the red. Radiant heat differs from light physically only in that its waves are much longer than those of light. It is therefore not capable of exciting ether waves of certain lengths and not to those that are longer or shorter is, of course, of no importance in discussing
349
350 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY (ch. xi, 211
the physical question of the sun's heat. Consequently, in the problem of solar radiation rays of all wave lengths are included, and together they constitute the radiant energy emitted by the sun.
Physicists have devised various methods of measuring the amount of energy received from a radiating source. In applying them to the problem of determining the amount of energy received from the sun the chief difficulty consists in making correct allowance for the absorption of light and heat by the earth's atmosphere. The best results have been obtained by making simultaneous measurements from sea-level, and from the top of lofty mountains and from balloons. Langley measured the intensity of solar radiation at the top of Mount Whitney, 14,887 feet above the sea, and at its base. He arrived at the conclusion that 40 per cent of the rays striking the atmosphere perpendicularly, when it is free from clouds, are absorbed before they reach the surface of the earth; later investigations have reduced this estimate to 35 per cent. The work initiated by Langley has been continued by several investigators, among whom are Dr. W. H. Bragg, Professor E. W. Morley, and Professor J. R. Aldrich, and they find that the rate at which radiant energy of all wave lengths is received by the earth from the sun at the outer surface of our atmosphere when the sun is at its mean distance is, in terms of mechanical work, 1.51 horse power per square yard.
The earth intercepts a cylinder of rays from the sun whose cross section is equal to a circle whose diameter equals the diameter of the earth. The area of this circle is, therefore, $\pi r^2$, where $r$ equals $3055 \times 1760 = 6,960,000$ yards. Hence, the rate at which solar energy is intercepted by the whole earth is in round numbers $230,000,000,000$ horse power.
In the evolution of life upon the earth the sun has been as important a factor as the earth itself. Consequently, geologists and biologists have a deep interest in the sun, and par- 1 The mean radius of the earth is 3055 miles and there are 1760 yards in a mile.
CH. XI, 212]
THE SUN
351
ticularly in the question whether or not its rate of radiation is constant. It has long been supposed that probably the sun is slowly cooling off and that the light and heat received from it are gradually diminishing, but it was a distinct surprise when Langley and Abbott found that its rate of radiation per square inch varied for a few days by as much as 10 per cent. If a change of this magnitude in the rate of radiation of the sun were to persist indefinitely, the mean temperature of the earth would be changed about 13° Fahrenheit; but a variation of 10 per cent for only a few days has no important effect on the climate. Abbott, Fowler, and Aldrich have continued the investigation of this question, and by making observations simultaneously in Algeria, in Washing-ton, and in California, so as to eliminate the effects of local atmospheric conditions, they have firmly established the reality of small and rapid variations in the sun's rate of radiation.
The question of variation in the amount of energy received from the sun can also be considered in the light of geological evidence. The fossils preserved in the rocks of all geological ages prove that there has been an unbroken life chain upon the earth for many tens of millions of years. This means that during any given period of time the temperature of the earth has been neither very high nor very low all life. Moreover, the record is clear that, in spite of glacial epochs and intervening warmer eras, the temperature changes have not been very great, and there is no evidence of a progressive cooling of the sun.
212. Sources of Energy used by Man.—One of the earliest extensive sources of energy for mechanical work used by man was fire. It was burned and still burns millions of windmills for driving machinery or pumping water. Until the last few decades it moved nearly all of the ocean-borne commerce of the whole world, and it is still an important factor in shipping. But that part of the energy of the wind which is used is an insignificant fraction of all that
352 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. xi, 212]
exists. For example, if, in a breeze blowing at the rate of 20 miles an hour, all the energy in the air crossing an area 100 feet square perpendicular to its direction of motion were used, it would do about 560 horse power of work.
What is the origin of the energy in the wind? The sun warms the earth's surface more than it warms the regions of the earth more than that over the higher latitudes, and the resulting convection currents constitute the wind. Consequently, all the energy in every wind that blows came originally from the sun.
Another source of energy which has been of great practical value is water power. The source of this energy is also the sun, because the sun's heat evaporates the water and raises it into the air a half mile or more, the winds carry part of it to other parts of the earth where it cools and condenses, descending again to the ocean it may now and then plunge over a precipice, where its energy can be utilized by men. Amazing as are the figures for such great waterfalls as Niagara, they give but a faint idea of the enormous work the sun has done in raising water into the sky, and the equally great amount of work the water does in falling back to the earth. During a heavy rain an inch of water may fall. An inch of rain on an area of 600 square miles will produce 36 million gallons of water. In the eastern half of the United States, where the annual rainfall is about 35 inches, every year over 2,000,000 tons of water fall on each square mile from a height of half a mile or more.
The great modern source of energy for mechanical work is coal. The coal has formed from vegetable matter which accumulated in peat beds ages and ages ago. Consequently, the immediate source of its energy is the plant material from which it has developed. But though it comes directly from the sun. In millions of tiny cells the sun's energy broke up the carbon dioxide which they inhaled from the atmosphere; then the oxygen was exhaled and the carbon was stored up in their tissues. When a plant is burned, as much
353
THE SUN
cn. xi, 213]
energy is developed and given up again as the sun put into it when it grew.
Thus it is seen that all the great sources of energy can be traced back to the sun; it is true of the minor ones also.
One naturally inquires whether these sources of energy are exhausted? The answer is no. Coal and petroleum will let the rains to descend as long as the earth and sun exist in their present conditions, but the coal and petroleum will eventually be exhausted. They will last several centuries and perhaps a few thousand years. This period seems long compared to the lifetime of an individual, or perhaps of a nation, but it is only a minute fraction of the time during which our ancestors will probably occupy this earth. It follows that the sun will continue to give up sources of energy at present but little utilized. Perhaps some great benefactor of mankind will discover a means of putting to direct use the enormous quantities of energy which the sun is now sending to the earth. At present we are depending on that infinitesimal residue of the energy which the earth received in earlier geological times and which has been stored up and preserved by petroleum and coal.
213. Amount of Energy Radiated by the Sun.—The earth as seen from the sun subtends an angle of only 17°.6'. That is, its apparent area is about $\frac{1}{4}$th the greatest apparent area of Venus as seen from the earth. A glance at Venus will show that this is an exceedingly small part of the whole celestial sphere. Since the little earth at a distance of 93,000,000 of miles receives the enormous quantity of heat given out by the sun, 211 it follows that the amount which is lost by the earth must be inconceivably small. It can be brought within the range of our understanding only by contemplating some of the things it might do.
The energy radiated per square yard from the sun's surface is equivalent to 70,000 horse power. This amount of heat energy would melt a layer of ice 2200 feet thick every hour all over the surface of the sun; and it would melt a globe of
2 a
354 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xi, 213
ice as large as the earth in 2 hours and 40 minutes. Less than one two-billionth of the energy poured forth by the sun is intercepted by the earth, and less than ten times this amount by all the planets together; the remainder travels on to the moon, the other to the regions of the stars at the rate of 186,000 miles per second.
214. The Temperature of the Sun. — Stefan's law (Art. 172) that a black body radiates as the fourth power of its absolute temperature, gives a basis for determining the temperature of a body whose rate of radiation is known.
While the sun is probably not an ideal radiator, such as is contemplated in the statement of Stefan's law, and while it radiates from layers at various depths below its surface, with an upper limit of about 10,000 degrees Fahrenheit from the lower, yet an approximate idea of the temperature of its radiating layers can be obtained from its rate of radiation. On using Stefan's law as a basis for computation, it is found that the temperature of the radiating layers of the sun is at least 10,000° Fahrenheit. Or, it would be more accurate to say that an ideal radiating surface at this temperature would have the same rate of radiation as the sun, and since the sun is not a perfect radiator, its temperature is probably somewhat higher. The temperature in the sun's layers is several degrees higher than has been obtained in the most efficient electrical furnaces, and is far beyond that required to melt or vaporize any known terrestrial substance; yet, the temperature of the interior of the sun is undoubtedly far higher.
Another method of determining the temperature of the sun is from the proportion of energy of different wave lengths which it radiates. A body of low temperature radiates relatively a large amount of light and a small amount of blue light. As the temperature rises the relative proportion of blue light increases. The uncertainties in the results obtained by this method of determining the temperature of the sun arise, in the first place, from the fact that, at the
CH. XI, 215]
THE SUN
355
best, it is not very precise, and, in the second place, from the fact that both the sun's and the earth's atmosphere absorb very unequally radiant energy of various wave lengths. After making the necessary allowances for the absorption, the results obtained by this method confirm those found by the other.
There have been a number of other methods of obtaining the temperature of the sun from the time of Newton, but most of them have rested on physical principles which are unsound, and in some cases they have led to most extravagant results.
21. The Principle of the Conservation of Energy. — Before taking up the question of the origin of the sun's heat, it is advisable to consider the principle of the conservation of energy. It is comparable in importance and generality to the principle of the conservation (indestructibility) of matter. It was once supposed that when inflammable material, as wood, is burned, it is utterly annihilated. But it has been known for about 150 years that if the ashes, the carbon and hydrogen combined by combustion are all gathered up and weighed in a vacuum, their weight would exactly equal that of the original wood together with the oxygen which united with it in burning.
Similarly, it was supposed until after 1840 that energy might be destroyed as well as transformed. For example, it was supposed that the energy lost by friction ceased to exist. But it had been noted that bodies produced heat, and hence it was thought that heat could not be destroyed, for it had been turned into work, for example, by means of the steam engine. It does not seem now to have been a large step to have conjectured that the heat produced by the friction is exactly equivalent to the energy lost. But many elaborate experiments were required (made mostly by Mayer and Joule) to prove the correctness of this conjecture and to lead to the generalization, now universally accepted, that the total amount of energy in the universe is always the
356 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ce. xi. 215
same. This is one of the most far-reaching principles of science, and, like the law of gravitation, is involved in every phenomenon in which there is motion of matter.
The energy of a body at rest in the principle of the conservation of energy (potential energy) and motion (kinetic energy) and also its energy of position or the power it may have of doing work because of its position (potential energy). It is the sum of the potential and kinetic energies of the universe which is constant. Since energy may be in a radiant form and in transit from one body to another, or from a body out into endless space, the principle holds only when the energy which is in either is also included.
215. Contractions of the Sun and Heat. The mutual attraction of the particles of which the sun is composed tend to cause it to contract. A contraction of the sun would be equivalent to a fall of all of its particles toward its center. If they should fall the whole distance one at a time, they would generate a certain amount of heat upon their impacts. If they should fall simultaneously, first a fraction of the distance and then another, the same total amount of heat would be generated. It might be supposed with some reason that such a simultaneous contraction would be necessary in order to produce enough heat to change appreciably the temperature of the sun.
The effect of the sun's contraction can be considered more exactly in terms of energy. The sun in an expanded condition would have more potential energy with respect to the force of gravitation than if it were contracted, because work would be done on it by gravitation in changing it from this state to that. In other words, since less potential energy or temperature, of the sun must rise on its contraction. It is analogous to a falling body. The higher it is above the surface of the earth, the greater its potential energy; the farther it falls, the more potential energy it loses and the more kinetic energy it acquires.
The problem is to determine whether the contraction of
cc. xi, 216]
THE SUN 357
the sun might not supply it with heat to take the place of that which it radiates so lavishly. With this insight of genius, Helmholtz saw the nature of the question and fore-
saw its probable answer. In 1854, at a celebration in com-
memoration of the philosopher Kant, he gave a solution of the problem under consideration. He supposed the sun contracts in such a way as to remain always homogeneous.
He presented data regarding its rate of radiation, its volume,
and its mass, it is found by the methods of Helmholtz that,
under the assumption that it is homogeneous and remains
homogeneous during its shrinking, a contraction of its radius
of 120 feet per year would produce as much heat as it radi-
ates annually. This contraction is so small that it could
not be detected from the distance of the earth with our most
powerful telescopes.
So far in this discussion it has been assumed that the sun
contracts, and the consequences of the contraction have been deduced.
It remains to consider the question whether under
the conditions which prevail it actually does contract. The
reason it does not at once shrink under the mutual gravitation
of its parts is that its high temperature gives it a great
tendency to expand. As it radiates energy into space its
temperature decreases, and as it cools down, its tem-
perature permits it to contract a little; the contraction pro-
duces heat which momentarily restores the equilibrium;
and so on in an endless cycle. This conclusion is certainly correct, as Ritter and Lane proved about 1870, provided
the sun behaves as a nonatomic gaseous body. Moreover,
Lane established the fact, known as Lane's paradox, that
a body of a purely gaseous body cannot contract, its
temperature will increase with decreasing volume and greater concentration of matter, the gravitational forces can withstand stronger expansive tendencies due to high temperature. If, with increasing concentration, the laws of gases fail because the deep interior becomes liquid or solid,
the temperature might no longer increase.
358 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xl, 216]
The question of the variation in the rate of radiation of a contracting sun with increasing age is an important one. Lane showed that, so long as the sun obeys the law of gases, its temperature is inversely as its radius. By Stefan's law the rate of radiation is proportional to the fourth power of the absolute temperature. Consequently, since the area of a surface, per unit area, of a contracting gaseous sphere is inversely as the fourth power of its radius. But the whole radiating surface is proportional to the square of the radius. Therefore the rate of radiation of the entire surface of a contracting gaseous sphere is inversely as the square of its radius. That is, according to this theory, the earth received continually less heat more than half the sun's supposed to be perfectly gaseous, if it had been hot yet at all times. When the sun's radius was twice as great as it is at present it gave the earth one fourth as much heat, and the theoretical temperature of the earth (Art. 172) was about 200 degrees lower than at present.
217. Other Theories of the Sun's Heat. — A number of other hypotheses as to the source of the sun's energy have been advanced, but they are all inadequate. They will be enumerated here in order that the reader may not suppose that they are important, and that astronomers have failed to consider them.
The most obvious suggestion is that the sun started hot and is simply cooling. If it had the very high specific heat of water, at its present rate of radiation its mean temperature would fall 25.7 degrees annually. On referring to its present temperature, it is seen that its radiation could not continue much longer than ten years, and that a few thousand years ago its rate of radiation was about seven times that at present. These results are absurd and show the falsity of the suggestion.
It is natural to associate heat with something burning, and one naturally inquiries whether the heat of the sun cannot be accounted for by the combustion of the material
CH. XI, 217)
THE SUN
359
of which it is composed. In considering this hypothesis the first thing to be noted is that the same material will burn only once. It is found from the amount of heat produced by coal that if the sun were entirely made up of the best anthracite coal and oxygen in such proportion that when burned it would produce exactly the same amount of heat as either, the heat generated would supply the present rate of radiation less than 1500 years. If none of the heat produced by the combustion were radiated away, and if the specific heat of the sun were unity, the temperature of the sun would rise to only about one third of its present value. Consequently this theory is even less satisfactory than the preceding.
Shortly after the discovery of the law of the conservation of energy, a large amount of heat generated by the impact of meteors was established. The heat generated by a meteor striking into the earth's atmosphere at the average rate of 25 miles per second is about 100 times as great as would be produced by its combustion if it were oxygen and anthracite coal. A meteor would fall into the sun from the distance of the earth with a velocity of about 380 miles per second, and since the energy is proportional to the square of the velocity, it would contain about 25,000 times that produced by the combustion of an equal amount of carbon and oxygen. Lord Kelvin supposed that possibly enough meteors strike into the sun to replenish the energy it loses by radiation.
A complete answer to the meteoric theory of the sun's heat is that it comprises an impossibly large total mass for all meteors. They could not possibly exist in sufficient number within the earth's orbit, and if they came from without, they would strike the earth in enormously greater numbers than are observed. In fact, computation shows that if the heat of the sun were due to meteors coming into it from all directions and from beyond the earth's orbit, the earth would receive $\frac{1}{2}$ as much heat directly from the
360 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY Icn. xi. 217
meteors as it receives from the sun. This is millions of times more heat than the earth receives from meteors, and, consequently, the theory that the sun's heat is maintained by the impact of meteors is untenable.
218 The Age of the Future of the Sun on the Basis of the Contraction Theory. The contraction theory of the sun's heat is the only one of those considered which even begins to satisfy the conditions a successful theory must meet. If it is the only important source of the sun's heat, it is possible to determine, at least roughly, how long the sun can have been radiating at its present rate, and how long it can continue to radiate in the future.
Considered in this light, if we assume that contracted from infinite expansion, the widest possible dispersion, the total amount of heat generated would have been less than 20,000,000 times the amount now radiated annually. If it had contracted only from the distance of the earth's orbit, the amount of heat that would have been generated would have been about one half of one per cent less. Therefore, according to the contraction theory, the earth can have received heat from the sun during a period of 20,000,000 years. If the sun is strongly condensed at its center, this time limit should be increased about 5,000,000 years.
In the future, according to this theory, the sun will contract more and more until it ceases to be gaseous. Probably by the time its mean density equals 5 its temperature will begin to fall. A contraction to this density will produce enough heat to supply the present rate of radiation only after 10,000,000 years. After this time has elapsed, if no other important source of its energy, its temperature will begin to fall, its rate of radiation will diminish, the temperature of the earth will gradually decline, and all life on the earth will eventually become extinct. The sun, a dead and invisible mass, will speed on through space with its retinue of lifeless planets.
219 The Age of the Earth. — After the development of the contraction theory of the sun's heat, physicists, among
cu. xx, 219] THE SUN 361
whom Lord Kelvin was especially prominent, informed the geologists and biologists in rather arbitrary terms that the earth was not more than 25,000,000 years of age, and that all the great series of changes with which their sciences had made them familiar must have taken place within this period. But the evidence of the geologists is far above all others, and other lines of evidence as to the age of the earth are entitled to a full hearing. If they should unmistakably agree that the earth is much more than 25,000,000 years of age, the inevitable conclusion would be that the contraction theory is not the whole truth. This is a matter of the greatest importance, for not only is it at the founda-
tion of our interpretation of many geological evolutions, but it also vitally concerns the question of the stars and on the past and the future of the sidereal universe.
One of the simplest methods employed by geologists for determining the age of the earth is that of computing the time necessary for the oceans to acquire their salinity. The rivers that flow into the oceans carry to them various kinds of salts in solution; the water that is evaporated from them leaves these salts behind. Consequently the salinity of the oceans continually increases. It is clear that it is possible to compute the age of the oceans from the present amount of salt in them and the rate at which it is being carried into them. Of course, it is necessary to make some assumptions regarding the rate at which salt was carried to the sea in earlier geological ages. The last factor is somewhat uncertain, but this method has led to the conclusion that when all the salt contained in all the oceans were formed and salt began to be carried down in them is more than 60,000,000 years, and that it is probably from 90,000,000 to 140,000,000 years.
Nearly all the rocks that are exposed on the surface of the earth are stratified. This means that, on the whole, they have been formed from silt carried by the wind and water and deposited on the bottoms of lakes or oceans.
362 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xx, 219]
These stratified deposits are in many places of enormous thickness. When it is remembered that the present rocks are usually not the result of the simple disintegration and depo-
osition of the original earth material, but that most of them have been repeatedly broken up and redeposited, it is evi-
dent that the earth requires a very long period of stratification which is now observed is enormous. There is obviously
no divergence of views regarding the rates at which these processes have gone on, but nearly every calculation on this basis has led to the conclusion that the time since the dis-
integration and stratification of the earth's rocks began is at least 100,000,000 years, and most of them have reached
much larger figures. The disintegration and total destruction
of mountains and plateaus is a closely related process and leads to similar results.
The rocks of the earliest geological formations contain
only a few fossils, and they are of primitive forms of life.
Later rocks contain the remains of higher forms of plants
and animals, until finally the vertebrates and the highest
types existing at the present time are found. Obviously
an enormous interval of time has been required for all this
great series of changes in life forms to have taken place, but
it is difficult to see how any one individual could give the
question much attention and thought a billion years would be
necessary for the evolution. The recent discovery of muta-
tion has shown that the process of evolution, at least in plants,
may be more rapid than he supposed; but, on the whole,
biologists feel that the contraction theory of the sun's heat
is much too restricted limits for the age of the earth.
The most recent, and possibly the best, method of arry-
ing at an age for the earth is by means of radioactive meta-
active substances. Uranium degenerates by a slow breaking
up of its atoms in which radium, lead, and helium are evolved.
From the relative proportions of these products in certain
rocks it is possible to compute the time during which de-
generation has been going on in them. This method has led
CH. XI, 210]
THE SUN
363
to a greater age for the earth than any other. Strutt, in Eng-
land, Boltwood, of Yale, and many others have given this
method a large amount of study, and have obtained figures
reaching up into several hundreds of millions of years.
Boltwood, especially, has found that the geologically older
rocks contain more uranium than do those belonging to
their age, and he reaches the conclusion that some of them
are nearly 2,000,000,000 years old.
It is difficult to reach a positive conclusion regarding the
age of the earth from this conflicting evidence. The geo-
logical methods point to an age for the earth since erosion
begun of at least 100,000,000 years. Geologists do not see
agreement in regard to an estimate of the age of the sun. This
problem can be brought into harmony with the theory that the sun
has been furnishing light and heat to the earth for only
25,000,000 years. This discrepancy between their figures
and those given by the contraction theory cannot be ig-
nored, and therefore we are forced to the conclusion that
the sun has other important sources of heat energy besides
its contraction. Aside from this, the fact that a contracted
mass of gas would occupy less than one square of its
radius gives a distribution of the radiation of solar energy
altogether at variance with geological evidence.
A possible source of energy for the sun which has not been
considered here as yet is that liberated in the degeneration
of radioactive elements. It is not certain that uranium and
radium exist in the sun, but helium, which is one of the
elements of the sun's atmosphere, is thought to be there in abundance; in fact, it is called helium because it was first discovered in the sun (Greek, helios =sun), and gives presumptive evidence of uranium and radium being there,
too. The disintegration of uranium and radium is accom-
panied by the evolution of an enormous quantity of heat,
the energy liberated by radium being about 260,000 times
that produced by the combination of an equal weight of coal
and oxygen. These results are startling, and at first it
364 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ca. xx, 219]
seems that if a small fraction of the sun were radium or uranium, its radiation of energy would be almost indefinitely prolonged.
If one part in 800,000 of the sun were radium, heat would be produced from this source alone as fast as it is now being radiated, but in less than 2000 years half of the radium would be gone and the production of heat would correspondingly diminish. Or, to go backward in time, only 2000 years ago the amount of radium would have been twice as great as at present, and the production of heat would have been twice as rapid. Since this conclusion is not in harmony with the facts, the hypothesis that the sun's heat is largely due to the subatomic energies of uranium.
Now consider uranium which degenerates 3,000,000 times more slowly than radium. In the case of this element the slowness of the rate of degeneration presents a difficulty. If the sun were entirely uranium, heat would not be produced more than one third as fast as it is now being radiated. But in the deep interior of the sun where the temperature and pressure are inconceivably high, the release of the subatomic energies may be so slow that it will take longer than under laboratory conditions, and the process may not be confined to the elements which are radioactive at the surface of the earth. There is no laboratory experience to support this suggestion because within the range of experiment the rates of the radioactive processes have been found to be independent of temperature and other physical conditions. But this seems to favor this suggestion, and especially if under the conditions prevailing in the interior of the sun all of the subatomic energies of all elements are released, the amount of energy may be sufficient for hundreds and even thousands of millions of years. But at once the question regarding the origin of the subatomic energies arises, and, at present, there is no answer to it.
cn. xi, 220]
THE SUN
365
XV. QUESTIONS
1. How many horse power of energy per inhabitant is received by the earth from the sun?
2. What is the average amount of energy per square yard re-
ceived by the whole earth from the sun?
3. What part of the energy absorbed in the tides comes from
the sun? What becomes of the energy in the tides?
4. What becomes of that part of the sun's energy which is
absorbed by the atmosphere?
5. If the earth's atmosphere absorbs 35 per cent of the energy
which comes to it from the sun, how can the atmosphere cause the
temperature of the earth's surface to be higher than it would oth-
erwise be?
6. Show from the data at which the earth receives energy from
the sun, the size of the sun, and the earth's distance from the sun,
that the sun radiates 70,000 horse power of energy per square
mile.
7. Taking the earth's mean temperature as 60° F. and the rates
of radiation of the earth (see question 2) and of the sun, compute
the rate at which heat is lost by each.
8. All scientists agree that the earth is more than 5,000,000 years old.
On the hypothesis that the contraction of the sun is its
only source of heat, and on this assumption, what was its tem-
perature when it was formed? How long has it been since then?
How much has it radiated at its present rate, what was its radius and density at the beginning of this period? On the basis of Lavoisier's law, what was its temperature? On the basis of Stefan's law, what was its tem-
perature? What does this show about the correctness of both laws?
On the basis of Planck's law, what was its temperature? What does this show about the correctness of Planck's law? On the basis of Planck's law, what was its temperature? What does this show about the correctness of Planck's law?
II. SPECTRUM ANALYSIS
220. The Nature of Light. - In order to comprehend
the principles of spectrum analysis it is necessary to under-
stand the nature of light. A profound study of the fun-
damental properties of light was begun by Newton, but,
unfortunately, some of his basal conclusions were quite erroneous. Thomas Young (1773-1829) laid the foundation for modern spectrophotometry by showing that light consists of waves in an all-per-
vading medium known as the ether, by showing that when
Image with text "SPECTRUM ANALYSIS" and "220. The Nature of Light."
Image with text "In order to comprehend
the principles of spectrum analysis it is necessary to understand
the nature of light. A profound study of the fun-
damental properties of light was begun by Newton, but,
unfortunately, some of his basal conclusions were quite erroneous. Thomas Young (1773-1829) laid the foundation for modern spectrophotometry by showing that light consists of waves in an all-per-
vading medium known as the ether, by showing that when".
366 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xl. 220
two similar rays of light meet they destroy each other where their phases are different, and add where their phases are the same. These phenomena, which are analogous to those exhibited by waves in water, would not be observed if Newton's idea were correct that light consisted of minute particles shot out from a radiating body.
Physical experiments prove that light waves in the ether are at right angles to the line of their propagation, like the up-and-down waves which travel along a弦 when it is struck by a hammer, and that these waves are transmitted along a solid elastic body when one of its ends is suddenly twisted. In an ordinary beam of light the vibrations are in every direction perpendicular to the line of propagation. If the vibrations in one direction are destroyed while those at right angles to it remain, the light is said to be polarized. Many substances have the property of polarization, which varies throughout the spectrum.
The distance from one wave to the next for red light is about $\frac{1}{2700}$ of an inch, and for violet light about $\frac{1}{5000}$ of an inch. There are vibrations both of smaller and greater wave lengths. The range beyond the violet is not very great, for, even though very short waves are emitted by a body, they are absorbed and scattered by the earth's atmosphere before reaching the observer; but there is no limit in the contrary direction. The sun emits all the visible and invisible rays, so-called heat rays of the sun with his bolometer far beyond those which are visible to the human eye. The waves used in wireless telegraphy, which differ from light waves only in their length, are often hundreds of yards long.
**221. On the Production of Light.** A definite conception of the way in which matter emits radiant energy is important for an understanding of the principles of spectrum analysis, but, unfortunately, the fundamental properties of radiant energy are still imperfectly known on this subject. However, the theory that radiant
1 Excepting the so-called X-rays, which are much shorter.
CH. XI, 221]
THE SUN
367
energy is due to accelerated electrons is in good standing and gives a correct representation of the principal facts.
The molecules of which substances are composed are themselves made up of atoms. The atoms were generally supposed to be indivisible until the year 1855, when the discoveries of Röntgen rays, radioactivity, and dis-
coveries in radioactivity and subatomic units. In con-
nection with these discoveries it was found that the atoms are made up of numerous still smaller particles, called e-
lectrons or corpuscles. An atom, according to the hypothesis of Rutherford, is composed of a small central nucleus, carry-
ing a positive charge of electricity; and one or more rings
A diagram showing a positively charged atom with a small central nucleus and surrounding negatively charged electrons.
A diagram showing a positively charged atom with a small central nucleus and surrounding negatively charged electrons, but with an additional ring of electrons around the outer edge.
Fig. 137. - Model of atom, non-radiating at left and radiating at right.
of electrons carrying (or perhaps consisting of) negative charges of electricity, which revolve around the positive nucleus at great speed. Under ordinary circumstances the electrons revolve in circular paths with uniform speed, all those of a given ring traveling in the same circle. Under these conditions represented in the left of Fig. 137, the atom is not radiating.
When a body is highly heated the molecules and atoms of which it is composed are in very rapid motion and jostle against one another with great frequency. These impacts disturb the motions of the electrons and cause them to describe wavy paths in and out across the circles in which they ordinarily move. This condition is shown at the
368 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xi, 22]
right in Fig. 137. These small vibrations, which are periodic in character, produce light waves in the ether; and light waves are also produced by the impacts themselves, but they are not periodic.
The character of the motions of the corpuscles can be understood by imagining a bell. Suppose it is suspended by a twisted cord which is rapidly untwisting. A ring of particles around the bell corresponds to a ring of corpuscles in an atom. If the bell is simply rotating, it gives out no sound. Suppose it strikes something. The particles of which it is composed vibrate rapidly in and out ; this, combined with its rotation, causes them to describe wavy paths across the surface of circular orbits. These waves produce the sound. Of course, if we suppose that the atoms should be rotating in order to produce sound, and in this respect the analogy is imperfect.
The frequency of the vibrations of a corpuscle in an atom is astounding. The length of a light wave of yellow light is in round numbers $3 \times 10^{15}$ of an inch. In a second of time enough waves are emitted to make a line of them 186,000 inches long. Therefore, the number of oscillations per second of the corpuscles in an atom is in round numbers 600,000,000,000,000.
It has often been suggested that the atoms of all the chemical elements are made out of exactly the same kind of electrons. Certainly there is as yet no evidence to the contrary. If the electrons are not composite structures themselves, the idea is reasonable enough; but if they are made up of smaller units, then it becomes very difficult.
The dynamics of an atom, according to the corpuscular theory, is of much interest. The positive nucleus attracts the revolving negative corpuscles. They are kept from falling in on the nucleus both by the centrifugal force due to their rapid revolution, and also by their mutual repulsions which result from their being similarly electrified. If the number of corpuscles in a ring is small, the atom is stable.
369
THE SUN
cu. xi, 222]
With an increasing number of corpuscles the stability of the atom diminishes. Finally, the atom is stable only if the corpuscles revolve in two or more rings. The regions of instability which separate atoms having a certain number of rings from those having other numbers possibly give a clue to the well-known periodic law of the chemical elements discovered by Mendeleev.
222. Spectroscopes and the Spectrum. — The energy which a body radiates is completely characterized by the wave lengths which it includes and their respective intensities. The spectroscope is an instrument which enables us to analyze light into its parts of different wave lengths, and to study each one separately.
There are three principal types of spectroscopes. In the first type, all the light passes through one or more prisms; in the second, perfected by Rowland and Michelson, the light is reflected from a surface on which are ruled many parallel equidistant lines; and in the third, invented by Michelson, the light passes through a plate of equally thick plane pieces of glass piled up like a stairway. The first type is most advantageous when the source of light is faint and when the spectrum is narrow. Its chief fault is that the scale of the spectrum is not the same in all parts. The second type is advantageous for bright sources of light like the sun or the electric arc in the laboratory. It gives the same scale for all parts of the spectrum, but uses only a small part of the incident light. The third type, known as the echelon, gives high dispersion without great loss of light. Only this last type, which is most used in astronomy, will be more fully described here.
The basis of the prism spectroscope is the refraction and the dispersion of light when it passes through a prism. Let Fig., 183, represent a beam of white light which passes through the prism $P$. As it enters at $A$ from a rarer to a denser medium, it is bent toward the perpendicular to the surface; and as it emerges at $B$ from a denser to a rarer
A diagram showing a beam of white light passing through a prism P.
2x
370 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xx, 222]
medium, it is bent from the perpendicular to the surface. This change in the direction of the beam of light is its refraction.
Not only is the beam of light refracted, but it is also spread out into its colors. As it enters the prism the violet light is refracted more than the red, and this same thing is true when it emerges. Consequently, instead of a beam of white light falling on the screen S there is found a band of colors which, in order from the most refracted to the least refracted, are violet, indigo, blue, green, yellow, orange, and red. This separation of light into its colors is called dispersion.
In the diagram only the visible part of the spectrum is indicated.
Fig. 138. — Refraction and dispersion of light by a prism.
The infra-red, or heat, rays $I-B$, and beyond the violet are the ultra-violet rays $U-V$. The colors are not separated by sharp boundaries, but fade one from another by insensible gradations. The ultra-violet rays are several times as long as the visible part, and the infra-red part is several times as long as the ultra-violet part.
While Fig. 138 exactly shows the way in which a spectrum might be formed, it would be too faint to be of any value in practice. In order to obtain a bright spectrum the apparatus is arranged as sketched in Fig. 139, though in practice one of them one after the other are often employed. The rays which enter through $A$ are made parallel by the lens $L_1$. They strike the prism $P$ in parallel lines, and those of a given color continue through $P$ and to the lens $L_3$ in parallel lines (the dispersion is not indicated in the diagram). The lens $L_3$ brings the rays to a focus at $F$, and the eyepiece $E$ sends all those of each color
14
CH. XI, 230]
THE SUN
371
out in a small bundle of parallel lines (only one color is represented in the diagram). The eye is placed just to the right of $E_1$, and all the parallel rays of each bundle are brought to a focus at a point on the retina. In this way many rays of each color are brought to a focus at the same place in the retina.
While strictly white light gives all colors, it is not necessary that a luminous body should emit all kinds of light, or that all colors emitted should be given out in equal intensity. In fact, it is well known that if a body is simply warm but not self-luminous, it gives out in sensible quantities only
A diagram showing the spectrum of light passing through a prism. The diagram shows the different colors of light separated by the prism.
Fig. 139. — A spectroscope having only one prism.
infra-red rays. If it is extremely hot, it may radiate mostly ultra-violet rays.
223. The First Law of Spectrum Analysis. — The first theoretical discussion of the principles of spectrum analysis which reached approximately correct conclusions was made by Ångström in 1853. The work of Bunsen, and especially of Kirchhoff in 1859, put the subject on essentially its present basis. The first law of spectrum analysis here is a consequence of a general law due to Kirchhoff, and of certain experimental facts. After they have been stated, they will be seen to be simple consequences of the mode of production of radiant energy.
The first law of spectrum analysis is: *A radiating solid*, liquid, or gas under high pressure gives a continuous spectrum whose position of maximum intensity depends upon the temperature of the source; and conversely, if a spectrum is con-
372 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xi, 225
tinuous, the source of light is a solid, liquid, or gas under high pressure, and the position of radiation of maximum intensity determines the temperature of the source.
This means that in the first place, that a radiating solid, liquid, or gas under high pressure gives out light, or more generally radiant energy, of all wave lengths; and, in the second place, the wave length at which the radiation is most intense depends upon the temperature of the source. It is clear from the way in which light is produced that the first part of the law should be true. When a body is in a solid or liquid state, or when it is a gas under high pressure, the molecules vibrate with great rapidity and continually interfere with one another. Under these circumstances the oscillations of the corpuscles cannot take place in their natural periods, but they are altered in all possible manners. This results in vibrations of all periods, and therefore the spectra are continuous.
The way in which the wave length of maximum radiation depends upon the temperature is given by Wien's law 1—
$$\lambda = \frac{0.2076}{T}$$
where $\lambda$ is the wave length in inches and $T$ is the absolute temperature on the Fahrenheit scale. For example, if the temperature of the sun is 10,000° its wave length of maximum radiation is about 1300A. of an inch.
224. The Second Law of Spectrum Analysis.—The second law of spectrum analysis is : A radiating gas under low pressure gives a spectrum which consists of bright lines whose relations to one another and whose positions in the spectrum depend upon the nature of the gas (and in some cases also upon its temperature). But this law does not give good results for low temperatures, but the applications in astronomy are to high temperatures.
The reason why this law fails for low temperatures is that many elements have several lines corresponding to one another; but in practice the lines of an element are usually identified by their relations to one another, just as a constellation is recognized by the relative positions of its stars.
1 Experiments show that this law does not give good results for low temperatures, but the applications in astronomy are to high temperatures.
2 The reason why this law fails for low temperatures is that many elements have several lines corresponding to one another; but in practice the lines of an element are usually identified by their relations to one another, just as a constellation is recognized by the relative positions of its stars.
CH. XL 224]
THE SUN
373
cases to some extent upon its temperature, density, electrical and magnetic condition); and conversely, if a spectrum consists of bright lines, then the source is a radiating gas (or gases) under low pressure, and the composition of the gas (or gases) can be determined from the relations of the lines to one another and from their positions.
When molecules are free from all restraints the oscillations of their electrons take place in fixed periods which depend upon the internal forces involved, just as free bells of given structure vibrate in definite ways and give forth sounds of definite pitch. Consequently, free radiating molecules emit light of one or more definite wave lengths depending on the structure of the molecules, and there are
A diagram showing a bright-line spectrum above and a reversed spectrum below.
Fig. 140.—A bright-line spectrum above and a reversed spectrum below.
bright lines at corresponding places in the spectrum and no light whatever at other places. A bright-line spectrum is shown in the top part of Fig. 140. Some elements give only a few lines and others a great many. For example, sodium has but two lines, both in the yellow, and iron more than any other element. It is necessary to say that all these facts are established by laboratory experiments.
It may be objected that in a gas, even under low pressure, the molecules are not free from outside interference, for they collide with one another many millions of times per second. But the intervals during which they are in collision are very short compared with the intervals between collisions. Consequently, when we consider the solid state of a gas, it will be inappreciable compared to that which is characteristic of the radiating gas, and the spectrum will seem to con-
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| First line |
Second line |
Third line |
Fourth line |
Fifth line |
Sixth line |
Seventh line |
| Yellow |
Green |
Blue |
Violet |
Orange |
Pink |
Red |
374 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xi, 224
sist of bright lines of various colors on a perfectly black background.
**225. The Third Law of Spectrum Analysis.** —The third law of spectrum analysis is: *If light from a solid, liquid, or vapor under great pressure passes through a cooler gas (or gases), then the ratio of the bright spectral lines which are crossed by the hotter gas to those which are not crossed by dark lines, and the dark lines have the positions which would be occupied by bright lines if the intervening cooler gas were the source of light*; and conversely, *if a bright spectrum is continuous except where it is crossed by dark lines, then the source of light is a solid, liquid, or gas under great pressure, and the light has passed through a cooler gas.* In this way, the nature of the gas (or gases) whose constitution can be determined from the relation between the dark lines to one another and from their positions in the spectrum.
In a word, a cool gas absorbs the same kinds of rays it would give out if it were incandescent, and no others. Similarly, a musical instrument absorbs tones of the same pitch as those which it can produce. For example, if the key for middle $C$ on a piano is held down and the tone produced is heard to be middle $C$, then any other tone, say if $D$ is produced, the piano will give no response. This phenomenon occurs in many branches of physics and is very important. For example, it is at the basis of wireless telegraphy. The receiving instrument and the sending instru- ment are tuned together, and only in this way do the effects of the feeble waves which reach to great distances become sensible. The fact that the sending and receiving instru- ments must be tuned explains how it is that many different wireless instruments can be working at the same time without sensible interference.
When the intervening cool gas absorbs certain parts of the energy which passes through it, it becomes heated and its rate of radiation is increased. It might be supposed that this new radiation would make up for the energy which has been absorbed. That which has been absorbed and that
ca. xx, 220j
THE SUN
375
which is radiated are, indeed, exactly equal, but the radiated energy is sent out in every direction and not alone in the direction of the original light passing through the gas. That is, certain parts of the original energy are taken out and scattered in every direction. Therefore, in a spectrum consisting of white light, only the violet and red are visible, but only black relatively to the remainder of the spectrum. A spectrum of this sort is called an absorption, or dark-line, or reversed spectrum. The reverse of the bright-line spectrum given in the top of Fig. 140 is shown in the bottom part of the figure.
**226. The Fourth Law of Spectrum Analysis.—The fourth law of spectrum analysis was first discovered by Doppler and was subsequently actually established by Fizeau. It is commonly called the Doppler principle, or the Doppler-Fizeau law. It is: If the source (radiating gas in the case of a spectrum of bright lines, and an intervening cooler gas in case of an absorption spectrum) and receiver are relatively approaching toward, or receding from, each other, then the lines of the spectrum are displaced respectively in the direction of the relative speed of approach or recession; and conversely, if the lines of a spectrum are displaced toward the violet or the red, the source and receiver are respectively approaching toward, or receding from, each other, and the relative speed of approach or recession can be determined from the amount of the displacement.
The explanation of the shift of the lines of the spectrum when there is relative motion of the source and the receiver is very simple. If the source is stationary, it sends out wave after wave separated by a given interval; if it is moving toward the receiver, it follows up the waves which it emits and the intervals between them are diminished. That is, the wave lengths have become shorter, which is another way of stating that the corresponding spectral lines have been shifted toward the violet. Of course, for motion
376 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cu. xi, 226
in the opposite direction the spectral lines are shifted toward the red.
If the receiver moves toward the source, he receives not only the waves which would reach him if he were stationary, but also those which he may receive conse-
quently by motion. The distance between the waves are diminished and the spectral lines are shifted toward the violet. Motion in the opposite direction produces the opposite results.
The formula for the shift in the spectral lines is
$$\Delta \lambda = \frac{v}{c} \lambda,$$
where $\Delta \lambda$ is the amount of the shift, $\lambda$ is the wave length of the line in question, $v$ the relative velocity of the source and receiver, and $c$ the velocity of light. Suppose $v$ is 18.6 miles per second; then, since $V$ is 180,000 miles per second and the greatest wave length in the visible spectrum is nearly twice that of the shortest, the displacement is about 15.84$\mu$ of wave length. The formula for the dis-
placement follows that for the velocities with which the planets move the displacements of the spectral lines are very small, and that refined means must be employed in order to determine them accurately. The usual method is to photograph the spectrum of the distant object and at the same time to send through the spectroscope beside it the light from some suitable laboratory source. The lines of which latter will have course have their normal positions. The displacements of lines of a celestial object with respect to them are measured with the aid of a micro-
scope.
When the spectral lines of an object are well defined, displacement results of astonishing precision can be obtained.
In the case of stars of certain types the relative velocities toward or from the earth, called radial velociti, can be de-
termined to within one tenth of a mile per second.
CH. XI, 227]
THE SUN
377
XVI. QUESTIONS.
1. What problems can be solved approximately for the sun and stars by the first principles of optics?
2. What would be the character of the spectrum of moonlight?
3. Comets have continuous bright spectra crossed by still brighter lines; what interpretation is to be made of these facts, remembering that the sun has no such lines?
4. The spectra of Uranus and Neptune contain dark lines and bands of great intensity at the positions of the less intense hydrogen lines of the solar spectrum; what interpretation is to be placed on these facts?
5. Can the motion of the earth with respect to the sun and moon be determined by spectroscopic means? The motion of the earth with respect to the planets?
6. If an observer were approaching a red star with the velocity of light, what color would the star appear to have? If he were receding with the velocity of light?
7. How different would the rapid rotation of a star have on its spectral lines?
8. Suppose an observer examines the spectra of the eastern and western parts of the sun; how would the spectral lines be related? Could they be distinguished from lines due to absorption by the earth's atmosphere?
III. THE CONSTITUTION OF THE SUN
227. Outline of the Sun's Constitution.---The apparent surface of the sun is called the photosphere (light sphere). It has been shown that this is not a solid surface, p. 141, and it is the boundary used to define the size of the sun, but the sun is disturbed by such violent vertical motions that it is probably very broken in outline. At the distance of the sun from the earth an object 500 miles across subtends an angle of only one second of arc, and therefore, irregularities in the photosphere would not be visible unless they amounted to several hundred miles. The part of the sun interior to the photosphere is called its corona (Fig. 142). The corona is a thin sheet of gas, probably from 500 to 1000 miles thick, which is called the reversing layer because, as will be seen (Art. 233), it produces a reversed,
A diagram showing the structure of the Sun, including its photosphere and corona.
378 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY (ch. xi, 227)
or absorption, spectrum. It contains many terrestrial substances, such as calcium and iron, in a vaporous state.
Outside of the reversing layer is another layer of gas, from 5000 to 10,000 miles deep, called the chromosphere
The Sun photographed by Fox with the 20-inch telescope of the Yerkes Observatory.
Fig. 141. — The Sun. Photographed by Fox with the 20-inch telescope of the Yerkes Observatory.
(color sphere). At the time of a total eclipse of the sun it is seen as a brilliant scarlet fringe whose outer surface seems
CH. XI, 228j
THE SUN 379
to be covered with leaping flames. There are often eruptions, called *prominences*, which break up into it and ascend to great heights.
The outermost portion of the sun is the *corona* (crown), a halo of pearly light which is so much fainter than the illumination of the earth's atmosphere that it can be seen only at night. The corona is a thin layer of light which gradually fades out into the darkness of the sky at the distance from 1,000,000 to 3,000,000 miles from the surface of the sun.
Figure 142 shows an ideal section through the sun. The upper surface of the invisible interior is the photosphere,
A diagram showing an ideal section through the sun. The upper surface of the invisible interior is labeled "INVISIBLE INTERIOR". Below this label, there is a rectangular area labeled "PHOTOSPHERE" with a smaller rectangle within it labeled "REVERSING LAYER". A line extends from the top left corner of the photosphere to the bottom right corner of the reversing layer.
Fig. 142.—Ideal section of the sun.
$R$ is the reversing layer, $S$ is a spot, $K$ is the chromosphere, $F$ is a prominence, and $C$ is the corona.
228. The Photosphere.—When the sun is examined through a good telescope it presents a finely mottled appearance, due to the uniform fluster which might be expected. The brighter parts are intensely luminous nodules, somewhat irregular in form, 500 or 600 miles across. These "rice grains," as they are sometimes called, have been resolved into smaller elements having a diameter of not over 100 miles; and although all these granules together do not constitute over one fifth of the sun's surface, yet, according
389 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. xi, 228
to Langley's estimates, they radiate about three fourths of the light. A small portion of the sun's surface highly magnified is shown in Fig. 143.
The photosphere of the sun gives a continuous spectrum. Therefore, according to the first law of spectrum analysis, it is a solid, liquid, or gas under great pressure. Since the photosphere is not transparent there is a strong inclination to infer that it is liquid, or at least consists of clouds of liquid particles (carbon, iron, calcium, etc.), floating in a vapor of similar substances. But the temperature of the sun is so high that this conclusion is not certain.
In considering the sun it must be remembered that its surface gravity is nearly 28 times that of the earth, and that the atmosphere under equal masses of atmosphere is correspondingly greater. Hence, it is not unreasona- ble to suppose that the pressure down under the chromosphere, corona, chromosphere, and reversing layer is great enough to produce a continuous spectrum. The conclusion that the photosphere is gaseous entirely, if not altogether, gaseous is supported by the fact that the cooler, overlying reversing layer is gaseous and contains some of the most refractory known substances. The "rice-grain" structure of the photosphere is explained by Abbott as being due to relative motions of layers at different levels analogous to those which produce a mackerel sky in the earth's atmosphere. He supposes that the dark places are regions where clouds form in our own atmosphere, and that they are regions where the temperature has fallen somewhat.
Fig. 143.—Small portion of the sun's surface, highly magnified.
Fro. 143. — Small portion of the sun's surface, highly magnified.
ch. xl. 220j THE SUN 381
below that of the remainder of the photosphere. There are other astronomers, however, who believe that the bright nodules are the summits of ascending convection currents, which, by expansion and cooling, are reduced to the state where the most refractory substances partially condense and radiate most brilliantly, while the darker spaces between are where the colder currents deposit.
The photosphere is the region from which the sun loses heat by radiation. This energy must be supplied from the interior. There are three processes by which heat may be transferred from one position to another, viz., by conduction, by convection, and by radiation. Conduction is entirely too slow to be quantitatively adequate for bringing heat to the surface of the sun. Convection currents might be violent enough and might reach deep enough to bring to the surface all of the heat generated at the core. But even a quantitative idea of the requirements suppose that essentially all of the sun's radiation is from a layer of the photosphere, of average density one tenth, 500 miles thick. Suppose its specific heat is unity. At the rate at which the sun radiates, the temperature of this layer would decrease one degree Fahrenheit in 1.6 hours if fresh energy were not supplied from below. Hence the requirements do not seem to be met by any reasonable assumption.
In a body as nearly opaque as the sun seems to be, radiation probably is of no importance in the escape of heat from the deep interior to the surface layers.
229 Sun Spots. — The most conspicuous markings ever seen on the sun are relatively dark spots which occasionally appear in the photosphere and last from a few days up to several months with an average life of about two weeks. The typical spot consists of a round, relatively black nucleus, called the umbra, and a surrounding less dark belt called the penumbra, Fig. 144. The penumbra is made up of converging filaments, or "willow leaves," of brighter material, which look as though the intensely luminous photospheric
382 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xi, 229]
columns were tipped over so as to make their sides visible.
The umbra and penumbra do not gradually merge into each other, and likewise the penumbra and surrounding photosphere have a fairly definite line of separation.
The umbra of a sun spot may be anywhere from 500 to 50,000 miles across; the diameter of the penumbra may be as great as 200,000 miles. When the spots are of these dimensions they can be seen simply with the aid of a smoked glass to reduce the glare of the sun. The Chinese claim to
A black and white photograph of a sunspot.
Fig. 144.—Great sun spot of July 17, 1903. Photographed by Fox with the 40-inch telescope of the Yerkes Observatory.
have records of observations of sun spots made centuries before their discovery by Galileo in 1610.
The umbra of a sun spot is dark only in comparison with the glowing photosphere which surrounds it, for a calcium light projected on it appears black. In fact, it sometimes shows many details of darker spots and brighter streaks which most often appear shortly before it breaks up. In the neighborhood of spots the brightness of the photosphere is unusually low, and this region is often called the aureole; within its vicinity very bright elevated masses of calcium which constitute the faculae. These faculae are especially con-
CH. XI, 230]
THE SUN
383
spicious when near the sun's apparent margin, or limb, as it is called, for in these regions the photosphere is greatly dimmed by the extensive absorbing material through which its rays must pass, while on the other hand the faculae project themselves into the absorbing material and shine with but slightly diminished lustre.
**230. The Distribution and Periodicity of Sun Spots.** — Sun spots are rarely seen except in two belts extending from latitude $6^{\circ}$ to latitude $35^{\circ}$ on each side of the sun's equator. Moreover, they are not always equally numerous. For three or four years they appear with great frequency, then they become rare, numerous again to a minimum for three or four years after which they become numerous again. The interval from maximum number to maximum number averages about 11.11 years, though the period varies from about 7 years to more than 16 years. When a period is short, the maximum which follows it is very marked, as though a large amount of sun-spot activity had been crowded into a short interval; on the other hand, when a maximum does not follow a short period, it is less marked.
There is a connection between the positions of sun spots and their numbers, first pointed out by Schwabe in 1852. After a sun-spot maximum has passed, the spots appear year after year for about five years, on the average, in successively lower latitudes, and they are continuously less numerous. At the sixth year a few are still visible in about latitude $+6^{\circ}$, and a new cycle starts in latitude about $-35^{\circ}$. After this time the spots gradually disappear those in the higher latitudes increase in numbers, but gradually descend in latitude until the maximum activity is reached in latitudes $\pm 16^{\circ}$. The areas covered by spots in years of maximum activity are from 15 to 45 times those covered in years of minimum activity. The results from 1876 to 1902 are shown in Fig. 145.
Since accurate records of the numbers and dimensions of sun spots have been kept, the sun's southern hemisphere
A graph showing the distribution of sunspots over time.
A line graph depicting the variation in sunspot numbers over time.
384 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xi, 230
has been somewhat more active than the northern. For the period from 1874 to 1902, 57 per cent of the total spot area was in the southern hemisphere of the sun and only 43 per cent in the northern. That is, the activity in the southern hemisphere was about one third greater than that in the
A graph showing the distribution of sun spots over time.
Fig. 145. — Distribution and magnitudes of sun spots for the period from 1876 to 1902 (Maunder).
northern. Whether this difference is permanent and what it means cannot at present be determined.
231. The Motions of Sun Spots. — Individual sun spots may drift both in latitude and in longitude, and they often have complex and different internal motions. Some of those spots which incline toward the equator drift slowly toward the sun's equator, and those which are in higher latitudes drift away from it. When two spots are near together they are generally on the same parallel of latitude. The spot which is ahead usually moves forward with respect to the sun's surface, while the one which is behind lags con-
cn.xi, 230
CH. XI, 231]
THE SUN
385
tiniually farther in the rear. If a large spot divides into two components, they generally recede from each other, sometimes at the rate of 1000 miles an hour.
Sun spots sometimes have spiral motions, but until recently the phenomenon was thought to be hardly-characteristic because it was observed in only a small percentage of cases. Hale's invention of the spectroheliograph (Art. 237) furnished a new and powerful means of studying solar phenomena, and it has led in recent years to a discovery of great interest and importance in this connection.
It is known that Hale found that the magnetic fields in the high levels of sun spots. One may well wonder how such a result could be established, since we receive only light and heat from the sun. Naturally it must be done from the characteristics of the radiant energy which the sun sends to the earth. About 1896 Zeeman found that most spectral lines are doublet, or at least widened, when observed along the lines of force of a magnet, and that the two components are circularly polarized upon opposite directions. He examined the widened spectral lines belonging to sun spots and proved that they have the properties of spectral lines in a magnetic field. Then he took up the question of the origin of the magnetic fields. It was shown by Rowland in 1876 that static electric charges in revolution produce electromagnetic waves like those produced by electrical currents. Consequently Hale concluded that the magnetic fields in sun spots are due to vertical motions of particles carrying static electric charges, and the explanation is almost certainly correct.
More recently the whole sun has been found to be involved in a magnetic field whose poles agree approximately with its poles of rotation; it may be analogous to that which envelops the earth. Schuster has suggested that this magnetic field is due to the motion of charged particles caused by their rotations, and that all rotating bodies must be magnets.
Hale's discovery is a proof of cyclonic motion in the
2c
386 AN INTRODUCING TO ASTRONOMY [cn. xl, 231
upper parts of sun spots. Unlike cyclones on the earth, the direction of motion in a hemisphere is not always the same.
Hale found numerous examples where two spots seemed to be connected, one having one polarity and the other the opposite (Fig. 140). It has been suggested they are the two ends of a cylinder, but this idea is not accepted at least to some extent, by the fact that, so far as observational evidence goes at present, when two spots are near together, they always have opposite polarity. Another remarkable
A photograph of two sunspots with opposite polarities.
**Fig. 140.** Sun spots having opposite polarity. Photographed at the Mt. Wilson Solar Observatory with the spectroheliograph (Halo).
fact is that if two neighboring spots are in the northern hemisphere of the sun, the one which is ahead has a counterclockwise vorticity, while the motion in the other is in the opposite direction. The conditions are the opposite in the sun's southern hemisphere.
Evershed, in India, announced in 1909 that at the lowest visible levels there is radial motion outward from spots parallel to the surface of the sun. More recently St. John, at the Mt. Wilson Solar Observatory (Fig. 147), has made extensive studies of the motions in sun spots with the ad-
CH. XI, 231J
THE SUN
387
vantage of most powerful instruments, and he concludes that at the lower levels there is motion radially inward from spot centers, at levels about 2500 miles higher there is no horizontal motion, and in the high levels of the chromosphere (10,000 to 15,000 miles) the motion is inward toward the centers of the spots. This suggests that spots are produced by cooler gases from high levels rushing in toward a center, descending some thousands of miles, and then spreading out at lower levels, but the consideration of the quality and quantity of the materials involved in the two move-
Fig. 147.--The Mt. Wilson Solar Observatory of the Carnegie Institution of Washington. Pasadena, California.
ments, together with their kinetic energies, led St. John to the conclusion that the material flowing inward and downward by no means equals that flowing outward at lower levels from the axes of spots. He believes, rather, that a spot is formed by currents ascending from the sun's interior and spreading out just above the photosphere. The in-rushing and descending chromospheric material is a secondary result of the primary currents. The spots are dark because they contain matter which has been compressed are cooler than those which constitute the photosphere.
Independent evidence of a conclusive character shows that spots are cooler than the ordinary photosphere. There
3SS AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [Cf. XI, 231]
is evidence from the so-called enhanced spectral lines which has been brought out by Hale, Adams, and Gale; the lines in the spectrum of spots are related to those in the spectrum of the remainder of the sun's photosphere. The spectra of spots on the periphery of electric furnaces are related to those with high temperatures; and finally, the spectra of spots contain flutings, or bands, which are believed to be due to absorption by chemical compounds which would be broken up into their constituent elements in the higher temperatures of the photosphere.
233. Rotation of the Sun. — The rotation of at least three-fifths of the sun in which the spots occur can be found from their apparent transits across its disk. The first systematic investigation of the sun's rotation was made by Carrington and Spoerer about the middle of the nineteenth century. They found that the sun rotates from west to east about an axis inclined $7^\circ$ to the perpendicular to the plane of the ecliptic. The sun's axis points to a position whose right ascension and declination are respectively 18 h. 44 m. and $+25^\circ$, while its motion is eastward at 16.30' per Polar arc. The period of the solar rotation depends upon the latitude. Spots near the sun's equator complete a revolution in about 25 days; in latitude $30^\circ$, in about 25.5 days; in latitude $45^\circ$, in about 27.5 days; in higher latitudes spots are not seen.
Reference has already been made to the faculae, or bright clouds, which are especially abundant in the neighborhood of sun-spots. The positions of the faculae are easily determined on photographs of the sun, and from photographs made at sufficiently short intervals the rotation of the sun can be found. This method has given results in accord with those obtained from observations of spots.
The remarkable developments of spectroscopic methods which followed Hale's invention of the spectroheliograph have furnished a third method of measuring the rotation of the sun. By its use bright clouds of calcium vapor, called
CH. XI, 232J
THE SUN 389
floculi by Hale, and both bright and dark floculi of hydro-gen have been photographed. The rotation of the sun has been determined by Hale and Fox from photographs of floculi.
Finally, the rotation of the sun has been determined by the Doppler-Fizeau effect. One limb of the sun at the equator approaches the earth at the rate of 3.1 miles per second, while the other recedes at the same velocity. The spectroscopic method is highly developed, that is not only gives the rate of rotation of the sun approximately but it shows that the period is shorter at the equator than it is in higher latitudes.
The results for the periods of rotation of the sun by the various methods are given in the following table, in which the results are expressed in mean solar days:
| TABLE X |
| Latitude |
Sun Spots |
FACULA |
CALCUL |
HYDROGEN |
DOPPLER- |
|
|
|
|
|
FIZEAU |
| 0° to 5° |
25.00 |
34.73 |
34.76 |
25.7 |
24.67 |
| 5° to 10° |
25.09 |
24.70 |
24.98 |
25.0 |
24.86 |
| 10° to 15° |
25.26 |
25.12 |
25.17 |
24.8 |
25.12 |
| 15° to 20° |
25.48 |
25.33 |
25.48 |
24.8 |
25.14 |
| 20° to 25° |
25.73 |
25.76 |
25.79 |
24.8 |
25.18 |
| 25° to 30° |
26.09 |
25.64 |
M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.M.A.<14>
| 30° to 35° |
M.LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL233 Rotation Layer. -- Newton began the analysis of light by passing it through a small circular opening. In 1802 Rowland passed the light from the sun through a narrow slit, instead of a pinhole, and found that the solar spectrum was crossed by 7 dark lines. In a few years the subject was taken up by Fraunhofer, who soon found that the spectrum was crossed by an immense number of dark lines. In 1816 he mapped 224 of them, and they have since been known as "Fraunhofer's lines." The greatly improved map of these lines was made by Kirchhoff in 1862, and still another by Ångström in 1808. In 1886 Langley mapped the solar spectrum with the aid of his bolometer far into the infra-red region, and in 1886, 1889, and 1890 Rowland published extensive and very accurate maps from measurements of the positions and characteristics obtained with his powerful grating spectroscope. In 1895 Rowland published his great "Preliminary Table of Solar Spectrum Wave Lengths,"
cn. xr, 233l
THE SUN
391
containing the results for about 14,000 spectral lines. A portion of the solar spectrum is shown in Fig. 148 with a bright-line comparison spectrum above.
The spectrum of the sun is continuous except for the very numerous dark lines which cross it. Therefore, in accordance with the third law of spectrum analysis, there is between the photosphere and the observer cooler gas, and its constitution can be determined from the relations among the dark lines and from their positions. The lines prove the presence of sodium, iron, and other heavy metals in this intervening gas, and since they cannot remain in the gaseous state in our own atmosphere they must be in that of the sun.
Fig. 148.—Portion of solar spectrum below with a Titanium comparison spectrum above.
This absorbing material which overlies the photosphere constitutes the reversing layer.
If the reversing layer could be viewed not projected against the brilliant photosphere, it would give a spectrum of bright lines similar to that of the sun at any time when it was under the conditions as they normally exist. At the total eclipse of the sun in 1870, Young placed the slit of his spectroscope tangent to the limb of the sun. Just as the moon cut off the last of the photosphere the spectrum suddenly flashed out in bright lines where an instant before the dark ones had been. Since 1895, during nearly every total eclipse of the sun, this "flash spectrum" has been photographed, and there is no doubt that it is identical with those of corresponding dark Fraunhofer lines. From the duration of their appearance as bright lines and the known rate at which the moon apparently passes across the disk of
392 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cf. x. 233
the sun, it has been found that the reversing layer is 500 or 600 miles deep.
As a rule the effect of pressure on an absorbing gas is to cause the dark lines to shift slightly toward the red end of the spectrum. Extensive studies by various astronomers of the displacements of the Fraunhofer lines have led to the conclusion that the pressure of the reversing layer, even at its lower levels, does not exceed 5 or 6 times that of the earth's atmosphere at sea level. This is a very remarkable result in view of the great extent of the sun's atmosphere and the fact that gravity at the surface of the sun is nearly 28 times as great as it is at the surface of the earth. Possibly elements may rupture under such high light pressure partly offset the great surface gravity of the sun.
234. Chemical Constitution of the Reversing Layer.
Of the 14,000 lines in Rowland's spectrum about one third are due to the absorption by the earth's atmosphere, and the remainder are produced by the sun's reversing layer and chromosphere. By comparing the positions of the lines of the sun's spectrum with those given by the various elements, it is possible to determine to what extent the chemical constitution of the material which produces the absorption. In this manner 38 elements are known certainly to exist in the sun, but more than 6000 of the lines mapped by Rowland have not as yet been identified as belonging to any element.
The presence of iron is established by more than 2000 lines, nickel by more than 200, calcium by more than 75, magnesium by 20, sodium by 11, copper by 2, and lead by 1. It will be noticed that nearly all the elements in the table which follows are metals, the exceptions being hydrogen, helium, carbon, and oxygen. On the other hand, a number of heavy metals, such as gold and mercury, are missing. The following table gives the elements found in the sun and their atomic weights :
| Element |
Number of Lines |
| Iron |
More than 2000 |
| Nickel |
More than 200 |
| Calcium |
More than 75 |
| Magnesium |
20 |
| Sodium |
11 |
| Copper |
2 |
| Lead |
1 |
| Element | Number of Lines |
|---------|----------------|
| Iron | More than 2000 |
| Nickel | More than 200 |
| Calcium| More than 75 |
| Magnesium| 20 |
| Sodium | 11 |
| Copper | 2 |
| Lead | 1 |
The presence of hydrogen and helium is indicated by several lines in Rowland's spectrum. The existence of carbon is shown by two lines in Rowland's spectrum. The existence of oxygen is indicated by several lines in Rowland's spectrum. The existence of gold and mercury is indicated by several lines in Rowland's spectrum.
CH. XI, 234J
THE SUN
TABLE XI
| Element |
Atomic Weight |
Element |
Atomic Weight |
| Hydrogen |
1 |
Copper |
64 |
| Helium |
7 |
Zinc |
65 |
| Ghentium |
9 |
Germanium |
72 |
| Carbon |
12 |
Strontium |
88 |
| Oxygen |
16 |
Titrium |
89 |
| Sodium |
23 |
Zirconium |
91 |
| Magnesium |
24 |
Niobium |
93 |
| Ashmumum |
28 |
Molybdenum |
96 |
| Silicon |
28 |
Bismuth |
103 |
| Potassium |
39 |
Palladium |
107 |
| Calcium |
40 |
Silver |
108 |
| Seandumum |
44 |
Cadmium |
112 |
| Titanium |
48 |
Tin |
119 |
Vendimiumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumumunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunmamunma
A table showing atomic weights of various elements. |
While the presence of the spectral lines of an element proves its existence, their absence does not show that it is not present. In the first place, heavy elements, like gold, mercury, and platinum, would probably sink far below the level of the neutral atmosphere of the sun, and consequently would not appear in the solar spectrum. Then, again, the characteristic spectra of some of the elements, particularly non-metals, are suppressed by the presence of some other elements, particularly metals. Sometimes the spectrum of an element is entirely obliterated by the presence of a small percentage of another element. This may be the explanation of the fact that the spectral lines of boron, beryllium, carbon, neon, sodium, tellurium, nitrogen, phosphorus, arsenic, antimony, and boron are not found in the sun, although most of these elements occur abundantly in the earth. Some elements have spectra that change radically with alterations in their
394 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cfr. xr, 234]
conditions of temperature, pressure, and electrical excitation.
One of these elements is oxygen, which was long sought for in the sun before it was certainly found. Of course, the proof of its existence was complicated by the fact that it occurs in abundance in the earth's atmosphere. Finally, Lockyer has shown that the so-called elements may be in reality compounds which are broken up under the extreme conditions of temperature prevailing in the sun, and their characteristic spectra may be in this manner destroyed.
The reversing layer is undoubtedly constantly receiving material from below and above, and therefore it is safe to conclude that its composition is not qualitatively different from that of the sun itself. The presence of constituents that nearly 40 terrestrial elements are found, for it points strongly to the conclusion that the sun and the earth have had a common origin.
The distribution of the elements in distance above the sun's photosphere was determined by Mitchell from excellent photographs of the flash spectrum which he secured in the years 1900, 1905, and by John from considerations of the Doppler-Fizeau effect. On the whole, these elements extend to high altitudes while the heavier elements are confined to the lower levels. A peculiar exception is that calcium, whose atomic weight is 40, extends in abundance up into the chromosphere 10,000 miles, even as high as hydrogen. Iron and the heavier metals are found only down in the reversing layer.
The Chromosphere -- As has been stated, the chromosphere is a gaseous envelope around the sun above the reversing layer whose depth is from 5000 to 10,000 miles. It gets its scarlet color from the incandescent hydrogen and calcium of which it is largely composed.
The spectrum of the chromosphere consists of many lines, some of which are permanent while others come and go. The permanent lines are due mostly to hydrogen, helium, and calcium; the intermittent lines are due to many elements
cu. xi, 236j
THE SUN
395
which seem to have been temporarily thrown up into it through the reversing layer.
The existence of the element helium was first inferred from the presence of a bright yellow line in the solar spectrum near the two yellow lines of sodium. It is universally prevalent in the chromosphere, giving a bright line when the sun is eclipsed, or at any time when the slit of the spectroscope is put on the chromosphere parallel to the sun's limb. For example, we find that there is no green line in the absorption spectrum when the light from the photosphere passes through it. This seems to be a direct contradiction to the third law of spectrum analysis, which holds true in all other known cases. But helium is a very remarkable element in several other respects. Next to hydrogen, it has the lowest atomic weight, it is very inactive, and enters into chemical combination with but few elements. Moreover, it has the lowest known refractive index, it is an excellent conductor of electricity, its rate of diffusion is 15 times its theoretical value, its solubility in water is nearly zero, and it is liquefied only with the utmost difficulty. It has already been explained that helium is one of the products of the disintegration of uranium, radium, and other radioactive substances. It was discovered on the earth until 1895, when Rammelkamp found traces of it in the mineral elevite, forming the yellow spectral line of helium.
**236. Prominences.** — Vast eruptions, called *prominences*, shoot up from the sun's photosphere through its chromosphere to heights ranging from 20,000 miles up to 300,000 miles, or even to greater elevations in extreme cases. One 80,000 miles in height is shown in Fig. 149. They usually occur in the neighborhood of sun-spots and are seen moving slowly away from them. They rise up in jets and flames, often changing their appearance greatly in the course of 10 or 15 minutes, as is shown in Fig. 150. Their velocity of ascent is frequently 100 miles per second and sometimes exceeds 200 miles per second.
396 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xi, 236]
If eruptive prominences should leave the photosphere with a velocity of more than 380 miles per second, and if they should suffer no resistance from the revolving layer and chromosphere, they would escape entirely from the sun and pass out beyond the planets to the distances of the stars. It is very difficult to account for their great velocities. No satisfactory theory has been developed for explaining how such violent explosive forces are long held in restraint and
Solar prominence, August 21, 1909, reaching to a height of 80,000 miles. Photographed at the Mt. Wilson Solar Observatory.
then suddenly released. Perhaps under the extreme conditions of temperature and pressure prevailing in the interior of the sun, all elements, like radium under terrestrial conditions, explode because of their subatomic energies. Julius has maintained that the prominences may be mirage-like appearances due to unusual refraction, and that they are not actual eruptions from the sun as they seem to be. But their velocity is so great that they must be seen perpendicularly to the line of sight when they are seen on the sun's limb, and also from spectral line displacements in accord-
149
CH. XI, 236J
THE SUN 397
ance with the Doppler-Fizeau principle, and it seems very improbable that they are not real.
The spectra of eruptive prominences show many lines, especially in the lower levels. In them the bright lines of sodium, magnesium, iron, and titanium are conspicuous, while those of calcium, chromium, and manganese are
A photograph showing a solar prominence in an interval of ten minutes. Photographed by Sluiter at the Yerkes Observatory.
Fro. 150. — Changes in a solar prominence in an interval of ten minutes.
Photographed by Sluiter at the Yerkes Observatory.
generally found. In the higher levels calcium is the pre-dominating element, a remarkable fact in view of its atomic weight of 40.
Prominences were formerly observed only when the sun was totally eclipsed, for at other times the illumination of the sky made them altogether invisible. But since the development of the spectroscope they can be observed at any time. If the light from the limb of the sun is passed through
398 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xi, 236
the spectroscope, the continuous illumination of the earth's atmosphere is spread out and correspondingly enfeebled; on the other hand, the light from the prominences consists of single colors and is not diminished in intensity by passing through the spectroscope. Consequently, if the dispersion is sufficient, the atmospheric illumination is reduced until the prominences become visible.
Not all the prominences are eruptive. Besides those which burst out suddenly, rising to great heights and soon disappearing or subsiding again, there are others, called *quiescent* prominences, which spread out, like a band, between two stars or between two regions below. They often develop far above the surface of the sun, without apparent connections with it, and seem to be due to material which for some mysterious reason suddenly becomes visible. They rest quietly at great altitudes, somewhat like terrestrial clouds, often for many days, notwithstanding the sun's gravity. They are made up of hydrogen, helium, and calcium.
297 The Spectroheliograph.—The photosphere radiates a continuous spectrum, while above it is the reversing layer which produces the dark absorption lines. Some of the lines, as the K-line due to calcium, are broad because of the great extent of the absorbing layer. Now, calcium is abundant in the prominences, and, moreover, it shines with an intensity greater than that of the reversing layer. The result is that the reversing layer makes a broad, dark line, say the K-line, and above it is more luminous calcium in a rare state. This gives rise to a bright line near the margin of the dark one. The line is said to be "double" or banded.
The spectroheliograph is an instrument invented and perfected by Hale in 1891 for the purpose of photographing the sun with the light from a single element. The ideas on which it depends were almost simultaneously developed and applied by Deslandres. In this instrument, or rather combination of instruments, the sunlight is passed through a
CUL. XI, 237]
THE SUN
399
spectroscope and is spread out into a spectrum. The $K$-line, which is most frequently used, is doubly reversed in the regions of faculae and prominences. All the spectrum is cut off by an opaque screen except the bright part of the $K$-line which passes through a second narrow slit. That is, the only light which reaches the photographic plate is the incident light from that portion of the sun's image which falls on the first slit of the spectroscope. In Fig. 151, $S$ is the image of the sun at the focal plane of the telescope, $A$ is the slit of the spectroscope (the prisms are not shown), $T$ is the spectrum which falls on the screen $B$, $R$ is a slit in the screen $B$ which is adjusted so that it admits the bright center of
A diagram showing a spectroheliograph setup with a telescope, spectroscopic slit, and photographic plate.
Fig. 151. — The spectroheliograph.
the doubly reversed $K$-line, and $P$ is a photographic plate on which the $K$-line falls. The apparatus is so made that the slit $A$ may be moved across the image of the sun $S$, and the slit $R$ simultaneously moved so that the $K$-line falls on successively different parts of the photographic plate $P$. In this manner a photograph of the hot calcium vapors which lie above the reversing layer may be obtained. Such photographs have been made by several observers. Some other spectral lines have also been used in this way. For example, two photographs of a spot with the so-called $H$-line are shown in Fig. 133.
The width of a spectral line depends upon the density of the gas which is emitting the light. Suppose a thick layer of calcium gas which is rare at the top and denser at the bottom gives a bright $K$-line. The central part will be due to
400 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [CH. XL 237
light coming from all depths, particularly from the higher layers where absorption is unimportant. On the other hand, the marginal parts of the line will be due to light
Fig. 152.—Spectroheliogram of the sun taken with the doubly reversed calcium line. Photographed by Hale and Ellerman at Yerkes Observatory.
coming from the lower levels where the gas is denser. Following out these principles, and using a very narrow slit, Hale first obtained photographs of different levels of the solar atmosphere.
CU. XI. 238]
THE SUN
401
238. The Corona. — During total eclipses the sun is seen to be surrounded by a halo of pearly light, called the corona, extending out 200,000 or 300,000 miles, while some of the streamers reach out at least 5,000,000 miles. So far as has been observed there are no definite evidences of the corona except at the times of total eclipse of the sun.
One of the reasons that eclipses are of great scientific interest is that they afford an opportunity of studying this remarkable solar appendage. The brief duration of total eclipses and their infrequency have made progress in the researches on the corona rather slow. The corona is not
Fig. 153.—Spectroheliograms of a sun spot with the doubly reversed H-line of calcium. Hale and Ellerman, Solar Observatory, Aug. 7 and 9, 1915.
arranged in concentric layers like an atmosphere, but is made up of complicated systems of streamers (Fig. 154), in general stretching out radially from the sun, but often simply darkly curved, and somewhat resembling auroras. Many observers have stated that its finely detailed structure resembles the Orion nebula.
The coronal streamers often, perhaps generally, have their bases in the regions of active prominences, but exceptions have been noted. That they are in some way connected with activity on the sun is shown by the fact that the form of the corona changes in a cycle of about eleven years, the same as that of sun-spot activity. At sun-spot maxima the coronal streamers radiate from all latitudes nearly
2D
402 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [CH. XI, 238]
A black and white photograph of a solar eclipse.
Fig. 164. - Photograph of the sun at the total eclipse of the sun, May 29, 1900 (Birmingham Observatory).
cn. xi, 238]
THE SUN
403
equally. As the maxima pass, the coronal streamers gradually withdraw from the poles of the sun and extend out to greater distances in the sun-spot zones. At the sun-spot minima, the corona consists of short rays in the polar regions, curved away from the solar axis, and long streamers extending out in the equatorial plane.
The spectroscope shows that the corona emits three kinds of light: First, there is a small quantity which is known to be reflected sunlight, for it contains no lines of the Fraunhofer absorption lines, and it is polarized. Second, there is white light whose source, according to the first law of spectrum analysis, must be incandescent solid or liquid particles. Lastly, there is a bright-line spectrum whose source, according to the second law of spectrum analysis, must be an incandescent gas. The most conspicuous line in this spectrum is the hydrogen line at 6563 angstroms, which is not yet known on the earth. There seems to be at least one other substance present, but no known elements.
According to present ideas, the corona consists of dust particles, liquid globules, and small masses of gas which are widely scattered. From the amount of light and heat radiated, and from the temperature which masses so near the sun must have, Arrhenius computed that there is one dust particle, on the average, for every 14 cubic yards of volume. This is shown by the fact that comets have ploughed through hundreds of thousands of miles of it without being sensibly retarded. The dust particles and liquid globules give the reflected light; the liquid, the continuous spectrum; and the gases, the bright-line spectrum.
The form of the corona shows that its condition of equilibrium is not at all similar to that of an atmosphere like one on earth. The rate of density change with distance from the sun is inexactly slow, though doubtless light pressure and electrical forces are opposed to gravity. Its radial structure and periodical variation in general form are without satisfactory explanation.
1
404 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xi, 239
239. The Eleven-Year Cycle.--It has been explained that sun spots vary in frequency and distribution on the sun's surface in a period averaging a little more than 11 years.
There are a number of other phenomena which undergo changes in the same period.
The faculae are most numerous in the sun-spot zones, although they occur all over the sun. Both their number and the positions of the zones where they are most numerous vary periodically with the sun-spot period. This is quite true also of the sun-spots themselves and the faculae are both photospheric phenomena.
The eruptive prominences are frequent in the sun-spot belts, and vary in position with them. The evidence so far also shows periodic variations in their numbers. The quiescent prominences, on the other hand, cluster in the polar regions.
The coronal types clearly vary in the eleven-year cycle, as was explained in the preceding article. Doubtless the total solar radiation varies to some extent in the same period, though this has not been verified observationally, but the time is now ripe for the investigation.
The spectrum of sun spots vary with the period of the spots, but the Fraunhofer lines are singularly invariable.
The great vibrations which so powerfully agitate the sun during its rotation about its axis affect the whole solar system. It has long been known that both the horizontal and vertical components of the earth's magnetism vary in the sun-spot period, and that magnetic disturbances ("storms") are most frequent at the times when sun spots are most numerous. Likewise, aurora occur most frequently at the epochs of great sun-spot activity. In fact, magnetic storms and aurora never occur except when there is great activity in sun-spots. In the form of sun-spots and prominences, but there are frequent disturbances throughout without accompanying terrestrial phenomena. The correlation of these phenomena is shown in Fig. 155.
CH. XI. 239J
THE SUN 405
The first suggested explanation of magnetic storms on the earth was that the sun induces changes in the earth's magnetic state by sending out electromagnetic waves. Lord Kelvin raised the objection that if the sun were sending out these waves in every direction, it would give out as much energy in 8 hours of an ordinary electric storm as it radiates in light.
A graph showing fluctuations in magnetic storms, prominence, faculae, and sun spots from 1882 to 1904.
FIG. 153. — Curves of magnetic storms, prominences, faculae, and sun spots from 1882 to 1904.
and heat in 4 months. A recent exhaustive discussion of the data has led Maunder to the conclusion that the source of the periodic magnetic storms is in the sun, that the magnetic disturbances are confined to restricted areas on the sun, and that these disturbances are caused by conical magnetic cones which rotate with the sun ; that when these cones of magnetic disturbances strike the earth, magnetic storms are
406 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ca. xi, 239
induced, and that these magnetic storms have intimate, though unknown, relations with sun spots. The most important contribution of this investigation was that there is no evidence to show that the sun is surrounded to be regarded as surrounded by a polarized magnetic sphere, but that there are definite and intense stream lines of magnetic influence, probably connected with the coronal rays, reaching out principally from the spot zones in directions which are not necessarily exactly radial. It is a little too early to formulate a precise theory as to whether these streams are electrified particles driven off by magnetic forces and light pressure, or whether they are the spontaneous appearance of matter and energy of a character and in a state not yet recognized by science.
XVII. QUESTIONS
1. The apparent diameter of the sun as seen from the earth is about 32° what are the apparent thicknesses of the corona, chromosphere, and reversing layer?
2. The sun's disk is considerably brighter at its center than near its margin (Fig. 141). Can this phenomenon be explained by the absorption of light by the atmosphere? Or by the presence of small solid or liquid particles somewhere above the photosphere?
3. If the smallest spot that can be seen subtends an angle of 1°, what is the diameter of the smallest sun spot that can be seen simply through a smoked glass?
4. In what direction do sun spots appear to cross the sun's disk as a consequence of its rotation?
5. Why cannot the corona be observed with the aid of the spectroscope at any time just as the prominences are observed?
CHAPTER XII
EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM
I. GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS ON EVOLUTION
240. The Essence of the Doctrine of Evolution. — The fundamental basis on which science rests is the orderliness of the universe. That it is not a chaos has been confirmed by an enormous amount of experience, and the principle that it is orderly is now universally accepted. This principle is embodied in a fundamental respect by the doctrine of evolution.
According to the fundamental principle of science the universe was orderly yesterday, is orderly to-day, and will be orderly to-morrow; according to the doctrine of evolution, the order of yesterday changed into that of to-day in a continuous and lawful manner, and the order of to-day will change into that of tomorrow continuously and systematically. Thus, the universe is not only systematic and orderly in time, but also in time. The real essence of the doctrine of evolution is that it maintains the orderliness of the universe in time as well as in space.
Evolution may be from the simple and relatively unorganized to the complex and highly organized, or it may be in the opposite direction. In fact, evolution generally involves the transformation of one form into another. The soil and the elements of the atmosphere sometimes combine and produce a tree having foliage, flowers, and fruit. But the tree grows, at least partly, on the disintegrating products of other trees or plants, and in its own trunk the processes of decay are active. Or, to take a less commonplace example, with the advancement of civilization men have become 407
408 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xii, 240
more sensitive to discord and more and more capable of appreciating certain types of harmony. There is almost certainly a corresponding improvement in the structure of their nervous system. On the other hand there is degener- ation in the sense that they tend to have less change in the two directions are both examples of evolution.
As knowledge increases it is found that everything is con- tinually changing. Individuals change, institutions change, languages change, and even the " eternal hills" are broken up and washed away by the elements in a moment of geo- logical time. Moreover, all these changes are found to be perfect and harmonious. The precise facts of evolution, as well as so fundamental as to be difficult to prove by so much experience that scientists, the world over, accept it with ab- solute confidence. There have been, and there doubtless will continue to be, differences of opinion regarding what the precise processes of certain particular evolutions may have been, but there is no disagreement whatever regarding the fundamental principle.
24. The Law of a Theory of Evolution. — The im- portance of a general principle is proportional to the number of known facts it correlates. This is a general proposition with special applications in science. Since a theory of evolution is concerned largely with the relations among the data established by experience, it naturally forces an attempt at their correlation. Moreover, the relations are examined in a critical spirit so that any errors in the data misconceptions regarding their relations are apt to be revealed. Therefore, an attempt to construct a theory of evolution is of value because it leads to a better understand- ing of the material upon which it is being based.
A theory of evolution invariably demands a knowledge of facts in addition to those upon which it is based. In this way it stimulates and directs investigation. A great majori- ty of the investigations which scientific men make are for the purpose of proving or disproving some theory they have
CH. XII, 241] EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 409
tentatively formulated. The true scientist often has pre-
conceived notions as to what is true, but he conscientiously
follows the results of experience.
A broad scientific theory involves many secondary theories
depending upon special groups of phenomena. For example,
a theory of the development of the solar system will involve theories of the sun's heat, of the revolution
of the planets, of the rotation of the planets, of the planetoids,
of the zodiacal light, etc. In the construction of a general
theory of evolution the secondary theories are related to
the whole, and in this way they are subjected to a searching
examination. The criticism of secondary theories whether
they are favorable or unfavorable is one of the most impor-
tant value of the development of a theory of evolution.
The activities of men are largely directed toward satisfying
their intellectual wants, though this fact might be easily
overlooked. For example, they do not ordinarily visit for-
eign countries to get more to eat or wear, but to acquire
broader views of the world. The important thing in travel-
ing is not that a person gets physically any particular
thing, but that he acquires an intellectual experience that
result from going there. Astronomers cannot travel through
the vast regions of space which they explore, but the long
arms of their analysis reach out and gather up the facts
and bring them to their consciousness with a vividness
scarcely surpassed in any experience. As their powerful
instruments and mathematical procedures extend their experi-
ences and increase their conception, to the extent that it is
complete and sound, extends their experience in time.
Finally, a theory which gives unity to a great variety of
observational data is of rare aesthetic value. It is related
to the catalogue of imperfectly correlated facts upon which
it is based as a finished and magnificent echedral is to the
untidy heaps of stone, brick, and wood from which it was built. In some reflections along this line, near the
close of his popular work on astronomy, Laplace said,
A page from a book with text discussing the development and criticism of scientific theories.
410 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xii, 241
" Contemplated as one grand whole, astronomy is the most beautiful monument of the human mind, the noblest record of its intelligence."
In view of these considerations it is evident that the evolution of the solar system is a subject to which the astronomer naturally devotes his anxious attention. The foremost authorities of the present time have treated the question in lectures, in essays, and in books. When new discoveries are made their bearings on evolutionary theories are at once examined. Astronomers are rapidly approaching the point of view of the biologists, who interpret all their phenomena in terms of evolutionary doctrines. Yet scarcely a generation ago many astronomers regarded with a dangerous scepticism the doctrine of evolution.
242. Outline of the Growth of the Doctrine of Evolution.
Every great discovery doubtless has been the culmination of a long period of preliminary work, and before final success has been attained generally many men have approximated to the truth. So it has been with the doctrine of evolution. The ancient Greeks developed theories that everything had evolved from nothing; from this they derived a law containing the germ of the idea of evolution, but their authors had not laid secure enough the foundations of science to enable them to treat successfully the development of the universe. After the decline of their intellectual activity the subject of evolution was not considered seriously for many centuries.
In the eighteenth century geologists were groping for a satisfactory theory regarding the succession of the life forms whose fossils were found in the rocks. They seem to have concluded on the whole that the earth had been sub- ject to a number of great cataclysms in which all life was destroyed. They supposed that following each destruction of life there had been a new creation in which higher forms were produced. The prevalence of such ideas as these shows with what difficulty the doctrine of evolution was developed.
cn. xn, 242] EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 411
In 1750 Thomas Wright, of Durham, England, published a theory of the evolution, not only of the solar system, but also of all the stars that fill the sky. The chief merit of this work was that indirectly it gave a straightforward exposition of the doctrine of evolution. Its chief influence seems to have been on the mind of William Herschel, into whose hands it fell. Kant at once turned his brilliant mind to the contemplation of the problems of cosmonomy, or the evolution of the celestial bodies, and in 1756 he published a remarkable book on the subject. But the world seems not to have been ripe for the idea of evolution, because neither the work of Wright nor that of Kant had any important influence upon science.
In 1796 the great French astronomer and mathematician Laplace published his celebrated "Nebular Hypothesis." It was supported by the great name of its author, and it was relatively simple and easily understood. Moreover, during the French Revolution the world had acquired a new point of view and had become more receptive of new ideas. For these reasons the theory of Laplace soon obtained wide acceptance among scientific men. It made a profound impression upon them, and they accepted it with account of the early history of the earth. It gave them astronomical authority for an originally hot and molten earth which had solidified on cooling. It encouraged them to interpret geological phenomena by geological principles.
In the early decades of the nineteenth century geologists largely abandoned the idea that the earth had necessarily visited by destructive cataclysms, and adopted the view that it had undergone a continuous series of great changes at a roughly uniform rate.
The work of the geologists led naturally to the extension of the doctrine of evolution to the biological sciences. In the first place, the belief that the earth was enormously old had become current. In the second place, there were unmistakable evidences that the surface of the earth had
412 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xii, 242
undergone extensive changes. In the third place, the early rocks contained only fossils of low forms of life, while the later rocks contained fossils of higher forms of life. In addition, there were many direct evidences of a purely biological character, though we have no continuous series of life from the lowest to the highest.
The principle of biological evolution seems to have been taking definite shape simultaneously in the minds of Charles Darwin, Alfred Russel Wallace, and Herbert Spencer. Darwin and Wallace were naturalists and Spencer was a philosopher. In 1858 Darwin published his *Origin of Species*, in which he brought together the results of almost fifty years' knowledge on the subject. He gave unanswerable evidence for his conclusion that during the geological ages, as a consequence of changing environment, natural selection, survival of the fittest, etc., one species of animals gradually changed into another, and that at the present time all the higher types of animals, including man, are more or less closely related.
In spite of this fact, however, the doctrine of evolution is full of hope for the future progress of the human race, Darwin's book aroused the bitterest antagonism. While biologists do not now fully agree with him as to the relative importance of the various factors involved in biological evolution, nevertheless they universally accept his fundamental conclusions.
Moreover, the changes in political, social, and religious institutions are now considered in the light of the same ideas. Thus it is evident that in the course of time one life evolves continuously and in obedience to all the factors operating on it into that which exists at another time.
In brief, the development of the modern doctrine of evolution is as follows: In the middle of the eighteenth century its first beginnings were laid in astronomy by Wright and Kant. At the end of the century it was given an enormous impulse by the astronomer and mathematician, Laplace. His theory of the origin of the earth stimulated geologists
cr. xn, 243 EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 413
to adopt it in the early decades of the nineteenth century.
By the middle of the century it was being definitely applied in the biological sciences. In 1858 Darwin published his great masterpiece, *The Origin of Species*, which gave the whole world a new point of view and revolutionized its thinking on this subject. The development and acceptance of the doctrine of evolution was the greatest achievement of the nineteenth century.
XVIII. QUESTIONS
1. Is the creation of the chaos below Niagara Falls an example of an evolution? Is the clearing away of the forests and the propagation of the land for cultivation? Is an explosion of dynamite?
2. Would the direct creation of men and lower animals be an example of evolution?
3. What facts in scientific ideas constitute an evolution?
4. Are religious ideas undergoing an evolution?
5. Will the doctrine of evolution undergo an evolution?
6. Is it possible that at present time is believed to be orderly; is it reasonable to suppose that in remote regions or at remote times it was not orderly?
7. Why was the doctrine of evolution first clearly understood in ancient times?
8. According to the doctrine of evolution, will two identical conditions of the universe lead to identical results? Is it probable that the universe is twice in exactly the same state?
II. DATA OF THE PROBLEM OF EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM
243. General Evidences of Orderly Development.—
There are certain obvious evidences that the solar system has undergone an orderly evolution. For example, the planets all revolve around the sun in nearly the same plane and in the same direction. There are in addition over 800 planetoids which have similar motions. Moreover, the sun and the four planets whose surface markings are distinctly visible rotate in the same direction. So great a uniformity can scarcely be the result of chance.
414 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xii, 243
In order to treat the matter numerically, suppose there are 800 bodies whose planes of motion do not differ from the plane of the earth's orbit by more than 18°, and whose directions of motion are the same as that of the earth. Since the inclination of an orbit could be anything from 0° to 180°, the chance of two orbits being at right angles would be one in 360, or a probability that the planes of the orbits of two bodies would be less than 18° is $\left(\frac{1}{360}\right)^2$. And the probability that the same would be true for 800 bodies is only $(\frac{1}{360})^{800}$, or unity divided by 1 followed by 800 ciphers. This probability is so small that we are forced to the conclusion that the arrangement of the planets in the solar system is not accidental.
Both Kant and Laplace made use of this line of reasoning in their theories. In both cases they assumed that all the planets have eccentricities greater than zero, and that each has an eccentricity between 0.2 and 0.5. For any eccentricity from 0 to 1. Of the more than 800 planets and planetoids, the orbits of 624 have eccentricities less than 0.2, the orbits of all except 26 have eccentricities less than 0.3, and the orbit of only one has an eccentricity greater than 0.5. These remarkable facts imply that some systematic cause has been at work which has produced planetary motions with such regularity. And besides, the positions of the planets and the small eccentricities of their orbits show that these planets prove conclusively that the solar system, in all its history, has not been subject to any important external disturbance, such as a closely passing star.
**244. Distribution of Mass in the Solar System.** — Nearly all the matter of the solar system is concentrated in the sun. In fact, all the planets together contain less than one seventh of one per cent of the mass of the entire system. Although the mass of Jupiter is more than 2.4 times that of all the other planets combined, it is less than one thousandth that of the sun.
It is important to know whether the masses of the sun and planets are now changing. There is certainly at present no appreciable transfer of matter from one body to another. The sun may be losing some particles by ejecting
CH. XII, 244] EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 415
from them its surface in an electrified condition, and a very small percentage of the ejected particles may strike the planets, but it is very improbable that the process has had important effects on the distribution of mass in the solar system, even in the enormous intervals of time required for its evolution.
The mass of the earth is slowly increasing by the meteoric material which it sweeps up in its journey around the sun. It is not unreasonable to suppose that the other planets, and possibly the sun, are growing similarly. This growth, at least in the case of the earth, is too slow at present to have a very important bearing on the evolution of the whole system. But if the meteors are permanent members of the solar system, the more they are swept up by the planet's gravity, the greater will be their number and the larger will be the number a planet encounters in a day. Consequently, the acquisition of meteoric material by collision may once have been a much more important factor in the evolution of the planets than it is at the present time. In fact, so far as general considerations go, appreciable fractions of the masses of the planets may have been obtained from meteoric material. But it is improbable that the great sun has generated matter in this way.
It follows from this conclusion that probably the remote antecedent of the solar system consisted of an overwhelming central mass and a very small quantity of matter distributed somewhat irregularly out from it to an enormous distance. At any rate, if this were not the original distribution of matter, the conditions must have been such that the central condensation resulted in harmony with the laws of gravitation. A diagram showing how this happened among the planets is shown in Figs. 96 and 97. The relatively small masses of the planets and their enormous distances from one another are among the most remarkable facts that need to be taken into account when considering their origin and evolution.
416 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cf. xn, 244]
An additional fact which must be noted is that the ter-
restrial planets contain the heaviest known substances. The
sun also contains heavy elements (Art. 234), though the
spectra of the sun the very heaviest have not been found.
The constitution of the large planets is not so well known,
though it may be inferred from their low densities and mod-
erate temperatures that they contain largely only the light
elements. Any hypothesis as to the origin of the planets,
in order to be satisfactory, must make provision for this
distribution of the elements. See Art. 245.
245. THE LAW OF Moment of Momentum.— In at-
tempting to go back to the origin of the solar system it is
natural to consider its mass and distribution of mass because
matter is indestructible. For a similar reason, the distribu-
tion of the moment of momentum of the system among its
various members is of fundamental importance. That is,
if the solar system has undergone its evolution free from
external disturbances, its total moment of momentum is
now exactly equal to what it was at the beginning and at
every stage of its development.
As has been stated, the small mutual inclinations of the
orbits of the planets and the small eccentricities of their orbits
both prove that the solar system has been subject to no important exterior influences since the planets were
formed. Hence any hypothetical antecedent of the system must be assigned a quantity of moment of momentum it
no longer possesses. Although this was perfectly clear, it was overlooked by Kant and was not given adequate consider-
ation by Laplace and his followers.
In Table XII the mass and moment of momentum is
given for the sun and each of the eight planets in such units
that the sums are unity. The moment of momentum of the
sun depends upon its law of density. In the computation it was assumed that its density increases exter-
ior according to a law of increase of density formulated by Laplace. The rotations of the planets contribute so
CH. XII, 245] EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 417
little to the final results that it is not important what law of density is used for them.
**TABLE XII**
| Body |
Mass |
Moment of Momentum |
| Sun. |
0.9986590 |
0.027423 |
| Mercury |
0.0000001 |
0.000017 |
| Venus |
0.0000025 |
0.000576 |
| Earth |
0.0000039 |
0.0019527 |
| Mars |
0.0000033 |
0.001122 |
| Jupiter |
0.009538 |
5.592733 |
| Saturn |
0.0262562 |
141.9544 |
| Uranus |
0.0004310 |
5.028485 |
| Neptune |
0.0005117 |
0.577963 |
| Total |
1.0000666 |
1.0006666 |
It is seen from this table that although the mass of the sun is 709 times as great as that of all the planets combined, its moment of momentum is only a little over $A_2$ that of the planets. Or, considering the internal interior to the orbit of Saturn, it is found that while Jupiter contains only $\frac{1}{4}$ of one per cent, or $\frac{1}{4}V_{\text{Jup}}$, of the entire mass, it possesses more than 95 per cent of the moment of momentum.
One at once inquires whether the distribution of moment of momentum is now being changed. The mutual attractions of the planets produce some changes in the distribution of moment of momentum, but these do not influence whatever in connection with the problem under consideration. The tides which a planet generates in the sun reduce the moment of momentum of the sun and increase that of the planet. But here again the results are inappreciable even for thousands of millions of years. The earth encounters meteoric matter in its revolution around the sun, and it is this matter which produces effect due to such dis- turbances. The result of the resistance by meteors is to reduce the moment of momentum of the planets. At pres...
2B
418 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xii, 245]
ent the effects of meteors on the motion of the earth are inappreciable, but it is not certain that they were once not important. However, whether or not they have been an influence at any time, they certainly relieve the inequalities in the table, for they are decreasing the moment of momentum of the planets, which are still relatively very large. In fact, there have been no known influences at work which could have sensibly modified the distribution of the moment of momentum of the system since the sun and planets have been separate bodies.
It remains to inquire whether the sun and planets may not each be parts of one mass with a distribution of moment of momentum quite different from that found at present. Since the planets are not receding from the sun, the only possibility is that the sun and the planets were formerly so expanded that the material of which they are composed was more or less intermingled.
According to the contraction theory of the heat of the sun, its dimensions must have been greater than they are at present. Indeed, the sun has been supposed to have once filled all the space now occupied by the planets. Followed backward in time, the sun is found to be larger and larger, rotating more and more slowly because its moment of momentum remained constant during contraction, and more and more nearly spherical because a rotating body becomes more oblate with contraction. It follows from this that if the atmospheres interior to Jupiter were added to the sun they would not have an important effect on its moment of momentum.
Now suppose the sun was once expanded out to the orbit of Jupiter; its radius was more than 1000 times its present radius, its volume was more than 1000$^3$ = 1,000,000,000 times its present volume, and its density was correspondingly less. The atmosphere now condensed inwardly, so that its density at its periphery was then less than one millionth of that of the earth's atmosphere at sea level. It follows from
cc. xii, 246] EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 419
the fact that the moment of momentum was necessarily constant, that its period of rotation must have been about 70,000 years. But Jupiter's period of revolution is about 12 years. Now, therefore, either Jupiter was then quite independent of the general solar mass; or, if not, in some unknown way the general solar mass had imparted to that minute fraction of itself which later became Jupiter enough moment of momentum to reduce the period of this part from 70,000 years to 12 years. More specifically, it is seen from the table that Jupiter, which contains one tenth of one per cent of the mass of the solar system within the orbit of Saturn, carries over 85 per cent of the moment of momentum of the entire system. The distribution of moment of momentum could have developed from an approximately uniform distribution, especially in a mass of such low density, and no one has been able to formulate a plausible explanation of it. Consequently, it must be concluded that the distribution of moment of momentum in the solar system has not changed appreciably since it has been acted upon by exterior forces.
246. The Energy of the Solar System. — In considering the energy of the solar system, the discussion must include its kinetic energy, heat energy, potential energy, and sub- atomic energy.
The kinetic energy of a body is its energy of motion including translation, rotation, and internal currents. The kinetic energy of the solar system consists of its energy of translation and rotation only. The former cannot have changed except by the action of exterior forces. Moreover, its value is not accurately known, and it has no relation to the remaining energy of the system so long as no other celestial body is encountered. Therefore it will be given no further consideration in this connection.
The mutual attractions of the planets change their translatory motions, but in such a way that the sum of their kinetic and potential energies remains constant.
420 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [CH. XII, 246]
The sun, planets, and satellites raise tides in one another. In these tides there is some friction in which kinetic energy degenerates into heat energy, which is radiated away into space. In this way the solar system is losing energy. The heat energy from all other sources is likewise being lost by radiation.
The potential energy of a system is equal to the work which may be done upon it, in virtue of the relative positions of its parts, by the forces to which it is subject. For example, a body 100 feet above the surface of the earth is subject to the force of gravity, and it requires 100 foot-pounds of work to lift an amount of work upon the body in causing it to fall from an altitude of 100 feet to its surface. This work equals the potential energy of the body in its original position. In the case of the translations of the planets, as has been stated, the sum of their kinetic and potential energies is constant.
But if the sun or a planet contracts, the potential energy of its expansion condition is transformed into heat (Art. 216), which is largely partly lost by radiation. In this way the total energy of the system decreases, and the diminution may be large in amount.
There is certainly a large amount of subatomic energy in uranium, radium, and probably in all other elements. In the case of the radioactive substances this energy is slowly transformed into heat, which is dissipated by radiation. As has been suggested (Art. 219), the subatomic energies may be liberated at great quantities under the extreme conditions of pressure and temperature which prevail in the interior of the sun.
Since the solar system is losing energy in several ways and acquiring only inappreciable amounts from outside, as, for example, the radiant energy received from the stars, it originally had more energy than at present, and this condition must be satisfied by all hypotheses respecting its evolution.
CH. XII, 247] EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 421
XIX. QUESTIONS
1. What is the probability that when 3 coins are tossed up they will all fall heads up? What is the probability that in a throw of 4 dice there will be 4 aces up? If 100 coins were found heads up, could it reasonably be supposed that the arrangement was accidental?
2. Suppose a star should pass near the solar system in the plane of the ecliptic, and by its gravity disturb the positions of the orbits of the planets and asteroids are accidental?
3. How many tons of meteors would have to strike the earth daily in order to double its mass in 200,000,000 years? How many tons would be required to double its mass in one year?
4. What is the definition of moment of momentum? How does it differ from momentum? Is it manifested in various forms of motion? What is the effect of energy of a body by radiation change its moment of momentum?
5. The mass of the earth is 1.2 times that of Venus (Table XII); why is its moment of momentum more than 1.2 times that of Venus?
6. Could the total energy of the solar system have been infinite at the start? Can the system have existed in approximately its present configuration for an indefinite period?
7. When carbon and oxygen unite chemically, heat is produced; this heat energy developed at the expense of the kinetic, potential, heat, or subatomic energies of the original materials?
III. THE PLANETESIMAL HYPOTHESIS.
247. Brief Outline of the Planetesimal Hypothesis. — The fundamental conditions imposed by the distribution of mass and energy in our solar system, together with many supplementary considerations, have led to the planetesimal hypothesis. According to this hypothesis, the remote ancestor of the solar system was a more or less condensed and well-defined central sun, having slow rotation, surrounded by a vast swarm of somewhat irregularly scattered secondary bodies, or planetesimals (little planets),
The Planetesimal Hypothesis was developed by Professor T. C. Chamberlin and the author in 1900 and the following years.
422 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xn, 247
which all revolved in elliptical orbits about the central mass in the same general direction. This organization evidently satisfies the data of the problem. Moreover, the spiral nebula [Art. 302] offer numerous examples of matter which is apparently in this state.
According to the planetesimal hypothesis, our present solar system was formed by the coalescence of masses and possibly some outlying parts which fell in upon it because they had small motions of translation. The revolving scattered material contained nuclei of various dimensions which, in their motions about the central sun, swept up the remaining scattered material and gradually grew into planets whose masses depend upon the original masses of the nuclei and the amount of matter in the regions through which they passed. The angles between the planes of the orbits were generally large, but as time went on and as the eccentricities became smaller, the eccentric orbits became more nearly circular. In the process of growth the planetary nuclei acquired their forward rotations.
**248. Examples of Planetesimal Organization.** — The planetoids afford a trace of the former planetesimal condition of the solar system. The average inclination and the average eccentricity of their orbits are considerably larger than those of the planets, quantities which would have been swept by a dominating nucleus, they would have combined with it in a planet occupying approximately the mean positions of the planes of their orbits and having a small eccentricity (Art. 252).
Another example of planetesimal organization is furnished by the particles of which the rings of Saturn are composed. It has been shown that these particles would have formed one or more satellites if dominating nuclei had been revolving around the planet in the zone which they occupy. But they are very close to Saturn, and a satellite revolving at their distance would be subject to the strains of the tides produced by the planet. As has been stated
CH. XII, 248j EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 423
(Art. 183). Roche showed that a fluid satellite could not re-
volve within 2.44 radii of a planet without being broken up, unless its density were greater than that of the planet.
Since the rings of Saturn are within this limit it follows that Saturn would not be a satellite, and that a large nucleus revolving among them instead of sweeping them up, would itself have been reduced to the planetesimal condition, unless it was solid and strong enough to withstand great tidal strains.
The examples of planetesimal organization which have been given may not be very convincing. But we may inquire whether there are any more examples in the heavens, besides the system conformatory of the planetesimal theory. The answer is in the affirmative. There are tens of thousands of spiral nebulae that are almost certainly in the planetesimal condition, though on a tremendous scale. They consist of central sunlike nuclei which are generally well defined, and arms of widening, scattered material. Their arms in most cases probably contain large masses but they do not appear to be very dense. Their great numbers imply that they are in general semi-permanent in character. Consequently, the material of which the arms are composed cannot in general be moving along them, either in toward or out from the central nucleus, for under these circumstances they would condense into sungs or dissipate into space, and in either case lose their peculiar characteristics. Besides, matter subject to the laws of gravitation could not move in such a manner as it does. It is therefore believed that in a spiral nebula the arms are composed of material which, instead of proceeding along them, moves across them around the central nucleus as a focus. The spirals owe their coils to the fact that the inner parts revolve faster than the outer parts. As a rule they radiate with light, which indicates that they are at least partly in a solid or liquid state. When a spiral is seen edgewise to the earth there is a dark band through its
424 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xii, 248]
center, doubtless produced by dark, opaque material revolv-
ing at its periphery.
While a few spiral nebulae have been known for a long time, their great numbers were not suspected until Keeler began to photograph them with the Crossley reflector at the Lick Observatory. In a paper published in 1900 shortly before his death he stated that
" Many thousands of unrecorded nebulae exist in the sky. A conservative estimate places the number within the reach of the Crossley reflector at about 120,000. The number of nebulae in our catalogues is but a small fraction of this.
" 2. These nebulae exhibit all gradations of apparent size from the great nebula in Andromeda down to an object which is hardly distinguishable from a faint star disk.
" 3. Most of these nebulae have a spiral structure. While I do not wish to claim any special importance of these conclusions, it seems to me that they have a very direct bearing on many, if not all, questions concerning the cosmovision. If, for example, the spiral is the form normally assumed by a contracting nebulous mass, the idea at once suggests itself that the solar system has been evolved from a spiral nebula, while the photographs show that the spiral is not, as a rule, characterized by the simplicity attributed to the contracting mass in the theory of the hydrogen hypothesis.
The existence of what has already been taken up by Chamberlin and Mouton of the University of Chicago."
While the spirals are almost certainly examples of plan-
etesimal organization, those which have been photographed are enormously larger than the parent of the solar system unless, indeed, there are many undiscovered planets beyond the orbit of Neptune. But as Keeler remarked, there is no lower limit to the apparent dimensions of the spiral nebula, and it is possible that many of them are actually of very moderate size.
249. Suggested Origin of Spiral Nebulae. Although the validity of the planetesimal theory does not hang upon any
CH. XII, 249 EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 425
hypothesis as to the origin of spiral nebula, yet, if the solar system has evolved from a spiral nebula, the theory of its origin will not be regarded as complete and fully satisfactory until the mode of generation of these nebulae has been explained. The best suggestion regarding their genesis, however, is still lacking.
There are several hundreds of millions of stars in the heavens and they are moving with respect to one another with an average velocity of about 600,000,000 miles per year. While their motions are by no means entirely at random, yet there are millions of them moving in essentially every direction. It is impossible that any two stars of the same order of time every other star will pass near some other star. If two stars should collide, the energy of their motion would largely be changed into heat and the combined mass would be transformed into a luminous nebula. If they should simply pass near one another without striking, an event which would occur many times more frequently than a collision, a spiral nebula would probably be formed, as will now be shown.
Consider two stars passing near each other. They both move in the same direction but no error will be committed in representing one of them as being at rest and the other as passing by it. If the stars are equal, their effects on each other are the same, but in order not to divide the attention, only the action of $S'$ on $S$ will be considered.
Consider $S$ when it is at the position $S_1$, Fig. 156. It raises tides on $S$, one on the side toward $S'$ and the other on the opposite side. The heights of the tides depend upon the
Fig. 156.—Deflection of ejected material by a passing star.
Fig. 156
426 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [c. xii, 249]
relative masses of the two suns and their distance apart compared to the radius of $S$. An approach within 10,000,000 miles is more than 100 times as probable as even a grazing collision. At this distance the tide-raising force of $S'$ on $S$ compared to the surface gravity of $S$ is more than 2000 times that of the earth.
The tide-raising force of the moon on the earth compared to the surface gravity of the earth. The tide-raising force varies directly as the radius of the disturbed body and inversely as the cube of the distance of the disturbing body (Art. 153). Hence, if the nearest approach were 5,000,000 miles, the tide-raising forces would be more than 10,000 times greater relatively times great than that of the moon on the earth. This force would raise tides approximately 500 miles high if the sun were a homogeneous fluid, and would be corresponding disturbances of the sun in a belt midway between the tidal cones. The tides on a highly heated gaseous body would probably be much higher.
The sun is the seat of violent explosive forces which now often eject matter in the eruptive prominences to distances of several hundred thousand miles (Fig. 157). If the sun were tidally distorted, the eruptions would be mostly toward and from the disturbing sun; certainly the ejections would
Fig. 157. —Eruptive prominence at three altitudes photographed by Slough at the Yerkes Observatory.
there would be a corresponding disturbance of the sun in a belt midway between the tidal cones. The tides on a highly heated gaseous body would probably be much higher.
The sun is the seat of violent explosive forces which now often eject matter in the eruptive prominences to distances of several hundred thousand miles (Fig. 157). If the sun were tidally distorted, the eruptions would be mostly toward and from the disturbing sun; certainly the ejections would
cn. xn, 240] EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 427
reach to greater distances in these directions. Besides this, after the ejected matter had once left the sun, its distance would be increased still further by the attraction of $S'$. Consequently, if $S'$ were not moving along its orbit, the ejections toward and from it would be to more remote distances than those toward $S$ itself. But $S'$ would be moving along in its orbit, and, in a short time, it would have a component of attraction at right angles to the original direction of motion of the ejected matter. Consequently, by the time $S'$ had arrived at $S'_t$, the paths of the ejected masser would be curved somewhat like those shown in Fig. 156. It is easy to see that, for the mass ejected toward $S'$, the curvature is in the same direction as that based on the resolution of the forces involved (Art. 153) proves that, for the mass ejected in the other direction, the indicated curvature is also correct. Eventually $S'$ would move on in its orbit so far that it would no longer have sensible attraction for the ejected masses, and they would be left revolving around $S$ in elliptical orbits. If the initial speed of the ejected material were very great, it might leave $S$ never to return.
The critical question is whether matter would be ejected far enough to produce the large orbits required by the theory. In order to throw light on this question the following table has been computed, giving the surface velocities necessary to cause undisturbed ejected matter to recede various distances from the surface of the sun.
The most remarkable thing about this table is that after a velocity is reached sufficient to cause the ejected matter to recede a few millions of miles, a small change in the initial speed produces radically different final results. Since prominences now ascend to a height of half a million of miles without the disturbing influence of a visiting sun, it is seen that the numerical requirements of the hypothesis are not excessive. Moreover, numerous actual computations of
428 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ce. xii, 249
hypothetical cases have shown that, on the recession of $S'$, the ejected material is usually left revolving around $S$ in elliptical orbits.
| Height of Ascent |
Initial Velocity |
Height of Ascent |
Initial Velocity |
| 100,000 mi. |
72 per sec. |
5,000,000 mi. |
333 mi. per sec. |
| 200,000 mi. |
121 mi. per sec. |
10,000,000 mi. |
368 mi. per sec. |
| 300,000 mi. |
157 mi. per sec. |
20,000,000 mi. |
376 mi. per sec. |
| 400,000 mi. |
214 mi. per sec. |
30,000,000 mi. |
383 mi. per sec. |
| 500,000 mi. |
268 mi. per sec. |
40,000,000 mi. |
383 mi. per sec. |
| 1,000,000 mi. |
316 mi. per sec. |
50,000,000 mi. |
384 mi. per sec. |
| 2,000,000 mi. |
Infinite |
|
|
As one star passes another the ejection of material is more or less continuous. When the visiting star is far away, the ejections are to moderate distances and the matter returns to the sun. As the visiting star approaches, the ejected materials recede farther and their paths become more curved. At a certain time the final distance of $S'$ becomes so great that the ejected material revolves around $S$ instead of falling back upon it. Let the orbits for this case be those marked 1 and 1 in Fig. 158, the former being toward $S'$ and the latter away from it. At a later time the ejections will be to greater distances and the materials will have greater lateral motions. Suppose they are 2 and 2', and so on for still later ejections until $S'$ recedes from $S$.
A diagram showing two stars orbiting each other with one star (S) moving away from the other (S'). The path of the second star (S') is shown as it moves closer to S'. The diagram illustrates the idea that as one star passes another, the ejected material from that star will move outward to a greater distance before returning to its original position around the first star. This is represented by the increasing distance between S' and S in subsequent frames of the animation.
Fig. 158.—The origin of a spiral nebula.
cm. xu, 249| EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM | 429
Now consider the location of all of the ejected material at a given time after $S'$ has passed its nearest point to $S$. If it has been sent out from $S$ continuously, it will lie along two continuous curves, represented by the full lines in Fig.
A diagram showing the spiral nebula in Cassiopeia Venatici (M. 51), with the arms indicated by dotted lines.
Fig. 159.—The great spiral nebula in Cassiopeia Venatici (M. 51), showing the two arms. Photographed by Ritchey at the Yerkes Observatory.
158. These are the arms of the spiral nebula whose individual particles move across them in the dotted lines. The diagram shows an ideal simple case, and Fig. 159 an actual photograph, so that if the approach of $S'$ were close, or if there were a partial collision, and if the ejected material should go beyond $S'$, a very complicated structure would result. The
430 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [C. XII, 249
arms of the spiral might be very irregular (Fig. 100), the particles might cross them at a great variety of angles, and some of them might continue to recede indefinitely.
The great spiral nebula in Triangulum (M. 53). Photographed by Ritchey at the Yerkes Observatory.
Thus, the suggested explanation of the origin of the spiral nebula rests upon the existence of a great number of stars, their motions being somewhat heterogeneous motions which imply near approaches now and then, their eruptive activities, and the disturbance of one star by another passing near it.
100
ch. xn, 250j EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 431
All the factors involved are well established — the only question is that of their quantitative efficiency. Here some doubts remain. It follows from the number of stars, the space they occupy, and their motions that, if they were moving at random, an individual sun would pass near some other one on its average, only once in many thousands of millions of years. Perhaps this essential precaution is not so important out on the average of the great clusters of suns of which the Milky Way is composed, where it may reasonably be supposed that their relative velocities are small, and it may be that in these regions close approaches are for this reason much more frequent. But in any case the demands of time are very formidable. Besides this, many of the spiral nebulae are of such enormous dimensions that it is difficult to conceive how they could have been formed by a near approach of ordinary suns. It may be stated, however, that, in the first place, there is no positive knowledge whatever respecting the masses of spiral nebula; and that, in the second place, near approaches are not confined to single stars, but may involve multiple stars, clusters, and systems of stars. The observed spirals may be simply the larger examples originating from several or many suns.
It should be noted also that while these doubts may remain respecting the validity of this or any other hypothesis, the spiral nebula certainly exist in great numbers, and they apparently have, on an enormous scale, an organization similar to that which we have inferred must have been the antecedent of the solar system. And it may be stated again that the planetesimal hypothesis rests primarily upon the evidence furnished by the solar system itself; it does not stand or fall with any theory respecting spiral nebula.
**250. The Origin of Planets.** According to the planetesimal hypothesis, the parent of the solar system consisted of a central sun surrounded by a vast swarm of planetesimals which moved approximately in the same plane in essentially independent elliptic orbits. Among these
432 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. xii, 250
planetesimals there were nuclei, or local centers of condensation, which, in their revolutions, swept up the smaller planetesimals and grew into planets. It is not to be understood that the planets were formed at once or even simultaneously. It is much more probable that in their early stages they were swarms of smaller masses having about the same motion with respect to the central sun, and that, under their mutual attractions and collisions, they gradually condensed into continuous bodies. Indeed, the condensation may have been very slow and may have been dependent to an important extent upon the impacts of other planetesimals.
It seems to me that the present probable masses of the original nuclei. If they were less than that of the moon at present, they could not have retained any atmospheres under their gravitative control. But as the nuclei grew, their surface gravities increased, and a time came when those which have become the larger planets possessed sufficient gravitative power to prevent the escape of atmospheres. The formation of atmospheres was inevitable because, in the first place, the materials grinding together and settling under the weight of accumulating planetesimals would squeeze out the lighter elements; in the second place, the pulverizing and heating effects of the impacts of meteors would liberate gases; and, in the third place, the growing planets in their courses around the sun would sweep directly great numbers of atmospheric molecules. The extent of the atmospheres of the planets at all stages of their growth depended primarily on their surface gravities.
The rate at which the nuclei swept up the planetesimals must have been excessively slow. This conclusion follows from the fact that if all the matter in the largest planet were scattered around the sun in a zone reaching halfway to the adjacent planets and sweeping them apart, and also from the fact that the orbits of only a fraction of them would at any one time intersect the orbit of the
CH. XII, 251] EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 433
nucleus. It must be remembered that the orbits of the planet-
esimals were continually changed by their mutual attractions
and especially by the attractions of the nucleus. Moreover,
the orbits of the nuclei were continually altered by collisions
with the planets, which may be regarded as a collision of one
another. Consequently, if the orbits of the nuclei and cer-
tain planetesimals did not originally intersect, they might
very well have done so later. But it does not follow that
they have all been swept up yet, or, indeed, that they all
ever will be swept up. Possibly some of the meteors which
the earth now encounters are the straggling remains of the
original planetesimals.
If the planetesimal theory is correct, the earth is very old
and the sun must have important sources of energy besides
its contraction. Most of the geological processes did not
begin until it became large enough to retain water and an
atmosphere. These same conditions were necessary for even
the beginnings of the development of life, which may have
had a continuous existence from the time the earth was half
its present age.
251. The Planes of the Planetary Orbits.—If the planet-
esimal hypothesis is true, it must explain the important
features of the solar system. The most striking thing about
the motions of the planets is that they all go around the sun
in the same direction, and the mutual inclinations of the
planes of their orbits are small. However, some deviations
exist, in particular in the case of Mercury and the planetoids.
It is assumed that the planetesimals all revolved around
the sun in the same direction. This would certainly have
been true if they originated by the close approach of two
suns, as explained in Art. 249. But the planes of their orbits
would not be exactly coincident. The plane of motion of an
object "revolved" would depend upon its direction of ejection and the forces to which it was subjected. The ejections would be nearly toward or directly away from the visit-2
434 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cf. xii, 25]
ing sun, but slight deviations would be expected because the ejecting body might be rotating in any direction, and the direction of ejection would depend to some extent upon its rotation.
Consider, therefore, a central body surrounded by an enormous swarm of planetesimals which move in intersecting elliptical orbits, some close to the sun and others far away. The system of planetesals now in the solar system gives a fair picture of the hypothetical situation, especially if, as seems very probable, there are countless numbers of small ones which are invisible from the earth. Suppose, also, that the total mass of all these bodies varies with time. They gradually sweep out the smaller masses and the problem is to determine what happens to the planets of their orbits.
Consider a nucleus and all the planetesimals which it will later sweep up. All together they have what may be called in a rough way an average plane of revolution. This is a perfectly definite dynamical quantity which Laplace treated and which he called the "invariable plane."
When this mass has been swept up, the resulting body will inevitably revolve in this plane. If the nucleus originally moved in some other plane, the plane of its orbit would continuously change as its mass increased. The same would be true for every other nucleus. There would be also an average plane for the whole system. Those nuclei which moved in regions that were richest in planetesimals, and that grew the most, would, in general, have final orbits mostly nearly coincident with this average plane. In other words, as long as the planes of the orbits of the planets are concerned (see Table IV), the consequences of the planetesimal theory are in perfect harmony with the facts established by observation.
252. The Eccentricities of the Planetary Orbits. — The orbits of the original planetesimals probably had a considerable range of eccentricities. This view is supported by the fact that the eccentricities of the orbits of the planetets vary
evn. xii, 252] EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 435
from nearly zero to about 0.5. It is also supported by the computations of orbits of particles which were assumed to be ejected from one sun when another was passing it. The probability that such near circular planetary orbits would be evolved from such a large planetesimal.
When a nucleus sweeps up a planetesimal, the impact on the larger body may be in any direction. If the nuclei overtakes the planetesimals so that they act like a resisting medium, the eccentricity of its orbit is in general diminished, as was proved by Euler more than 150 years ago. But many other cases of encounters can occur between bodies all moving in the same plane. Collisions will obviously be most numerous between bodies whose orbits are approximately of the same dimensions; if the orbits of two bodies differ greatly in size, collision between them is impossible unless the orbits are very elongated. It is a remarkable general proposition that if two bodies are moving in orbits of the same size and shape, but differently placed, and if they collide at any way, the eccentricity of the orbit of the combined mass will remain almost the same common eccentricity of the orbits of the separate parts.
To prove this, suppose a nucleus $M$ and a planetesimal $m$ are moving in orbits whose major semi-axis and eccentricity are $\alpha_1$ and $e_1$. Let their velocities at the instant preceding collision be $v_1$ and $v_2$, and their combined velocity at the instant of collision be $V$. Then, according to Newton's law, the instantaneous precession of $M$ is $(M + m)v_1$. Its kinetic energy after their union is $(M + m)\frac{1}{2}v^2$. The latter will be smaller than the former because of the loss of kinetic energy due to the impact of the two parts. Therefore $M + m > \frac{1}{2}(M + m)$. It is shown in celestial mechanics in the problem of two bodies that in elliptic orbits $y^2 = \frac{a^2}{b^2}$. Hence, the inequality becomes
$$\frac{M + m}{(M + m)} > \frac{a^2}{b^2} > \frac{(M + m)}{(M + m)}$$
where $a$ is the major semi-axis of the combined mass. It follows from this inequality that $\frac{M + m}{(M + m)} < \frac{a^2}{b^2}$, whence $a < b$. That is, under the circumstances of the problem a collision always reduces the major semi-axis of the orbit.
Another principle established in celestial mechanics is that the moment
436 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xii, 252
Of course, if two orbits were of exactly the same size, the periods of the bodies would be the same and collisions would result either at the first revolution or only after their mutual attractions had modified their motions. But if they were in nearly the same size, the conditions for collisions would be favorable, and in nearly all cases the eccentricity would be reduced.
It follows from this discussion that, in general, collisions between planetesimals cause the eccentricities of their orbits to decrease. Consequently, the more a nucleus grows by sweeping up planetesimals, the more nearly circular, in general, its orbit will be. If a nucleus revolves in a region rich in planetesimals, the result is likely to be a large planet whose orbit has small eccentricity. These conclusions agree precisely with what is found in the solar system, for the orbits of all the larger planets are nearly circular, while the orbits of some of the smaller planets and many of the planetoids are considerably eccentric.
253. The Rotation of the Sun. — If the central body in the planetesimal system rotates in the direction of the motion of the outlying parts, the final result will be a sun rotating in the direction of revolution of its planets. But if the planetesimal organization is the result of the close approach of two suns, the central mass might originally have been revolving in one direction. In this case the final outcome is not quite so obvious.
The only planetesimals which could seriously affect the rotation of the central mass are those which fall back upon it. If the planetesimals originated by the close approach of momentum is constant whether there are collisions or not. The orbital moment of momentum of a mass $m$ is $\sqrt{1-e^2}$, where $e$ is the eccentricity. The condition that the moment of momentum before collision shall equal that after collision is
$$M\sqrt{1-a_1} + m\sqrt{1-a_2} = (M+m)\sqrt{1-a_0},$$
or
$$\sqrt{1-a_1} = \frac{M}{M+m}\sqrt{1-a_0},$$
Since $a > a_0$, it follows that $\sqrt{1-a_0} < \sqrt{1-a_1}$, and therefore that $e < e_0$.
CH. XII, 254J EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 437
of two suns, there would certainly be many which would return to the central mass. They would not fall straight in towards its center, but would have a small forward motion similar in character to that of the remainder of the planetesimals. The suns would therefore be able to move so as to acquire their moment of momentum. It does not seem unreasonable that the mass of the central sun might grow in this way by as much as 10 per cent. Since the planetesimals would have enormously more moment of momentum than equal masses in the central body, they would substantially determine its direction of rotation. In fact, if the initial rotation of the whole system was 0.9 and if they just reached the sun their perihelion, the mass necessary to account for the present rotation of the sun, if it had no rotation originally, would be one fifth of one per cent of the sun's mass.
Another interesting result remains to be mentioned. The planetesimals would strike the equatorial region of the sun in greater abundance and would give it the most rapid motion. Under these conditions in motion were worn down by friction the equatorial zone would be rotating fastest, as is the case with our own sun.
**254. The Rotations of the Planets.** — The earth, Mars, Jupiter, and Saturn rotate in the direction in which the planets revolve; the surfaces of the other planets have not been observed well enough to enable astronomers to determine their rotations. It has been generally supposed that the equator of Uranus and Neptune coincide with the planes of the orbits of their satellites, but the evidence in support of the supposition is as yet inconclusive.
The earlier theories regarding the origin of the planets all fail to explain their forward rotations.
Chamberlin has shown that if a planet develops from a planetesimal system it will probably rotate in the direction of its revolution. Consider a nucleus $N$, Fig. 161, which, in its early stages, will probably be simply an immense
438 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [CH. XII, 254
swarm of planetesimals. For simplicity, suppose its orbit is a circle $C$ around the sun as a center (if this assumption were not made, the discussion would not be essentially modified). The planetesimals which can encounter $N$ are divided into three classes: (a) those whose aphelion points are inside the circle $C$; (b) those whose perihelion points are inside $C$ and whose aphelion points are outside of $C$; and (c) those whose perihelion points are outside of $C$. They are represented by $(a)$, $(b)$, and $(c)$ respectively in Fig. 161.
Consider collisions of the planetesimals of class $(a)$ with the nucleus. This collision can occur only when a planetesimal is near its aphelion point. At and near this point the planetesimal is moving slower than the nucleus.
Hence the nucleus will overtake the planetesimal, and the collision will be a blow backward on the inner side of the nucleus. That is, planetesimals of class $(a)$ tend to give the nucleus a forward rotation.
Planetesimals of class $(b)$ can strike the nucleus so as to tend to give it a rotation in either direction, or so as not to have any effect on its rotation. If they are not distributed in some special way, the collective result of the collision of many of them will be very small.
Let $V$ and represent the velocity of the nucleus and planetesimal respectively, and let $\varphi$ and $\psi$ denote the angles of their orbits. It is shown in celestial mechanics that $V^2 = \frac{2}{r} - \frac{1}{r}$, and $V^2 = \frac{2}{r} + \frac{1}{r}$. Since $a < A$ and $r$ is the same in the two equations, it follows that $V^2 > V^2$.
Fig. 161.—Development of the forward rotation of the nucleus by the accretion of planetesimals.
1 Let $V$ and represent the velocity of the nucleus and planetesimal respectively, and let $\varphi$ and $\psi$ denote the angles of their orbits. It is shown in celestial mechanics that $V^2 = \frac{2}{r} - \frac{1}{r}$, and $V^2 = \frac{2}{r} + \frac{1}{r}$. Since $a < A$ and $r$ is the same in the two equations, it follows that $V^2 > V^2$.
CH. XII, 254] EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 439
Planetesimals of class (c) move faster than the nucleus at the time of collision. Therefore they overtake the nucleus and tend to give it a forward rotation.
It follows from this discussion that two of the three classes of planetesimals tend to give the nucleus a forward rotation, while one tends to give it a backward rotation of the planet, for there they strike farthest from its axis. Hence, the impacts of planetesimals on the whole tend to make the equators of fluid planets rotate faster than the higher latitudes, as is the case with Jupiter and Saturn. The precise final result depends upon the initial rotation of the nucleus and upon the distribution of the planetesimals among the three classes.
Obviously the relative numbers of planetesimals in classes (a) and (c) would generally be such that, for some idea of the number required to account for the observed rotations, a numerical example has been treated. It was assumed that the original earth nucleus had no rotation and that the planetesimals of class (b) gave it none. It was assumed that all the planetesimals of classes (a) and (c) moved in orbits having the eccentricity 0.2 and that they struck the nucleus 4000 miles from the center of mass. In this case, after 100 million years, only 1/6th of the earth's mass was found that their total mass must have been about 5.7 per cent of that of the whole earth. Whether or not these results are reasonable cannot be determined without further quantitative investigations. But it must be insisted that the results are qualitatively correct, and that not even this much can be said for any earlier hypothesis regarding the origin of the planets.
In discussing previous theories, it is true that in those presenting discussion the effects of the rotations of the original nuclei, or swarms of planetesimals out of which the nuclei condensed, have been ignored. As a matter of fact, they were probably in rotation around axes essentially perpendicular to the plane of the system. There seems to be no conclusive reason why the original rotations should have been in one direction rather than in the other. The
440 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. xii, 254
observed rotations of the planets seem to indicate that, for some reason at present unknown, the original nuclei rotated in the forward direction.
**255. The Origin of Satellites.** — According to the planetesimal theory, the satellites developed either from small secondary nuclei which were associated with the larger planetary nuclei from the beginning, or from neighboring secondary nuclei which became enveloped at some stage in the outlying parts of the swarms of planetesimals constituting the nuclei. If the satellites originated in the former way, their directions of revolution would be the same as those of rotation of their respective primaries; if in the latter way, they might evolve originally in any directions around their primaries.
With the exception of the eighth and ninth satellites of Jupiter and the ninth satellite of Saturn (and possibly the satellites of Uranus and Neptune), all the known satellites revolve in the directions in which their primaries rotate. This seems to indicate that at least most of the satellites originated from secondary nuclei which were associated with their respective primary nuclei from the beginning and partook of their common motion of rotation. The satellite like the Phoebe nucleus swept up the diamantines and grew by accretion. The other satellites soon may have been produced by the impact of planetesimals.
With the growth in mass of a planet its attraction for its satellites increases and this results in a reduction in the dimensions of their orbits. Suppose the most remote direct satellites were originally revolving at the greatest distances at which their primaries could hold them in gravitational contact. Their orbits would then be reduced in these dimensions by the growth of the planets. The amount of reduction in the size of the orbit of a satellite depends upon the amount of growth of the planet around which it revolves, and furnishes the basis for computing the increase in the mass of the planet.
CH. XII, 250j EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 441
The three retrograde satellites revolve at great distances from their respective primaries in orbits which are rather eccentric and considerably inclined to their respective systems. Their origin is evidently different from that of the direct satellites. They may have been neighboring planetesimals which became entangled in the remote parts of the planetary swarm. The question arises why they revolve in the retrograde direction. The answer probably depends on the fact that the primary is given a very large angular momentum, so that its satellite is much more stable, so far as the disturbance of the sun is concerned, than a direct one. Consequently, a retrograde satellite would not be driven by collisions away from the control of its planet so easily as a direct one. Also, the effects of collisions with planetesimals and satelliteseismals (planetesimals revolving around planetary nuclei) must be considered.
266. The Rings of Saturn. The rings of Saturn are swarming particles revolving in the plane of the planet's equator. According to the planetesimal theory, they are the remains of outlying masses in the original nucleus which were moving so fast that they did not fall toward the center. Of course, they were subject to encounters with in-falling planetesimals. These collisions transformed some of their energy of motion into heat and some of them fell toward, but not into, the central mass. It may be that only a small part of the original ring material now remains. But when they fell, they retained at least a portion of their motion of revolution, and the result was that they struck the planet obliquely in the direction in which it rotated. This increased its rotation, especially in the plane of its equator.
There may be also probable are collisions even now among the particles which constitute the rings of Saturn. If there are collisions, the energy of motion is being transformed into heat, and this comes from the energy of the orbital motions, with the result that the dimensions of the rings are being decreased. They may ultimately disappear
442 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xii, 256
for this reason, and it is not impossible that other planets also once had ring systems.
**257. The Planetoids.** — The planetoids occupy a zone in which there was no predominating nucleus. They probably have not grown so much relatively as the planets by the accretion of planetesimals. Hence the ranges in the eccentricities and inclinations of their orbits give a better idea of the character of the orbits of the original planetesimals.
Besides the known planetoids, there are probably thousands of others which are so small that they have not been observed, but may be found between the orbit of Jupiter and Saturn and beyond the orbit of Saturn. At those vast distances none but large bodies would be visible, both because they would not be strongly illuminated by the sun and also because they would always be very remote from the earth. The planetoid Eros has escaped collision with Mars only because of the inclination of its orbit. It is not unreasonable to suppose that there are many other asteroids beyond the limits of the earth and Mars which are too small to be visible.
**258. The Zodiacal Light.** — It is universally agreed that the zodiacal light is due to a great swarm of small bodies, or particles, revolving around the sun near the plane of the earth's orbit. These small bodies are in reality planetesimals which have not been swept up by the planets either because of the high inclinations of their orbits, or possibly because their orbits are so nearly circular that they do not cross the orbits of any of the planets.
**259. The Comets.** — Recent investigations have shown that it is very probable that comets are permanent members of the solar system. As they have no intimate relationship to the planets, the question of their origin presents new problems and difficulties.
According to the planetesimal theory, the comets are possibly only the outlying and tenuous fragments of the original nebula which did not partake of the general rotation
cb. xii, 200] EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 443
of the system. If the planetesimal system was produced by the near approach of two suns, they may have had their origin, as Chamberlin has suggested, in the dispersion and scattering of earlier planetesimals which revolved in different planes. The planets may have been formed by the light of the sun in various directions, which, under the disturbing action of the visiting sun, did not fall back upon our own; or the comets may be matter which was ejected from the visiting sun. The differences in the lengths of their orbits and in the positions of the planes of their orbits may originally have been much less than now, for, the planets may have dis-
turbed the motion of all the planets. The sun may have captured some comet and greatly enlarged its or-
bite of an equal number of others, and they may have entirely changed the positions of the planes of the cometary orbits.
260. The Future of the Solar System. — The theory has been developed that the planets have grown up from nuclei by the accretion of scattered planetesimals. They acquired and retained atmospheres when their masses became great enough to permit them to retain gas molecules by molecular force. Their masses are still increasing, but the process of growth seems to be essentially finished. Those planets which are dense and solid like the earth will retain all their essential characteristics as long as the sun continues to furnish radiant energy at its present rate. The large rare planets will lose heat from their interiors and may contract appreciably.
The loss of that amount of heat may take millions of years for some and not for other planets because it can be carried to the surface rapidly by convection in a gaseous or liquid body, while in a solid body it is transferred from the interior only by the excessively slow process of conduction.
The duration of the sun is a very important factor in the future of the planets. There is no known source of energy which could supply an indefinite amount of radiation over tens of millions of years. Yet it is not safe to conclude that the sun will cool off in a few millions of years because the earth
444 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xii, 260
gives indisputable evidences (Art. 219) that the sun has radiated more energy than could have been supplied by any known source. The existence of hundreds of millions of stars blazing in full glory, and the fact strongly that the life of the sun will last long, for it is not reasonable to pose that, if it continues only a comparatively short time, so many of them would now have such great brilliancy. In view of these uncertainties it is not safe to set any definite limit on the future duration of the sun, however probable its final extinction may be.
If the sun cools off before something destroys the planets, to wit, before it becomes cold, lifeless, and invisible, while it pursues its journey through the trackless infinity of space. If the radiation of the sun does not sensibly diminish, the earth, and possibly some of the other planets, will continue to be suited for the abode of life until they are in some way destroyed. Whether or not the sun becomes cold, the planets will be broken into fragments when our sun passes sufficiently near another star. Their remains may then be dispersed throughout a new solar system, to become in time parts of new planets. Indeed, the meteores which now strike the earth often give evidence of having once been in the interior of masses of planetary dimensions, and Chamberlin has suggested that they may be the remains of a family of planets antedating our own.
To such dizzy heights are we led in sober scientific pursuits ! This question of purpose is one of fundamental things in the universe, one which ever arises in the human mind. With sublime egotism men have usually asserted that everything was created for their pleasure and benefit. The sun was made to give them light by day, and the moon and the myriads of stars to illuminate their way by night. The numberless plants and animals of forest and prairie and sea were supposed to exist primarily for the profit of the human race. But with the increase of knowledge this conclusion is seen to be absurd. How infinitesimal a part of
CH. XII, 260] EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 445
the solar system and its energy man can use, to say nothing of that in the hundreds of millions of other systems which are found in the sky!
How many billions of creatures were born, lived, and died before man appeared! The precise time of the beginning of life on earth is unknown, but the manner of its origin are lost in the distant past. In the oldest rocks laid down as sediments tens of millions of years ago in the Archeozoic era there are indications of the existence of low forms of life on the earth.
In the Cambrian period trilobites and other lowly creatures lived in great abundance. In the Ordovician period the types of low forms greatly increased and the vertebrates began to appear in the seas. In the Silurian further development took place, in the Devonian they were still further developed. And after many other geological periods had passed, the higher forms of life, including man, appeared. Now man finds himself a part of this great life stream, not something funda-
mentally different from the rest and that for which it exists.
If the earth shall last some millions or tens of millions of years in the future, as seems likely, the physical and mental evolution of man will race with that of all other life forms as those through which the animal kingdom has passed during the long periods of geological time. This is especially prob-
able if men learn how to direct the processes of their own evolution.
But if they do not, the human race may become extinct just as many other species of animals have become extinct. However this may be, it seems certain that its end will come for essentially the light of day will go out, or the earth and all its plants will be wrapped by a passing star, and the question of the purpose of it all if indeed there is any purpose in it, still remains unanswered.
XX. QUESTIONS
1. Are the particles which produce the solar light an example of the planetesimal organization?
2. In the case of one star passing by another, why would their ejections of material be largely toward or from each other?
446 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xii, 200
3. Show by a resolution of the forces that the material ejected both toward and from $S'$ will describe curves around $S$ in the same direction.
4. Will the orbit of $S'$ be changed if it changes the moment of momentum of the system $S$? What will be the result in the very eccentric cases where the orbit of $S'$ relatively to $S$ is originally a parabola?
5. In view of Table XIII, what fraction of the material ejected from $S$ would reasonably be expected (a) to fall back on $S$, (b) to move away from $S$ with a velocity greater than that of gravitative control? On the basis of these figures, find what frac- tion of $S$ would need to be ejected altogether in order to provide merely one plane planet.
6. Would the eccentricities of the orbits of the material which fell back upon $S$ have been large or small? Would most of the collision have been grazing, as was assumed in the discussion in Art. 253?
7. To what extent would the planets formed from materials as massive as the moon concentrate or dissipate? Would a nucleus of the materials found in the sun remain gaseous on cooling?
IV. HISTORICAL COSMOGONIES
261 The Hypothesis of Kant. — The work of Thomas Wright, which preceded that of Kant by five years, was concerned chiefly with the evolution of the whole sidereal universe. Wright supposed the Milky Way was made up of a great number of mutually attracting systems which are spread out in a great double ring rotating about an axis perpendicular to its plane. Kant was the first one to under- take the development of a detailed theory of the evolution of the solar system on the basis of the laws of gravitation.
Kant's hypothesis of cosmo genesis was announced by a book of Wright, which fell into his hands in 1751. He at once, turned his keen and penetrating mind to the question of the origin of the planets, and wrote a brilliant work on the sub- ject. On almost every page he gave proof of the intellectual power which later made him the foremost philosopher of his time, yet his theories were not without serious imperfections.
Kant postulated that the parent of the solar system was a vast aggregation of simple elements, without motion and
CH. XII, 261] EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 447
subject only to gravitational and chemical forces and the repulsion of molecules in a gaseous state. Nothing could have been simpler for a start. The problem was to show how such a system could develop into a central sun and a family of widely separated planets.
Kant reasoned that motions among the molecules would be set up by their chemical affinities and mutual attractions. He stated that the larger masses would tend to themselves, because once in their immediate neighborhood, and that with growth their power of growing would continually increase. He believed that not only would aggregations of molecules be formed, but that these masses would acquire motions both because of the attraction of the system as a whole and also because of their mutual attractions. Kant paid attention to the fact that attractions were opposed by gasage expansions, and he assumed that these repulsive forces in some obscure way would generate lateral motions in the small nuclei. At first the nuclei would be moving in every possible direction, but he assumed that successive collisions would eliminate all except a few moving in the same direction in nearly circular orbits.
The beauty and generality of Kant's theory are enticing, but it involves some obvious and fatal difficulties. In the first place, it is clear that repulsive forces would not be competent to set up a general revolution of a system which was originally at rest. His conclusion in this matter squarely violates the principle that the moment of momentum of an isolated system remains constant.
Notwithstanding clear statements by Kant, some writers have modified his theory by supposing that there was heterogeneous motion of the original chaos, so that the resemblance in form which he had supposed the planets now revive. But with this concession to the theory, which makes it dynamically a different theory, difficulties still remain. It is not at all clear that in a system of such enormous extent the orbits of all bodies except those having motion in the dominant
**448 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY** [ca. xii, 261
direction would be destroyed by collisions. There is, indeed,
no apparent reason why, if this were the true history of the
origin of the planets, some planets should not now be found
revolving at right angles to the general plane of the system,
or even in the retrograde direction. This is not impossible,
as is proved by the motions of the comets. Thus it is seen that
if Kant's hypothesis is taken strictly as he gave it, the condi-
tion that the moment of momentum of the system should
have its maximum value when all particles are at rest, if they
are changed so as to relieve this difficulty, others still remain.
Kant's theory has also secondary difficulties of a serious
nature. For example, in a gas the mutual attractions of the
molecules could not draw them together into small nuclei.
Even the moon could not now add to its mass if it should
pass through a gas. To avoid this difficulty one might assume
that there was first condensation into the liquid or solid state.
So many molecules would then have to be drawn together
even the minutest drop that, by an averaging process, their
lateral motions would essentially destroy one another, the
particle would fall toward the center of the whole system,
and no planets would be formed. In order to avoid this difficulty it is necessary to depart from Kant's ideas and to
assume either that the whole gaseous mass was rotating with
considerable velocity before condensation took place into any
state. If the first of the two assumptions is made, it is found
by a mathematical treatment that the moment of momen-
tum of the system would be more than 200 times what it is
at present. Since the moment of momentum would remain
unaltered, the second alternative must be adopted. But
this is directly contrary to the fundamental assumptions of
Kant, and it is hardly permissible to regard a theory as hav-
ing preserved its identity after having been modified to this
extent. The only possible explanation for a group of discrete particles in orbital revolution in the same direction,
is actually the planetesimal organization.
In successive chapters Kant considered the densities and
CH. XII, 262] EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 449
ratios of the masses of the planets, the eccentricities of the planetary orbits and the origin of comets, the origin of satel-lites and the rotation of the planets, etc. He even claimed to have proved without observational evidence the existence of life on other planets. In spite of the keenness of his intellect and his remarkable powers of generalization, his theory has not had much influence on speculations in cos-mology, because it contains many obvious and serious errors in its application of physics and dynamical laws.
262. The Hypothesis of Laplace. — The hypothesis of Laplace appeared near the end of a splendid popular work on astronomy which he published in 1796. He advanced it " with that distrust which everything ought to inspire that we do not believe in observation or of calculation." How great an advance over Kant this one sentence indicates!
In outline, the hypothesis of Laplace was that originally the solar atmosphere (in later editions a nebulous envelope), in an initial state, extended out beyond the orbit of the farthest planet; the whole mass rotated as a solid in the direction in which the planets now revolve; the dimensions of the solar atmosphere were maintained mostly by gaseous expansion of the highly heated vapors, and only slightly by contraction due to gravitation; most of the heat was lost heat by radiation, it contracted under the mutual gravitation of its parts; simultaneously with its contraction, its rate of rotation necessarily increased because the moment of momentum remained constant; after the rotating mass had contracted to certain dimensions the cen-

2
450 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cn. xii, 262
trifugal acceleration at the equator equalled the attraction by the interior parts and an equatorial ring was left behind, the remainder continuing to contract; a ring was abandoned at the distance of each planet; a ring could scarcely have had absolute uniformity, and, separating at some point, it united with another ring, which would have constituted one of its parts and formed a planet; and, finally, the satellites were formed from rings which were left off by the contracting planets, Saturn's rings being the only examples still remaining.
The contraction theory of the sun's heat, which was developed by Helmholtz in 1854, fitted in very well with the Laplacian hypothesis and was considered as supporting it. Some objections to the Laplacian theory, however, began to appear. In 1873 Römer, the author of the theorem that a satellite revolves round its primary in such a way that from its primary should become less than 2.44 radii of the latter, seriously undertook to modify the hypothesis of Laplace so as to relieve it of the difficulties with which it was beset. His modifications were for the most part improbable and do not in the least meet later objections. Kirkwood, an American astronomer, criticized the Laplacian hypothesis on physical grounds, and suggested that the rotation of the planets might be due to the effect of the sun's tides upon them when they were expanded in the gaseous state. In 1884 Faye made very radical modifications of the hypothesis of Laplace for the purpose of avoiding the difficulties in which it was becoming involved. He supposed that the planets were formed in the depths of the solar nebula and that those nearer the sun are actually older than those which are more remote. Although Darwin began his great work on the tides which he regards as supplementing and strengthening the hypothesis of Laplace.
It is now generally recognized that the Laplacian hypothe- sis fails because it does not meet the most fundamental requirements of the problem. For example, the density of the hypothetical solar atmosphere must have varied in har-
cn. xii, 202j EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 451
mony with the laws of gases. With this distribution of density, which can be theoretically determined, and the rotation which is given by the revolution of the planets, it is an easy matter to compute the moment of momentum pos-
sessed by the hypothetical system when it extended out to
the distance of the earth's orbit. The result would be that at 200
times that of the system at present. If the hypothesis of
Laplace were correct, the two would be equal; the discrep-
ancy is so enormous that the hypothesis must be radically
wrong.
The details of the Laplacian hypothesis are subject to
equally serious difficulties. For example, it would be impos-
sible for successive rings to be left off. Kirkwood long ago
pointed out that if instability in the equatorial zone once
arose, it would continue until all the material was condensed,
the result would be a continuous disk of particles describing
near circular orbits. Further, if a ring were left off, it
could not even begin to condense into a planet because both
gaseous expansion and the tidal forces due to the sun would
more than offset the mutual gravitation of its parts. It has
been seen how large and dense a planet must be in order
to have an atmosphere, and yet it is difficult to see how its
density could be extremely low and it could not control the
lighter elements. And it has been shown that even if a cir-
cular ring had in some way largely condensed into a planet,
the process could not have completed itself. In order that
a nucleus may gather up scattered materials, it is necessary
that they shall be moving in considerably eccentric orbits.
Since the Laplacian hypothesis fails in the fundamental re-
quirement of conservation of momentum, as well as in a num-
ber of other essential respects, it will be sufficient simply to
enumerate some of the phenomena which are obviously not
in harmony with it :
(1) It does not provide for the planetoids with their
The power of control of a planet on an atmosphere is proportional to the product of its density and radius.
452 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ca. xii, 262]
interlacing orbits, some having high inclinations or eccentricities.
(2) It does not permit of the existence of an object hav-
ing such an orbit as that of Eros, which reaches from near
that of the earth out beyond that of Mars.
(3) It does not allow of the risk of particles, such as
that producing the zodiacal light, cannot exist.
(4) It does not anticipate the considerable eccentricity
and inclination of Mercury's orbit.
(5) It does not agree with the fact that the terrestrial
planets seem to be at least as old as the more remote ones.
(6) It does not permit of there being any retrograde satel-
lites because the rings abounding by a contracting nebula would have been destroyed by this process.
(7) It implies that the rotation period of each planet shall be shorter than the shortest period of revolution of its satel-
lites. This condition is not only violated in the case of
the inner satellite of Mars, but the particles of the inner ring of Saturn revolve in half the period of the planet's rotation.
263. Tidal Forces. --- The sun and moon generate tides in the oceans that cover the earth. Tides are raised also in the atmosphere and in all bodies of water. Every celestial body raises tides in every other celestial body.
The first problem which will be considered here will be the
character of the tide-raising forces, and the second will be
the effects of the tides on the rotations and revolutions of
the two bodies.
Consider the tide-raising effects of $m$ on $M$, Fig. 103.
For simplicity, consider the effects of $m$ on $P$ and $P'$ two particles on the surface of $M$. The problem of the resolu-
tion of the forces as that was treated in Art. 153. Let $MA$ represent the acceleration of $m$ on $M$ in direction and amount. Then the acceleration of $m$ on $P$ and $P'$ will be represented by $PB$ and $PB'$ respectively. The former is
\begin{equation}
\text{1 Attempte have been made, though not successfully, to avoid this diffi-} \\
\text{culty by invoking tidal friction (Art. 264).}
\end{equation}
Let us now consider what happens when we take away one particle from $P$ and put it into $P'$. We then have two particles on $M$ separated by a distance $AB$. The force between them is given by Newton's law,
$$F = \frac{G m_1 m_2}{r^2},$$
cu. xn, 263] EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 453
greater than $MA$ because the acceleration varies inversely as the square of the distance, and $Mm$ is greater than $Pm$. For a similar reason $P'B'$ is less than $MA$. Now resolve $PB$ into two components, $PC$ and $PD$, in such a way that $PC$ shall be equal and parallel to $MA$. Similarly, resolve $P'D'$ into two components, $PC'$ and $PD'$, in such a way that $PC'$ and $PC'$ are equal and parallel to $MA$, they have no tendency to displace $P$ and $P'$ respectively with respect to $M$. The remaining components, $PD$ and $P'D'$, are the tide-raising accelerations.
Now consider the tide-raising forces all around $M$. They are as indicated in Fig. 94. The forces toward $m$ are slightly
A diagram showing the tide-raising force on a body around a central body M.
Fig. 163. — The tide-raising force.
greater than those in the opposite direction, while the compressional forces at 90° from these directions are half as great. It is clear from this figure that if $M$ were not rotating and $m$ were not revolving around it, there would be a tide on the side of $M$ towards $m$, and a nearly equal tide on the side of $M$ away from $m$ (compare Art. 153). The motions of the bodies produce important modifications.
Suppose the rotation of $M$ and revolution of $m$ are in the same direction, then the period of rotation of $M$ is shorter than that of the revolution of $m$. This is the case in the earth-moon system. Under these circumstances the tides $T_1$ and $T_2$ are carried somewhat ahead of the line $Mm$, as represented in Fig. 164. The more nearly equal the rates of rotation of $M$ and revolution of $m$, the more nearly will the tides $T_1$ and $T_2$ be in the line $Mm$.
454 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xii, 203]
Consider a point on the rotating body $M$. It will first pass the line $Mm$, and then somewhat later it will pass the tide $T_i$. The interval is the lag of the tide. In the case of the earth-moon system a meridian passes eastward across the moon (the moon seems to pass westward across the meridian), and somewhat later the meridian passes the tidal cone and has high tide. The reason is easily seen: consider a point on the earth, and let us take the time due to the sun, by the varying distances of the moon and sun north or south of the equatorial equator, by their changing distances from the earth, and especially by the irregular contours of the continents and the varying depths of the oceans. These modifying factors are so numerous and in some cases so poorly known that at present it is not possible to predict with any certainty the tides at any station, except those of the tides; but, after a few observational data have established the way in which the tides at a station depend upon the unknown factors, predictions become thoroughly reliable, for the tides vary in perfect harmony with the tidal forces.
264. Tidal Evolution. — The tides are not fixed on the surface of $M$, Fig. 164, unless the period of its rotation equals the period of revolution of $m$. When the periods are unequal so that the two move relative to each other, some energy is dissipated by heat friction. This loss of kinetic and potential energies of the system; and, in accordance with the laws of dynamics, the transformation of energy takes place in such a way that the total moment of momentum of the system remains unchanged. Of course, in general there will be tides on both of the mutually attracting bodies.
The character of the transformation of energy that takes place under tidal friction depends upon the dynamical properties of the system. Suppose that the motions of rotation and revolution are in the same direction and that the period of $M$ is shorter than that of $m$. It can be shown that under these circumstances the periods of both $M$ and $m$
A diagram showing a rotating body M with a smaller body m orbiting around it.
CH. XII, 264] EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 455
and their distance apart are increased. The reason that the period of rotation of $M$ is increased is that $m$ has a component of attraction back on both $T_1$ and $T_0$, Fig. 164, as can be seen by resolving the forces as they were resolved in Fig. 163. If $m$ pulls $T_1$ and $T_2$ backward, it follows from the reasoning given in the last paragraph that the effect of all of a forward component on $m$ is to increase the size of its orbit and to lengthen its period.
If $m$ is near $M$, the effect of the tides on the period of revolution of $m$ is greater than their effect on the period of rotation of $M$. If the bodies are far apart, the result is the opposite.
Suppose the two bodies are initially close together and that the period of rotation of $M$ is only a little shorter than the
A diagram showing tidal cones and the lag of the tide.
Fig. 164. — Tidal cones and the lag of the tide.
period of revolution of $m$. The friction of the tides will lengthen both periods and increase the difference between them. If nothing else interferes, this will continue until a certain distance between the bodies has been reached. After that, the effect on the period of rotation of $M$ will be greater than that on the period of revolution of $m$. Consequently, although both periods will continue to increase in length, they will approach equality. Eventually, the periods of rotation and revolution will be equal, the tides will remain fixed on $M$, and there will be no further tidal friction or tidal evolution.
The most important case from a practical point of view has been considered, but there are two others. In the first the bodies move in the same direction, but the period of
456 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xii, 264]
rotation of $M$ is longer than that of revolution of $m$. Under these circumstances both periods are decreased, the relative amounts depending on the distance of the bodies from each other. If the bodies are initially far apart, the effect will be greater on the period of rotation of $M$ than on the period of revolution of $m$, and the two periods will approach equality. But if the bodies are near together, the effect will be relatively greater on the period of $m$, the periods will not approach equality, and the bodies will ultimately collide. In the instance of a collision between $M$ and $m$, if $T_1$ is the direction opposite to that of the revolution of $m$, under these circumstances $M$ rotates faster and faster, the distance of $m$ continually decreases, and the inevitable outcome is the collision and union of the two bodies.
The rate at which tidal friction takes place depends upon the physical properties of the bodies. If they are perfect fluids so that no degeneration of energy, there is no tidal friction. Likewise if they are perfectly elastic, there is no tidal friction.
The rate of tidal friction also depends upon the difference in the periods of the two bodies. If the difference between the periods is small, i.e., the times $T_1$ and $T_2$, Fig. 164, are almost in the line $Mm$, and it is obvious that the backward components are small and the rate and tidal friction is very slow. Suppose that periods are approaching equality. The smaller the difference the slower their rate of change, and they never become exactly equal but approach equality as the time becomes infinitely great.
**265. Effects of the Tides on the Motions of the Moon.**
The most striking thing in the earth-moon system is that the moon's periods of rotation and revolution are equal. It is extremely improbable that this unique relation is accidental, and it is an explanation of it that we can surmise that the moon's period of rotation has been brought into equality with its period of revolution by the tides generated in it by the earth.
ch. xi, 265] EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 457
The tidal force exerted by the earth on the moon is about 20 times the tidal force exerted by the moon on the earth. The amount of tidal friction is proportional to the square of the tidal force. Therefore, if the physical properties of the earth and moon were the same and if their periods of rotation were equal, the effect of the earth on the moon in changing the moment of momentum of the moon would be 400 times that of the tides generated by the moon on the earth in changing the moment of momentum of the earth. Since the moment of momentum of a body is proportional to the product of its mass and the square of its radius, a slight change in the moment of momentum of the moon due to its rotation would cause a much larger change in the moment of momentum after it changes the rate of rotation of the earth. Consequently, taking the two factors together, if the earth and moon were physically alike and had the same period of rotation, tidal friction would change the period of rotation of the moon $400 \times 1200 = 480,000$ times as fast as it would change the period of rotation of the earth.
The results which have been obtained seem to be very favorable to the theory that the tides have caused the moon to present one side toward the earth, but some serious difficulties remain. It can be shown that, considering the tidal interactions of the earth and moon and the effect of the sun's tides on the moon, the present condition of the earth-moon system is not one of equilibrium. The tides raised by the sun on one hand have no effect under present circumstances on the rotation and revolution of the moon. The tides raised by the moon on the earth increase the length of the month but do not affect the rotation of the moon. The tides raised by the sun on the moon increase the moon's period of rotation but do not affect its revolution. Consequently, the moon's periods of rotation and revolution are both increasing, and it is infinitely improbable that all the factors on which these effects depend are so related that
458
AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [CH. XII, 265]
they are exactly equal. Even if they were equal at one time, they would become unequal with a changed distance of the moon from the earth. That is, the present is not a fixed state of equilibrium, and the consideration of the tides does not remove the difficulties. It seems probable from this line of thought that the earth has been revolving around the sun, and that the moon always to present the same face toward the earth.
**266. Effects of the Tides on the Motions of the Earth.** — The theory of the tidal evolution of the earth-moon system, on the basis of certain assumptions regarding the physical condition of the earth, was elaborated by Sir George Darwin in a splendid series of investigations. While the experiment of Michelson and Gale (Art. 25) proves that his assumptions are not satisfactory at present, at least for the time, the possible sequence of events which he worked out is interesting.
Since the tides are increasing the lengths of both the day and the month, both of these periods were formerly shorter and the moon was nearer the earth. On the basis of his assumptions, Darwin traced the day back until it was only four or five of our present hours. At that time the moon was revolving close to the earth in a period almost equal to that of our present day. He supposed that at an earlier stage the earth and moon were one body that they divided into two parts because of the rapid rotation of the combined mass, and that they attained their present state as a consequence of tidal friction. The same reasoning leads to the conclusion that in the future they will continue to separate and that the day will continually increase in length.
The critical question is whether the physical properties of the earth are such that the rate at which tidal evolution takes place makes it an appreciable factor in the history of the earth. Darwin supposed the main effects were due to bodily tides in the earth which he assumed to be viscous. Since it is highly elastic, they cannot at present be important, but it has generally been assumed that, whatever its present
CH. XII, 206] EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 459
condition may be, it was formerly viscous. There is abso-
lutely no evidence to support the assumption, and if its
present properties of solidity and elasticity are a conse-
quence of the pressure in its interior, the assumption seems
very improbable. As Poisson and Lord Kelvin showed,
the temperature of the interior of the earth cannot have
fallen appreciably for several hundred million of millions of years by
cooling of heat on its surface. Since the temperature of the interior of the earth cannot have changed appreciably, there seems to be no good ground for assuming that
the earth was once viscous.
Since there cannot now be an important degeneration of
energy in the bodily tides of the earth, tidal evolution must
depend at present almost entirely upon the tides in the ocean and the atmosphere. The latter may be neglected
without serious error. The former are so irregular that it is difficult to determine their effects on the rotation
of the earth. But MacMillan has made liberal estimates of
the unknown factors, and has found that at present
the length of the day cannot be increasing at a rate of more
than one minute in 30,000,000 years.
It is possible to determine observationally the present rate
of tidal evolution. The date of the month are increasing in
length, but the effect on the day is greater. Conse-
quently, if the length of the month is measured in days, as
is done practically, it will seem to be decreasing in length.
It is found from observations that the moon is getting ahead
of its predicted place from 4 to 6 seconds of arc in 100 years.
That is, in 1240 revolutions the moon gets ahead of its pre-
dicted place about $\frac{1}{2}$th of its diameter. On the basis of these
facts it is evident that the proper discussion of the length
of the month is due to tidal interactions of the earth and moon,
the proper discussion shows that at the present time
the length of the day is increasing as a consequence of all the
factors affecting the rotation of the earth at the rate of one
minute in 900,000,000 years.
460 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xii, 266]
It is evident that tidal evolution is not an important fac-
tor in the earth-moon system for any period short of several
hundred millions of years. Either the theory of tidal evolu-
tion as elaborated by Darwin must be abandoned as not
representing what has actually taken place, or a condition
of equality of periods of rotation and revolution which exists
at present must be arbitrarily assumed.
267. Tidal Evolution of the Planets. — There is perhaps
some slight evidence that Mercury and Venus always keep
the same side toward the sun, and this condition has been
ascribed to the effects of tides which the sun may have raised in them. The tidal force exerted by the sun on Mercury is about 2.5 times as great as that of the moon on the earth,
while Venus receives only one-fifth as much. Since these de-
tails do not have appreciable effects, it does not seem proba-
ble that the sun's tides have radically changed the rotations
of Mercury and Venus. Besides this, it must be remem-
bered that the condition of equality of periods of rotation and
revolution would be attained in any case only after an infinite time.
The tidal action of the sun on the more remote planets is
much less than that on the earth. No other satellite has rela-
tively as great effects on its primary as the moon has on
the earth. Consequently, we are forced to the conclusion
that in the solar system tidal evolution has not been an im-
portant factor for a period of at least several hundreds of
millions of years.
XXI. QUESTIONS
1. According to Kant's theory, why should the sun rotate in the direction the planets revolve?
2. Is the assumption of Laplace that the original nebula was highly heated in harmony with the present temperature of the sun at all times correct?
3. Why did Laplace assume that the original nebula was rotating as a solid?
4. To what extent does the contraction theory of the sun's heat
CH. XII, 207] EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM 461
support the Laplacian hypothesis? Is it opposed to the planetesimal hypothesis and Kant's hypothesis?
5. In what way does the Laplacian hypothesis fail to meet the requirements of moment of momentum?
6. On what assumption was the temperature of the surface of the sun if it extended to the orbit of the earth? How do you account for the presence of refractory materials in the earth, under the Laplacian hypothesis?
7. In what respect does the Laplacian hypothesis differ from that in Art. 202 are opposed to the Laplacian hypothesis.
8. What should be the present shape of the sun if the Laplacian hypothesis were true?
9. In the case of the earth and moon, what is the magnitude of the tidal force at the point on the side of the earth toward the moon compared to the whole attraction of the moon? Compared to the attraction of the moon itself?
10. The tides produced on the earth by the moon decrease the earth's moment of momentum; what becomes of that which the earth loses, and what is changed in the solar system?
11. Show that when $M$ revolve faster than $m$ does, the attractions of $m$ for both $T_1$ and $T_2$ tend to decrease the rate of rotation of $M$.
12. Suppose that the rate of rotation of the earth is constant and that in a century the moon gets $6^{\circ}$ ahead of the place it would occupy if its rate of revolution were constant. How long would be required for its period to decrease 1 per cent?
462 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [CH. XII, 267
Fig. 165. — Milky Way in Aquila. Photographed by Barnard at the Yerkes Observatory, August 27, 1906.
CH. XII, 267
CHAPTER XIII
THE SIDERAL UNIVERSE
I. THE APPARENT DISTRIBUTION OF THE STARS
268. On the Problems of the Sideral Universe. — The invention of the telescope and the discovery of the law of gravitation were followed by a long period of successes in unraveling the mysteries of the solar system. The positions of the sun, moon, and planets were measured with extraordinary precision, and the law of gravitation accounted for their motions. The mystery of the origin of the stars had been mysterious and inexplicable; became familiar and thoroughly understood. Telescopes of continually increasing power enabled astronomers to measure accurately the distances and diameters of these bodies and to learn much of their surface conditions. At last the invention of the spectroscope enabled them to determine the chemical constitution of the sun.
There is great pleasure now in working in a science whose data are exact and whose laws are firmly established. The certainty of the results satisfies the human instinct for final truth. But there was also pleasure of a different kind for those pioneers who first explored the planetary system with good instruments and showed by mathematical processes that its members are obedient to law. For them every observation and every calculation was an adventure. They were continually in fear that their dreams of knowing the secrets of nature would prove false, but they were continually elated by having their theories confirmed.
The pioneer days of discovery in the solar system are past. Not that great discoveries do not remain to be made, but
463
404 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xii, 268]
they will henceforth fit into a large body of organized facts.
From now on the romance and excitement of astronomical adventure will be largely furnished by the explorations of the sidereal universe. Astronomers have become accustomed to think that the sun is much larger than the earth; and familiarity has dulled their amazement at activities; from now on they must deal with millions of stars, some of them much larger and thousands of times more luminous than the sun. They have measured and at least partially grasped the enormous dimensions of the solar system; from now on they must conceive of and deal with distances millions of times as great. They have observed the tremendous variety of celestial bodies; from now on they will be face to face with the infinite diversity presented by the stars. They have definitely accepted the doctrine that the solar system has undergone a great evolution whose details are yet much in doubt; the corresponding question for hundreds of millions of other systems is looming up more indistinctly through the fog of uncertainties which still surround them. It might be supposed that astronomers would speedily drop down all of their understanding before the transcendental and apparently difficult problems presented by the sidereal system. Instead, with all the weapons at their command, they are making more vigorous, persistent, and successful attacks than ever before. Astronomers of all the leading countries are united and cooperate in this campaign; they employ telescopes of many kinds, spectroscopes, photographic plates, measuring instruments, and employ astronomical processes in their attempts to penetrate the unknown.
269. The Number of Stars of Various Magnitudes.—The simplest and most easily determined thing about the stars is their number. Of course the number that can be seen depends upon the power of the instrument with which the observations are made. If the stars extend indefinitely in every direction with approximately equal distances from
CH. XIV, 209] THE SIDEREAL UNIVERSE
one another, the number of them revealed by a telescope will be proportional to the space it brings within visual range.
On the other hand, if the stars are evenly distributed at a great distance in any direction, then the number of the distant stars seen in that direction will fall short of being proportional to the space penetrated by the instrument. For this reason it is important to find the number of stars of each magnitude down to the limits of range of the most powerful telescopes.
Consider first what the apparent distribution in magnitude would be if every actual size and luminosity were scattered uniformly throughout space. Take a large enough volume so that accidental groupings will not sensibly affect the results. For example, suppose there are 5000 stars in the first six magnitudes and compute the number there should be, under the hypothesis, in the first seven magnitudes.
The sixth-magnitude stars are 2.512 · · · times as bright as the seventh-magnitude ones, and so on. If the magnitudes of stars are given absolute brightness are directly propor-
tional to the squares of their distances, it follows that stars of the seventh magnitude are $2^{5.12} = 1.585 \cdot \cdot \cdot$ times as distant as corresponding stars of the sixth magnitude.
Therefore the volume occupied by stars out to the seventh magnitude, inclusive, is $(1.585 \cdot \cdot \cdot)^{3} = 3.08 \cdot \cdot \cdot$ times that occupied by those out to the sixth magnitude. If all stars were uniformly distributed and the light of the remote ones were in no way obstructed, there would be $3.08 \cdot \cdot \cdot$ times as many stars in the first seven magnitudes as in the first six magnitudes, or nearly 20,000 stars. The ratio is the same for the total number of stars up to any two successive magnitudes because the particular magnitudes do not enter into its computation. And it can be shown easily that the ratio of the number of stars out to one magnitude to that out to another magnitude is also $3.08 \cdot \cdot \cdot$
It remains to examine the results furnished by the observa-
tions. The stars are so extremely numerous that only a
2
466 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xii, 209
small fraction of the total number within reach of modern instruments has been counted. But an approximation to the solution of the problem of determining the number of stars has been obtained by counting simple regions of known size in many parts of the sky, thus thereby applying the unit by number necessary to include the whole celestial sphere. By far the most extensive work of this kind has been carried out by Chapman and Melotte of the Royal Observatory at Greenwich. They made use of stars down to magnitude 17.5, where 4,000,000 of them send to the earth only a little more light than one star of the first magnitude. Their results are given in the following table :—
| Magnitude |
Number of Stars |
Magnitude |
Number of Stars |
| 5 to 6 |
2,026 |
11 to 12 |
961,000 |
| 6 to 7 |
7,095 |
12 to 13 |
2,023,000 |
| 7 to 8 |
13,538 |
14 to 15 |
4,849,000 |
| 8 to 9 |
65,040 |
14 to 15 |
7,823,000 |
| 9 to 10 |
172,400 |
15 to 16 |
14,049,000 |
| 10 to 11 |
426,200 |
16 to 17 |
25,398,000 |
The ratio of the number of stars of a given magnitude to the number of stars one magnitude fainter is 2.5 at the beginning of the table, and it continually decreases to 1.8 at the end. Therefore, not only is the ratio for every interval of one magnitude less than the 3.98 corresponding to uniform distribution of the stars, but it falls off about 50 per cent in 12 magnitudes.
What conclusions can be drawn from the facts given by the table? It is certain that the stars cannot be uniformly distributed to indefinite distances unless there is something special about our own solar system. For example, when we come back here, in the first line, for example, the number is that of stars from magnitude 5.0 to 6.0, while in Table II the corresponding number is that of stars whose magnitudes are 4.5 to 5.5.
cii. xii, 269j THE SIDERELLE UNIVERSE
467
which prevents their light from coming to us. If there were a sufficient number of dark stars and planets, the light from remote luminous stars would be shut off; but the number of non-luminous bodies required to account for the black sky would be millions of times the number of bright ones. In spite of the fact that certain variable stars (Ares 385) prove the existence of planets, it is probable that the light with which the planets would lead to the conclusion that there are many non-luminous bodies of secondary dimensions, it seems extremely improbable that they are sufficiently numerous to explain the observed phenomena. But if the obscure matter were finely divided, as in meteoric dust, a given mass of it would be a much more effective screen,1 than the total mass of all the worlds we know on earth. Finely divided material would not only absorb light, but it would scatter the blue light and cause distant stars to appear redder than nearer stars of the same character.
There are certain phenomena which give slight support to the hypothesis that there is some scattering of light of this nature, but they are not conclusive. One of them is the apparent reduction in the magnitude of stars found from an investigation of stars down to the fourteenth magnitude, part of the data being furnished by the visual observations of Sir John Herschel, that the number of stars of the fainter magnitudes is much greater than is given in the table of Chapman and Melotte. The faintest stars used in the construction of their table are obtained from the Franklin-Adams photographic chart of Greenwich. Turner has shown that most of this reduction in light due to remote faint stars may be deflected in the blue end of the spectrum, to which photographic plates are most sensitive, and consequently that a considerable part of the stars belonging visually to a certain magnitude belong photographically to a fainter magnitude. In spite of these possible indications of
1 The effectiveness of opaque matter of given total mass in cutting off light is inversely proportional to the radius of its separate parts.
468 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xiii, 209]
scattered particles, it seems extremely improbable that the falling off of the star ratio from 3.98 to 1.8 is due appreciably to this cause.
The most obvious, though not necessary, conclusion which has generally been drawn from the table is that the stars are limited in number and that they occupy a limited portion of space. In the first seventeen magnitudes there are in round numbers 55,000,000 stars. Chapman and Melotte derived a simple formula which represented the numbers closely for these magnitudes. By applying this formula, it was found that the same formula holds indefinitely beyond, those determined the magnitude for which there are as many stars brighter as there are fainter, and computed the total number of stars altogether. By this process they concluded that the median magnitude lies between 22.5 and 24.3, which are several magnitudes beyond the reach of existing instruments, and that the number of stars of all magnitudes is between 100,000,000 and 1,000,000,000. It is obvious that such an extrapolation is hazardous, and they did not lay any particular stress on the results. In fact, the data given by the observations can be as exactly represented by many other less simple formula which will give totally different results for the fainter magnitudes.
There is an even simpler line of reasoning which led many astronomers to the conclusion that the celestial universe is limited. Since the stars of any magnitude are 2.512 times fainter than those of the next preceding magnitude, and, under the hypothesis of uniform distribution, 3.98 times more numerous, it follows that if the star density did not diminish as the distance increases, the stars of each magnitude would give $3.98 \times 2.512 = 1.68$ times as much light as those of the next magnitude brighter. Consequently, the first 20 magnitudes would give 17,000 times so much light as those of the next magnitude brighter, and so forth until we get $3.98^{20} \times 2.512^{20} = 168,000,000,000,000,000$ times as much light, and so on. If there were no limit to the number of magnitudes and
cn. xin, 269j THE SIDEREAL UNIVERSE 469
no absorbing material, there would be no limit, except for the mutual eclipsing of the stars, to the amount of light received from all of them. The sky would be everywhere ablaze with the average brightness of a star, perhaps equal to that of the sun. The stars in one hemisphere would give us more than 90,000 times as much light as the sun, but actually only about 300,000 times as much light as all the stars together. Therefore, unless much light is absorbed, the hypothesis of uniform distribution of the stars to infinity is radically false.
It is necessary, therefore, to conclude that the number of stars is limited and that they occupy only a finite part of space? By no means; simply that they cannot be distributed with approximate uniformity throughout infinite space.
It was pointed out by Lambert long ago that just as the solar system is a single unit among a great number of hundred millions stars, so the Galaxy may be but a single one out of an enormous number of galaxies separated by distances which are very great in comparison with their dimensions, and that these galaxies may form larger units, or super-galaxies, and so on without limit. There is nothing in such an organization which is inconsistent with the facts established by observation. It is possible to have infinite systems of stars in this way which would give us only a finite amount of light. Hence the conclusion to be adopted is that the sun is in the midst of an aggregation of at least several hundred millions of stars which form a sort of system, and that beyond and far distant from this system there may be other somewhat similar systems in great numbers which may be units in themselves and yet still infinitely limited.
It must be admitted that the ether is not infinitely extensive, because it surrounds the stars of the sidereal system (and other stellar systems if there are such) as the atmospheres surround the planets. Light could not come to us from beyond its borders, however many stars might exist there, as sound cannot come to the earth from other bodies beyond
470 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xii, 269
the limits of its atmosphere. It must be understood that this is merely a suggestion entirely without any observational basis.
**270. The Apparent Distribution of the Stars.** The brighter stars of the Milky Way are distinctly visible to the naked eye, but a careful examination of the fainter of even those which can be seen with the unaided eye shows that they are considerably more numerous in and near the Milky Way than elsewhere. When those stars which can be seen only with the help of a telescope are included, the condensation toward the Milky Way is still more pronounced.
Precise numbers for all the stars are known only to the main magnitude class, viz., those given by Herschels, and especially the work of Chapman and Melotte, go much further and give what are very probably approximately correct results down to the seventeenth magnitude. Since the stars are apparently condensed towards the Milky Way, it is natural to use its plane as the fundamental plane of reference. According to E. Pickering the north pole of the Galaxy is at right ascension 190° and its declination is about $-25^{\circ}$; in the Milky Way itself it is difficult to locate its center; but its median line is possibly not quite a great circle, from which it follows that the sun is somewhat out of the plane near which the stars are congregated.
Let the center of the Milky Way be the circle from which galactic latitudes are counted. Chapman and Melotte divided the sky into eight zones by first finding the belts of galactic latitude $\pm 30^{\circ}$, $\pm 20^{\circ}$, $\pm 10^{\circ}$, then $\pm 5^{\circ}$, $\pm 4^{\circ}$, $\pm 3^{\circ}$, $\pm 2^{\circ}$, $\pm 1^{\circ}$, and finally the two belts from $\pm 10^{\circ}$ to $\pm 20^{\circ}$, the third two belts from $\pm 20^{\circ}$ to $\pm 30^{\circ}$, the fourth from $\pm 30^{\circ}$ to $\pm 40^{\circ}$, the fifth from $\pm 40^{\circ}$ to $\pm 50^{\circ}$, the sixth from $\pm 50^{\circ}$ to $\pm 60^{\circ}$, the seventh from $\pm 60^{\circ}$ to $\pm 70^{\circ}$, and the eighth regions from $\pm 70^{\circ}$ to $\pm 90^{\circ}$ around the galactic poles. With the belts numbered in this order they found for the average number of stars in each magnitude in 10 square degrees the results given in Table XV.
CH. XIII, 270j THE SIDERELLE UNIVERSE
| TABLE XV |
| Zone |
I |
II |
III |
IV |
V |
VI |
VII |
Galactic Latitude 0 to +90° |
± 10° to ± 30° |
± 20° to ± 50° |
± 30° to ± 60° |
± 50° to ± 80° |
± 60° to ± 90° |
± 70° to ± 90° |
± 90° to ± 180° |
| Mag. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 1 to 5 |
0.27 |
0.33 |
0.15 |
0.11 |
0.11 |
0.13 |
0.13 |
| 6 to 7 |
0.77 |
0.54 |
0.43 |
0.43 |
0.33 |
0.33 |
0.33 |
| 8 to 9 |
8.89 |
7.61 |
6.43 |
5.83 |
5.34 |
3.32 |
3.31 |
| 10 to 12 |
62.55 |
59.88 |
58.38 |
| 28 | 26 | 22 | 22 | 22 | 22 | 22 |
|---|
| 14 to 16 | 157.15 | 153.49 | 149.63 | 143.78 | 139.92 | 135.47 | 131.09 |
|---|
| 17 to 19 | 265.65 | 262.69 | 259.74 |
|---|
Three things follow from this table:
(a) Stars of all magnitudes down to the seventeenth are more numerous in the plane of the Milky Way than near its poles.
Since the only reasonable supposition is that the nearer stars are distributed more or less uniformly with no special relations to the Milky Way, it follows from the fact the bright stars are condensed near the Milky Way that some of them are very distant. That is, the stars differ greatly in absolute magnitude, and this difference can be accounted for by their distances.
(b) The decrease in the number of stars is on the average gradual from the Milky Way to its poles, showing that the sun is actually in the midst of the clouds of stars on which the table is based.
(c) The relative condensation in the plane of the Milky Way is greater, the fainter the stars. This proves that the stars are not only much more numerous near the plane of the Milky Way, but also that they extend to much greater distances in this plane than in the direction
(d) The number of stars decreases rapidly with increasing distance from the sun.
The following table gives the number of stars per square degree at different distances from the sun:
| Distance (degrees) | Number of Stars |
|-------------------|-----------------|
| Less than 1 | ~1,000 |
| From 1 to 5 | ~5,000 |
| From 5 to 10 | ~2,500 |
| From 10 to 20 | ~1,250 |
| From 20 to 30 | ~625 |
| From 30 to 40 | ~312 |
| From 40 to 50 | ~156 |
| From 50 to 60 | ~78 |
| From 60 to 70 | ~39 |
| From 70 to 80 | ~19 |
| From 80 to 90 | ~9 |
| From 90 to 180 | ~4 |
This table shows that the number of stars decreases rapidly with increasing distance from the sun, and that there are comparatively few stars beyond about one hundred degrees from the sun.
The following table gives the number of stars per square degree at different distances from the sun:
| Distance (degrees) | Number of Stars |
|-------------------|-----------------|
| Less than 1 | ~1,000 |
| From 1 to 5 | ~5,000 |
| From 5 to 10 | ~2,500 |
| From 10 to 20 | ~1,250 |
| From 20 to 30 | ~625 |
| From 30 to 40 | ~312 |
| From 40 to 50 | ~156 |
| From 50 to 60 | ~78 |
| From 60 to 70 | ~39 |
| From 70 to 80 | ~19 |
| From 80 to 90 | ~9 |
| From 90 to 180 | ~4 |
This table shows that the number of stars decreases rapidly with increasing distance from the sun, and that there are comparatively few stars beyond about one hundred degrees from the sun.
The following table gives the number of stars per square degree at different distances from the sun:
| Distance (degrees) | Number of Stars |
|-------------------|-----------------|
| Less than 1 | ~1,000 |
| From 1 to 5 | ~5,000 |
| From 5 to 10 | ~2,500 |
| From 10 to 20 | ~1,250 |
| From 20 to 30 | ~625 |
| From 30 to 40 | ~312 |
| From 40 to 50 | ~156 |
| From 50 to 60 | ~78 |
| From 60 to 70 | ~39 |
| From 70 to 80 | ~19 |
| From 80 to 90 | ~9 |
| From 90 to 180 | ~4 |
This table shows that the number of stars decreases rapidly with increasing distance from the sun, and that there are comparatively few stars beyond about one hundred degrees from the sun.
The following table gives the number of stars per square degree at different distances from the sun:
| Distance (degrees) | Number of Stars |
|-------------------|-----------------|
| Less than 1 | ~1,
472 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xiii, 270
A starry sky with a large, dark nebula in the center.
Fig. 166. — Great star clouds in Sagittarius. Photographed by Barnard at the Yerkes Observatory.
CH. XIX, 271] THE SIDEREAL UNIVERSE
of its poles. The counts of stars by Kapteyn, based in part on the visual observations of Sir John Herschel, give still greater relative concentration in the plane of the Milky Way, and still less in the direction of the poles.
271. The Form and Structure of the Milky Way. — Before attempting to arrive at a more precise conclusion regarding the distribution of the stars in space, it is desirable to obtain a better idea of the form and properties of the Milky Way.
As has been stated, the center of the Milky Way is nearly a great circle around the celestial sphere. Its greatest northerly declination (45° to 63°) is at first ascension zero and southward it reaches about 20°. It is thus a broad circle. It extends from this point southeastward across Perseus with very irregular outlines (Fig. 1, Art. 82), and narrows down where it crosses the borders of Taurus to a width of about 5". It then bulges wider in Monoceros and across the northeast corner of Canis Major. Further south in Argo, with its numerous divisions, it becomes as much as 30" wide. In Sagittarius its width increases to about 40", while by vacant lanes, one of which in its center is called the "coal sack," and at right ascension about 9 hours and declination 45° south a dark gap stretches almost across it. After reaching its most southerly point in Crux it stretches out in irregular outline through Centaurus, part of Musæ, Cireneus, Norma, and then north again into Ara, Lupus, and Scorpius.
In Scorpius and Sagittarius to the east are areas of the most remarkable concentration of stars. The Plateau, Fig. 167. Barnard's photographs of these regions show countless suns massed in banks, with intervening dark lanes, the whole often enveloped by a soft nebulous haze (see Fig. 167). North-east of Scorpius lie Ophiuchus, Serpens, and Aquila. From Aquila and Ophiuchus northward through Vulpecula and Cygnus to Cepheus, the Milky Way is divided longitudinally by a belt of varying width. This belt, which extends through more than 50° of its length, is one of its most remarkable features. In Cepheus the two branches
A diagram showing the distribution of stars in the Milky Way.
474 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xii], 271
join and reach on into Cassiopeia, where the description of the Milky Way began.
It is obvious that the stars do not form any simple system. It seems probable that the Galaxy is composed of a large
Fig. 167. — The region of Rho Ophiuchi. Photographed by Barnard.
number of star clouds, each with peculiarities of its own, but having relations to the whole mass of stars. Since the Milky Way is roughly in the form of a great discus, or "grindstone" as Herschel called it, the prevailing motions must be in its plane in order to have preserved its shape.
cu. xii, 271] THE SIDEREAL UNIVERSE 475
This does not mean that the relative velocities would need to be great enough to be easily observed; they would, in fact, be very slight as seen from the enormous distances separating the stars from the earth.
XXIL. QUESTIONS
1. Prove that the magnitude of stars of equal absolute brightness vary inversely as the square of their distance.
2. Prove that, under the hypothesis of the second paragraph of Art. 269, the ratio of the number of stars of any magnitude to the number of stars of greater magnitude is 3.5.
3. If there are 2000 stars of first magnitude and if the ratio for successive magnitudes were 3.08, how many stars would there be of magnitude 10 to 17?
4. Prove that the effectiveness of a given mass in screening off light is inversely proportional to the radius of the particles into which it is divided.
5. Show by what means we know how it follows from Table XV. and the assumption under (a) that some of the bright stars are very distant.
6. How many of the 20 first-magnitude stars have parallaxes greater than 0'.2 (see Table XVI.)?
7. If a star were discovered in parallax (Art. 372), would the sun be a first-magnitude star? A sixth-magnitude star? If Canopus has a parallax of 0'.005, how does its absolute brightness compare with that of the sun?
8. Prove that the area of one hemisphere of the sky is 92,000 times the apparent area of the sun.
9. Prove in detail that conclusion (b) of Art. 270 follows from Table XVII.
10. At what time of the year does the portion of the Milky Way which is divided by a longitudinal rift pass the meridian at S.P.M.? If possible, observe it.
11. Prove by experiment and show that the fact that the central line of the Milky Way is not quite a great circle proves that the solar system is not in the center of the disk of stars of which the Milky Way is composed.
12. If all visible objects belong to the Galaxy, is it possible to prove the rotation of the Milky Way by observations of the stars?
| XXIL. QUESTIONS |
|
| 1. |
Prove that the magnitude of stars of equal absolute brightness vary inversely as the square of their distance. |
| 2. |
Prove that, under the hypothesis of the second paragraph of Art. 269, the ratio of the number of stars of any magnitude to the number of stars of greater magnitude is 3.5. |
| 3. |
If there are 2000 stars of first magnitude and if the ratio for successive magnitudes were 3.08, how many stars would there be of magnitude 10 to 17? |
| 4. |
Prove that the effectiveness of a given mass in screening off light is inversely proportional to the radius of the particles into which it is divided. |
| 5. |
Show by what means we know how it follows from Table XV. and the assumption under (a) that some of the bright stars are very distant. |
| 6. |
How many of the 20 first-magnitude stars have parallaxes greater than 0'.2 (see Table XVI.)? |
| 7. |
If a star were discovered in parallax (Art. 372), would the sun be a first-magnitude star? A sixth-magnitude star? If Canopus has a parallax of 0'.005, how does its absolute brightness compare with that of the sun? |
| 8. |
Prove in detail that conclusion (b) of Art. 270 follows from Table XVII. |
| 9. |
At what time of the year does the portion of the Milky Way which is divided by a longitudinal rift pass the meridian at S.P.M.? If possible, observe it. |
| 10. |
Prove by experiment and show that the fact that the central line of the Milky Way is not quite a great circle proves that the solar system is not in the center of the disk of stars of which the Milky Way is composed. |
| 11. |
If all visible objects belong to the Galaxy, is it possible to prove the rotation of the Milky Way by observations of the stars? |
476 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xiii, 271
13. What observational evidence disproves the hypothesis that there are infinitely many galaxies distributed with approximate uniformity, but separated from one another by distances which are enormous compared to their dimensions?
II. DISTANCES AND MOTIONS OF THE STARS
272. Direct Parallaxes of the Nearest Stars. — One of the proofs that the earth revolves around the sun is that the apparent directions of the nearest stars vary with the position of the earth in its orbit (Art. 51). The difference in direction of a star as seen from two points separated from each other by one second of arc is called the parallax of the star; or, in other terms, the parallax of the star is the angle subtended by the mean radius of the earth's orbit as seen from the star (Fig. 35). If the parallax were one second of arc, the distance of the star would be 206,265 times $^{\prime}$ i.e. the mean distance from the earth to the sun. This distance, which is a very convenient unit in discussing the distances of the stars, is called the parsec, and for most purposes may be taken as equal to 200,000 astro nomical units, or 20,000,000,000 miles. It is the distance that light travels in about 3.3 years.
The stars are so remote that the problem of measuring their parallaxes is one of great practical difficulty. Alpha Cen tauri, the nearest known star, has a parallax of only 0".75. That is, its direction in direction as seen from two points on the earth's orbit, separated by the distances from the earth to these points, differs by less than one second of arc at an object at the distance of 10.8 miles when first seen with one eye and then with the other. Not only is the difference in the apparent position of a star very small as seen from different parts of the earth's orbit, but it can be determined only from observations separated by a number of months
1 This number is the number of seconds in the arc of a circle which equals its radius in length.
CH. XIII, 272] THE SIDEREAL UNIVERSE 477
during which climatic conditions and the instruments may have appreciably changed.
The best direct means of determining the parallax of a star is by comparing, at various times of the year, its apparent position with the positions of more distant stars. Let $S$, Fig. 168, represent a star whose parallax is required, and $S'$ a much more distant star. When the earth is at $E$, the angular distance between them is $= SE'S'$; when the earth is at $E_1$, it is $SE_1'S_1$; the parallax of $S$ is $\angle ESE_1$; the parallax of $S'$ is $E'E_1E_2$, which will be negligible if $S'$ is sufficiently remote, as seen from $E$. The difference of these angles is equal to the figure that the parallax of $S$ minus the parallax of $S'$ equals the difference of the measured angles $SE_1'S$ and $SE_2'S_1$.
A diagram showing two stars, S and S', with their respective parallaxes represented by angles. The angle between S and S' is shown as being equal to the difference between the measured angles SE1'S and SE2'S'.
Fig. 168.—Determination of parallax from apparent changes in relative positions of stars.
Hence, if the parallax of $S'$ is inappreciable, the parallax of $S$ can be found.
In practice the position of $S$ is measured with respect to a number of comparison stars. At present the work is done almost entirely by photography. Plates of a star and the surrounding region are secured at different times of the year, and the distances between the stars are measured under a microscope on a machine designed for the purpose. The scale of the photograph is proportional to the focal length of the telescope, and consequently for this purpose only large and excellent instruments are of value.
With such instruments it has been found that a parallax of 0° 02 or less cannot be determined with sufficient accuracy to be of much value; in fact, the probable error in one of 0° 05 is large. The great distances of the stars can be inferred
478 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [cii. xiii, 372
from the fact that only about 100 are known whose parallaxes come within the limits of these distances.
The distances of stars whose parallaxes are 0'02 or greater can be determined with an accuracy exceeding about 25 per cent of the quantity to be determined. There are at present 19 such stars known, 9 of which are too faint to be seen without optical aid. These stars are given in Table XVI. When the distance of a star of known magnitude has been determined, the total amount of light it radiates, or its luminosity, as compared with the sun can be computed. The luminosity each of the nineteen stars is given in the fifth column.
| Star |
Mag. |
Paral- |
Luminosity |
Mass |
Velocity |
| Lax. |
Distance |
(Sec. U) |
(Sec. L) |
(Sec. P) |
| α Centauri |
0.3 |
0.76 |
1.32 |
2.0 |
1.9 |
20 |
| Lalande 21,185 |
7.6 |
0.40 |
5.00 |
0.099 |
? |
35+ |
| β Persei |
3.6 |
0.33 |
3.00 |
0.50 |
? |
11 |
| τ Ceti |
3.6 |
0.33 |
3.00 |
0.50 |
? |
20 |
| C. Z. p5438 |
8.8 |
0.32 |
3.13 |
0.067 |
? ?
\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\nd \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation.\t\tnotation. |
The 19 stars of Table XVI together with our sun occupy a sphere whose radius is 5 parsecs. If they were uniformly distributed over this space, the distance between adjacent stars would be about 3.5 parsecs, or 122 light years. In view of the fact that a number of stars in the list are far
CH. XIII, 272] THE SIDEREAL UNIVERSE 479
below the limits of visibility without optical aid, it is reason- able to suppose that there may be a considerable number of others within 5 parsecs of the sun which are as yet undis- covered.
It should not be supposed that attempts have been made to measure the parallaxes of all stars brighter than the ninth, or even the sixth, magnitude. The process is exces- sively laborious, and only those stars are selected which are believed to be within measurable distance, or which are sufficiently bright for the light to reach us with a given motion across the line of sight will apparently move faster the nearer it is to the observer. Consequently, those stars will be nearest on the average whose proper motions, as they are called, are greatest. As a rule only those stars are examined for parallax which have been found to have large proper motions.
Under this hypothesis the stars are uniformly dis- tributed throughout the space occupied by the Galaxy and that their density is the same as it is in the vicinity of the sun, the extent of the stellar universe can be computed. Suppose the space occupied by the stars is spherical in shape and that there are 500,000,000 of them. Then it turns out that, under the hypotheses adopted, the radius of this sphere is 150 parsecs, or 500 light-years. Since the Galaxy is very flat in its general form and its center probably lies at a few hundred parsecs while the borders of its periphery are probably several thousand parsecs from its center.
One very interesting and important conclusion follows from Table XVI, and that is that the luminosities of the stars vary enormously. For example, Sirius radiates 12,000 times as much light as OAOI. Therefore, the difference in luminosity may be due to the fact that some are larger than others, or at least partly to the fact that some are intrinsically more brilliant than others. Probably both factors are important. Some stars are certainly much more massive than others, and the table gives examples of stars
480 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xii, 272]
whose masses differ very much less than their luminosities. For example, while the mass of Sirius is only 3.4 times that of the sun, its luminosity is 48 times as great. But Sirius is a double star and presents in its own system a still more remarkable contrast. The mass of the brighter component is about 15 times greater than that of the fainter, but its luminosity is at least 5000 times greater. There are other stars, such as Rigel and Canopus, which, though they are so remote that no evidence of their having measurable parallaxes has been found, shine with the greatest brilliancy. Their luminosity must be at least several thousand times that of the sun.
In fact, the average luminosity of the stars visible to the unaided eye probably exceeds that of the sun. In half-dark fields one may find it necessary from this fact that the luminosity of the sun is below the average, for it is exceeded in luminosity by only five of the 19 stars in the table.
In order to determine the velocity of a star its motion both along and across the line of sight must be found. The proper motions of all the stars in Table XVI are known, but the radial velocities of six of them are unknown; in these cases a mean value must be given for each velocity because the radial component is not known. It follows from the table that the less luminous stars move with much higher velocities than the brighter ones. The average speed of those five stars whose luminosities exceed the sun is 17 miles per second, while the average speed of the six whose luminosities are less than 0.01 that of the sun is more than 50 miles per second. Since the more luminous stars are also larger, and since the more massive it follows that the more massive stars move more rapidly than the less luminous ones.
One may inquire to what extent reliance can be put in conclusions based on only 19 stars. When compared to hundreds of millions the number is ridiculously small, but all the conclusions which have been stated are strongly supported by the evidence furnished by the much more numerous stars having smaller and less accurately determined parallaxes.
CH. XIII, 273] THE SIDEREAL UNIVERSE
273. Distances of the Stars from Proper Motions and Radial Velocities.--The parallaxes of possibly 100 stars have been determined by direct means with considerable accuracy. Probably not over 1000 are within reach of present instru-
ments and methods. Are astronomers doomed to remain forever without knowledge of the distances which fill the sky? By no means. There are several indirect methods of finding the average distances of classes of stars.
Consider all the stars of a large class, say the stars of the sixth magnitude. Suppose they are moving at random; that is, that they do not tend to move in any particular direction, or with any particular speed. Suppose both their proper motions and their radial velocities have been deter-
mined. Then, if we take the mean of these two quantities, many stars will be approaching as receding, and the average velocities of approach will average the same as those of recession. Also, the proper motions will be as numerous and as large in one direction as in the opposite. The extent to which these conditions are fulfilled is a measure of the accuracy of the assumptions.
Whatever the individual motions of the class of stars under consideration, they will have an average speed of motion which may be represented by $V$. The average component of motion toward or from the observer will be $V\sqrt{2}$, as can be shown by a mathematical discussion. This is the aver-
age radial velocity as determined by the spectroscopic, and is therefore known. The average component at right angles to the line of sight is found by a mathematical discussion to be $\sqrt{2}V$. This quantity is also known because $V$ has been given by spectroscopic observations.
Now consider the proper motions. They are expressed in angle, and they depend upon the distances of the stars and the speed with which they move across the line of sight. Since both the linear speed across the line of sight and the angular velocity, or proper motion, have been found, the distances of the stars can be computed.
21
482 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xii, 273
The hypotheses on which this discussion has been made are not exactly fulfilled, and the necessary modifications of the proposed method must now be considered.
**274. Motion of the Sun with Respect to the Stars.** — Since the stars are in motion, it is reasonable to suppose that the sun is moving in accordance with them. Such was found to be the case by William Herschel many years ago. He proved by observations extending over many years that the apparent distances between the stars in the direction of the constellation Hercules are increasing, on the average, and that they are decreasing in the exactly opposite part of the sky. He interpreted this as meaning that the sun is moving toward the constellation Hercules, and it is obvious that this would explain the observed phenomena, since the stars in that direction move toward larger angles. While Herschel's observations gave the direction of motion of the sun, they did not give its speed, which could be found by this method only if the distances of the stars were known. Since the distances of only a few stars can be measured directly, there is little hope of determining the motion of the sun in this way with any considerable degree of accuracy.
The trigonometrical method is used to determine both the direction of the sun's motion and also the rate at which it moves. Instead of finding as many stars approaching as receding in every part of the sky, as was assumed in the discussion in Art. 273, it has been found that the stars in the direction of the constellation Hercules on the whole are relatively approaching the sun, while those in the opposite direction are relatively receding. This means that with respect to the stars which were observed the sun is moving toward Hercules.
The best determination of the direction of the sun's motion from proper motions of the stars is by Lewis Boss, who based his discussion on the 6188 stars in his catalogue. The best spectroscopic determination is by W. W. Campbell, who
483
THE SIDEREAL UNIVERSE
based his discussion on the radial velocities of 1193 stars measured at the Lick Observatory and its branch in South America. The results of these determinations are as follows :
| Solar Apex (Bom) |
Declination |
Speed |
| Solar Apex (Campbell) |
270° 2' 5" -1° 3' 26" 270° 2' 5" -2° 3' 46" |
34° 3' 17" -1° 3' 46" |
12 mi. per sec. |
The agreement of these results in right ascension is remarkable, and the disagreement in declination is small considering the difference in the methods and the stars used.
The number of stars used by Boss in his determination of the direction of the motion of the sun is so great that he could divide them up into separate groups and make the discussion more definite. He determined the motions of stars with equa-
tic latitudes and obtained essentially the same result for each group. Dyson and Thackeray found from another (the Groombridge) list of 3707 stars that the declination of the apex of the sun's way increases from +16° to the brightest stars to +43° for those from magnitude 8.0 to 8.9. This was confirmed by Comstock, who found even a greater decli-
nation for the apex of the sun's way as determined from still fainter stars, but the result was not accepted, which appears to be due to a misprint defining a point on a much larger and better distributed list of stars. The spectra of the stars are divided into a number of classes (Art. 295), and it was found both by Boss and by Dyson and Thackeray that the declination of the apex of the sun's way is about 12° greater when determined from stars of Secchi's second type than it is when determined from stars of the first type. But this difference is very small, being relatively to the few thousand brightest stars, toward a point whose right ascension is about 270° and whose declination is about 34°, and that the speed of relative motion is about 12 miles per second.
484 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xiii, 274]
The motion of the sun with respect to the stars evidently requires some modification of the process described in Art. 23. There is, however, no real difficulty, because the effect of the sun's motion can be avoided by considering only those components of the proper motions of the stars which are at right angles to the line of the sun's way.
Campbell made a determination of the mean parallaxes of the stars down to magnitude 5.5 by the method of this article. The brighter stars are not sufficiently numerous to give very good results. He found that the mean parallaxes of stars of magnitudes 4.5 to 5.0 was 0.070125, corresponding to a distance of 80 parsecs. This volume is 4096 times that occupied by the 20 nearest stars, and if the stars were uniformly distributed throughout it, the total number of them down to magnitude 5.50 would be 81,920, which is much in excess of the number actually observed.
**276. Distances of the Stars from the Motion of the Sun.** The number of stars a constant distance from any number of stars can be measured directly because their distances are so enormously great compared to the diameter of the earth's orbit. If the orbit of the earth were as large as that of Neptune, the problem would be much easier because of the larger base line which could be used. But the sun's motion can be made to afford an indefinitely large base line in statistical discussions, as will be shown later.
Suppose first that all of the stars of the observable sidereal universe except the sun are relatively at rest. The motion of the sun among them will give them an apparent displacement, or proper motion, in the direction opposite to that in which it is moving. The farther a star is away the smaller this proper motion will be. If a star is so far away that no displacement due to the sun's motion can be observed in one year, then 10 years, 100 years, or any other necessary number of years must elapse before its proper motion will be observable. Since the sun travels about 4 astronomical units per year, it follows that the parallax of a
CH. XIII, 275] THE SIDEREAL UNIVERSE 485
star is one fourth of that part of its annual proper motion which is due to the motion of the sun.
The false hypothesis that all the stars except the sun are relatively at rest has greatly simplified the problem. As a matter of fact, the stars are moving with respect to one another in various directions and with various speeds, and the proper motion of a star is due both to its own motion and also to the motion of the sun with respect to the system. Since the actual motion of a particular star is in general unknown, it necessarily follows that the average motion of many, and then the result will be consistent, for the motion of the sun is defined with respect to the many. For any class of stars the average proper motion perpendicular to the direction of the sun's motion will be zero, while the average proper motion in the direction of the sun's motion will depend only on the motion of the sun itself.
This statistical study of the stars was taken up about 20 years ago by Kapteyn, of Groningen, who pursued it with rare skill and great industry. A number of other astronomers have also made important contributions to the subject. It is interesting to note the different kinds of work which contribute to the final results. In the first place, the proper motions of the stars are involved. They are obtained from two or more determinations of apparent position separated by intervals of time, and as long as these intervals are short enough, the more accurately are the proper motions determined. In the second place, the spectroscopy is of fundamental importance because it furnishes the motion of the sun with respect to the stars. Since certain classes of stars may be moving as a whole with respect to other classes (Art. 278), it follows that the spectroscopic determination of the motion of the sun depends upon all those stars whose motions are sought after their proper motions. At present the radial velocities of stars farther than the sixth magnitude can be obtained only by costly long exposures, and the practical limits do not reach beyond the eighth magnitude. On the
486 AN INTRODUCTION TO ASTRONOMY [ch. xiii, 275
other hand, the determination of the proper motions of stars by many magnitudes fainter offers no observational difficulties.
**276. Kapteyn's Results Regarding the Distances of the Stars.** — As will be seen in Art. 295, most of the stars are of two principal spectral types. Type I, of which Sirius and Vega are examples, are the blue-white stars. Their spectra are characterized by absorption lines due to hydrogen in their atmospheres. They are intensely hot and probably always of large mass. Type II are the yellowish stars, of which the sun, Capella, and Arcturus are examples. The atmospheres of these stars contain many metals.
Kapteyn derived formula giving the mean parallaxes of all stars of each magnitude, and also the mean distances of stars of each magnitude. Table XVII gives Kapteyn's results transformed from parallax to parsecs and using Campbell's more recent determination of the rate of motion of the sun.
TABLE XVII DISTANCES IN PARSECS1 |
| MAGNITUDE |
All Stars |
SPECTRAL TYPE I |
SPECTRAL TYPE II |
| 1 |
24.2 |
39.4 |
16.8 |
| 2 |
31.0 |
50.5 |
21.6 |
| 3 |
37.8 |
(41.7) |
27.6 |
| 4 |
50.9 |
82.9 |
35.4 |
| 5 |
65.3 |
106.3 |
45.4 |
| 6 |
83.5 |
(88.3) |
58.2 |
| 7 |
107.3 |
174.7 |
74.7 |
| 8 |
137.5 |
224.0 |
93.7 |
| 9 |
152.7 |
(158.1) |
122.7 |
| 10 |
226.1 |
(308.3) |
157.4 |
| 11 |
289.8 |
(472.1) |
201.7 |
| 12 |
(391.6) |
| | |
|---|
| | |
|---|
| | |
|---|
| | |
|---|
| | |
|---|
| | |
|---|
| | |
|---|
| | |
|---|
| | |
|---|
| | |
|---|
| | |
|---|
| | |
|---|
| | |
|---|
| | |
|---|
| | Table XVII DISTANCES IN PARSECS1 <table> <thead> <tr> <thead> <thead> <thead> <thead> <thead> <thead> <thead> <thead> <thead> <thead> <thead> <thead> <thead> <thead> <thead> <thead> <thead> </tbody> </tbody> </tbody> | </tbody> </tbody> </tbody> |
|---|
</tbody> </tbody> | </tbody> </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> </tbody> | </tbody> </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> | </tbody> |